I don't have any real explanation, but I could see the coaching staff / AD letting them drop to 4A after the last 2 years, and their estimate of the current underclassmen.
I think the real question is what is actually a more difficult road.....
4A- Rochester and SHG (south), Montini (north), Morris (N/S borderline)
5A-Cary Grove and St. Francis (both North)
Assuming Providence wins this week and gets bumped to 6A and Naz wins too and stays 6A, that leaves an interesting question. 4A perhaps more winnable as Cary-Grove looks to be a load next year and SF is always dangerous, but there isn't much of anything in 5A south to stop even an average JCA team from walking to the finals. in 5A, they are 95 percent likely to represent the south in the championship game. In 4A, they would have major barriers before the title game whether they wound up north or south.
Could easily see a case for preferring the 5A path even if CG is the best of all teams in 4A/5A next year. And this is precisely why I think even offering the option to move up is wrong because it is used at least as often for reasons like this (charting the most favorable route) as it is for seriously trying to challenge oneself.
And I am not suggesting JCA would look at playoff routes and choose the softest path. But the fact that they option is even there seems quite ridiculous. It is why I am in favor of getting rid of enrollment based altogether. Let an algorithm put the top 32 regular season teams in 8A and so on. Mount Carmel can play Morris in an 8A semifinal. IC can play WWS in a 7A quarterfinal. Plainfield East can play Wilmington in 4A.