OT some things I'd like to see changed in football

pondscum

Redshirt
Jun 18, 2011
7
12
3
First off is to narrow the goalposts by at least 4 feet. To me football is about touchdowns not winning a game with 60 yard field goals. Just make it tougher not ending it. my second rule change would be to not allow spiking the ball. It's just a cheap timeout. third would be to change the rule about the hand moving forward. Many times, this is open to controversy. the rule change would go to is the ball in his hand or not. If it's in that is one thing if out another.
 

eyesofhawk

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2011
3,941
3,665
113
First off is to narrow the goalposts by at least 4 feet. To me football is about touchdowns not winning a game with 60 yard field goals. Just make it tougher not ending it. my second rule change would be to not allow spiking the ball. It's just a cheap timeout. third would be to change the rule about the hand moving forward. Many times, this is open to controversy. the rule change would go to is the ball in his hand or not. If it's in that is one thing if out another.
The sport is literally called "foot"ball and you want to make FG's less prevalent. 🤣

Can't make that up
 
  • Love
Reactions: Pointingdogsrule

LetsGoHawks83

All-American
Mar 20, 2015
4,020
7,972
113
I could maybe see some kind of FG adjustment. The others are non-starters.

Does college allow the kickers to use their own ball? I know that is said to be part of the reason the NFL is getting longer kicks. INFLATE Gate
 

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
985
2,408
93
First off is to narrow the goalposts by at least 4 feet. To me football is about touchdowns not winning a game with 60 yard field goals. Just make it tougher not ending it. my second rule change would be to not allow spiking the ball. It's just a cheap timeout. third would be to change the rule about the hand moving forward. Many times, this is open to controversy. the rule change would go to is the ball in his hand or not. If it's in that is one thing if out another.
Agree with you on the goal posts. Similar to how golf courses had to do something to respond to the new equipment, college football needs to do something similar. Back in the day, a 40 yard FG wasn't automatic and a 50 yarder was pretty much non existent. Not sure it needs to be 4 feet, but maybe start with a foot on each side (2 feet total) and see what happens. I'd also move the extra points back to the 20.

I've never understood spiking the ball. I assume it's specifically called out in the rules, but how is that not grounding?
 

r_desihawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
3,782
5,463
112
A reasonable salary cap for both coaches and players
Separation of church and state i mean espn and cfp
Public performance reviews promotions and firing of officials
 
  • Like
Reactions: DukeSlater

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,667
15,912
113
First off is to narrow the goalposts by at least 4 feet. To me football is about touchdowns not winning a game with 60 yard field goals. Just make it tougher not ending it. my second rule change would be to not allow spiking the ball. It's just a cheap timeout. third would be to change the rule about the hand moving forward. Many times, this is open to controversy. the rule change would go to is the ball in his hand or not. If it's in that is one thing if out another.
So what is your position on this then?
4832.jpg
 
  • Haha
Reactions: PinkShizzle

Fight4Iowa

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
460
651
93
First off is to narrow the goalposts by at least 4 feet. To me football is about touchdowns not winning a game with 60 yard field goals. Just make it tougher not ending it. my second rule change would be to not allow spiking the ball. It's just a cheap timeout. third would be to change the rule about the hand moving forward. Many times, this is open to controversy. the rule change would go to is the ball in his hand or not. If it's in that is one thing if out another.
We were 0-3 last week on field goals, Hassel.
 

LetsGoHawks83

All-American
Mar 20, 2015
4,020
7,972
113
Not on the original list, but since moving the XP back was mentioned... I'd like to do the opposite. Just completed skip the XP.

Score a TD. You can just take the automatic 7 or go for 2.

I hate having a team down 7 late in the game, have a great TD drive... Only to miss and XP and lose by 1.

NFL moved XPs back to reduce overtime games. College has good OT rules that don't result in playing an entire 5th quarter of FB.
 

LIV4GOD

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2001
787
1,719
93
  • Before 1991: NCAA goalposts were 23 feet 4 inches wide, a dimension adopted in 1959.
  • Beginning in 1991: The NCAA narrowed them to 18 feet 6 inches, the same width then used in the NFL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PinkShizzle

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,696
5,372
113
First off is to narrow the goalposts by at least 4 feet. To me football is about touchdowns not winning a game with 60 yard field goals. Just make it tougher not ending it. my second rule change would be to not allow spiking the ball. It's just a cheap timeout. third would be to change the rule about the hand moving forward. Many times, this is open to controversy. the rule change would go to is the ball in his hand or not. If it's in that is one thing if out another.
Take the NFL rule of where the defending team gets the ball if the FG is missed. The teams taking over get the ball at the spot the ball was spotted which is usually 7 yards which is almost first down yardage. So a team trying a 56 yard FG has a line of scrimmage LOS of the 39 yard line. That would change to the 46 yard line for the team taking over.

The question is though what happens when you narrow the goalposts and make FG tried harder, well you get more punts and what is more exciting punts or FGoals made followed by a kickoff. Most punts from the opponents 40 yard line are not that exciting
 
  • Like
Reactions: OnlyTheObscure
Oct 12, 2021
368
661
93
Not on the original list, but since moving the XP back was mentioned... I'd like to do the opposite. Just completed skip the XP.

Score a TD. You can just take the automatic 7 or go for 2.

I hate having a team down 7 late in the game, have a great TD drive... Only to miss and XP and lose by 1.

NFL moved XPs back to reduce overtime games. College has good OT rules that don't result in playing an entire 5th quarter of FB.
If your team can NOT kick an extra point they deserve to lose.
 

KuwaitHawk

All-American
Apr 18, 2004
8,617
9,390
113
I would make offensive pass interference a loss of down because without it it COULD have been an interception or stayed incomplete which in all other situations is ‘loss’ of down.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LIV4GOD

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
985
2,408
93
Not on the original list, but since moving the XP back was mentioned... I'd like to do the opposite. Just completed skip the XP.

Score a TD. You can just take the automatic 7 or go for 2.

I hate having a team down 7 late in the game, have a great TD drive... Only to miss and XP and lose by 1.

NFL moved XPs back to reduce overtime games. College has good OT rules that don't result in playing an entire 5th quarter of FB.
I mean, it is called FOOTball. :)
 

SoDakHawk

Senior
Sep 14, 2006
286
505
93
Every list should begin with changing/getting rid of targeting. Call it a personal foul penalty, 15 yards. A second personal foul results in an ejection.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LIV4GOD

Hawk_4shur

All-Conference
Jan 2, 2009
941
2,238
93
I would like to see them take a very hard look at pre-snap penalties. I'm not sure I even understand offsides, and illegal procedure is simply ponderous. Left guard takes a deep breath and it's a 5 yard penalty, but only after a couple of minutes of finger pointing and referee meetings.
 

Burghawk87

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
985
1,736
93
Penalties almost exclusively favor the offense. I've never understood that. This isn't the 1920s where a high scoring game is 16-12.
 

Madman_1

Senior
Dec 28, 2002
2,377
522
113
First off is to narrow the goalposts by at least 4 feet. To me football is about touchdowns not winning a game with 60 yard field goals. Just make it tougher not ending it. my second rule change would be to not allow spiking the ball. It's just a cheap timeout. third would be to change the rule about the hand moving forward. Many times, this is open to controversy. the rule change would go to is the ball in his hand or not. If it's in that is one thing if out another.

How about they narrow the goalposts to a total inside width of 6 feet. Then, make the points scored equal to the yard line you are kicking the ball from. For example, a ball snapped and held at the 29 yard line for the kick would be worth 29 points!
 

MeetTheFerentzes

All-American
Sep 6, 2022
3,310
6,676
113
The sport is literally called "foot"ball and you want to make FG's less prevalent. 🤣

Can't make that up
Narrowing the goal posts might make FGs less prevalent, but would make them more meaningful with the higher degree of difficulty.

Fewer long FG's would mean more punting (still using the foot) and more going for it on 4th down. I'd say that a majority of football fans would not interpret that as bad overall.
 

MeetTheFerentzes

All-American
Sep 6, 2022
3,310
6,676
113
Not sure that this is a rule change, but I really would like officials to stop interpreting defensive pass interference when there is a poorly thrown (typically underthrown) pass requiring the receiver to suddenly stop or change direction to get to the ball, and the defender who is running step by step with the WR is essentially forced to run into him.

Intentional grounding shouldn't be a spot foul. There should be a 5-yard penalty in addition to the lost yardage and loss of down. It shouldn't be the same as just taking the sack.

Lost yardage from delay of game should not be able to be declined.
 

Gonzo_Bloor

All-Conference
Jun 30, 2025
1,242
3,546
113
Make PI, roughing the passer, and holding calls reviewable/reversable but only by coach's challenge. Both teams get 1 challenge, if they win it, they keep it. If not they lose it and it costs them a TO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PinkShizzle
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Rivals Football Recruiting Four-star Iowa QB commit Chase Grove talks latest experience inside Kinnick Stadium
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Kelvin Bell talks Iowa defensive line development
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Basketball WATCH: Jan Jensen, Hawkeyes recap Vandy, preview Montana State
  4. 04 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Inside the recruitment of No. 12-ranked Grant Duggins: Where things stand with UNC, NC State, Kansas & more
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Basketball Recruiting Keller Daugherty officially signs with Iowa