Would you at least give Mullen a call?

Do you give Mullen a call

  • Yes

    Votes: 124 62.0%
  • No

    Votes: 76 38.0%

  • Total voters
    200

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
6,386
3,334
113
Of course. I'm not saying he's the #1 best choice as far as the long-term success of the program, but he would win with Kamario, and he would inject badly-needed enthusiasm back into the program.

And just when people were thinking that maybe he's lost his mojo, this past weekend he went on the road and got a win over a ranked team.
 

NorrisFByrd

Redshirt
Oct 24, 2026
10
26
13
I would make the call, just to hear him out. Mullen knows Starkville, and he knows what it takes to win there, which is not a small thing after a 41-9 loss. I watched that Auburn game with a friend on Saturday night, and the sideline just looked flat by the third quarter. A call costs nothing, even if the answer is no. What would worry you most about bringing him back?
 

TPIPER36

Senior
May 19, 2023
771
982
93
I would make the call, just to hear him out. Mullen knows Starkville, and he knows what it takes to win there, which is not a small thing after a 41-9 loss. I watched that Auburn game with a friend on Saturday night, and the sideline just looked flat by the third quarter. A call costs nothing, even if the answer is no. What would worry you most about bringing him back?
I would have a ton of confidence he could turn it around year 1. He’s team would look prepared to play, and lesser talented guys would look more developed. The fans would buy into the program, as his presence would generate excitement. KT would be ready to go and look sharp out of the gate. The O line would actually protect him. I honestly couldn't tell you a single negative other than re hiring coaches often doesn’t work. Job hunting too but I don’t care as much if he got the program right
 
Last edited:

triton28

Junior
Dec 18, 2009
1,504
284
78
I’ll tell you one thing we need a guy that’s been a head coach before. This is tough place to start a career as a head coach. Mullen is like the only successful one
Jeff lebby went undefeated with a healthy kt. I feel like someone besides Dan Mullen could do ok.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bullldawg78

Indndawg

Senior
Nov 16, 2005
7,287
816
113
Just to gauge his interest and maybe a fall back position. I still think its best for an enema of football. Get rid of all the dross on the team and build around K1.
 

Indndawg

Senior
Nov 16, 2005
7,287
816
113
magic target sparkle GIF by Target
 

Captain Ron

Junior
Aug 22, 2012
747
384
63
CALL? I would walk barefoot across the hot desert just to hear him fart over a walkie talkie.

Those that are justifying Lenny scoring 7 points a game because we lost our starter, remember what Don did in his first year without a D1 QB as starter and then the backup later in the year..
Stats provided by Grok.


25.6 points per game (307 total points in 12 games).


Dan Mullen’s first season as head coach at Mississippi State was 2009 (the Bulldogs went 5–7 overall, 3–5 in the SEC against the nation’s toughest schedule). Sports-Reference and contemporary stats sources list the team’s scoring offense at 25.6 PPG.


This was a clear improvement from the prior year (about 15.2 PPG under the previous staff), driven largely by a stronger rushing attack (227.6 yards per game).
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,468
33,330
113
I know we have run this several times, but we’re desperate. I don’t see how it could be worse than Lebby. I’m just interested in a poll
We need a higher bar than not worse than Lebby. Dan Mullen today isn’t the same as Dan Mullen 20 years ago, or even 10 years ago. He wouldn’t be on my A list to call. It’s never as good the second time around. It ranges anywhere from a little bit worse to disaster. I would call to get his thoughts on other candidates.
 
Last edited:

DoggieDaddy13

All-Conference
Dec 23, 2017
4,035
2,450
113
Mullen knows Starkville, and he knows what it takes to win there...
Mullen knew he could win about 8 games a year here max and maybe get extremely lucky with a strong QB. But that was his ceiling.

Which admittedly is better than what we have now. By a whole hell of a lot. BUT....

Mullen's a quitter and proven he doesn't give a **** about MSU or Starkville.

He may be alright at player development and perhaps he's got the x's and o's.

But he's not relentless recruiting the johnny's and joe's and kamario's.

He bailed on us once OM went all in on their football program and Freeze rolled into town.

I'm a solid no.

He'd only be trying to cash in on a final paycheck. We need to do better with a coach as hungry as Dan "was" when he first arrived in Starkville....

Oh so many years ago!
 

615dawg

All-American
Jun 4, 2007
7,501
5,334
113
I think you guys are forgetting that the man won 9 games with Chris Relf as quarterback.

We beat out some FCS teams for his recruitment.

Somebody on here nailed it last week. The MSU fanbase treats coaches like a marriage. Im not saying that we need to treat coaches like one night stands, but sometimes even if the sex is good, you can tell its not going to work long term and you need to move on.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,678
13,493
113
I think you guys are forgetting that the man won 9 games with Chris Relf as quarterback.

We beat out some FCS teams for his recruitment.

Somebody on here nailed it last week. The MSU fanbase treats coaches like a marriage. Im not saying that we need to treat coaches like one night stands, but sometimes even if the sex is good, you can tell its not going to work long term and you need to move on.
I think it depends on where Mullen's headspace is. Most guys his age (55+) are ready to settle down for the long term, which minimizes us having to worry about them leaving. But, you have to make sure they are hungry (Mullen still is) AND you have to factor in that Mullen is a different breed and he's always looking around.

If we don't take things personally, he's nearly a perfect candidate. But it's impossible to not take things a little personally when it comes to a previous coach, because you have a data set. I'd talk to him, but I think I may ultimately look another direction. There are other good candidates out there if we know what we're looking for.
 

57stratdawg

Heisman
Dec 1, 2004
148,785
24,669
113
No. I dont want to have a HC leaking his name to every job opening, because he thinks it helps the perception of the program.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bully12

615dawg

All-American
Jun 4, 2007
7,501
5,334
113
why would we call someone that did not & does not want to be here
No one wants to be here. We are not a destination program. We have to accept that when coaches come to Mississippi State, there are basically two options: Mullen and Lebby.

You either have enough success to get attention from bigger jobs, or you are so bad that you are fired and your career goes backwards.

There is a third option, but its rare, and State has had two this century. An older coach that is in the twilight of their career but still has a little to give. Sherrill and Leach have blinded our fanbase to the reality of college football.

Give me the young, hungry coach that wants to win and get a better job every time. Then when he leaves for a better job, get another one.

Would you rather have a decade of 8+ wins every season and have three coaches or a decade with no winning seasons and have three coaches?
 

The Peeper

Heisman
Feb 26, 2008
17,048
12,949
113
He's kind of like that gorgeous woman that you see all the time in the neighborhood, at PTA, at the kids soccer games, etc, but you also constantly hear about the stupid outrageous sh-it she does at home and work and you remember that old saying about no matter how good looking she is, somebody somewhere is tired of her sh-it
 

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
15,325
7,753
113
No one wants to be here. We are not a destination program. We have to accept that when coaches come to Mississippi State, there are basically two options: Mullen and Lebby.

You either have enough success to get attention from bigger jobs, or you are so bad that you are fired and your career goes backwards.

There is a third option, but its rare, and State has had two this century. An older coach that is in the twilight of their career but still has a little to give. Sherrill and Leach have blinded our fanbase to the reality of college football.

Give me the young, hungry coach that wants to win and get a better job every time. Then when he leaves for a better job, get another one.

Would you rather have a decade of 8+ wins every season and have three coaches or a decade with no winning seasons and have three coaches?
Even a decade is an anomoly. Very rare. Give me 4 years and let someone jump to the next gig.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,303
5,857
113
I think it depends on where Mullen's headspace is. Most guys his age (55+) are ready to settle down for the long term, which minimizes us having to worry about them leaving. But, you have to make sure they are hungry (Mullen still is) AND you have to factor in that Mullen is a different breed and he's always looking around.

If we don't take things personally, he's nearly a perfect candidate. But it's impossible to not take things a little personally when it comes to a previous coach, because you have a data set. I'd talk to him, but I think I may ultimately look another direction. There are other good candidates out there if we know what we're looking for.
I don't care that Mullen will look around (he will). I'd be worried about him signing a fat contract and coasting. I'd be all about having him on an incentive heavy deal. Pay him what Lebby makes base (still I think an $800k bump over what he's making now).

Bump him to $6M at six wins. $8M at 8 wins puts him at number 10 in the SEC (at least compared to base; presumably other coaches have their own incentives). I think it'd be pretty easy to justify $1M per regular season win over 8 wins. If we go 10-2, compared to 6-6, pretty sure that's worth $4M a year to the school, but don't have any actual numbers to back that up.
 

60sdog

Senior
Oct 9, 2010
758
513
93
Again, absolutely not!! Let's not forget that this guy was the one who single-handedly lost at least 2 EB's, by checking out the week of the games and directly texting AD's of various schools, constantly shopping for a new job.
 

skip dog

All-Conference
Nov 15, 2005
1,612
1,514
93
No one wants to be here. We are not a destination program. We have to accept that when coaches come to Mississippi State, there are basically two options: Mullen and Lebby.

You either have enough success to get attention from bigger jobs, or you are so bad that you are fired and your career goes backwards.

There is a third option, but its rare, and State has had two this century. An older coach that is in the twilight of their career but still has a little to give. Sherrill and Leach have blinded our fanbase to the reality of college football.

Give me the young, hungry coach that wants to win and get a better job every time. Then when he leaves for a better job, get another one.

Would you rather have a decade of 8+ wins every season and have three coaches or a decade with no winning seasons and have three coaches?
Don't disagree with a single thing you said, and what you said is exactly why we don't call Mullen
 

John Deaux VII

All-Conference
Jun 7, 2024
1,345
3,308
113
I might be wrong on this, but I think if Mullen is honestly interested in coming back to Mississippi State, he has already communicated that indirectly to someone in charge, given the way our season has gone. I don't think we would have had to call him.
 

MississippiTexan

Sophomore
Jun 11, 2014
149
135
43
Mullen knew he could win about 8 games a year here max and maybe get extremely lucky with a strong QB. But that was his ceiling.

Which admittedly is better than what we have now. By a whole hell of a lot. BUT....

Mullen's a quitter and proven he doesn't give a **** about MSU or Starkville.

He may be alright at player development and perhaps he's got the x's and o's.

But he's not relentless recruiting the johnny's and joe's and kamario's.

He bailed on us once OM went all in on their football program and Freeze rolled into town.

I'm a solid no.

He'd only be trying to cash in on a final paycheck. We need to do better with a coach as hungry as Dan "was" when he first arrived in Starkville....

Oh so many years ago!
I'm not sure what to say if you think Mullen wasn't a good recruiter. I think he got a bad rap in recruiting. Maybe you should good the guys that he recruited who played in the NFL. Several of them ended up as the highest paid players ever at their position for a while. Dak, Charles Cross, Elgton Jenkins, Gabe Jackson, Anthony Dixon, Fletcher Cox, Chris Jones, Montez Sweat, Jeffrey Simmons, Jonathan Banks, Darius Slay, Jonathan Abram. Even Pernell Mcphee and Preston Smith.

You might could make a case that he wasn't all that good compared to bigger programs, but he's light years of ahead of what we have now.

He's also light years better as a coach than what we have now. He won with different types of QBs in Relf and Russell, so I'm confident that he could find a way to win with Puckett or Swann. I'm also confident that he would have at least beat Vandy and Auburn and probably Oklahoma too.

I'm not saying I want him, but I definitely wouldn't be unhappy if they said he was coming back.
 

Darryl Steight

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
4,993
8,314
113
Again, absolutely not!! Let's not forget that this guy was the one who single-handedly lost at least 2 EB's, by checking out the week of the games and directly texting AD's of various schools, constantly shopping for a new job.
There is also the chance that the man has had a taste of what he thought was a "bigger job" at UF, didn't like it that much, matured throughout the process, learned from that mistake, and found that - hey, maybe making $6M + at a "smaller job" (if anyone thinks head coach at an SEC school is a small job) and living like a king in Starkville wasn't so bad after all.

I don't know if he has matured, but anything is possible. You make the call and ask him questions for sure. You can always go in a different direction if you don't like the answers.
 

Darryl Steight

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
4,993
8,314
113
I think the list of people that would consider our job at this juncture is pretty humbling and Mullen would be one of the best on that list….if he would consider it.
I agree that Mullen should be on a list, but I don't get this thinking about the list.

Of course there are certain coaches who would turn their noses up at a - what, Top 30? Top 40? - job in the country, but that list is pretty short. There are probably like 50 current and former coaches - all the guys who already have/had more successful head coaching gigs in most of the P4 who might say 'nah, I'm good, or I'll wait and see what else comes up' (we aren't getting Saban, Urban, Cignetti, Dabo, etc.)... but every current G6 head coach, not to mention most likely every single P4 assistant, a lot of NFL assistants, etc., etc. would absolutely jump at the chance to make mid-7-figure salary as the head coach of an SEC program.

These guys love attention, and are extremely confident that they can come in and turn this program around. They've seen Sherrill, Leach, Mullen be highly successful and 'know' they can do it too. They might even see it as attractive at this point, as we've just demonstrated we will shell out as much/more than anyone when needed, and look at the situation he would be following. The next guy could be seen as our savior at this point.

We will have a lot of good choices as the next head coach. Will we - or can we possibly - not step on our own dicks and make a good decision -- that is the real question.
 

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
15,325
7,753
113
I agree that Mullen should be on a list, but I don't get this thinking about the list.

Of course there are certain coaches who would turn their noses up at a - what, Top 30? Top 40? - job in the country, but that list is pretty short. There are probably like 50 current and former coaches - all the guys who already have/had more successful head coaching gigs in most of the P4 who might say 'nah, I'm good, or I'll wait and see what else comes up' (we aren't getting Saban, Urban, Cignetti, Dabo, etc.)... but every current G6 head coach, not to mention most likely every single P4 assistant, a lot of NFL assistants, etc., etc. would absolutely jump at the chance to make mid-7-figure salary as the head coach of an SEC program.

These guys love attention, and are extremely confident that they can come in and turn this program around. They've seen Sherrill, Leach, Mullen be highly successful and 'know' they can do it too. They might even see it as attractive at this point, as we've just demonstrated we will shell out as much/more than anyone when needed, and look at the situation he would be following. The next guy could be seen as our savior at this point.

We will have a lot of good choices as the next head coach. Will we - or can we possibly - not step on our own dicks and make a good decision -- that is the real question.
Right or wrong I don’t think anyone will be excited to see an assistant on the list. So that leaves us with G5 coaches. Huff and Mullen. Neal Brown is the best name to me and may be gettable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darryl Steight

Darryl Steight

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
4,993
8,314
113
Right or wrong I don’t think anyone will be excited to see an assistant on the list. So that leaves us with G5 coaches. Huff and Mullen. Neal Brown is the best name to me and may be gettable.
I do agree about the assistant. I don't want to wait for another guy to learn on the job either. We need someone who has done it before.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,678
13,493
113
No one wants to be here. We are not a destination program. We have to accept that when coaches come to Mississippi State, there are basically two options: Mullen and Lebby.

You either have enough success to get attention from bigger jobs, or you are so bad that you are fired and your career goes backwards.

There is a third option, but its rare, and State has had two this century. An older coach that is in the twilight of their career but still has a little to give. Sherrill and Leach have blinded our fanbase to the reality of college football.

Give me the young, hungry coach that wants to win and get a better job every time. Then when he leaves for a better job, get another one.

Would you rather have a decade of 8+ wins every season and have three coaches or a decade with no winning seasons and have three coaches?
Sherrill and Leach (older guys) = 100% hit rate

Mullen and Lebby (go ahead and add in Moorhead here too): 33% hit rate

The third option isn't the rare one, hiring the young coordinator is

We should have hired Willie Fritz, knowing what you truly need makes decision-making easy
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darryl Steight
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout
  2. 02 Maroon and White Chris Jans proud of Mississippi State's "must-win" performance on the road at UCF
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Injury Update: QB AJ Swann and S Isaac Smith to miss Senior Day game
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Tennessee Tech Players to Know
  5. 05 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 86-83 UCF: Bulldogs earn road win in fight from start to finish with Golden Knights