Rigorous, close to infallible science in action

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,126
5,816
113


Very similar to silly climate change projections for which Lefties want us to spend trillions of dollars.


So re population expansion, the doomsday scenario didn't occur, in large part, because humans changed their behavior?

And you want to apply that to climate science by saying that, in order to avoid a doomsday scenario, humans need to change their behavior?

DailyBuck7 is not a smart man.
 

pjhawk

All-American
Oct 13, 2001
1,997
5,849
113


Very similar to silly climate change projections for which Lefties want us to spend trillions of dollars.

Did you make it past middle school let alone high school?

You people are logical fallacy machines, no reasoning skills.

What does the one have to do with the other? Was this the scientific consensus in 1960 or the conclusions of one paper? Related to what the one has to do with they other, why would the projections by someone in this field have anything at all to do with the projections by those in the climate science field?
 

fsu1jreed

Heisman
Apr 1, 2002
9,896
17,905
113
Did you make it past middle school let alone high school?

You people are logical fallacy machines, no reasoning skills.

What does the one have to do with the other? Was this the scientific consensus in 1960 or the conclusions of one paper? Related to what the one has to do with they other, why would the projections by someone in this field have anything at all to do with the projections by those in the climate science field?

they're MAGA, they don't need no book learning
 
  • Like
Reactions: flotiger and pjhawk

DailyBuck7

Senior
Mar 4, 2026
759
705
93
Did you make it past middle school let alone high school?

You people are logical fallacy machines, no reasoning skills.

What does the one have to do with the other? Was this the scientific consensus in 1960 or the conclusions of one paper? Related to what the one has to do with they other, why would the projections by someone in this field have anything at all to do with the projections by those in the climate science field?
Because "climate science" is based on projections far into the future of doom pretty much the same as this. Notwithstanding the many times that future predictions of doom have not occurred. If you weren't a dumb*ss, you would understand this. For instance, Al Gore predicted that Arctic sea ice would disappear around 2015. Of course, Obama chose John holdren, a failure, as his science of advisor and one of Holdren's failed predictions was that climate change would cause a billion deaths by the year 2020.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatpiggy

DailyBuck7

Senior
Mar 4, 2026
759
705
93
What significant evidence? Two opinion from news channels?
Doubling down and working hard to be extremely stupid. Here are the so-called opinion news channels I cited:
"
Several prominent scientists, including respected microbiologists support the lab Leak theory
1. Richard Ebright — Rutgers University. A prominent molecular biologist and professor of chemistry and chemical biology. In testimony before the U.S. Senate on June 18, 2024, he stated that a large preponderance of the evidence indicates that SARS-CoV-2 entered humans through a research-related incident. He has been particularly critical of risky coronavirus research and inadequate laboratory safeguards
Robert Redfield — Former director of the CDC (2018–2021). A virologist and infectious-disease researcher who believes the virus originated in a Wuhan laboratory. In an August 9, 2026, CNN interview, Redfield said, "I don't have any question as a virologist that this virus came from the lab." He has suggested that laboratory research could have increased the virus's ability to infect humans"

Former director of CDC who stated that there was no question that the virus came from the lab. Also, the FBI and CIA thought that covid most likely came from the lab. This is only part of the evidence. You of course, put your head in the sand and in your narrow bubble believe whatever you want to believe is true. As I said before, I don't deny that there is a lot of evidence going the other way but what I am saying is that there is substantial evidence going both ways.
 

fsu1jreed

Heisman
Apr 1, 2002
9,896
17,905
113
Doubling down and working hard to be extremely stupid. Here are the so-called opinion news channels I cited:
"
Several prominent scientists, including respected microbiologists support the lab Leak theory
1. Richard Ebright — Rutgers University. A prominent molecular biologist and professor of chemistry and chemical biology. In testimony before the U.S. Senate on June 18, 2024, he stated that a large preponderance of the evidence indicates that SARS-CoV-2 entered humans through a research-related incident. He has been particularly critical of risky coronavirus research and inadequate laboratory safeguards
Robert Redfield — Former director of the CDC (2018–2021). A virologist and infectious-disease researcher who believes the virus originated in a Wuhan laboratory. In an August 9, 2026, CNN interview, Redfield said, "I don't have any question as a virologist that this virus came from the lab." He has suggested that laboratory research could have increased the virus's ability to infect humans"

Former director of CDC who stated that there was no question that the virus came from the lab. Also, the FBI and CIA thought that covid most likely came from the lab. This is only part of the evidence. You of course, put your head in the sand and in your narrow bubble believe whatever you want to believe is true. As I said before, I don't deny that there is a lot of evidence going the other way but what I am saying is that there is substantial evidence going both ways.

Where's the evidence? None of that is evidence.......it's their opinions. I want to see the peer-reviewed paper showing the evideence.......and CNN is an opinion channel. Here's 4 lines of evidence showing it was natural........now show me yours

Scientific papers and health organizations favor a natural zoonotic spillover origin for COVID-19, though a laboratory accident has not been definitively ruled out. [1, 2]

Key Papers and Reports Supporting Natural Origin (Zoonotic Spillover)
    • "The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2" (Nature Medicine, 2020): One of the earliest and most-cited genomic analyses arguing that SARS-CoV-2 has natural evolutionary features rather than being engineered in a lab. [1]
    • "The Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan was the early epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic" (Science, 2022): Geospatial and genomic studies showing that early human cases and positive environmental/animal samples clustered heavily around specific stalls in Wuhan's Huanan Market. [1, 2, 3]
    • Cell Critical Review (2021): A peer-reviewed evaluation by international virologists concluding that natural animal-to-human transmission is statistically and biologically far more probable than a lab leak. [1]
    • WHO / SAGO Reports (most recently updated through 2025): The World Health Organization's Scientific Advisory Group for the Origins of Novel Pathogens concluded that zoonotic spillover remains the most scientifically supported hypothesis, while noting that a lab leak cannot be completely dismissed due to missing data and incomplete transparency from local authorities. [1, 2]
Status of the Lab-Leak Hypothesis
  • What studies/agencies say: While intelligence and government bodies are divided, major scientific consensus papers view direct proof of a lab leak as largely circumstantial or speculative, pointing out that proving it would require specific internal laboratory records from the Wuhan Institute of Virology that have not been provided. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • Official Assessments: The U.S. Intelligence Community remains split, with some agencies favoring natural spillover, others considering a lab incident plausible, and broad agreement that the virus was not developed as a biological weapon. You can read the full declassified breakdown via the Office of the Director of National Intelligence Assessment. [1]
 
Last edited:

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,126
5,816
113
Because "climate science" is based on projections far into the future of doom pretty much the same as this. Notwithstanding the many times that future predictions of doom have not occurred. If you weren't a dumb*ss, you would understand this. For instance, Al Gore predicted that Arctic sea ice would disappear around 2015. Of course, Obama chose John holdren, a failure, as his science of advisor and one of Holdren's failed predictions was that climate change would cause a billion deaths by the year 2020.

Poor DailyBuck7 still hasn't seen the fatal flaw in his thread starter ... because he has me on ignore and wants to remain a dumb-dumb. He provided an example of a doomsday scenario that didn't come true, in part because people changed their behavior. Then he tried to analogize it to climate change, thereby absent-mindedly making the argument that if humans change their behavior, we can avoid climate change doomsday scenarios.

His lack of ability to compete, intellectually, with Ivy-League-level folks, and his resultant jealousy, is the real reason he has consistently lashed out against elite academic institutions, and intentionally harmed his children's academic/career achievements. Sad. Almost as sad as what he did to his 2 ex-wives. BowlingGreen4eva!
 

DailyBuck7

Senior
Mar 4, 2026
759
705
93
Where's the evidence? None of that is evidence.......it's their opinions. I want to see the peer-reviewed paper showing the evideence.......and CNN is an opinion channel. Here's 4 lines of evidence showing it was natural........now show me yours

Scientific papers and health organizations favor a natural zoonotic spillover origin for COVID-19, though a laboratory accident has not been definitively ruled out. [1, 2]

Key Papers and Reports Supporting Natural Origin (Zoonotic Spillover)
    • "The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2" (Nature Medicine, 2020): One of the earliest and most-cited genomic analyses arguing that SARS-CoV-2 has natural evolutionary features rather than being engineered in a lab. [1]
    • "The Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan was the early epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic" (Science, 2022): Geospatial and genomic studies showing that early human cases and positive environmental/animal samples clustered heavily around specific stalls in Wuhan's Huanan Market. [1, 2, 3]
    • Cell Critical Review (2021): A peer-reviewed evaluation by international virologists concluding that natural animal-to-human transmission is statistically and biologically far more probable than a lab leak. [1]
    • WHO / SAGO Reports (most recently updated through 2025): The World Health Organization's Scientific Advisory Group for the Origins of Novel Pathogens concluded that zoonotic spillover remains the most scientifically supported hypothesis, while noting that a lab leak cannot be completely dismissed due to missing data and incomplete transparency from local authorities. [1, 2]
Status of the Lab-Leak Hypothesis
  • What studies/agencies say: While intelligence and government bodies are divided, major scientific consensus papers view direct proof of a lab leak as largely circumstantial or speculative, pointing out that proving it would require specific internal laboratory records from the Wuhan Institute of Virology that have not been provided. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • Official Assessments: The U.S. Intelligence Community remains split, with some agencies favoring natural spillover, others considering a lab incident plausible, and broad agreement that the virus was not developed as a biological weapon. You can read the full declassified breakdown via the Office of the Director of National Intelligence Assessment. [1]
You apparently have a reading disability regarding the meaning of "no evidence". Even your response here supports the conclusion that there is some significant evidence. Additionally, whoever made the comment denigrating circumstantial evidence is uninformed in a practical and legal sense. The law does not distinguish between direct evidence and circumstantial evidence. Circumstantial evidence can be extremely probative. For instance dna tests to determine paternity are circumstantial evidence.

Finally, you have an amateur's conception of peer review. Here is Gene Gordon speaking in a comment on the old dotearth NYTs blog:

". I comment as a founder of two prestigious, scientific publications in elctrical engineering, and long time associate editor on two. I have also served on the publication committee of IEEE.

Peer review is a process designed to improve the quality of journal articles. It is not a stamp of approval; it doesn't guarantee that the data is accurate or complete, that the conclusions are correct, and that the author(s) are not playing games. There is an old boys club element. A good and conscientious editor learns to help the peer review process along but editors typically are volunteers, not professionals, they are busy people, and they are not typically experts in all the various subjects being published by the journal. Reviewers, usually only two, are busy also. Sometimes reviews are cursory, sometimes detailed. Sometimes reviewers have fish to fry. .....

In other words the process is spotty and in no way should be viewed as a stamp of correctness or guarantee of validity, However, it is somewhat better than no peer review."

Additionally, some of his work covering 80 patents and 50 peer reviewed papers includes: ""Dr. Eugene I. Gordon is a world-renowned scientist and engineer. During his 26 years at AT&T Bell Labs he and his group discovered and developed several important laser systems, including the well-known, red, helium-neon laser. He invented and developed the powerful, continuous, blue- green argon ion laser. He also invented and developed acousto-optic light modulators and deflectors used currently in many opto-electronic systems. Similarly he and his group invented and developed the charge coupled device (CCD) used as the sensing array in most digital camera, television and infra-red imaging systems for military applications, especially the CAMCORDER and facsimile machines and for astronomy."
 
  • Haha
Reactions: fsu1jreed

pjhawk

All-American
Oct 13, 2001
1,997
5,849
113
Because "climate science" is based on projections far into the future of doom pretty much the same as this. Notwithstanding the many times that future predictions of doom have not occurred. If you weren't a dumb*ss, you would understand this. For instance, Al Gore predicted that Arctic sea ice would disappear around 2015. Of course, Obama chose John holdren, a failure, as his science of advisor and one of Holdren's failed predictions was that climate change would cause a billion deaths by the year 2020.
Oh FFS. It took me about a minute to discover that your claim about Gore and Arctic sea ice is just a flat-out lie, and that this Holdren person apparently made a prediction in the 1980's that was intended as a worst case possible prediction.

In any event, none of this, your original completely unrelated assertion/analogy or the claims per doomsday climate predictions by Gore and Holdren provide an iota of backing or evidence for your assertions that climate change projections are "silly".

And if you had ANY critical/logical thinking skills/abilities you could see that.
 

DailyBuck7

Senior
Mar 4, 2026
759
705
93
Oh FFS. It took me about a minute to discover that your claim about Gore and Arctic sea ice is just a flat-out lie, and that this Holdren person apparently made a prediction in the 1980's that was intended as a worst case possible prediction.

In any event, none of this, your original completely unrelated assertion/analogy or the claims per doomsday climate predictions by Gore and Holdren provide an iota of backing or evidence for your assertions that climate change projections are "silly".

And if you had ANY critical/logical thinking skills/abilities you could see that.
Another Lefty ignoramus with an aversion to facts. Here is what the left wing polifact said about Al Gore predictions, which amounted to typical left-wing fear mongering. "

" Citing researchers during a 2009 climate change conference, Gore said there was a 75% chance that ice in the Arctic could be gone during at least some summer months within five to seven years. "


Here is one of many of Holdren's fear-mongering predictions which was wrong. Not the least bit surprising that the Democrats would appoint a dunce to be their Chief science advisor. He was not a nobody or a simple academician, but he was Obama's Chief science advisor.

From chat GPT " However, Holdren and Ehrlich did make a dramatic joint prediction in a 1971 publication titled Global Ecology:

Some form of eco-catastrophe, if not thermonuclear war, seems almost certain to overtake us before the end of the century.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: Knickslions69

pjhawk

All-American
Oct 13, 2001
1,997
5,849
113
Another Lefty ignoramus with an aversion to facts. Here is what the left wing polifact said about Al Gore predictions, which amounted to typical left-wing fear mongering. "

" Citing researchers during a 2009 climate change conference, Gore said there was a 75% chance that ice in the Arctic could be gone during at least some summer months within five to seven years. "


Here is one of many of Holdren's fear-mongering predictions which was wrong. Not the least bit surprising that the Democrats would appoint a dunce to be their Chief science advisor. He was not a nobody or a simple academician, but he was Obama's Chief science advisor.

From chat GPT " However, Holdren and Ehrlich did make a dramatic joint prediction in a 1971 publication titled Global Ecology:
You fruitcake. So it turns out that Al Gore didn't actually predict what you said he predicted! What a shock! Surprise!

In any event, the overall point here is that whatever individual people predicted as far as various scenarios or possibilities as a result of climate change, you haven't debunked or even begun to critique the actual science behind the climate change hypothesis. You've just cherry picked prognostications by individuals and even with that have outright distorted or lied per those prognostications.

Logic fail.
 

DailyBuck7

Senior
Mar 4, 2026
759
705
93
You fruitcake. So it turns out that Al Gore didn't actually predict what you said he predicted! What a shock! Surprise!

In any event, the overall point here is that whatever individual people predicted as far as various scenarios or possibilities as a result of climate change, you haven't debunked or even begun to critique the actual science behind the climate change hypothesis. You've just cherry picked prognostications by individuals and even with that have outright distorted or lied per those prognostications.

Logic fail.
You are the fruitcake. I was simply pointing out the consistent fear mongering associated with "climate science" and that people should not give it any presumption of correctness. The actual proof or disproof of climate science has to be done by deep and thorough scientific papers in a climate of openness. I was pointing out one element of climate science that has been wrong many times. Because of the many failed projections and predictions, it is ridiculous for climate change advocates to call people who are skeptical deniers. However, that is the common practice of the left and the climate change advocates who are remarkably insular and stupid many times. There are many, many more failed stupid predictions and presumptions I could have cited by people that are prominent climate change advocates, including Harvard professor and Obama science advisor John holdren.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatpiggy
Mar 8, 2010
9,705
18,488
113


Very similar to silly climate change projections for which Lefties want us to spend trillions of dollars.

What specifically is the lefty prediction you're speaking of.

Furthermore... there are almost certainly a number of different predictions. It seems if we're interested in this question we should research which predictions are doing well and which aren't. Only selecting serious science of course, not somebodies stupid blog post.
 

fsu1jreed

Heisman
Apr 1, 2002
9,896
17,905
113
You apparently have a reading disability regarding the meaning of "no evidence". Even your response here supports the conclusion that there is some significant evidence. Additionally, whoever made the comment denigrating circumstantial evidence is uninformed in a practical and legal sense. The law does not distinguish between direct evidence and circumstantial evidence. Circumstantial evidence can be extremely probative. For instance dna tests to determine paternity are circumstantial evidence.

Finally, you have an amateur's conception of peer review. Here is Gene Gordon speaking in a comment on the old dotearth NYTs blog:

". I comment as a founder of two prestigious, scientific publications in elctrical engineering, and long time associate editor on two. I have also served on the publication committee of IEEE.

Peer review is a process designed to improve the quality of journal articles. It is not a stamp of approval; it doesn't guarantee that the data is accurate or complete, that the conclusions are correct, and that the author(s) are not playing games. There is an old boys club element. A good and conscientious editor learns to help the peer review process along but editors typically are volunteers, not professionals, they are busy people, and they are not typically experts in all the various subjects being published by the journal. Reviewers, usually only two, are busy also. Sometimes reviews are cursory, sometimes detailed. Sometimes reviewers have fish to fry. .....

In other words the process is spotty and in no way should be viewed as a stamp of correctness or guarantee of validity, However, it is somewhat better than no peer review."

Additionally, some of his work covering 80 patents and 50 peer reviewed papers includes: ""Dr. Eugene I. Gordon is a world-renowned scientist and engineer. During his 26 years at AT&T Bell Labs he and his group discovered and developed several important laser systems, including the well-known, red, helium-neon laser. He invented and developed the powerful, continuous, blue- green argon ion laser. He also invented and developed acousto-optic light modulators and deflectors used currently in many opto-electronic systems. Similarly he and his group invented and developed the charge coupled device (CCD) used as the sensing array in most digital camera, television and infra-red imaging systems for military applications, especially the CAMCORDER and facsimile machines and for astronomy."

no......you said SIGNICANT evidence, of which there is none. Could it have came from the lab? Sure, but that's not, as of now, what the evidence shows.
 
Last edited:

DailyBuck7

Senior
Mar 4, 2026
759
705
93
What specifically is the lefty prediction you're speaking of.

Furthermore... there are almost certainly a number of different predictions. It seems if we're interested in this question we should research which predictions are doing well and which aren't. Only selecting serious science of course, not somebodies stupid blog post.
He quoted a real science post. No. 1. You should learn to read better. I agree that the good and bad predictions should be compared. Other bad predictions. IPCC in 2007 said Himalayan glaciers would be gone in 2035. David Viner of East Anglia Climate Change Research (a major research center) stated in 2000: "winter snowfall in Britain would become a very rare and exciting event within a few years and that “children just aren’t going to know what snow is.” He also said snow would probably cause chaos in 20 years’ time, because people would be unprepared when it did return." James Hansen made the ridiculous comparison of climate change negative effects to Holocaust deaths stating: "If we cannot stop the building of more coal-fired power plants, those coal trains will be death trains – no less gruesome than if they were boxcars headed to crematoria, loaded with uncountable irreplaceable species.” The basic point being that what Lefties view as objective science is quite often motivated reasoning and essentially a religious cult that is not open to the back and forth of real science.
 

pjhawk

All-American
Oct 13, 2001
1,997
5,849
113
You are the fruitcake. I was simply pointing out the consistent fear mongering associated with "climate science" and that people should not give it any presumption of correctness. The actual proof or disproof of climate science has to be done by deep and thorough scientific papers in a climate of openness. I was pointing out one element of climate science that has been wrong many times. Because of the many failed projections and predictions, it is ridiculous for climate change advocates to call people who are skeptical deniers. However, that is the common practice of the left and the climate change advocates who are remarkably insular and stupid many times. There are many, many more failed stupid predictions and presumptions I could have cited by people that are prominent climate change advocates, including Harvard professor and Obama science advisor John holdren.
Cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs. Maga gonna Maga.
 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
35,386
10,809
113
Doubling down and working hard to be extremely stupid. Here are the so-called opinion news channels I cited:
"
Several prominent scientists, including respected microbiologists support the lab Leak theory
1. Richard Ebright — Rutgers University. A prominent molecular biologist and professor of chemistry and chemical biology. In testimony before the U.S. Senate on June 18, 2024, he stated that a large preponderance of the evidence indicates that SARS-CoV-2 entered humans through a research-related incident. He has been particularly critical of risky coronavirus research and inadequate laboratory safeguards
Robert Redfield — Former director of the CDC (2018–2021). A virologist and infectious-disease researcher who believes the virus originated in a Wuhan laboratory. In an August 9, 2026, CNN interview, Redfield said, "I don't have any question as a virologist that this virus came from the lab." He has suggested that laboratory research could have increased the virus's ability to infect humans"

Former director of CDC who stated that there was no question that the virus came from the lab. Also, the FBI and CIA thought that covid most likely came from the lab. This is only part of the evidence. You of course, put your head in the sand and in your narrow bubble believe whatever you want to believe is true. As I said before, I don't deny that there is a lot of evidence going the other way but what I am saying is that there is substantial evidence going both ways.
Buck: I have no idea what the actual source of the SARS-Covid-2 virus was. But the statements you provided above from Richard Ebright and Robert Redfield are conclusory statements. Ebright stated that "a large preponderance of the evidence indicates that SARS-COV-2 entered humans through a research-related incident." WHAT evidence? Unless he cites it and it appears reliable, that is a conclusory statement. Similarly, Redfield said "I don't have any question as a virologist that this virus came from the lab." He may be a virologist and a very qualified virologist at that, but his status proves nothing. What is his evidence?
 
  • Like
Reactions: fsu1jreed

DailyBuck7

Senior
Mar 4, 2026
759
705
93
Buck: I have no idea what the actual source of the SARS-Covid-2 virus was. But the statements you provided above from Richard Ebright and Robert Redfield are conclusory statements. Ebright stated that "a large preponderance of the evidence indicates that SARS-COV-2 entered humans through a research-related incident." WHAT evidence? Unless he cites it and it appears reliable, that is a conclusory statement. Similarly, Redfield said "I don't have any question as a virologist that this virus came from the lab." He may be a virologist and a very qualified virologist at that, but his status proves nothing. What is his evidence?
Do you really think he testified in front of Congress with no evidence? Same with the other guy. Also, do you think that CIA & FBI made up their conclusions out of thin air? I am going to Italy tomorrow, but all you have to do is ask Chatgpt what was there and the intelligence agencies basis and I am sure significant evidence will come up. These people are not going to stand up essentially in front of the whole world and just make pie in the sky conclusions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatpiggy

DailyBuck7

Senior
Mar 4, 2026
759
705
93
Buck: I have no idea what the actual source of the SARS-Covid-2 virus was. But the statements you provided above from Richard Ebright and Robert Redfield are conclusory statements. Ebright stated that "a large preponderance of the evidence indicates that SARS-COV-2 entered humans through a research-related incident." WHAT evidence? Unless he cites it and it appears reliable, that is a conclusory statement. Similarly, Redfield said "I don't have any question as a virologist that this virus came from the lab." He may be a virologist and a very qualified virologist at that, but his status proves nothing. What is his evidence?
I couldn't resist going to chat since it is so simple. Here it is:

Ebright's principal evidence​

Ebright argued that the combined evidence overwhelmingly favored a research-related origin. His June 2024 submission organized the argument into several categories.

1. The geographic coincidence

The original outbreak appeared in Wuhan, where the Wuhan Institute of Virology was conducting extensive research on SARS-related bat coronaviruses.

Ebright emphasized that the closest known bat populations carrying related viruses were approximately 800 miles away. He considered Wuhan's position as both an early outbreak center and a major coronavirus research center particularly significant.

2. The actual research being conducted in Wuhan

Ebright cited documentation showing that Wuhan researchers had created genetically modified, or chimeric, coronaviruses capable of infecting human cells.

He highlighted experiments in which certain engineered viruses exhibited substantially increased replication and pathogenicity in experimental mice.

These experiments established that researchers were conducting potentially hazardous work, although they did not establish that SARS-CoV-2 itself was created in the laboratory.

3. The 2018 DEFUSE research proposal

This was one of Ebright's most important arguments.

A research team involving the Wuhan Institute of Virology and American collaborators proposed inserting specialized features, including furin cleavage sites, into SARS-related coronaviruses.

SARS-CoV-2 subsequently emerged with a furin cleavage site, a feature not previously observed in the known SARS-related viruses Ebright compared.

He believed this correspondence between the proposal and the emerging virus was powerful circumstantial evidence.

Importantly, the DARPA DEFUSE proposal was rejected for funding. Ebright inferred that overlapping NIH-funded work might have allowed related experiments to proceed, but that inference was not direct proof that the proposed experiments were performed.

4. Unusual genetic characteristics

Ebright identified several features of SARS-CoV-2 that he considered suggestive of laboratory engineering:

  • A furin cleavage site in the spike protein.
  • Two adjacent CGG codons at that site, which he described as unusual among related bat coronaviruses.
  • A pattern of restriction-enzyme recognition sites that he argued was consistent with synthetic genome assembly.
  • An apparently high capacity to bind human receptors early in the outbreak.
These observations formed an important part of his argument, but their interpretation is disputed. They are not universally accepted as genetic evidence of engineering.

5. Laboratory biosafety conditions

He argued that substantial coronavirus research in Wuhan was being performed under biosafety level 2 conditions, which he considered inadequate for viruses capable of causing a pandemic.

He also cited documented laboratory infections involving the original SARS coronavirus in Asia during 2003–2004 to demonstrate that laboratory-acquired infections can occur.

6. Missing data and the Wuhan laboratory's response

Ebright cited the removal of online access to a Wuhan Institute of Virology virus-sequence database in September 2019.

He also discussed the institute's failure to supply requested research records and virus sequences.

He argued that the lack of transparency prevented investigators from determining whether the laboratory possessed a closer precursor to SARS-CoV-2.

7. Reports of sick Wuhan researchers

Ebright cited intelligence reporting that Wuhan laboratory researchers experienced respiratory illnesses during autumn 2019, before the publicly recognized outbreak.

However, those illnesses have not been conclusively established as COVID-19 infections.

8. The absence of a confirmed infected intermediate animal

Ebright contrasted COVID-19 with the original SARS outbreak, in which infected civets were identified relatively quickly.

He argued that the failure to identify an animal carrying the immediate precursor of SARS-CoV-2 weakened the natural-spillover hypothesis.

His full submission also discussed statistical analyses, intelligence assessments, and scientific papers supporting a laboratory origin.


3-29 (01727713).DOC+1


3. Redfield's principal evidence​

Redfield's conclusions overlapped with Ebright's, but his argument focused more heavily on viral behavior and events in Wuhan during 2019.

1. The virus appeared unusually well adapted to human transmission

Redfield emphasized that SARS-CoV-2 was highly infectious between humans from the beginning of the recognized outbreak.

He considered its apparent ability to spread efficiently among humans unusual for a newly emerging animal virus.

He also believed that the virus's early behavior was consistent with adaptation occurring before the outbreak, potentially through laboratory research.

2. Three unusual developments at the Wuhan laboratory in September 2019

During the March 8, 2023, hearing, Redfield identified three developments that he regarded as particularly suspicious:

  • The removal of virus-sequence information from public access.
  • An alleged transfer of laboratory control from civilian to military authorities.
  • Reported work involving the laboratory's ventilation system.
Redfield argued that these events suggested a significant incident might have occurred in September 2019.

The events and their significance have not all been independently verified. In particular, the public record does not establish that they resulted from a SARS-CoV-2 accident.

3. Research involving enhanced coronaviruses

Redfield emphasized that researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology were conducting experiments involving genetic modifications of coronaviruses.

He also raised concerns that American government funding may have supported aspects of this research.

4. His early assessment as CDC director

Redfield testified that he had considered a laboratory origin more likely from the early stages of the pandemic.

He also said he had been excluded from some scientific discussions about the virus's origins because he disagreed with the emerging natural-origin interpretation.

These statements concern the scientific deliberations, rather than direct physical evidence of a laboratory accident.


House Oversight Committee+1


4. How strong is their evidence?​

An important distinction is that neither Ebright nor Redfield presented a publicly verified laboratory record, infected laboratory worker, or precursor virus definitively connecting the Wuhan Institute of Virology to the pandemic.

Their arguments primarily combine documented research activities, features of the virus, laboratory-safety concerns, intelligence reporting, and inferences from missing information.


The two original congressional documents are publicly accessible through the links above. [
Richard Ebright

June 18, 2024 · U.S. Senate

Professor at Rutgers University, laboratory director at the Waksman Institute of Microbiology.

Read his complete written testimony (PDF) Ebright

Read his complete written testimony (2 pages)Redfield

This took 90 seconds to find on Chat GPT
 
Last edited:

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
27,989
26,989
113
Idk who to believe. 99.9% of the scientific world, or a couple of anonymous shitposters who seem to have a tenuous grasp of reality
Yeah the “scientific” world where they need to fake data. Very “scientific”. It’s a fake science
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Recruiting Tuesday Clemson Football Recruiting Nuggets
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football The days of Clemson rubber-stamping Dabo Swinney's contractual decisions are probably over
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Dabo Swinney on administration alignment, program rebuild, winning another national championship, injuries, Trent Pearman
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Football Tuesday Clemson Football Insider: The blueprint moving forward, player evaluations, when we saw this coming, Brock Bradley
  5. 05 Tiger Illustrated Football TUESDAY CLEMSON FOOTBALL INTERVIEWS: Collin Sadler, Kobe McCloud, Ashton Hampton