Good seasons repeatedly ending in early outs from the tourney won’t satisfy anyone. Mediocre seasons with deep tourney runs satisfy many. Getting better and peaking makes for a fun ride. Cal lost the fun.
March ultimately is how the team is remembered/graded in most fans minds 99% of the time. At least the vast majority of everyday UK fans.
The rare exceptions are 2015 (when they were chasing perfection) and came up short, the whole season is remembered.
The casual fan, much past 5-10 years back, don't remember the regular season. They might remember the REALLY bad losses (Evansville at home, Kansas beating us by 55 in 1989, Vandy beating us by 41 in 2008, Georgia Tech ending our 129 home winning streak in 1955, Penn State in 2000, etc). But otherwise, when asked about seasons a few years removed from memory, people only remember how the team fared in March and not the lumps along the way.
2013-2014 Team is remember for finishing National Runner Up, not for losing 11 games, not for not winning either the SEC title or SEC tournament.
That team lost to Mich St in the Champions Classic that year and BARELY beat Cleveland State in Rupp. Lost to unranked Arkansas (Twice) that year, and ONLY BEAT ONE RANKED TEAM the entire regular season (#6 UofL). People forget that team, despite being loaded with 5 stars, and pre-season #1, was hot buttered arse until they went on a run in the NCAA tourney. A good finish erases the painful start. This coming on the heels of the previous season FIRST ROUND NIT loss to Robert Morris.
Pick a "10 Loss Tubby" year besides his 98 team and try to recall specific "bad losses" in November, close calls to cupcakes, or looking woefully unprepared. Outside of the most die hard fans, most can't from memory. They would have to look it up. And even then, revisionist history takes over.
Our special place in our hearts 1992 squad got blown out of Rupp by unranked Pittsburgh to start the season. My point has nothing to do with Pope as a Coach, recruiter, or person. I'm much more concerned with what we become when it matters.
Compete for the Regular Season SEC Title (Finish Top 4 bare mimimum)
Compete for the SEC Tournament Championship (Play in the Championship Game)
Make the Elite 8
Regardless of who is the head coach. Regardless of what you've done in the past. You can't have 3 consecutive years below the standard and survive here. But I'm less concerned with how close Sister Lucy's School for the Blind played us in October than I am with how we performed on the road against a top 5 team in February. While playing bad before Christmas is concerning, it's not always indicative of the finished product. I try and stay optimistic. Otherwise I'd be miserable watching this team since Covid. Just beat whoever is in front of you (whether by 1 point or 50) and none of the other noise matters.