Deadman Schiano isn’t good at anything anymore…

scarletrat99

Junior
Oct 3, 2025
131
231
43
He can’t pick the groceries, despite being given middle of pack Big 10 money

He clearly can’t coach, has lost the identity of aggressive special teams and defense.

He can’t coach up teams

He can’t outcoach or out-scheme anyone except for Locksley, who was fired

he can’t overcome adversity, like other teams with backup QBs

25+ years and he can’t figure out running QBs

he takes copious notes on sidelines and always says he has to change, he has to review…really?

He can’t stop making boneheaded, stubborn in game decisions

he can’t coach D that was supposed to be his strength

do results ever matter?
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,042
108
It’s a fair question to ask what advantage he brings now. Used to have tough Ds. Used to block kicks, albeit vs mostly bad teams with inferior athletes so to me that was always over sold. Used to seem above average at finding hidden gems and developing them…..Haslam, McCourtys, Renkart, etc. DBs always seemed to be a strength.

In 2.0, since he’s older and more experienced, you might expect things to look a little bit different. Maybe he is now more of a CEO and his skill is hiring coordinators but we have not seen this to say it nicely. Maybe with all of his years of experience, he knows a lot of guys in talent evaluation and would bring in an exceptional scout. I don’t think we’ve seen that either.

IDK
 

rosenst2

Junior
Nov 6, 2021
212
299
63
He's been more gun shy on D and special teams the last few years.

What happened to the corner blitz off the short side of the field on 2nd or 3rd and long? What about those jail break blitzes he ran during 1.0,?

The worst are the lack of kick returns for a struggling offense. Every yard he gives up doing that has to be made up for by the offense. Would he do the same if he had a Cruickshank or Janarion Grant? Sadly, I think he would.

It's time to cut ties with him, but the buyout money is preventing it. Next year, we are going to be Maryland this year. ☹️
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,715
151,549
113
He can’t pick the groceries, despite being given middle of pack Big 10 money

He clearly can’t coach, has lost the identity of aggressive special teams and defense.

He can’t coach up teams

He can’t outcoach or out-scheme anyone except for Locksley, who was fired

he can’t overcome adversity, like other teams with backup QBs

25+ years and he can’t figure out running QBs

he takes copious notes on sidelines and always says he has to change, he has to review…really?

He can’t stop making boneheaded, stubborn in game decisions

he can’t coach D that was supposed to be his strength

do results ever matter?
Good post. I’d say he’s great. At fair catches, killing excitement and destroying a program and fanbase. This is much worse than Ash. He was done quickly in comparison.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,546
61,873
113
He's been GREAT at not changing for 25-years. Anyone thinking he's going to "change," in any sort of increment that matters, is out of their freakin' minds. IT'S NOT HAPPENING. Here's my guess:

- he will come out of the portal telling everyone that we "got the guys we needed." Some "really good character kids" who "fill the holes...we're not a million miles away here, we're close...to fill a couple of those holes we needed to fill" AND USE THIS as a catalyst to NOT CHANGE a single damn thing going into next season.

...and after Akron scares the bejesus out of us, at home, he loses to BC (again).
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,715
151,549
113
He's been GREAT at not changing for 25-years. Anyone thinking he's going to "change," in any sort of increment that matters, is out of their freakin' minds. IT'S NOT HAPPENING. Here's my guess:

- he will come out of the portal telling everyone that we "got the guys we needed." Some "really good character kids" who "fill the holes...we're not a million miles away here, we're close...to fill a couple of those holes we needed to fill" AND USE THIS as a catalyst to NOT CHANGE a single damn thing going into next season.

...and after Akron scares the bejesus out of us, at home, he loses to BC (again).
Always said that which made him moderately successful in 1.0 will ultimately be his down fall.

Great or even good coaches evolve and change. Saban's last teams played completely different than his early teams. He saw where the game was going and when his teams started having trouble with up tempo faster teams, that's what he built. Schiano by comparison has been getting curb stomped by uptempo and running QBs dating all the way back to when Chip Kelly was the OC at New Hampshire. We were up 10 at the half and Kelly completely outcoached Schiano at the half, which happens nearly every game. We do more of the same, they adjust, they win. Wash rinse repeat. It's what makes him a terrible coach. Stubborn and inability to adapt. His first, second, third, fourth, etc. inclination is to always do more of what you are already doing, only do it better. That's the only reason it isn't successful. I love when he tells everyone he's going to assess everything and figure it out, only to do the exact same things he's been doing his entire career. He's the definition of meathead. Not one creative bone in his body.
 

charliem24

All-Conference
Jul 18, 2005
16,914
1,470
103
It’s a fair question to ask what advantage he brings now. Used to have tough Ds. Used to block kicks, albeit vs mostly bad teams with inferior athletes so to me that was always over sold. Used to seem above average at finding hidden gems and developing them…..Haslam, McCourtys, Renkart, etc. DBs always seemed to be a strength.

In 2.0, since he’s older and more experienced, you might expect things to look a little bit different. Maybe he is now more of a CEO and his skill is hiring coordinators but we have not seen this to say it nicely. Maybe with all of his years of experience, he knows a lot of guys in talent evaluation and would bring in an exceptional scout. I don’t think we’ve seen that either.

IDK
Seems like he is coaching very hard to not lose, used to coach, at least defensively, to win.
 

RUChet

All-Conference
Apr 8, 2023
3,471
4,228
113
He's been GREAT at not changing for 25-years. Anyone thinking he's going to "change," in any sort of increment that matters, is out of their freakin' minds. IT'S NOT HAPPENING. Here's my guess:

- he will come out of the portal telling everyone that we "got the guys we needed." Some "really good character kids" who "fill the holes...we're not a million miles away here, we're close...to fill a couple of those holes we needed to fill" AND USE THIS as a catalyst to NOT CHANGE a single damn thing going into next season.

...and after Akron scares the bejesus out of us, at home, he loses to BC (again).
Actually he has changed a lot from 1.0 to 2.0 and all for the worse

1.0 defenses were exciting between the blitzing, schemes, overall speed etc - our D is vanilla and sucks

1.0 special teams were one of the best - now we never block kicks, don’t return kicks, boring and vanilla

1.0 offense at its peak used the TE and RB much better in passing game

So yes, he’s changed. And all changes are hurting us
 

LeapinLou

All-American
Jul 24, 2001
13,547
7,654
113
It's not his fault Rutgers is too screwed up to be able to fire him. The only thing we could have hoped for is that he loved Rutgers enough to know his time has come and negotiate a buyout that doesn't cripple us. Since that's not the case, we have one more year of this. These next two weeks are going to be a disaster and next year seems to be shaping up the same, barring some miraculous portal acquisitions this winter.
 
Last edited:

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,715
151,549
113
Schiano couldn't win the watered down BE when he had more resources than anyone. To think he can compete in the B1G when he has mid tier NIL is crazy. Rutgers needs a coach that is an actual good coach. Someone who can assess talent and recruit it to their system, and scheme to mitigate any talent deficiencies. Schiano is the complete opposite of that. It's all just a timing game now.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,715
151,549
113
It's not his fault Rutgers is too screwed up to be able to fire him. The only thing we could have hoped for is that he loved Rutgers enough to know his time has come and negotiate a buyout that doesn't cripple us. Since that's not the case, we have one more year of this. These next two week are going to be a disaster and next year seems to be shaping up the same, barring some miraculous portal acquisitions this winter.

Said it earlier in the year but I'd starve Schiano's program if I was Keli. Schiano has proven that the more money he has and spends the more he loses. As such, forget about giving him more. He's squandered that right. He obviously wouldn't play ball with the administration so play hardball with him. "Greg, we no longer believe in you and are forced to keep you. Your budget is being stripped down to enough to keep the lights on."

I'd then use those dollars for programs that deserve them and have proven they can win to bolster their chances of making tournaments and winning championships.

Let's be honest. Does it matter at this point if Greggo is losing 31-0 or 45-0 at this point? Strip his program down to the studs and let him wear those L's until a real staff can be brought in.
 

Jersey Al 64

Redshirt
Jul 9, 2025
26
17
3
Schiano couldn't win the watered down BE when he had more resources than anyone. To think he can compete in the B1G when he has mid tier NIL is crazy. Rutgers needs a coach that is an actual good coach. Someone who can assess talent and recruit it to their system, and scheme to mitigate any talent deficiencies. Schiano is the complete opposite of that. It's all just a timing game now.
In his big year of 2006 after beating Louisville, he came in 3rd. Flood got a 4 way tie for first.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Caliknight
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Basketball How to watch Rutgers / UNLV; Pregame Info, More: Gameday Central
  2. 02 The Knight Report Basketball Rutgers vs. UMES: How to Watch, Starting Lineups, Rankings & More
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Notre Dame Postgame Press Conference