Past bracket round games that should have been the State Championship game

McCaravan

All-American
Feb 1, 2016
5,592
8,724
113
With the big BR/ESL semi matchup there is the yearly topic of "This should have been the State Championship game". What game in the past can you remember was played in the bracket rounds but truly was the matchup of the two best teams? I'm sure there are many.

Off the top of my head for MC what comes to mind is the 2002 quarterfinal between MC and COM that was clearly the two best teams and an amazing game that was played in the quarterfinals when they did it by region. It was a great game too!!

Loyola/HF in the quarterfinals from several years ago too was an amazing game played too early
 

rocketnation

All-Conference
Aug 12, 2017
1,683
2,672
113
2016 4A Quarterfinals (South)
Rochester (10-1) 48 @ Belleville Althoff (11-0) 47
The 2nd matchup of what would become three straight years of these programs colliding in the playoffs. Althoff had ended Rochester's 5-year title run the year before by a 46-42 score in the Quarterfinals, when the Crusaders defense held on the last drive of the game.

In this contest, Althoff was ahead 47-28 in the 3rd Quarter behind 5 TDs by RB Jaylon Bester before QB Nic Baker and WRs Avante and D'Ante Cox led the Rocket comeback. The game ended on a 4th down sack of the Althoff QB at the Rocket 30-yard line. Rochester would go on to defeat Canton in the semifinals 49-21 and Johnsburg in the final 38-14.

I am a technology Luddite but an excellent video highlight of the game by Sports Radio 1450 is available on YouTube.
 
Last edited:

FB1976

Senior
Aug 26, 2023
324
480
63
2016 4A Quarterfinals (North)
Rochester (10-1) @ Belleville Althoff (11-0)
The 2nd matchup of what would become three straight years of these programs colliding in the playoffs. Althoff had ended Rochester's 5-year title run the year before by a 46-42 score in the Quarterfinals, when the Crusaders defense held on the last drive of the game.

In this contest, Althoff was ahead 47-28 in the 3rd Quarter behind 5 TDs by RB Jaylon Bester before QB Nic Baker and WRs Avante and D'Ante Cox led the Rocket comeback. The game ended on a 4th down sack of the Althoff QB at the Rocket 30-yard line. Rochester would go on to defeat Canton in the semifinals 49-21 and Johnsburg in the final 38-14.

I am a technology Luddite but an excellent video highlight of the game by Sports Radio 1450 is available on YouTube.
Here it is:

 

CCHS-Fan

Senior
Oct 4, 2001
2,113
680
66
The CCHS NG in the MC/CCHS video is a Cronin (bloodlines to St. Rita).

Carmel Catholic drove 95yds on the opening drive and didn’t score. Unreal.

The CCHS team was 14-15 Jr’s and younger.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: RockSoup

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,199
4,599
113
2001 Joliet Catholic @ Riverside Brookfield in front of 10,000+. 56-50
Final. Best game of all time
Amazing game no doubt, but tough to call this one the defacto title game when the actual title game was pretty memorable with Morris pulling out the "lonesome polecat" formation and losing on the last play of the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4Anorth(not4aFan)

mmca

Freshman
Aug 23, 2004
129
96
28
1979 5A Semi, St Laurence won in the final seconds to beat Deerfield 17-14. Deerfield almost returned the kick for a TD.
 

USD24

All-American
May 29, 2001
5,656
5,620
113
Nationally ranked Morris at Joliet Catholic, 1st round Wednesday game in 1990.
I would say the state championship game that year was between the best two teams. JC blew out Morris in the 1st round and needed a game saving tackle in the championship game vs Geneseo to preserve a 21-20 victory. In fact, the Morris game that year was the widest margin of victory of all JCA's playoff games.
 

Running_Clock

Freshman
Nov 18, 2025
53
64
17
I’ve mentioned this one before, but what a game. Mount Carmel vs. Providence in the semis on Nov. 20, 2004. Double OT with a trip to state on the line. It felt like the state title game.

If I remember right, MC went for two and the win, and Providence stuffed ’em.

MC had an up-and-down regular season, but they got hot at the right time. They beat Rita in OT in the first round, and that one was a blast to watch, too.
 

McCaravan

All-American
Feb 1, 2016
5,592
8,724
113
I’ve mentioned this one before, but what a game. Mount Carmel vs. Providence in the semis on Nov. 20, 2004. Double OT with a trip to state on the line. It felt like the state title game.

If I remember right, MC went for two and the win, and Providence stuffed ’em.

MC had an up-and-down regular season, but they got hot at the right time. They beat Rita in OT in the first round, and that one was a blast to watch, too.
100% on this on. Totally forgot about this game. Maybe because it wasn't one of MC's stronger teams but like you said they got hot at the right time, beat Wade Weyer and SR twice that year. They did go for two and I agreed with the call to go for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlabamaTimberwolf
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football Watch: The 3rd and Leng Podcast
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football Watch Live Tonight: WJOL Pigskin Preview
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football 8A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  4. 04 Edgy Tim Football 7A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football 6A: Semifinalist Player of the Year