IOWA #15 in the 3rd CFP Rankings (Nov 17). "Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee."

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
Heather dimich pipes in
" The committee is using a new metric this year that measures conference strength in conference games only and I think that really boosted the SEC"

Ya think...keeps those 4 4 loss sec teams in top 25.
Wow. No shite. So them starting most of the SEC in the early polls ranked means they play more ranked teams? Who'd a thunk it.. Heather can shut her pie hole too. Another SEC hack.....
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
For everyone whining and crying about SEC bias, it isn't SEC bias that moved Oregon and OSU up as the only 3 loss teams above Iowa. This says way more about the perception of Iowa than the SEC-Big10 divide.
For everyone whining and crying about SEC bias, it isn't SEC bias that moved Oregon and OSU up as the only 3 loss teams above Iowa. This says way more about the perception of Iowa than the SEC-Big10 divide.
No b ut as that one writer pointed out, ranking those 6-4 crap SEC teams in the top 25 just sets up what the 24 team playoff will look like. They'll have 8 or 9 teams in there somehow.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
And it certainly didn't help Iowa's case when they "coasted" in the 2nd half of both NW and Purdue.

But that's always been a KG trademark with a Parker defense.
I honestly don't think KF is motivated by the CFP.
We beat NW worse ON the Road than OSU did in the Shoe, and they jumped OSU over us with one more loss. Wouldn't have mattered if we scored again. They have their own metrics..
 

JmM52990

Senior
Jan 3, 2017
285
407
63
Hawk fans I hate to say this but you guys need to drop the ISU game and start playing a quality OOC P4 team for once. You also need to drop 2 of the 3 conference rivalry games so when they schedule there is a better chance you get the good teams on your schedule to boost it. Having 4 trophy games every year against average to terrible teams is going to help you stack wins but they won’t be quality. Last year was Iowa’s first respectable schedule in what a decade?
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,376
4,217
113
Hawk fans I hate to say this but you guys need to drop the ISU game and start playing a quality OOC P4 team for once. You also need to drop 2 of the 3 conference rivalry games so when they schedule there is a better chance you get the good teams on your schedule to boost it. Having 4 trophy games every year against average to terrible teams is going to help you stack wins but they won’t be quality. Last year was Iowa’s first respectable schedule in what a decade?
You Get It Max Greenfield GIF by CBS
 
  • Like
Reactions: JmM52990

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
The weird thing is that Iowa wasn't even mentioned on the show after they showed them at 15. They talked about 1-12 and then the 3 and 4 loss teams that were just outside that group. Iowa wasn't mentioned once after that.
That's because they have NO intention of Iowa getting in regardless. I watched a show yesterday and both Heather and Dumbo ears were on and they talked about both Oregon and OSU as potential teams and NEVER mentioned Iowa and that was when we were ranked ahead of both of them. They knew days ago Iowa wasn't moving up no matter what they did.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Rambler Hawk

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
You arent the brightest bulb. Iowa shouldn't have lost to Minn, it is their fault they lost. Nothing they can do now will matter. I never mentioned any other teams. What they do is irrelevant, because the committee has made their mind up about Iowa. Thanks for tagging along.
Clearly what other teams do SHOULD matter. You saying "what they do doesn't matter" makes you really smart I guess???? I mean it is supposed to matter what all the teams do correct? Not just Iowa, a team that's won their last three games 82-17 and has the number ONE defense in fewest points allowed in the NCAA.Suppose they don't want those SEC / big 12 teams being shut down in the playoffs by lowly Iowa......
 

85Bears

All-American
Aug 31, 2019
6,344
7,036
108
That's because they have NO intention of Iowa getting in regardless. I watched a show yesterday and both Heather and Dumbo ears were on and they talked about both Oregon and OSU as potential teams and NEVER mentioned Iowa and that was when we were ranked ahead of both of them. They knew days ago Iowa wasn't moving up no matter what they did.
I think KF knew in the presser today, and that makes some of his remarks more telling. Athletic depts probably knew the rankings last night or this morning.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
Hawk fans I hate to say this but you guys need to drop the ISU game and start playing a quality OOC P4 team for once. You also need to drop 2 of the 3 conference rivalry games so when they schedule there is a better chance you get the good teams on your schedule to boost it. Having 4 trophy games every year against average to terrible teams is going to help you stack wins but they won’t be quality. Last year was Iowa’s first respectable schedule in what a decade?
Uh, excuse me. We don't get a say in what conference games we play
 

JmM52990

Senior
Jan 3, 2017
285
407
63
Uh, excuse me. We don't get a say in what conference games we play
Yes that’s true but when you have 3 guaranteed rivalries against pedestrian teams your schedule is going to have less spots for the top teams to get placed. Oregon has played OSU 4 times in the last 5 years, Iowa hasn’t played OSU 4 times in the last decade. Taking Minnesota and Nebby off the schedule gives you a chance for the committee to put in a better conference opponent.
 

10001110101

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2003
1,328
1,772
113
Hawk fans I hate to say this but you guys need to drop the ISU game and start playing a quality OOC P4 team for once. You also need to drop 2 of the 3 conference rivalry games so when they schedule there is a better chance you get the good teams on your schedule to boost it. Having 4 trophy games every year against average to terrible teams is going to help you stack wins but they won’t be quality. Last year was Iowa’s first respectable schedule in what a decade?
Or...

the powers that be in college football could stop being corrupt as ****.
 

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,637
5,155
113
He won't be next Year with Iowa returning nearly it's entire roster and at home and mad
In this era, nobody is guaranteed to be back next year. Players will get bigger offers and might feel Iowa cannot make playoffs ever.
Elevating Oregon and OSU ahead of Iowa makes no logical sense and that means no one can trust them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kceasthawk@77

oldxbbc

All-American
Sep 19, 2013
2,167
7,702
113
Was kind of suprised at #15. thought we would be up on or two more. Going to need a lot of help now. Just take care buisness and it is what it is. Still 10-2 on the table and a very good season.
 

trfhawk

Senior
Jul 10, 2020
250
439
63
really is

But infinite mulligans for the blue bloods. Committee is a joke
We knew this would happen. Playoffs suck.. We knew the same old schools would get preference over all the others. The exact scenario is playing out as we feared. 3 and 4 loss Blue bloods would find their way in over 1 and 2 loss other schools.
Nobody left on our schedule is helping our résumé and at this point we have to count on like five teams to lose. It ain’t happening. The party is over.
**** the playoffs.. The old bowl system was better and kept more fans interested for a longer period of time. Almost every SEC team has a guaranteed 4 wins in non- league games. Alabama squeezes past Vanderbilt and moves up. OSU squeezes by NW and jumps 5 spots! Florida State was kept out of the playoffs a few years ago when they were underfeated. OSU qb is hurt and they jump 5 spots beating an average team at home.
 

Anychawk

Junior
Nov 13, 2007
164
309
63
Hawk fans I hate to say this but you guys need to drop the ISU game and start playing a quality OOC P4 team for once. You also need to drop 2 of the 3 conference rivalry games so when they schedule there is a better chance you get the good teams on your schedule to boost it. Having 4 trophy games every year against average to terrible teams is going to help you stack wins but they won’t be quality. Last year was Iowa’s first respectable schedule in what a decade?
Ok fine.
But our schedule included Washington and Michigan. Both teams who were ranked in the top 16 press on but turned out to be not as good. Why are we getting punished cause other teams didn’t play up to expectations? Did they not meet expectations cause they lost to Iowa? Who was expected to be worse. Before the year exactly zero people were saying Iowa had an easy schedule and pointed out the very touch stretch of Washington, Michigan and Ohio state. We beat two out of three.

Out of conference Schedules are made years in advance. If we drop Iowa state and schedule say Texas AM and they turn out to have a worse record than Iowa State would we get more credit for the schedule then? What sense does that make?
 

Doctor Hawktagonapus

All-Conference
Sep 20, 2025
966
1,553
93
Hawk fans I hate to say this but you guys need to drop the ISU game and start playing a quality OOC P4 team for once. You also need to drop 2 of the 3 conference rivalry games so when they schedule there is a better chance you get the good teams on your schedule to boost it. Having 4 trophy games every year against average to terrible teams is going to help you stack wins but they won’t be quality. Last year was Iowa’s first respectable schedule in what a decade?
Why do we need to drop ISU? We could just lose to the lousy B12 team like Oregon did?
 

Hawk-A-Doodle-Doo

All-Conference
Oct 1, 2001
1,005
2,847
93
Who cares about the 4 loss teams? None of them are making the playoffs anyway.
It matters because it is used to artificially prop up the higher tanked SEC teams. A bunch of sh-tty SEC teams lose to each other over and over and remain ranked, giving their upper echelon credit for "ranked" wins. Meanwhile similar Big Ten teams like Illinois, Wisconsin and Northwestern can't even sniff the rankings, which in turn gives the SECFP Committee the ability to rationalize (for lack of a better word) downplaying Big Ten resumes as being bereft of ranked wins.

It's a self-fulfilling vicious cycle prophecy over which they alone have 100% control. They are quite literally making up the rules as they go along.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
Yes that’s true but when you have 3 guaranteed rivalries against pedestrian teams your schedule is going to have less spots for the top teams to get placed. Oregon has played OSU 4 times in the last 5 years, Iowa hasn’t played OSU 4 times in the last decade. Taking Minnesota and Nebby off the schedule gives you a chance for the committee to put in a better conference opponent.
Again, I'm not sure that's up to Iowa. That was set years ago. Not sure why Nebraska is in there either. Someone chime in if we have a say in changing that......
 

iahawkeyes17

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
962
2,396
83
Looking at their schedule. Seriously how is bama #3? 2 losses top 10 but looking at their wins. Kentucky is their best W who plays at mizzou this week. And now I know another reason S Carolina barely dropped and stayed in the rankings it’s bama’s 2nd best win and they play Georgia. I fully expect a 24/25 gamecock team next week at 6-5. But will bama drop if their 2 best wins lose, I’d bet $ no. End of day shouldn’t losses matter? Guess name recognition means more this year.
 
Last edited:

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
Don't lose to MN and show a pulse against OSU and Iowa is in easily. Don't put your outcome in someone else's control
Once AGAIN, WHY is this an Iowa thing? Just answer that. Why does "the committee" not rank teams fairly? That's the question. Good Lord, so Iowa can only get in basically if they only go undefeated but SEC teams can lose 3 or 4 games and sn eak in and once again we have people saying we did this to ourselves. That's pure nonsense.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
True but you don’t have any quality wins so a single loss will hurt the Hawks more.
We played 3 or 4 ranked teams when we played them. Wisconsin coming off bullying USC was ranked and people were talking about them as a playoff team, then we beat them down 30-0 and we get ZERO credit. If Wisconsin wins that game and goes the rest of the way they might have been in. And YET again that Iowa win means literally nothing. Try making that make sense.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
It matters because it is used to artificially prop up the higher tanked SEC teams. A bunch of sh-tty SEC teams lose to each other over and over and remain ranked, giving their upper echelon credit for "ranked" wins. Meanwhile similar Big Ten teams like Illinois, Wisconsin and Northwestern can't even sniff the rankings, which in turn gives the SECFP Committee the ability to rationalize (for lack of a better word) downplaying Big Ten resumes as being bereft of ranked wins.

It's a self-fulfilling vicious cycle prophecy over which they alone have 100% control. They are quite literally making up the rules as they go along.
Best post in the whole thread, because that is the entire issue in a nutshell......
 

yrunvs

Senior
Feb 18, 2012
329
550
93
What most if not all of you are missing is that this is a setup for years to come.

There is no CFP trophy coming to Iowa City this year or forever!
It will not be permitted.
 

yrunvs

Senior
Feb 18, 2012
329
550
93
Looking forward to thrashing another sec team Jan 1 or 2. Want no part of a tainted and crooked tournament.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football PFF Deep Dive: Illinois Fighting Illini
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football PFF Deep Dive: Iowa Hawkeyes
  3. 03 On3 Football College Football Playoff Top 25: Third official 2026 CFP rankings revealed
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Basketball Four numbers to know ahead of Iowa-Montana State
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Football Kirk Ferentz updates injuries, talks Fighting Illini