Beamer back on the warm seat?

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
Conventional wisdom was that he saved his job with the 4-game win streak, which is probably true. Except...we just got absolutely boat raced by one of the worst teams in the SEC. If we just played sloppy and lost a close game on the road without our starting QB, then you could blame it on all the parity that's bitten everyone else this season. But we go absolutely manhandled, bullied and pushed around at every position on the field the entire night. Start to finish. Given the stakes, it goes in the collection of worst losses in our history. The magnitude, timing and manner of the loss was such that it erased all good vibes from the 4-game win streak. We can't even chalk it up to just Sellers being out. It was an obliteration. Even when were losing 3 straight conference games, our fan base had Arkansas circled as the one game we could look forward to as a win.

Next we are going to get blown out by UGA. Not might. Will. Mark it down. We're a 16 point dog....at home. UGA shoved Mizzou in a locker and had the game sewn up in the first quarter. We will not be competitive with them. UGA is very highly motivated right now and it shows in their play.

If the team spirals into Death Valley and stumbles to a loss there, it will make things interesting. We'll have a losing conference record at 4-5 and a season that include two 3-game losing streaks.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Gr8spur

SouthernBelly

Senior
Sep 16, 2024
1,050
799
113
I highly doubt it. I think he would only have been in danger with another 4-8 or worse. And not completely convinced in that case. Don’t know what kind of money does or doesn’t exist but just don’t think they could afford a change over in staff.

Regarding UGA. That Auburn loss was the worst thing that could have happened to the rest of college football. You see that with national championship teams, where they take a bad loss and then lock in even more. Kirby was worried about that game going into because his team was worn down. Got their bye the following week and now nobody really wanna play them.
 

nlstanford

Joined Sep 9, 2002
Sep 9, 2002
330
868
73
Firing coaches every 5 years isn’t the answer. Trust the coach. Give him time.
Or look at what has been successful this season (read: offensive line play and play calling), keep that part intact, and cull the rest.

I’m all onboard for promoting Briles and shedding Beamer.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
Firing coaches every 5 years isn’t the answer. Trust the coach. Give him time.

1. 5 years is above average for college football coaches tenure.

2. Its been 6 years now.

3. Muschamp got 5 years, the guy before him 11, and the guy before him 6.

So one coach in the last 4 only got 5 years. Why do we keep hearing "firing a coach every 5 years......"
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
Conventional wisdom was that he saved his job with the 4-game win streak, which is probably true. Except...we just got absolutely boat raced by one of the worst teams in the SEC. If we just played sloppy and lost a close game on the road without our starting QB, then you could blame it on all the parity that's bitten everyone else this season. But we go absolutely manhandled, bullied and pushed around at every position on the field the entire night. Start to finish. Given the stakes, it goes in the collection of worst losses in our history. The magnitude, timing and manner of the loss was such that it erased all good vibes from the 4-game win streak. We can't even chalk it up to just Sellers being out. It was an obliteration. Even when were losing 3 straight conference games, our fan base had Arkansas circled as the one game we could look forward to as a win.

Next we are going to get blown out by UGA. Not might. Will. Mark it down. We're a 16 point dog....at home. UGA shoved Mizzou in a locker and had the game sewn up in the first quarter. We will not be competitive with them. UGA is very highly motivated right now and it shows in their play.

If the team spirals into Death Valley and stumbles to a loss there, it will make things interesting. We'll have a losing conference record at 4-5 and a season that include two 3-game losing streaks.

No, he saved his job with win #6. We probably move forward with the basketball buyout this year.

Beamer gets another year and Donati can spread out the buyouts.
 

RL09

All-Conference
Dec 29, 2025
1,167
1,341
113
I agree with 18istheman, it is very difficult to see the Gamecocks staying on the field with Georgia this week, I was surprised to see how badly they defeated Mizzou. The interesting part for me is the game with Clemson, if we lose against the Tigers, as bad as they are, that would place the Gamecocks at 6-6, is that enough for this AD to keep him. Hopefully we won't have to see because the Gamecocks find a way to win that game.
 

Deathstar

Senior
Sep 6, 2026
755
576
93
We would like to fire Beamer, but we simply cannot afford to pay all of the buyouts if we do it. Beamer got the kind of coaching contract that others can only dream of.
 

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,771
1,542
113
1. 5 years is above average for college football coaches tenure.

2. Its been 6 years now.

3. Muschamp got 5 years, the guy before him 11, and the guy before him 6.

So one coach in the last 4 only got 5 years. Why do we keep hearing "firing a coach every 5 years......"
Because two of those were Lou Holtz and Steve Spurrier. Any other names and the braintrust would have fired them too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
First of all, no way we lose to Clemson this year. Mark it down.

My thinking is that we won't fire Beamer this year because of the buyout. That said, I know little and claim less.

What would I do? I would send Beamer packing and make Briles Head Coach, starting off at a ridiculous low salary to save money. Once he would prove himself, then raise him accordingly. He would retain some of the current staff to save money. If we fire Beamer at the end of the year, we save more money.

The bottom-line is I don't trust Beamer to get the job done in the long run. Briles has saved Beamer this season. Briles won't be here long. I don't believe that Beamer can make a good OC hire. I consider Briles a Donati hire (they both were at TCU at the same time). Donati has his fingerprints all over the football program. Beamer had not fired coaches in mid-season until last year when he fired 2. Last year was Donati's first here. Coincidence? I don't believe in coincidences. What's going to happen when Briles leaves?

I guess we can roll the dice for another year with Beamer. But I don't like that. This is Beamer's 6th season here. Shouldn't we be further along in Year 6? Yes. Some want to say "look at our history". BS If we had hired someone who was a proven Head Coach, I could buy that excuse. But we instead hired a "Nepo baby" who did not even have Offensive or Defensive Coordinator experience, much less Head Coaching experience. We need to confess that we rolled the dice on someone hoping he was a "chip off the old block". It failed. We need to correct. Beamer does not give us a "coaching edge". We need that. It's not personal. it's business. But I have no say so.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
Because two of those were Lou Holtz and Steve Spurrier. Any other names and the braintrust would have fired them too.

I know some people like to say that, but Spurrier didn't have a single losing season his first 5 years, and what would be this year (his 6th) he won 9 games and the division.

Holtz is a maybe. After taking over and going 0-11, he had 8 and 9 wins in years 2 and 3. Than two 5 win seasons and his last year, 6 wins.

But the fact remains, 6 years, 5 years, 11 years, then 6 years does not constitute "every 5 years".
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
First of all, no way we lose to Clemson this year. Mark it down.

My thinking is that we won't fire Beamer this year because of the buyout. That said, I know little and claim less.

What would I do? I would send Beamer packing and make Briles Head Coach, starting off at a ridiculous low salary to save money. Once he would prove himself, then raise him accordingly. He would retain some of the current staff to save money. If we fire Beamer at the end of the year, we save more money.

The bottom-line is I don't trust Beamer to get the job done in the long run. Briles has saved Beamer this season. Briles won't be here long. I don't believe that Beamer can make a good OC hire. I consider Briles a Donati hire (they both were at TCU at the same time). Donati has his fingerprints all over the football program. Beamer had not fired coaches in mid-season until last year when he fired 2. Last year was Donati's first here. Coincidence? I don't believe in coincidences. What's going to happen when Briles leaves?

I guess we can roll the dice for another year with Beamer. But I don't like that. This is Beamer's 6th season here. Shouldn't we be further along in Year 6? Yes. Some want to say "look at our history". BS If we had hired someone who was a proven Head Coach, I could buy that excuse. But we instead hired a "Nepo baby" who did not even have Offensive or Defensive Coordinator experience, much less Head Coaching experience. We need to confess that we rolled the dice on someone hoping he was a "chip off the old block". It failed. We need to correct. Beamer does not give us a "coaching edge". We need that. It's not personal. it's business. But I have no say so.


If we beat Clemson, that will be 7 wins. I agree with you about the long term prospects of nepo baby, but I cant see firing him after 7 wins.

What i would hope at that point, is some sort of nominal extension tied to a more realistic buyout. We cant be held ransom to this horrible contract when/if Shane falls back to a losing season(s).

If youre hoping for long term success with this staff, i suppose we can hope Donati does all the hiring for Shane. Because like you, I believe he had more than just a hand in some of the staff turnover that has helped us so much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyMcK

SouthernBelly

Senior
Sep 16, 2024
1,050
799
113
1. 5 years is above average for college football coaches tenure.

2. Its been 6 years now.

3. Muschamp got 5 years, the guy before him 11, and the guy before him 6.

So one coach in the last 4 only got 5 years. Why do we keep hearing "firing a coach every 5 years......"
Idk why we keep hearing that either, especially when the coaches who were fired after five years should have been. Woods, Scott, Muschamp. All started off well and were doing worse by year five, the latter two considerably so. Beamer is going to get at least 7 years.
 
Last edited:

SouthernBelly

Senior
Sep 16, 2024
1,050
799
113
I know some people like to say that, but Spurrier didn't have a single losing season his first 5 years, and what would be this year (his 6th) he won 9 games and the division.

Holtz is a maybe. After taking over and going 0-11, he had 8 and 9 wins in years 2 and 3. Than two 5 win seasons and his last year, 6 wins.

But the fact remains, 6 years, 5 years, 11 years, then 6 years does not constitute "every 5 years".
Holtz wasn’t going to be fired, but not because of his name. He got 6 wins in year 5, that will always keep you at SC. The only thing I could possibly see is him being approached about retirement due to the chaos at the end of the year with the Clemson brawl and then several players breaking into the football offices after the self-imposed bowl suspension announcement.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,144
3,709
113
With 6 wins, Beamer is safe for at least another year. If he can find another win, UGA or Clemson, he will be at 7 wins with 2 big wins (Tenn and UGA or Clemson) and the fans will be fired up for next season. "WAIT TIL NEXT YEAR" will be the cry of the land from December until August.

I'm not sure UGA blows us out. If Sellers can play, mobile QBs have always been a problem for Kirby's defense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

PrestonyteParrot

All-Conference
May 28, 2024
3,480
3,417
113
Lose your last game and the previous four wins are forgotten. You're only as good as your last game so they say.
So, I guess that means beat Clemson and he's good.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
What i would hope at that point, is some sort of nominal extension tied to a more realistic buyout. We cant be held ransom to this horrible contract when/if Shane falls back to a losing season(s).
Donati is an educated attorney. I would be very surprised and disappointed if he pulled a "Tanner". He needs to correct Tanner's blunder. And if Shane does not like it, he can leave for another school that wants him as Head Coach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
Donati is an educated attorney. I would be very surprised and disappointed if he pulled a "Tanner". He needs to correct Tanner's blunder. And if Shane does not like it, he can leave for another school that wants him as Head Coach.

How do you correct a standing contract?
 

Gamecock Jacque

Joined Dec 20, 2020
Jan 30, 2022
5,933
5,406
113
I know some people like to say that, but Spurrier didn't have a single losing season his first 5 years, and what would be this year (his 6th) he won 9 games and the division.

Holtz is a maybe. After taking over and going 0-11, he had 8 and 9 wins in years 2 and 3. Than two 5 win seasons and his last year, 6 wins.

But the fact remains, 6 years, 5 years, 11 years, then 6 years does not constitute "every 5 years".
OK. Changing every 5 years to every 6 years will make everybody happy.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Lurker123

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,144
3,709
113
OK. Changing every 5 years to every 6 years will make everybody happy.
I've been on the "keep him" train for a while. I don't see the point in firing him. After 50 years of watching gamecock football, I have come to the conclusion that who the coach is really isn't that important. If a coach can win about half of his games and throw in a couple 8+ win seasons, that is about all SC fans can really hope for.

Everyone needs to be honest with themselves.
 

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,874
3,739
113
His job is safe this year, whether he goes 7-5 or 6-6. But I would hate to see a .500 or .583 season rewarded with a significant raise and extension that puts you back in the exact same "impossible buyout" situation next year. A 6-6 or 7-5 record isn't going to turn him into a hot prospect this year, no matter what his agent tells the AD. So, let's both (he and the AD) agree that we're going to move forward in the comfortable middle ground that exists between a hot seat and irrational exuberance.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,144
3,709
113
His job is safe this year, whether he goes 7-5 or 6-6. But I would hate to see a .500 or .583 season rewarded with a significant raise and extension that puts you back in the exact same "impossible buyout" situation next year. A 6-6 or 7-5 record isn't going to turn him into a hot prospect this year, no matter what his agent tells the AD. So, let's both (he and the AD) agree that we're going to move forward in the comfortable middle ground that exists between a hot seat and irrational exuberance.
One thing you can fully count on in life is that there will be irrational exuberance about gamecock football next August. Every portal pickup will be a "huge get", every true freshman will "bring immediate help" to his position, if Sellers returns, he will be "poised for a Heisman run", if Sellers doesn't return, some untested QB will be a "game changer for the offense", the RBs and WRs will be much better than last season, the D will be loaded.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
I've been on the "keep him" train for a while. I don't see the point in firing him. After 50 years of watching gamecock football, I have come to the conclusion that who the coach is really isn't that important. If a coach can win about half of his games and throw in a couple 8+ win seasons, that is about all SC fans can really hope for.

Everyone needs to be honest with themselves.

Giving up is just so distasteful.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,144
3,709
113
Giving up is just so distasteful.
I don't look at it as giving up, I look at it as accepting reality. Pretty much everyone has to accept reality in many phases of life. Not becoming a touring pro in golf, an NFL or MLB player, a titan of industry or recording or movie star are all things many people end up accepting. It doesn't mean they give up on things they enjoy. They realize they are only going to be so successful at those things and they are much happier when they accept reality.

That is what I have done.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
I don't look at it as giving up, I look at it as accepting reality. Pretty much everyone has to accept reality in many phases of life. Not becoming a touring pro in golf, an NFL or MLB player, a titan of industry or recording or movie star are all things many people end up accepting. It doesn't mean they give up on things they enjoy. They realize they are only going to be so successful at those things and they are much happier when they accept reality.

That is what I have done.

Tomato, potato
 

Jonesz2

Joined Aug 9, 2005
Aug 9, 2005
1,821
2,333
113
1. 5 years is above average for college football coaches tenure.

2. Its been 6 years now.

3. Muschamp got 5 years, the guy before him 11, and the guy before him 6.

So one coach in the last 4 only got 5 years. Why do we keep hearing "firing a coach every 5 years......"
Right. Stop talking fire and get behind the coach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyMcK

Harvard Gamecock

All-Conference
May 5, 2014
3,465
3,183
113
The problem with Beamer is that after all of these years as HBC here he is still making seriously stupid coaching mistakes. He has learned nothing in all of these years coaching here. Clock management? No! Smart play calling? No! Game strategy? No!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rob Hawk

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
The problem with Beamer is that after all of these years as HBC here he is still making seriously stupid coaching mistakes. He has learned nothing in all of these years coaching here. Clock management? No! Smart play calling? No! Game strategy? No!
Spot on.
 

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,771
1,542
113
One thing you can fully count on in life is that there will be irrational exuberance about gamecock football next August. Every portal pickup will be a "huge get", every true freshman will "bring immediate help" to his position, if Sellers returns, he will be "poised for a Heisman run", if Sellers doesn't return, some untested QB will be a "game changer for the offense", the RBs and WRs will be much better than last season, the D will be loaded.
Of course there will be. Same for everyone.

The problem, if we want to call it that, is when the consumer buys into it as if it were gospel. Beamer makes his statement about watching the CFP standings a year hence and the consumer takes it as the sermon on the mount. Then if they don’t get what they expected from Santa they have hissy fits and tantrums.

Fandom would be quite boring without anticipation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyMcK

Deathstar

Senior
Sep 6, 2026
755
576
93
I don't look at it as giving up, I look at it as accepting reality. Pretty much everyone has to accept reality in many phases of life. Not becoming a touring pro in golf, an NFL or MLB player, a titan of industry or recording or movie star are all things many people end up accepting. It doesn't mean they give up on things they enjoy. They realize they are only going to be so successful at those things and they are much happier when they accept reality.

That is what I have done.
You are right about this place. The problems here are at the institutional level. Our school has been putting a mediocre football product on the field for over 100 years. They can almost never hire the right coach, if they replace Beamer they may actually hire someone who is worse than Beamer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyMcK

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,874
3,739
113
One thing you can fully count on in life is that there will be irrational exuberance about gamecock football next August. Every portal pickup will be a "huge get", every true freshman will "bring immediate help" to his position, if Sellers returns, he will be "poised for a Heisman run", if Sellers doesn't return, some untested QB will be a "game changer for the offense", the RBs and WRs will be much better than last season, the D will be loaded.
Sure, and that's fine for fans. I'm referencing irrational exuberance on the part of administrations in giving coaches huge raises and extensions based on either average results or good results from a small data set. Sometimes coaches merely "meet expectations" rather than "exceed" or "fail to meet." Meeting means you kept your job, but it doesn't warrant a substantial boost to your contract.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 GamecockCentral Football Details you may have missed: South Carolina vs. Arkansas
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Football Insider Mailbag Vol. 12: Briles and Sellers, what's next for South Carolina
  3. 03 GamecockCentral Football South Carolina remains in College Football Playoff rankings after Arkansas loss
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Womens Basketball Photos: Gamecocks roll past FGCU in home opener
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Womens Basketball South Carolina women's basketball: Rapid Reaction - FGCU