We coulda been somebody... we coulda been a contendah...

Bleem Phuppert

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2018
1,158
1,496
113
Watching Indiana - a team that I saw Rutgers beat handily out in Bloomington not too many years ago - is painful. Yeah, they had Mark Cuban money last year. But Kurt Cignetti can by ******** well coach.
 

rutgersguy2

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
5,663
2,794
112
UCLA was a dumpster fire last year and they're 10-0.
Clawson was 4-8 in his last 2 seasons at WF and left because he thought they couldn't compete in the new NIL/portal landscape.

Dickert came in and should've had 10 wins last year (non call offsides at the end of GT game screwed them when they were killing the clock) and will likely have 10 this year. Strong chance for the ACC champ game and I think will make it into the playoff rankings this week.

He's done it with 2 qbs at WF and multiple over his tenure as HC at WSU/WF and multiple OCs too. I like that, faces change and you're still performing solid to well means the constant is the HC not any particular coach or player.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,140
90,298
113
Clawson was 4-8 in his last 2 seasons at WF and left because he thought they couldn't compete in the new NIL/portal landscape.

Dickert came in and should've had 10 wins last year (non call offsides at the end of GT game screwed them when they were killing the clock) and will likely have 10 this year. Strong chance for the ACC champ game and I think will make it into the playoff rankings this week.

He's done it with 2 qbs at WF and multiple over his tenure as HC at WSU/WF and multiple OCs too. I like that, faces change and you're still performing solid to well means the constant is the HC not any particular coach or player.
but but but only Greg can do it. And what if we get another Ash or Flood?

Rob Saturday Night Live GIF
 

NewHondo77

Junior
Jul 8, 2025
196
204
43
Clawson was 4-8 in his last 2 seasons at WF and left because he thought they couldn't compete in the new NIL/portal landscape.

Dickert came in and should've had 10 wins last year (non call offsides at the end of GT game screwed them when they were killing the clock) and will likely have 10 this year. Strong chance for the ACC champ game and I think will make it into the playoff rankings this week.

He's done it with 2 qbs at WF and multiple over his tenure as HC at WSU/WF and multiple OCs too. I like that, faces change and you're still performing solid to well means the constant is the HC not any particular coach or player.
Yeah, but we don’t have a field house.
 

Jerseylegends

All-Conference
Mar 15, 2023
1,761
1,914
113
but but but only Greg can do it. And what if we get another Ash or Flood?

Rob Saturday Night Live GIF
Listen, the infrastructure is outdated, I know schiano said this was the most talented team he's ever had at the beginning of the season and that he was finally able to spend his time coaching because the athletic department stepped up in a big way. Kc's new "smart" offensive game plan that prioritizes execution as opposed to deception is not the problem here. It's the outdated infrastructure, 50 billion should cover it. Then Schiano and Rutgers football will take flight. 😉
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,140
90,298
113
Listen, the infrastructure is outdated, I know schiano said this was the most talented team he's ever had at the beginning of the season and that he was finally able to spend his time coaching because the athletic department stepped up in a big way. Kc's new "smart" offensive game plan that prioritizes execution as opposed to deception is not the problem here. It's the outdated infrastructure, 50 billion should cover it. Then Schiano and Rutgers football will take flight. 😉
Seems other teams have repeated the error of "R" ways.

WVU.

"If you're in the administration at Florida State and talking yourself into Jimbo Fisher as the new/old head coach, it might be useful to look at a recent example of a school reaching into its past. At West Virginia, the second go-round with Rich Rodriguez simply isn't working. If anything, it's worse than ever after a 37-14 loss at home to Kansas. This is what happens when boosters who don't know anything about football beyond their nostalgia clamor for a coach who makes them feel the warm fuzzies they remember from the good old days."

DING, DING, DING

And while not a retread/rehire, this fits Schiano:
"Instead, Michigan has gotten the grandfather-philosopher version of Whittingham whose general serenity is not matching the nature of the results."

And Dabo at Clemson, but Greg never got the results Dabo got in his prime:
"Yes, Clemson had injuries, including to quarterback Tait Reynolds early in the game. But giving up 269 rushing yards to Georgia Tech is an indictment of the entire operation and demands accountability. Swinney's $57 million buyout (without a mitigation clause if he takes another job) is ridiculous and perhaps prohibitive. A forced separation would be painful and ugly. But so is a 2-9 record in Swinney's last 11 home games against power conference opponents."


 
  • Like
Reactions: Jerseylegends

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Listen, the infrastructure is outdated, I know schiano said this was the most talented team he's ever had at the beginning of the season and that he was finally able to spend his time coaching because the athletic department stepped up in a big way. Kc's new "smart" offensive game plan that prioritizes execution as opposed to deception is not the problem here. It's the outdated infrastructure, 50 billion should cover it. Then Schiano and Rutgers football will take flight. 😉
FWIW, the small playbook and execution mantra was the same last year.
 

RobertG

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
13,771
13,493
113
Coaching and winning came before any money showed up!!!
Here is an article from Mar 12, 2024, 08:00 AM ET


"That belief is backed by what he deems a substantial financial investment, something that hasn't always existed at Indiana. That began with a $15.5 million buyout to fire coach Tom Allen. Curt Cignetti said the NIL investment "is at least triple" what it had been."

Cignetti asked for and received the money before his first season.
 

Rob from NJ

Sophomore
Jul 8, 2025
78
160
33
Here is an article from Mar 12, 2024, 08:00 AM ET


"That belief is backed by what he deems a substantial financial investment, something that hasn't always existed at Indiana. That began with a $15.5 million buyout to fire coach Tom Allen. Curt Cignetti said the NIL investment "is at least triple" what it had been."

Cignetti asked for and received the money before his first season.

Coach Cignetti’s first year at Indiana (2024) saw NIL spending in the $15 million range, according to his own comments, which he used to counter higher claims and to support a competitive roster without the extreme spending seen in 2026. The NIL spending in 2024 did not include one penny from Cuban's wallet as Cuban jumped on board in December 2024 after Indiana made their Playoff appearance. Indiana's 2024 roster did not include one 5 star recruit, and only a handful of 4 star recruits. The backbone of Indiana's roster was JMU portal transfers that played in the Sun Belt Conference.
 

rutgersguy2

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
5,663
2,794
112
Coach Cignetti’s first year at Indiana (2024) saw NIL spending in the $15 million range, according to his own comments, which he used to counter higher claims and to support a competitive roster without the extreme spending seen in 2026. The NIL spending in 2024 did not include one penny from Cuban's wallet as Cuban jumped on board in December 2024 after Indiana made their Playoff appearance. Indiana's 2024 roster did not include one 5 star recruit, and only a handful of 4 star recruits. The backbone of Indiana's roster was JMU portal transfers that played in the Sun Belt Conference.
That number was for the 2025 championship roster not 2024.

How much did Indiana spend last year to build a national championship roster? We may never know the exact figure, but Hoosiers coach Curt Cignetti dropped some significant breadcrumbs Wednesday.

“What I will tell you, honestly, okay, is our final number was closer to $15 million than $40 million,” Cignetti said during an appearance on Andy and Ari On3. “Now, obviously, it was somewhere in between.”

 

Rob from NJ

Sophomore
Jul 8, 2025
78
160
33
That number was for the 2025 championship roster not 2024.

How much did Indiana spend last year to build a national championship roster? We may never know the exact figure, but Hoosiers coach Curt Cignetti dropped some significant breadcrumbs Wednesday.

“What I will tell you, honestly, okay, is our final number was closer to $15 million than $40 million,” Cignetti said during an appearance on Andy and Ari On3. “Now, obviously, it was somewhere in between.”

Yes you're correct. I do know that the Indiana NIL Collective raised approximately $14M in 2024. Not all of it went for football so the spend in 2024, a year in which Cignetti and Indiana went to the Playoffs was less than $15M for the football roster. Point is Cignetti won a lot of football games in 2024 and Cuban was not involved.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,140
90,298
113
That number was for the 2025 championship roster not 2024.

How much did Indiana spend last year to build a national championship roster? We may never know the exact figure, but Hoosiers coach Curt Cignetti dropped some significant breadcrumbs Wednesday.

“What I will tell you, honestly, okay, is our final number was closer to $15 million than $40 million,” Cignetti said during an appearance on Andy and Ari On3. “Now, obviously, it was somewhere in between.”

I see Rob accepted your clarification/correction. But it would be useful if there was a scroll/pinned thread of these things/myths/narratives about NIL, Greg's buyout, Greg's original hiring and contract extension being forced on Hobbs by the big donors, etc.
 

rutgersguy2

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
5,663
2,794
112
I see Rob accepted your clarification/correction. But it would be useful if there was a scroll/pinned thread of these things/myths/narratives about NIL, Greg's buyout, Greg's original hiring and contract extension being forced on Hobbs by the big donors, etc.
Yea I always said you can't trust all these accounts of NIL and amounts with any sort of granularity. There is no transparency and everyone can talk up or talk down numbers depending on who is doing the talking or who is the audience. So I don't really trust anything on its face too much. The most I'd go to is that in terms of relative vicinity maybe there's some accuracy there but beyond that who knows.

The IU AD had to take an internal loan from the school to pay Allen's buyout. If they were so flush with cash why would they need to do that? You also have a coach in his 60s who had never gotten an opportunity for a P4 job in his career. He had to go the losingest program in the P4 to get a chance. How much leverage do you think a candidate like that has to demand anything? You can't view this backwards through the prism of CC the national champion HC but CC the 60+ yr old coach who never has gotten a shot anywhere in the P4 after decades. He also brought a bunch of players from JMU, how much demand was there for them, what would the market value been for them? It's not to say IU didn't have anything but more to say I think there's some inflation on what some think vs what they actually had in year 1 of CC.
 

RedTeamUpstream94

All-American
Jan 15, 2021
3,566
6,693
113
Greg is a straight up con artist. That's how he will be remembered here. Guy is living proof of becoming the villain over the years instead of being remembered as a hero.

so unfortunate.

i have, for decades, been on the “Schiano is the only guy that can make it happen for RU” boat.

But now it’s really inarguable that the critics/ cynics were right all along

it’s a painful realization . I hate when the haters are correct .

he’s been conning us along.
 
  • Like
Reactions: newell138

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,140
90,298
113
Yea I always said you can't trust all these accounts of NIL and amounts with any sort of granularity. There is no transparency and everyone can talk up or talk down numbers depending on who is doing the talking or who is the audience. So I don't really trust anything on its face too much. The most I'd go to is that in terms of relative vicinity maybe there's some accuracy there but beyond that who knows.

The IU AD had to take an internal loan from the school to pay Allen's buyout. If they were so flush with cash why would they need to do that? You also have a coach in his 60s who had never gotten an opportunity for a P4 job in his career. He had to go the losingest program in the P4 to get a chance. How much leverage do you think a candidate like that has to demand anything? You can't view this backwards through the prism of CC the national champion HC but CC the 60+ yr old coach who never has gotten a shot anywhere in the P4 after decades. He also brought a bunch of players from JMU, how much demand was there for them, what would the market value been for them? It's not to say IU didn't have anything but more to say I think there's some inflation on what some think vs what they actually had in year 1 of CC.
As usual, you are far too rational for a football message board. ;) False and/or inaccurate narratives and unhinged bellyaching rule college sports message boards.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,140
90,298
113
so unfortunate.

i have, for decades, been on the “Schiano is the only guy that can make it happen for RU” boat.

But now it’s really inarguable that the critics/ cynics were right all along

it’s a painful realization . I hate when the haters are correct .

he’s been conning us along.
Are they haters though, if they saw something sooner than others?
"Hater" is just a label used to silence or discredit someone. That Shelby guy is an exception, however.
 

rutgersguy2

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
5,663
2,794
112
so unfortunate.

i have, for decades, been on the “Schiano is the only guy that can make it happen for RU” boat.

But now it’s really inarguable that the critics/ cynics were right all along

it’s a painful realization . I hate when the haters are correct .

he’s been conning us along.
That should be the case for anywhere not just GS/RU. The world is big and there are a lot of capable people out there for any sort job, including coaching. No one should ever think, this is the only person who can do this.

I've said this in one of these threads. Look at a small school like WF. Their last 3 coaches will likely have won double digit games in a season. Clawson (one of those WF coaches who won double digits) left after 2 4-8 seasons thinking they couldn't compete in a NIL/portal world and Dickert comes in an wins 9 (should've been 10 if not for refs at the end of the GT game) in year 1 and probably double digits and competing for the ACC title game and CFP spot in year 2. There are capable people out there. You just have to keep trying and not be stuck.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU on Manns Planet

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,140
90,298
113
Defense?

The QB from Wisconsin- first start against Rutgers: 18/24 241 yards and 3 TDs. He's the next Brett Favre!

Against Maryland on Saturday (a team Rutgers scored 37 points on): 11/22 for 77 yards QBR of 5.3!!!!!! Wisconsin had 201 yards of total offense.

Some teams get better as the season goes on, especially after they fire their HC. Rutgers is not that team.
 

RobertG

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
13,771
13,493
113
Yea I always said you can't trust all these accounts of NIL and amounts with any sort of granularity. There is no transparency and everyone can talk up or talk down numbers depending on who is doing the talking or who is the audience. So I don't really trust anything on its face too much. The most I'd go to is that in terms of relative vicinity maybe there's some accuracy there but beyond that who knows.

The IU AD had to take an internal loan from the school to pay Allen's buyout. If they were so flush with cash why would they need to do that? You also have a coach in his 60s who had never gotten an opportunity for a P4 job in his career. He had to go the losingest program in the P4 to get a chance. How much leverage do you think a candidate like that has to demand anything? You can't view this backwards through the prism of CC the national champion HC but CC the 60+ yr old coach who never has gotten a shot anywhere in the P4 after decades. He also brought a bunch of players from JMU, how much demand was there for them, what would the market value been for them? It's not to say IU didn't have anything but more to say I think there's some inflation on what some think vs what they actually had in year 1 of CC.
Cignetti has done a phenomenal coaching job at Indiana, but the narrative that he won with no NIL and his winning then brought in the NIL is not supported by the articles from 2024.

May 22nd 2024


Indiana football's NIL is 'a lot more than what I was promised,' says Curt Cignetti​



Aside from the NIL this article gives an insight into how Cignetti changed his philosophy and apparently Schiano didn't.

Cignetti said his approach to recruiting has also changed over the years to adjust for the transfer portal and NIL. Instead of building programs through mostly high school recruits and multi-year, developmental players, like he did at his previous head coaching stops, the strategy now is immediate success, which means adding immediate-impact transfers.

"I think you always want to sign 15 to 20 high school kids, always," Cignetti said. "And then you're always going to be in the portal to fill immediate needs. But you can't say that we're going to do it with high school kids because they may leave. That's just how it is nowadays; it's free agency.

"So a lot of things have changed in the last two to three years. You've got to be light on your feet, flexible and adjust, improvise and thrive or you're not going to survive."

Change in college football is inevitable, and Cignetti is adjusting on the fly, just as all other coaches and programs must do.

But if not for Indiana's increased NIL pool, it would be a much tougher job for Cignetti in the present and future. Instead, he's received everything he was promised in NIL support since he arrived — and more.

"I think football's really changed. Back in the old days, (coaches) would get four to six-year contracts and by year three would want to be here," Cignetti said. "You got to win every year now. I mean, with the internet, social media, you've got to win every year. You got to, period. Every year to me is like four years in the past."
 

rutgersguy2

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
5,663
2,794
112
Cignetti has done a phenomenal coaching job at Indiana, but the narrative that he won with no NIL and his winning then brought in the NIL is not supported by the articles from 2024.

May 22nd 2024


Indiana football's NIL is 'a lot more than what I was promised,' says Curt Cignetti​



Aside from the NIL this article gives an insight into how Cignetti changed his philosophy and apparently Schiano didn't.

Cignetti said his approach to recruiting has also changed over the years to adjust for the transfer portal and NIL. Instead of building programs through mostly high school recruits and multi-year, developmental players, like he did at his previous head coaching stops, the strategy now is immediate success, which means adding immediate-impact transfers.

"I think you always want to sign 15 to 20 high school kids, always," Cignetti said. "And then you're always going to be in the portal to fill immediate needs. But you can't say that we're going to do it with high school kids because they may leave. That's just how it is nowadays; it's free agency.

"So a lot of things have changed in the last two to three years. You've got to be light on your feet, flexible and adjust, improvise and thrive or you're not going to survive."

Change in college football is inevitable, and Cignetti is adjusting on the fly, just as all other coaches and programs must do.

But if not for Indiana's increased NIL pool, it would be a much tougher job for Cignetti in the present and future. Instead, he's received everything he was promised in NIL support since he arrived — and more.

"I think football's really changed. Back in the old days, (coaches) would get four to six-year contracts and by year three would want to be here," Cignetti said. "You got to win every year now. I mean, with the internet, social media, you've got to win every year. You got to, period. Every year to me is like four years in the past."
I've read and seen all the articles. I didn't say they didn't have any NIL but I don't also don't believe it's probably as much some think. I gave the logic of why I think that too and I don't think there's anything unreasonable about the conclusion. People used to say Cuban donated in year 1 too but eventually that article with his quotes came out and that was disproven. A lot of assumptions without really looking deeper.

I've seen plenty of articles, not IU specifically, that NIL numbers aren't always as high as reported also. Like I said depending on who is doing the talking and who is the audience people can talk up or even talk down the numbers. Anyone can say double or triple or more than promised but from what starting point. 1 dollar to 3 dollars is triple. Without transparency, you can't know. If it was like coaching contracts, I can believe it but otherwise anyone can just talk up or talk down numbers to suit their needs of the moment. Everyone lift the curtain and let's see but they're not doing that.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,140
90,298
113
Cignetti has done a phenomenal coaching job at Indiana, but the narrative that he won with no NIL and his winning then brought in the NIL is not supported by the articles from 2024.

May 22nd 2024


Indiana football's NIL is 'a lot more than what I was promised,' says Curt Cignetti​



Aside from the NIL this article gives an insight into how Cignetti changed his philosophy and apparently Schiano didn't.

Cignetti said his approach to recruiting has also changed over the years to adjust for the transfer portal and NIL. Instead of building programs through mostly high school recruits and multi-year, developmental players, like he did at his previous head coaching stops, the strategy now is immediate success, which means adding immediate-impact transfers.

"I think you always want to sign 15 to 20 high school kids, always," Cignetti said. "And then you're always going to be in the portal to fill immediate needs. But you can't say that we're going to do it with high school kids because they may leave. That's just how it is nowadays; it's free agency.

"So a lot of things have changed in the last two to three years. You've got to be light on your feet, flexible and adjust, improvise and thrive or you're not going to survive."

Change in college football is inevitable, and Cignetti is adjusting on the fly, just as all other coaches and programs must do.

But if not for Indiana's increased NIL pool, it would be a much tougher job for Cignetti in the present and future. Instead, he's received everything he was promised in NIL support since he arrived — and more.

"I think football's really changed. Back in the old days, (coaches) would get four to six-year contracts and by year three would want to be here," Cignetti said. "You got to win every year now. I mean, with the internet, social media, you've got to win every year. You got to, period. Every year to me is like four years in the past."
That's great. But it was not a lot. "A lot more" is not a number. $61.6 million was Indiana’s total football spending for 2024, while Rutgers' total spend was $64.4M.

Reasonable estimates indicate their NIL spend was $12.6-13.6M.
Rutgers' spend for 2024 was estimated between $8M-15M. Not vastly different.
Illinois spent about $9M in 2024 and went 10-3.
Iowa spent about $9.6M and went 6-3 in the B1G.

 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,972
8,946
113
Yea I always said you can't trust all these accounts of NIL and amounts with any sort of granularity. There is no transparency and everyone can talk up or talk down numbers depending on who is doing the talking or who is the audience. So I don't really trust anything on its face too much. The most I'd go to is that in terms of relative vicinity maybe there's some accuracy there but beyond that who knows.

The IU AD had to take an internal loan from the school to pay Allen's buyout. If they were so flush with cash why would they need to do that? You also have a coach in his 60s who had never gotten an opportunity for a P4 job in his career. He had to go the losingest program in the P4 to get a chance. How much leverage do you think a candidate like that has to demand anything? You can't view this backwards through the prism of CC the national champion HC but CC the 60+ yr old coach who never has gotten a shot anywhere in the P4 after decades. He also brought a bunch of players from JMU, how much demand was there for them, what would the market value been for them? It's not to say IU didn't have anything but more to say I think there's some inflation on what some think vs what they actually had in year 1 of CC.
This is the clearest analysis of what actually went on at Indiana. There was an article in The Athletic with anonymous comments from multiple power conference coaches after Indiana won the NC. When all of those JMU players went into the portal, there was no interest. The general consensus was that those players weren't good enough to play major conference football at a high level. The explanations in the media for Indiana's turnaround were laughable. The hot take pundits were wrong every step of the way.
 

RobertG

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
13,771
13,493
113
That's great. But it was not a lot. "A lot more" is not a number. $61.6 million was Indiana’s total football spending for 2024, while Rutgers' total spend was $64.4M.

Reasonable estimates indicate their NIL spend was $12.6-13.6M.
Rutgers' spend for 2024 was estimated between $8M-15M. Not vastly different.
Illinois spent about $9M in 2024 and went 10-3.
Iowa spent about $9.6M and went 6-3 in the B1G.

I think we are all in agreement here. Cignetti did a great job with less than the big boys had. My initial response was to RUBlackout who wrote :

"Coaching and winning came before any money showed up!!!"

Which is simply not the case. And by me saying that, I'm not defending Schiano.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,140
90,298
113
I think we are all in agreement here. Cignetti did a great job with less than the big boys had. My initial response was to RUBlackout who wrote :

"Coaching and winning came before any money showed up!!!"

Which is simply not the case. And by me saying that, I'm not defending Schiano.
I was not following, and not trying to impugn any particular poster. The narratives do grow tired about NIL spend vs. coaching ability and player development.
Sorry to beat a dead horse, but Greg's spend has been middle of pack in the B1G each year, but his coaching and player development has been terrible. We need to look no further than the QB position. On a positive side, RB and WR development has been good, but most every other position has been terrible, particularly on defense and special teams.
 

RobertG

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
13,771
13,493
113
I was not following, and not trying to impugn any particular poster. The narratives do grow tired about NIL spend vs. coaching ability and player development.
Sorry to beat a dead horse, but Greg's spend has been middle of pack in the B1G each year, but his coaching and player development has been terrible. We need to look no further than the QB position. On a positive side, RB and WR development has been good, but most every other position has been terrible, particularly on defense and special teams.
I'm agreeing with you. Schiano has done a bad coaching job, inclusive of misspending NIL money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Given the opportunity cost of Schiano raising his own NIL, I tried to build this into my view of the performance of the program prior to 2026. After all, every person has finite bandwidth. Thus, I left SOME possibility open that after being freed from NIL that he was finally playing on a level playing field from the standpoint of his own time AND had a decent level of money to work with.

Never in a million years did I envision this. I was thinking 5-6 wins, figuring almost every season, a couple of Big Ten teams are worse than predicted and I figured he’d go 3-0 OOC and find 2-3 wins in the Big Ten.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  2. 02 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three
  3. 03 The Knight Report Basketball How to watch Rutgers / Notre Dame; Pregame Info, More: Gameday Central
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Houston Postgame Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener