Records of the Top 10 NIL

M.Sherrane

Sophomore
Sep 10, 2026
105
112
43
Coaches Poll RankProgramEstimated NIL money (millions)Record
8Texas$52.00 8-2
14Oregon$51.50 7-3
23LSU$50.756-4
17Ohio State$50.507-3
6Miami$49.509-1
3Notre Dame$49.259-1
UnrankedTexas A&M$48.254-6
16 (before losing to Oklahoma)Ole Miss$43.506-4
11Texas Tech$41.759-1
9Tennessee$41.508-2

It appears that about half of the top NIL programs will miss the playoffs this season and at least one wouldn't make the 24-team playoff next season. Throwing money at an issue doesn't always solve it. Always seems to come down to coaching...
 

Jtung230

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
19,523
12,641
82
Coaches Poll RankProgramEstimated NIL money (millions)Record
8Texas$52.00 8-2
14Oregon$51.50 7-3
23LSU$50.756-4
17Ohio State$50.507-3
6Miami$49.509-1
3Notre Dame$49.259-1
UnrankedTexas A&M$48.254-6
16 (before losing to Oklahoma)Ole Miss$43.506-4
11Texas Tech$41.759-1
9Tennessee$41.508-2

It appears that about half of the top NIL programs will miss the playoffs this season and at least one wouldn't make the 24-team playoff next season. Throwing money at an issue doesn't always solve it. Always seems to come down to coaching...
Unless you are getting an automatic bid, it does matter. The problem for the list is that most of the teams are fighting for the same spot.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,125
90,286
113
#CoachingMatters
I invented that hashtag, and I must be paid a royalty each time it is used. 😜

There is no direct correlation in amount of money spent and ranking.
LSU is a good example. Should have been a plug and play winning situation for them with an experienced coach and large NIL spent. And for them to be ranked with 4 losses is comical SEC bias.

#1 Georgia estimated spend is $31.25M
#2 Utah $22.25M
#4 UCLA $29.5M
#10 Wake Forest $19.75M

#CoachingMatters!!!!!!
 

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,443
13,325
113
I hate to sound like Al but.....I think it's a sliding scale.
Both coaching and money matter.

  • Money can compensate for coaching - to a limit.
  • Coaching can compensate for money - to a limit.

Cignietti at Rutgers with $25m isnt winning a National Championship.
But we would be better than we are now.

Giving Chris Ash $50m isnt winning a National Championship either.
But he would have fallen backwards into better than we were with better talent.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,517
61,834
113
I hate to sound like Al but.....I think it's a sliding scale.
Both coaching and money matter.

  • Money can compensate for coaching - to a limit.
  • Coaching can compensate for money - to a limit.

Cignietti at Rutgers with $25m isnt winning a National Championship.
But we would be better than we are now.

Giving Chris Ash $50m isnt winning a National Championship either.
But he would have fallen backwards into better than we were with better talent.
If both matter then, how did we lose to UMass (est.10x NIL)and Boston College (est. 2.5x NIL) if we have such a superior coaching staff??!!

see: #coachingmatters


BTW - this all came out because of one idiot poster, insisting, unequivocally, that NIL was/is the only thing that “mattered.”
 

M.Sherrane

Sophomore
Sep 10, 2026
105
112
43
Unless you are getting an automatic bid, it does matter. The problem for the list is that most of the teams are fighting for the same spot.

The thing is that none of those teams may get the automatic bid.

ACC: Miami, Wake Forest, and Louisville are most likely in contention for the ACC Championship Game.
Big 12: Utah, Texas Tech, and BYU are the most likely in contention for the Big 12 Championship Game
Big Ten: UCLA, Indiana, Oregon, Ohio State, and Iowa are the most likely in contention for the Big Ten Championship Game
SEC: Georgia, Alabama, and Texas are in contention for the SEC Championship Game

14 teams in contention to play for their conference title and only 5 are in the top 10 spenders.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,125
90,286
113
The thing is that none of those teams may get the automatic bid.

ACC: Miami, Wake Forest, and Louisville are most likely in contention for the ACC Championship Game.
Big 12: Utah, Texas Tech, and BYU are the most likely in contention for the Big 12 Championship Game
Big Ten: UCLA, Indiana, Oregon, Ohio State, and Iowa are the most likely in contention for the Big Ten Championship Game
SEC: Georgia, Alabama, and Texas are in contention for the SEC Championship Game

14 teams in contention to play for their conference title and only 5 are in the top 10 spenders.
Louisville is likely eliminated, unless Wake Forest loses their last 2 games against Ga Tech and Duke, the latter being possible, but anything is possible. If Louisville and Wake Forest both wind up 6-2, Wake Forest beat Louisville head to head. Cool stat- Louisville lost all three of their games by 3 points.
 
  • Like
Reactions: M.Sherrane

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,969
8,945
113
I invented that hashtag, and I must be paid a royalty each time it is used. 😜

There is no direct correlation in amount of money spent and ranking.
LSU is a good example. Should have been a plug and play winning situation for them with an experienced coach and large NIL spent. And for them to be ranked with 4 losses is comical SEC bias.

#1 Georgia estimated spend is $31.25M
#2 Utah $22.25M
#4 UCLA $29.5M
#10 Wake Forest $19.75M

#CoachingMatters!!!!!!
The idea of Lane Kiffin as a head coach is usually better than the reality.
 

B6510

Freshman
Jun 29, 2026
91
85
3
I hate to sound like Al but.....I think it's a sliding scale.
Both coaching and money matter.

  • Money can compensate for coaching - to a limit.
  • Coaching can compensate for money - to a limit.

Cignietti at Rutgers with $25m isnt winning a National Championship.
But we would be better than we are now.

Giving Chris Ash $50m isnt winning a National Championship either.
But he would have fallen backwards into better than we were with better talent.
Unpopular opinion, but I always feel it’s funny that people bring up Chris Ash so much. Not trying to defend the guy, but he came into the program with depleted talent , recruiting sanctions, no money for staff, no connections or understanding of how the state university works, but he still recruited several eventual NFL players and at least tried to run a progressive modern offense. I’d say if he was given $50 million and a SChiano size staff. The results would’ve been much different.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Caliknight

B6510

Freshman
Jun 29, 2026
91
85
3
This argument is slightly twisted. Good coaching wins, good players win. More money gets good coaches and good players. Good coaches plus good players means more wins. The part everyone skips over is what makes a good coach and what makes a good player. What someone costs doesn’t always equate to them being good.
No matter how much money you have if the coach can’t teach and inspire the team won’t reach its potential. No matter how much you pay a player, if he can’t understand what he’s supposed to do then he won’t be effective.
The key is having a coach that can evaluate talent and then teach and inspire them then having the funding to pay what’s necessary to secure that coach. That doesn’t mean the highest costing coach is the best. Then you need players who want to win and are willing to do what it takes. That doesn’t meant he highest paid players are the best for your program. Is finding the right balance. When your broke you can still find value in the bargain the bin and win. Then you once you’re winning you can start shopping at the high end. But you still have to shop for the right fits.
 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,969
8,945
113
Unpopular opinion, but I always feel it’s funny that people bring up Chris Ash so much. Not trying to defend the guy, but he came into the program with depleted talent , recruiting sanctions, no money for staff, no connections or understanding of how the state university works, but he still recruited several eventual NFL players and at least tried to run a progressive modern offense. I’d say if he was given $50 million and a SChiano size staff. The results would’ve been much different.
Would Mehringer still have been the OC? Despite Oregon's talent level, his offense before he got fired was not very good.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,125
90,286
113
Unpopular opinion, but I always feel it’s funny that people bring up Chris Ash so much. Not trying to defend the guy, but he came into the program with depleted talent , recruiting sanctions, no money for staff, no connections or understanding of how the state university works, but he still recruited several eventual NFL players and at least tried to run a progressive modern offense. I’d say if he was given $50 million and a SChiano size staff. The results would’ve been much different.
IDK about that. Don't totally disagree, but some have made the same case for Flood. But in both cases, their own personality defects (Flood-checked out and not working hard enough) and Ash (a punchable face and obnoxious) did nothing to ingratiate them to fans.

That said, Ash's best season was 2017, going 3-6 in the B1G, but losing to a mediocre Eastern Michigan. I was on the field for that pregame, and I remarked about how small the EMU players were. But despite the 3-6, that team got beat 41-0 by a mediocre Indiana, 56-0 to Ohio State and 40-7 by MSU.
 
  • Like
Reactions: redking

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
7,833
9,069
113
I hate to sound like Al but.....I think it's a sliding scale.
Both coaching and money matter.

  • Money can compensate for coaching - to a limit.
  • Coaching can compensate for money - to a limit.

Cignietti at Rutgers with $25m isnt winning a National Championship.
But we would be better than we are now.

Giving Chris Ash $50m isnt winning a National Championship either.
But he would have fallen backwards into better than we were with better talent.
Cignetti almost won a national championship at Indiana in 2024. IU historically is a worse program than RU. And he did that with less than 25M. Why couldn’t he compete with the same level of support at RU? He won because he’s a good coach that knows how to evaluate talent. Money didn’t come pouring in until the following year. Posted similar information multiple times over the last 2 years:


Estimated Spending: $12M–$20M Range
Coach Cignetti’s Direct Estimates: Cignetti addressed outside speculation regarding roster costs, stating that Indiana’s total roster spending was "closer to $15 million" than the $30M–$40M budgets seen at elite programs. He publicly clarified that Indiana was not operating in the upper tier of $25M+ rosters.


Media & Industry Tracking: Valuation reports (such as On3 and local beat reporting) estimated Indiana’s actual total roster cost for their breakout 2024 season to fall between $12 million and $20 million.
 
Last edited:

RobertG

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
13,771
13,488
113
If both matter then, how did we lose to UMass (est.10x NIL)and Boston College (est. 2.5x NIL) if we have such a superior coaching staff??!!

see: #coachingmatters


BTW - this all came out because of one idiot poster, insisting, unequivocally, that NIL was/is the only thing that “mattered.”
We lost because both matter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,443
13,325
113
If both matter then, how did we lose to UMass (est.10x NIL)and Boston College (est. 2.5x NIL) if we have such a superior coaching staff??!!

see: #coachingmatters


BTW - this all came out because of one idiot poster, insisting, unequivocally, that NIL was/is the only thing that “mattered.”

Shows you how big a coaching/roster construction mismatch it was for UMass (and even BC) to easily overcome such a money disparity.

Or why we are unable to overcome even a modest money disparity.

Saying "NW had $2m to spend. No way we can compete with that" just magnifies how poor our coaching is - not excuses it like some seem to think.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,040
108
Shows you how big a coaching/roster construction mismatch it was for UMass (and even BC) to easily overcome such a money disparity.

Or why we are unable to overcome even a modest money disparity.

Saying "NW had $2m to spend. No way we can compete with that" just magnifies how poor our coaching is - not excuses it like some seem to think.
And ‘coaching’, of course, can be split up into multiple buckets. Recruiting, player development, roster construction, game planninggame day management.

It’s hard to say that any of those appear to be managed at a strong level.

Umass literally brought in over 50 new players, including a quarterback that wanted to come here, and got them ‘acclimated ‘quickly and beat the crap out of us.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,517
61,834
113
Shows you how big a coaching/roster construction mismatch it was for UMass (and even BC) to easily overcome such a money disparity.

Or why we are unable to overcome even a modest money disparity.

Saying "NW had $2m to spend. No way we can compete with that" just magnifies how poor our coaching is - not excuses it like some seem to think.
Well, people are morons!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: NickRU714

superfan01

All-American
May 29, 2003
8,832
8,081
78
If both matter then, how did we lose to UMass (est.10x NIL)and Boston College (est. 2.5x NIL) if we have such a superior coaching staff??!!

see: #coachingmatters


BTW - this all came out because of one idiot poster, insisting, unequivocally, that NIL was/is the only thing that “mattered.”
Both do matter obviously. As for umass, Greg clearly whiffed on his portal picks this year. He overpaid for bad players. His evaluation gets an F.
 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,969
8,945
113
And ‘coaching’, of course, can be split up into multiple buckets. Recruiting, player development, roster construction, game planninggame day management.

It’s hard to say that any of those appear to be managed at a strong level.

Umass literally brought in over 50 new players, including a quarterback that wanted to come here, and got them ‘acclimated ‘quickly and beat the crap out of us.
Those poorly managed buckets are most of the reason this team is mediocre. Especially game planning/game day management. That alone kept this team from being 9-3 in 2024, at least 7-5 in 2025, and a mediocre 4-5 so far this season instead of an abysmal and disgraceful 2-7.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,517
61,834
113
Both do matter obviously. As for umass, Greg clearly whiffed on his portal picks this year. He overpaid for bad players. His evaluation gets an F.
Stop. JUST STOP. He STILL should've won that game and done so easily. SMDH. THE FREAKING EXCUSES NEVER END WITH YOU GUYS!!!

BTW - UMass is now #152 in Sagarin with and SOS of 145, at 5-5, while we're sitting at #87 with an SOS of 36 getting boat-raced at home by the former.

COACHING F***ING MATTERS!!!!

(*** sorry for yelling but haven't you had enough of the nonsense by now?)
 

Randal7

All-American
Jul 22, 2009
6,727
6,143
77
Coaches Poll RankProgramEstimated NIL money (millions)Record
8Texas$52.008-2
14Oregon$51.507-3
23LSU$50.756-4
17Ohio State$50.507-3
6Miami$49.509-1
3Notre Dame$49.259-1
UnrankedTexas A&M$48.254-6
16 (before losing to Oklahoma)Ole Miss$43.506-4
11Texas Tech$41.759-1
9Tennessee$41.508-2

It appears that about half of the top NIL programs will miss the playoffs this season and at least one wouldn't make the 24-team playoff next season. Throwing money at an issue doesn't always solve it. Always seems to come down to coaching...
That’s not how you isolate and test a variable.
 

RUBlackout

All-American
Mar 11, 2008
11,112
7,455
113
All I know is if we had more kk eh and spent top dollar we would still lose with this staff AND there would be some new excuses generated as to why we can’t win. It’s been happening for 20yrs!!
 

RUChet

All-Conference
Apr 8, 2023
3,460
4,218
113
I hate to sound like Al but.....I think it's a sliding scale.
Both coaching and money matter.

  • Money can compensate for coaching - to a limit.
  • Coaching can compensate for money - to a limit.

Cignietti at Rutgers with $25m isnt winning a National Championship.
But we would be better than we are now.

Giving Chris Ash $50m isnt winning a National Championship either.
But he would have fallen backwards into better than we were with better talent.
Cignetti with our NIL would have built a more talented roster with better player evals and gotten them to perform at a higher level . Give him our spend and our schedule and he builds a team that at least goes 8-4 if not 9-3
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,703
151,532
113
Cignetti with our NIL would have built a more talented roster with better player evals and gotten them to perform at a higher level . Give him our spend and our schedule and he builds a team that at least goes 8-4 if not 9-3
He lost one game with less NIL his first year. Dude would win a NC with what we offer.
 

matei

Freshman
Feb 16, 2026
46
76
17
If both matter then, how did we lose to UMass (est.10x NIL)and Boston College (est. 2.5x NIL) if we have such a superior coaching staff??!!

see: #coachingmatters


BTW - this all came out because of one idiot poster, insisting, unequivocally, that NIL was/is the only thing that “mattered.”
Right on.
Everyone here acknowledges that coaching AND NIL matter. The problem is when coaching is so bad that it makes NIL irrelevant. That’s what’s happening at Rutgers. The ship is sunk. Can’t patch holes on a boat at the bottom of the ocean.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,040
108
Those poorly managed buckets are most of the reason this team is mediocre. Especially game planning/game day management. That alone kept this team from being 9-3 in 2024, at least 7-5 in 2025, and a mediocre 4-5 so far this season instead of an abysmal and disgraceful 2-7.
And I didn’t even include ‘resourcing/staffing’, meaning hiring and in particular the 2 most important positions, OC and DC.

We tried to outline the domino effect of the following but some would not listen as the NIL Manifesto does allow for such ‘radical’ thinking:
  • Damage from replacing DC 2 years in a row
  • Damage for taking 60+ days to hire a DC because 1) DC couldn’t help recruit, 2) opportunity cost of Greg distracted so he couldn’t go 100% on recruiting and 3) who wants to commit to no DC?
  • Damage from hiring an OC (Gleason) he was not compatible with
  • Potential* damage for having to take a big risk on a 300k coach by giving him a guaranteed 4.2 million dollar contract
*At least this hasn’t fallen apart yet but IMO, it was a very big risk that most head coaches don’t need to take.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kandy11

AdventureHasAName

All-Conference
Mar 1, 2022
1,991
2,113
113
Cignetti with our NIL would have built a more talented roster with better player evals and gotten them to perform at a higher level . Give him our spend and our schedule and he builds a team that at least goes 8-4 if not 9-3
That's swell. He's not available. Rutgers has to choose from the list of available candidates who are willing to take the job for the salary available, assistant coaching salary resources available, available NIL money to spend, and infrastructure already in place. Are there coaches who will take the job? Almost certainly. Are they statistically more likely to have a better on-field result than Schiano? No. And if the answer is "no," then you have to be 100% certain you've got the guy or the $25ish million to buyout Schiano (and staff) becomes an epic waste of money.

The problem is there is no "the guy" (100% certainty of dramatic improvement) that will both (a) take the job for available salary and (b) be worth the $25 million buyout. You're far more likely to hire another Ash than you are to hire the next Cignetti. And the current Cignetti is not leaving his (better) job to come here.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: AreYouNUTS

RUChet

All-Conference
Apr 8, 2023
3,460
4,218
113
That's swell. He's not available. Rutgers has to choose from the list of available candidates who are willing to take the job for the salary available, assistant coaching salary resources available, available NIL money to spend, and infrastructure already in place. Are there coaches who will take the job? Almost certainly. Are they statistically more likely to have a better on-field result than Schiano? No. And if the answer is "no," then you have to be 100% certain you've got the guy or the $25ish million to buyout Schiano (and staff) becomes an epic waste of money.

The problem is there is no "the guy" (100% certainty of dramatic improvement) that will both (a) take the job for available salary and (b) be worth the $25 million buyout. You're far more likely to hire another Ash than you are to hire the next Cignetti. And the current Cignetti is not leaving his (better) job to come here.
We have to try something as Schiano is clearly not the answer unless you are happy with 2-10
 

AdventureHasAName

All-Conference
Mar 1, 2022
1,991
2,113
113
We have to try something as Schiano is clearly not the answer unless you are happy with 2-10
I'm not happy with 2 and 10. I'd be far less happy with 2 and 10 that costs an additional $25 million. I'd even be less happy with 4 and 8 that costs an additional $25 million. And frankly, what I'm happy with (or even what Tate and Zinn are happy with) is irrelevant ... you can't get blood from a stone. There is no money for the buyout.
 

RUChet

All-Conference
Apr 8, 2023
3,460
4,218
113
I'm not happy with 2 and 10. I'd be far less happy with 2 and 10 that costs an additional $25 million. I'd even be less happy with 4 and 8 that costs an additional $25 million. And frankly, what I'm happy with (or even what Tate and Zinn are happy with) is irrelevant ... you can't get blood from a stone. There is no money for the buyout.
We will never know until we try. It’s been incorrectly reported we need $80m+. We don’t need it all at once. It’ll be paid over time.

but there is a cost to not making a change as revenues will continue to drop. Boosters will get less interested.

It’s a fair argument to make RU will be worse off economically longer term by brining him back
 

AdventureHasAName

All-Conference
Mar 1, 2022
1,991
2,113
113
We will never know until we try. It’s been incorrectly reported we need $80m+. We don’t need it all at once. It’ll be paid over time.

but there is a cost to not making a change as revenues will continue to drop. Boosters will get less interested.

It’s a fair argument to make RU will be worse off economically longer term by brining him back
Not 80. It's about 25 million (counting the assistant salaries) to do it today. And we don't have it. If we did; there'd be a new coach. It might be 80 if you are going to pay hire the type of coach you want (name coach who has won as head coach at other schools) and have to come up with the salary, assistant salaries, NIL commitments, infrastructure upgrades, etc. But we don't have 25, so we sure as hell don't have 80.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano talks Penn State game week
  3. 03 The Knight Report Almost Six Years Later, Rutgers - Houston Signifies a Pivotal Moment Once Again
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Albany Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball topples Albany with dominant second half