Collins has to go

SDakaGordie

Junior
Dec 29, 2016
2,629
314
73
I'm not sure Jackson should completely, positively, faithfully retain Collins, SD. Hopefully, there will be an open and honest post-season discussion between MJ and CC about what "went" wrong and whether both of them can adjust in the new world. CC isn't blameless in this whole thing. I wonder how much of a role his post-season meetings have in these departures. I wonder if he's an NIL-era type of guy. But none of us have a clue about those details.

And as I've said, NU is clearly not blameless either. Hopefully the two of them can agree on STRONG, IMPACTFUL changes. A tweak here and there is going to bring the same mediocre (and worse) results.

But I'm not sure this is the highest level of internet BS. I'm loving how Reid and Page are improving after every loss. Either people didn't watch last season or they're forgetting Reid's ole defense and Page's ongoing battles with his effort. Gee, with them, NU could've a .500 team. Whopee. No big loss.

But my personal favorite is the SCREAM for wholesale changes but not at the cost of how NU runs its athletics or the temptation to keep pace with NIL and be competitive. So just get another body and hope for the best despite the CLEAR dive since open NIL has begun. If that's not an old school NU mindset and 90% of the problem since the 60s, I don't know what is.
Thanks for the post; agreed. My point on the internet BS was specifically directed at the Boo claims, et al.
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,397
331
83
I believe that the consensus opinion was that CC was behind the exodus of Paige, Reid, Windham, et al. Singleton may have been an NIL issue.
You might be wrong about your belief. I haven't seen any evidence beyond rumors and wishful thinking that this is true. I have read many posts that want to believe it's true. It is possible Collins wasn't willing or able to match other offers or player salary demands and in that way he was "behind" it.


So now CCC only won because of James?
"Only" sounds like a strawman. It seems reasonable to me to assert that Collins depended/relied on James for the things James brought to the table and now that James has retired, those things are gone and the team will suffer until Collins fixes the problem.


You make a pretty good case that Collins is stubborn and instead of working with the players he had, decided to run them off and gamble on a complete re-roll of talent from the portal.
Not really, but if someone was predisposed to believe all of that regardless the evidence, they might support any case presented and call it good.


If you’re losing at home by 20 to a team that literally doesn’t have NIL, I’m not sure you can say it’s too early to call for someone’s head.
It's too early to call for Collin's head.


You could make a case (and I’m not saying this, but the internet has been so I’ll just throw it out there) that he’s a Boo merchant. He fell backwards into Boo and rode him to two NCAAT appearances… and outside of those years, his program has been a DISASTER for a decade. That’s the case people have made, and I am beginning to disagree with it less and less.
If you don't believe this, why give it any air time?

The 'Boo merchant' is false and Collins history at NU demonstrates that adequately. I'm sure there were people who said he road BMac as well, ignoring, as with Boo, all of the talent surrounding him. One of Collins problems is consistency in his recruiting - he hasn't developed "reload" and "rebuild" takes a long time the traditional way. Now it takes a lot of money every year, too. And I see you've gotten a lot of pushback already for this, sorry I'm late to respond.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,571
4,850
113
You might be wrong about your belief. I haven't seen any evidence beyond rumors and wishful thinking that this is true. I have read many posts that want to believe it's true. It is possible Collins wasn't willing or able to match other offers or player salary demands and in that way he was "behind" it.



"Only" sounds like a strawman. It seems reasonable to me to assert that Collins depended/relied on James for the things James brought to the table and now that James has retired, those things are gone and the team will suffer until Collins fixes the problem.



Not really, but if someone was predisposed to believe all of that regardless the evidence, they might support any case presented and call it good.



It's too early to call for Collin's head.



If you don't believe this, why give it any air time?

The 'Boo merchant' is false and Collins history at NU demonstrates that adequately. I'm sure there were people who said he road BMac as well, ignoring, as with Boo, all of the talent surrounding him. One of Collins problems is consistency in his recruiting - he hasn't developed "reload" and "rebuild" takes a long time the traditional way. Now it takes a lot of money every year, too. And I see you've gotten a lot of pushback already for this, sorry I'm late to respond.
Thanks for condensing all OC your responses into one post.
 

lunker35

Junior
Jan 1, 2010
5,717
237
62
I am suggesting he didn’t have enough money to compete and he knew it. This is what the resources bought. It’s not an intentional tank where he deliberately brought in poor players.

it’s come to Jesus for the Athletic department. They either up the resources to a competitive level of they fire CCC. I believe he has no intention staying at NU if the resources a 1/3 or 1/4 of the top teams in conference. John Wooden isn’t going to win under those circumstances. Either way, firing CCC and not increasing the payroll won’t make NU competitive. It just won’t.
Baseball is in the same boat in that they have a great coach, but are vastly underfunded compared to the rest of the conference. We have so much institutional money why can we not put it towards something that is good for the school and can potentially drive revenue.
 
Jan 7, 2012
734
299
58
Forbes: “Men’s basketball coach Chris Collins was Northwestern’s highest-paid employee in 2024, according to tax returns filed last summer by the University.

Collins earned nearly $4 million in total compensation, a slight increase from earning about $3.8 million in 2023, according to NU’s Form 990 filings.”
 

NJCat

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2016
22,019
2,178
113
Forbes: “Men’s basketball coach Chris Collins was Northwestern’s highest-paid employee in 2024, according to tax returns filed last summer by the University.

Collins earned nearly $4 million in total compensation, a slight increase from earning about $3.8 million in 2023, according to NU’s Form 990 filings.”
So presumably we're talking $12 million to sack him at the end of the year, as he is under contract through the 2029-30 season. Unlikely to happen.
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,397
331
83
Forbes: “Men’s basketball coach Chris Collins was Northwestern’s highest-paid employee in 2024, according to tax returns filed last summer by the University.

Collins earned nearly $4 million in total compensation, a slight increase from earning about $3.8 million in 2023, according to NU’s Form 990 filings.”
So he's what, the fifth lowest paid head coach in the conference?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catmandoo78

macarthur31

Junior
Nov 9, 2006
1,773
397
83
Like waaaay, way better. Jayden Reid was AP NATIONAL player of the week last week for Memphis. And he was ours. I'm sure Collins taught him some good lessons though.
If you picked JReid to stay, then you still needed to pair him with a defensive guard. Did you want Jake West (and three more years of eligibility) to go elsewhere? No, of course not.

Don't get me wrong - JReid was fun to root for when it was good, and he really seemed to have great off-court chemistry with Jake. But, if you wanted Jake West to stay, you had to make it clear that he was going to be the alpha.
 

macarthur31

Junior
Nov 9, 2006
1,773
397
83
Internet BS of the highest order. A few years ago, we were two injuries away (Matt and Ty) from success we’ve never seen before. And are you forgetting Brooks and Matt as part of this “disaster”? Mart may be one of the greatest success stories ever. But the point of it all is - we don’t get brand name players very often if ever, we are never deep enough to withstand injuries, and yet Collins still made us very successful at times and always competitive (despite poorer records at times) save this year (likely due to NIL). Our ride at NU is bumpier than any other school for the reasons we all know - I vote to hold on (again) through the downs with someone who has proven he has the ups.
Apparently Collins was a Barnhizer Merchant and a Martinelli Merchant as well.
 
  • Love
Reactions: SDakaGordie

macarthur31

Junior
Nov 9, 2006
1,773
397
83
I don't totally disagree with the issue that the lows are SO low. It's a reasonable point. But it's NU. And the asterisks are tourney invites. You can't highlight the losing seasons on one hand and just sweep away three NCAA tournaments on the other if you want to be objective.

But it's clear some people don't want that. P*ssing all over this guy after five games is just ridiculous. Yes, it's going to be a bad season. And catch me on the right day, and I can give you many more reasons than you see here why Chrissy has problems. But in the end, he's done his job and far more. He's been here 13 years!! He even stayed with Derrick Gragg who undercut him a few times. And with fan support like this - as we've seen this week - I give the guy a standing ovation for legging it out this long. He has more-than-earned a respectful evaluation.
"The record is what it is." Yep, you get to call this after 15.6% of the season being played. Oh yeah, and they're 3-2.

If you wanna get rid of Collins, fine. However, like Sec says, it's ludicrous to think that someone else is gonna step in here with the same setup and get better results. And if they did, don't get too comfy cause that dude is gonna just using us to get a gig at a place that actually aligns its resources with reasonable expectations.
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,397
331
83
At the same time, Barnhizer is on the OKC Thunder's bench tonight - and he's been there pretty much every game this early in the year, and Nick's not doing too bad professionally either.
 
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Northwestern working to support, improve QB Nicco Marchiol ahead of Minnesota
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Northwestern embarrassed by Columbia, 75-53
  3. 03 Wildcat Report Notebook: Braun looks to snap three-game losing streak at Minnesota
  4. 04 Wildcat Report The 3-2-1 after Northwestern's loss to Ohio State
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Three Wildcat commits crack new Rivals300