Petition up one year rather than two

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
726
367
51
Right now, if you elect to move up a level, it’s a two year deal. I would think a school would way more likely to take a chance in the next class if it was a year by year thing. By the time summer workouts begin, you know what you have for the upcoming season. Two years out, not so much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DirtySixThirty

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,198
4,599
113
My assumption is they did two years to discourage teams trying to move around to find the most advantageous class. I could be totally wrong.
I interpret it the same way. If it's just one year you'll get teams moving up when they have a good class and back down if they know another team has a better class.
 

rocketnation

All-Conference
Aug 12, 2017
1,682
2,672
113
Any idea on how long this option has been in place and who has utilized?

I can think of only a handful of schools that have petitioned up. East St Louis has probably done it the most. Batavia and Loyola are others which I am aware of but after that am struggling to think of any other schools.

While I agree that the 2-year arrangement cuts down on potential "class shopping", predicting talent over that timeframe and the unknown of injuries have to be deterrents to teams.
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,712
4,442
113
Any idea on how long this option has been in place and who has utilized?

I can think of only a handful of schools that have petitioned up. East St Louis has probably done it the most. Batavia and Loyola are others which I am aware of but after that am struggling to think of any other schools.

While I agree that the 2-year arrangement cuts down on potential "class shopping", predicting talent over that timeframe and the unknown of injuries have to be deterrents to teams.
St. Rita
 
  • Like
Reactions: rocketnation

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
726
367
51
My assumption is they did two years to discourage teams trying to move around to find the most advantageous class. I could be totally wrong.
Not sure on that. You would only move up if you thought you were good enough to win that class. When you move back down, you can only go back to where you belong. I don’t see many examples of a team moving up for an easier path.
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,198
4,599
113
Not sure on that. You would only move up if you thought you were good enough to win that class. When you move back down, you can only go back to where you belong. I don’t see many examples of a team moving up for an easier path.
That's because you don't see many teams petitioning up at all. You could make the argument that Batavia and St. Rita petitoned up to avoid ESL when they were in 6A. The same argument could be made with Loyola moving up to avoid MC when they were in 7A. Not saying any of that is true, but the possibility is there and that's the window that gets opened if you only have to petition up for one year.

Coaches know what they have coming up and could plan to move up in 2 years because they have a phenomenal sophomore class and then move back down as soon as that class leaves. It should require a commitment and not just be able to cherry pick your class based on how easy it would be to win a title.
 
  • Like
Reactions: flyer4life

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
204
189
31
Didn't Antioch and Glenbard South move up to 6A for two years? That would have been 3 years ago and this year we’re back in 5A.

So those 2 and Batavia petitioned up. What other public schools did. I think JCA is back to 5a next year

Also won’t a couple private schools like Fenwick and Providence move up if they make the finals.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave Brody

JCHillmen10

Junior
Jul 29, 2025
196
269
63
That's because you don't see many teams petitioning up at all. You could make the argument that Batavia and St. Rita petitoned up to avoid ESL when they were in 6A. The same argument could be made with Loyola moving up to avoid MC when they were in 7A. Not saying any of that is true, but the possibility is there and that's the window that gets opened if you only have to petition up for one year.

Coaches know what they have coming up and could plan to move up in 2 years because they have a phenomenal sophomore class and then move back down as soon as that class leaves. It should require a commitment and not just be able to cherry pick your class based on how easy it would be to win a title.
Antioch petitioned up to avoid the previously heavy 5A private school field.

Batavia petitioned from 6A to 7A because at the time ESL was limited to only being able to petition to 6A by their league and Nazareth-who has eliminated Batavia 3-4 times in the playoffs-was being success factored into 6A. So avoiding the top ranked Flyers and perpetual thorn in the side Roadrunners made sense when 7A seemed more winnable on the surface. Unfortunately for them, ESL was allowed to petition up to 7A finally this year and Rice became a power.

The two year window is absolutely to avoid the gamesmanship and even it doesn't always work.

Even JCA could have a choice to make next year. They may naturally fall down to 4A. In which case they can pick their route of 4A with Morris, Montini, Rochester, SHG, etc. or they can take a flyer on a 5A field with Cary-Grove and St. Francis because there is a good chance both PC and Naz will be bumped to 6A. I really don't like any self selection of classification because it allows for too much gamesmanship.
 

Wittymoniker1

All-Conference
Aug 6, 2007
5,580
1,947
113
That's because you don't see many teams petitioning up at all. You could make the argument that Batavia and St. Rita petitoned up to avoid ESL when they were in 6A. The same argument could be made with Loyola moving up to avoid MC when they were in 7A. Not saying any of that is true, but the possibility is there and that's the window that gets opened if you only have to petition up for one year.

Coaches know what they have coming up and could plan to move up in 2 years because they have a phenomenal sophomore class and then move back down as soon as that class leaves. It should require a commitment and not just be able to cherry pick your class based on how easy it would be to win a title.
This is why I would encourage Rita to stay in 6A. Take your chances with Batavia, Nazareth, Fenwick, although a very tough task. Forgot the other DuKane schools as well: WWS, Geneva, etc.

Not sure where those 3 schools would belong: South or North region. It changes year to year it seems. Rita would probably always be in the South bracket and definitely face a PC team.
 
Last edited:

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
726
367
51
My assumption is they did two years to discourage teams trying to move around to find the most advantageous class. I could be totally wrong.
Could you use the one year rule to avoid the SF? Let’s say you win a lower level class this year and you are heavily favored to win it next year and will be SFd up for two years. So you move up a level and make it to the finals. Win or loose, you won’t be SFd because your final appearances were not in the same class. The next year you have a less talented team and you drop back down
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,712
4,442
113
Could you use the one year rule to avoid the SF? Let’s say you win a lower level class this year and you are heavily favored to win it next year and will be SFd up for two years. So you move up a level and make it to the finals. Win or loose, you won’t be SFd because your final appearances were not in the same class. The next year you have a less talented team and you drop back down

In this hypothetical scenario I would put a rule in place that you cannot petition up to avoid the SF. So the same class rule does not apply to a petitioned up team and the SF class they would move to would be the higher of the two classes. Or something similar to that.
 
Last edited:
Jul 2, 2025
351
294
63
Even JCA could have a choice to make next year. They may naturally fall down to 4A. In which case they can pick their route of 4A with Morris, Montini, Rochester, SHG, etc. or they can take a flyer on a 5A field with Cary-Grove and St. Francis because there is a good chance both PC and Naz will be bumped to 6A. I really don't like any self selection of classification because it allows for too much gamesmanship.
I don't have any real explanation, but I could see the coaching staff / AD letting them drop to 4A after the last 2 years, and their estimate of the current underclassmen.
 

JCHillmen10

Junior
Jul 29, 2025
196
269
63
I don't have any real explanation, but I could see the coaching staff / AD letting them drop to 4A after the last 2 years, and their estimate of the current underclassmen.
I think the real question is what is actually a more difficult road.....

4A- Rochester and SHG (south), Montini (north), Morris (N/S borderline)
5A-Cary Grove and St. Francis (both North)

Assuming Providence wins this week and gets bumped to 6A and Naz wins too and stays 6A, that leaves an interesting question. 4A perhaps more winnable as Cary-Grove looks to be a load next year and SF is always dangerous, but there isn't much of anything in 5A south to stop even an average JCA team from walking to the finals. in 5A, they are 95 percent likely to represent the south in the championship game. In 4A, they would have major barriers before the title game whether they wound up north or south.

Could easily see a case for preferring the 5A path even if CG is the best of all teams in 4A/5A next year. And this is precisely why I think even offering the option to move up is wrong because it is used at least as often for reasons like this (charting the most favorable route) as it is for seriously trying to challenge oneself.

And I am not suggesting JCA would look at playoff routes and choose the softest path. But the fact that they option is even there seems quite ridiculous. It is why I am in favor of getting rid of enrollment based altogether. Let an algorithm put the top 32 regular season teams in 8A and so on. Mount Carmel can play Morris in an 8A semifinal. IC can play WWS in a 7A quarterfinal. Plainfield East can play Wilmington in 4A.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave Brody

IHSAfan207

Freshman
Sep 9, 2024
120
90
28
Not sure on that. You would only move up if you thought you were good enough to win that class. When you move back down, you can only go back to where you belong. I don’t see many examples of a team moving up for an easier path.
Glenbard South and Antioch did this 3 years ago to try and get away from Naz, JCA, and Carmel in 5A only to have Naz and JCA move up also. Completely back fired, GBS lost 1st round both years by a total of 87 - 23.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SiuCubFan8
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football 8A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football 7A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football 6A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  4. 04 Edgy Tim 5A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football 4A: Semifinalist Player of the Year