Barring a Major Let Down, Our Defensive Rankings Should be Enough to Get In

Fight4Iowa

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
438
625
93
There will be some considerable value placed on these stats by the playoff committee at the end of the year if they hold up, I think.

#1 scoring defense in nation
#1 red zone defense in nation


#6 rushing defense in nation
#10 total defense in nation
#14 4th down conversion defense in nation
 

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,331
4,510
113
There will be some considerable value placed on these stats by the playoff committee at the end of the year if they hold up, I think.

#1 scoring defense in nation
#1 red zone defense in nation


#6 rushing defense in nation
#10 total defense in nation
#14 4th down conversion defense in nation
I think they value quality wins over stats.
 

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,466
5,468
113
There will be some considerable value placed on these stats by the playoff committee at the end of the year if they hold up, I think.

#1 scoring defense in nation
#1 red zone defense in nation


#6 rushing defense in nation
#10 total defense in nation
#14 4th down conversion defense in nation
How much the SEC-dominated committee will weigh these impressive facts is debatable, but the effectiveness of the Iowa defense is not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,331
4,510
113
Define Quality? If a team is overrated when beaten is that a quality win? If a particluar set of teams are with bias rated highly can beating them be a claimed "quality" win?
You’re talking to the wrong guy. You can argue that Michigan or Wisconsin or NW were top 25 wins but unfortunately they’re not now. Michigan sucks. Wisconsin just lost Maryland. I’m with you that you can only play who is in front of you. Just keep winning and hope we end up on the right side of things.
 

yrunvs

Senior
Feb 18, 2012
321
540
93
The "newish" CFP format did not fix in any way the previous way of establishing a national champion rather it made it worse. To much subjectiveness. And 12/16/24 teams doesn't matter.

subjectiveness

noun​

  1. Judgment based on individual personal impressions and feelings and opinions rather than external facts.
 

85Bears

All-American
Aug 31, 2019
6,328
6,994
108
They are plying a shell game with “ranked wins“, Michigan and Wisconsin were ranked when Iowa beat them. Michigan just coming off a win over Oklahoma. For the sec they are counting ranked wins when teams are no longer ranked or have four losses.
 

BunchofAholes

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
2,635
4,997
113
I think they value quality wins over stats.
It's entertaining to dig into all the details, but in the end its:

1. What's your record?
2. Who did you beat?
3. Who did you lose to?

1. 10-2 is a good record
2. We have no signature wins. NW and Wiscy sniffed the Top25 briefly but they're both just over .500 now. Michigan was a fraud
3. We have one bad loss
 

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
963
2,381
93
It's entertaining to dig into all the details, but in the end its:

1. What's your record?
2. Who did you beat?
3. Who did you lose to?

1. 10-2 is a good record
2. We have no signature wins. NW and Wiscy sniffed the Top25 briefly but they're both just over .500 now. Michigan was a fraud
3. We have one bad loss
Let's not pretend there isn't an "eye test" element when we know there absolutely is. Especially when evaluating teams with similar records. There's going to be quite a few 10-2/9-3 teams at the end of the year whose resumes are going to look very similar. At that point, I guarantee that the "eye test" is going to play some part in which teams are ultimately picked. And if we can boast a #1 defense, that's going to go pretty far in that room....especially since most of the committee is made up of former coaches that understand the value of a great defense.
 

BunchofAholes

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
2,635
4,997
113
Let's not pretend there isn't an "eye test" element when we know there absolutely is. Especially when evaluating teams with similar records. There's going to be quite a few 10-2/9-3 teams at the end of the year whose resumes are going to look very similar. At that point, I guarantee that the "eye test" is going to play some part in which teams are ultimately picked. And if we can boast a #1 defense, that's going to go pretty far in that room....especially since most of the committee is made up of former coaches that understand the value of a great defense.
Certainly there are tie-breaking factors. I don't know how much of that would be a top defense.. I'd suggest offense carries more weight as it's "sexier". Either way I think strength of schedule, big wins, and bad losses are the ultimate differentiators.

Unfortunately, we don't have any impressive wins. We do have a bad loss. I think the perception of how strong the B1G is overall will play a role. Some suggest that the conference may not get 3 bids this year. Who knows?

Iowa's best hope is to just destroy both Illinois and Nebraska and look like a hot team that's peaking (which I think we are). 21-10 won't do it.
 
Last edited:

JerseyCityHawk

All-Conference
Jul 6, 2025
1,595
2,623
112
There will be some considerable value placed on these stats by the playoff committee at the end of the year if they hold up, I think.

#1 scoring defense in nation
#1 red zone defense in nation


#6 rushing defense in nation
#10 total defense in nation
#14 4th down conversion defense in nation
Agree 💯
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,354
4,167
113
You’re talking to the wrong guy. You can argue that Michigan or Wisconsin or NW were top 25 wins but unfortunately they’re not now. Michigan sucks. Wisconsin just lost Maryland. I’m with you that you can only play who is in front of you. Just keep winning and hope we end up on the right side of things.
Wisconsin losing to Maryland was killer. I think the committee will look for a reason to get Iowa in, but having zero high profile victories is going to be a problem. Wisconsin would’ve finished 9-3 that would’ve been enough in my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ClarindaA’s

Locke

Redshirt
Jul 1, 2025
29
49
13
Nebraska cant score points to save their lives, but they have pretty solid defensive numbers as well. Wonder what the o/u is going to be on BF. 24.5?
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,780
45,729
113
The "newish" CFP format did not fix in any way the previous way of establishing a national champion rather it made it worse. To much subjectiveness. And 12/16/24 teams doesn't matter.

subjectiveness

noun​

  1. Judgment based on individual personal impressions and feelings and opinions rather than external facts.
At least with the computer rankings you could see the data. The committee is just "vibes" because people wanted more "eye test" than the computer models could provide.
 

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,331
4,510
113
Nebraska cant score points to save their lives, but they have pretty solid defensive numbers as well. Wonder what the o/u is going to be on BF. 24.5?
We're going to score at least 28 on Nebraska. Now they might not score, but there aren't many Iowa games that have a 40 over under! Lol.
 

Locke

Redshirt
Jul 1, 2025
29
49
13
We're going to score at least 28 on Nebraska. Now they might not score, but there aren't many Iowa games that have a 40 over under! Lol.
Certainly possible. Especially if the team is completely demoralized by Ohio State. But they haven't given up more than 24 points all season and are averaging 14 ppg. Iowas offense seems to be getting hotter, but they've shown offensive ineptitude at times as well.

Im not expecting a lot of scoring personally. Walk off FG by Iowa as time expires to win 10-7 feels like the type of game we're in store for...
 

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
963
2,381
93
Certainly there are tie-breaking factors. I don't know how much of that would be a top defense.. I'd suggest offense carries more weight as it's "sexier". Either way I think strength of schedule, big wins, and bad losses are the ultimate differentiators.

Unfortunately, we don't have any impressive wins. We do have a bad loss. I think the perception of how strong the B1G is overall will play a role. Some suggest that the conference may not get 3 bids this year. Who knows?

Iowa's best hope is to just destroy both Illinois and Nebraska and look like a hot team that's peaking (which I think we are). 21-10 won't do it.
Agreed on the overall perception of offense being more sexy than defense. And certainly agree on the sentiment to just destroy Illinois and Nebraska! :cool:
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Hawkeyes land top 2028 kicker Dima Petrov
  2. 02 On3 Football College Football Rankings: AP Poll Top 25 after Week 11 released
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football The Chuck Long Podcast
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Inside the rankings on Iowa's 2027 recruiting class
  5. 05 On3 Basketball Women's College Basketball Rankings: AP Poll Top 25 released after Week 2