Football Situational Question

TarVikes1

All-Conference
Nov 23, 2017
758
1,070
93
I was watching the end of the Gates County–North Duplin game last night, and there’s one decision I still can’t wrap my head around.

Gates County was leading 20-12 with a little over a minute remaining. North Duplin had the ball inside its own 20, facing 4th and forever, with either one or two timeouts left.

Instead of going for it, North Duplin elected to punt. Gates County took over, ran out the clock, and North Duplin never got the ball back.

I understand the odds of converting 4th and that long were slim, but punting the ball down eight points with that little time remaining seems like you’re essentially conceding the game.

Am I missing something here? Can anybody give me a logical explanation for that decision?
 

The Patriot

All-Conference
Mar 2, 2022
1,351
2,251
113
All I can think is that the coach figured a turnover (fumbled punt or fumble trying to run out the clock) closer to his opponent’s end zone was a higher probability than going for it on fourth down.
Maybe he thought he could use his timeouts and force a punt and then either block it or run it back.
But all of those options seem like longer odds than going for it.
 

SPRedRaider

Junior
Aug 9, 2025
214
397
63
I was watching the end of the Gates County–North Duplin game last night, and there’s one decision I still can’t wrap my head around.

Gates County was leading 20-12 with a little over a minute remaining. North Duplin had the ball inside its own 20, facing 4th and forever, with either one or two timeouts left.

Instead of going for it, North Duplin elected to punt. Gates County took over, ran out the clock, and North Duplin never got the ball back.

I understand the odds of converting 4th and that long were slim, but punting the ball down eight points with that little time remaining seems like you’re essentially conceding the game.

Am I missing something here? Can anybody give me a logical explanation for that decision?
If punting was my choice I would have instead lined up for a FG. Missed FG goes to the 20 yard line.
 

Anon1751589158

Redshirt
Jul 3, 2025
30
29
13
If punting was my choice I would have instead lined up for a FG. Missed FG goes to the 20 yard line.
Missed FG goes to the 20 only if the ball makes it to the end zone. ND had the ball inside its own 20, so the kicker would have to kick the ball 80 yards to get it to the end zone.

In high school, a FG attempt is treated just like a punt if it fails to make the end zone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SPRedRaider

SPRedRaider

Junior
Aug 9, 2025
214
397
63
Missed FG goes to the 20 only if the ball makes it to the end zone. ND had the ball inside its own 20, so the kicker would have to kick the ball 80 yards to get it to the end zone.

In high school, a FG attempt is treated just like a punt if it fails to make the end zone.
Hmmmm.... I'll look this up. I've 100% seen a missed FG not make the endzone and get spotted at the 20.
 

SPRedRaider

Junior
Aug 9, 2025
214
397
63
Missed FG goes to the 20 only if the ball makes it to the end zone. ND had the ball inside its own 20, so the kicker would have to kick the ball 80 yards to get it to the end zone.

In high school, a FG attempt is treated just like a punt if it fails to make the end zone.
Good call. You are correct. Although, I have seen this misinterpreted in game. I feel better about the rule now.
 

MoDean

Sophomore
Sep 7, 2018
429
193
43
I was watching the end of the Gates County–North Duplin game last night, and there’s one decision I still can’t wrap my head around.

Gates County was leading 20-12 with a little over a minute remaining. North Duplin had the ball inside its own 20, facing 4th and forever, with either one or two timeouts left.

Instead of going for it, North Duplin elected to punt. Gates County took over, ran out the clock, and North Duplin never got the ball back.

I understand the odds of converting 4th and that long were slim, but punting the ball down eight points with that little time remaining seems like you’re essentially conceding the game.

Am I missing something here? Can anybody give me a logical explanation for that decision?
Even if they were successful in forcing a punt, they would have had time for at most three plays, to more than likely go the length of the field...I agree, makes no sense. Gotta go for it there.
 
NC Preps

Latest

  1. 01 NC Preps Deana's Playoff Picks - Round 3
  2. 02 NC Preps Class of 2029 Versatile Prospects Ready to Shine
  3. 03 NC Preps Deana's Playoff Picks - Round 2
  4. 04 NC Preps Two Class of 2029 Playmakers to Watch
  5. 05 NC Preps Deana’s State Football Playoffs Picks