Poll: Rafters, who do we want as our next coach & why?

Who do you want as our next coach and why?

  • Tommy Lloyd (Arizona)

    Votes: 42 26.1%
  • Nate Oats (Bama)

    Votes: 66 41.0%
  • Ben McCollum (Iowa)

    Votes: 18 11.2%
  • T.J. Otzelberger (Iowa St)

    Votes: 17 10.6%
  • Grant McCasland (Texas Tech)

    Votes: 14 8.7%
  • Josh Schertz (Saint Louis)

    Votes: 43 26.7%
  • Jai Lucas (Miami)

    Votes: 31 19.3%
  • Mark Byington (Vanderbilt)

    Votes: 10 6.2%
  • Ryan Odom (Virginia)

    Votes: 22 13.7%
  • Scott Drew (Baylor)

    Votes: 4 2.5%

  • Total voters
    161
Aug 4, 2025
609
901
93
Most of the above mentioned names are just as unproven as Pope and none of them are going to do anything in 2 years.

The guys who are more accomplished don’t really need this gig.

I think what people are most pissed about is that we don’t have the 24/7/365 hype infrastructure.

Knew that would be the hardest change post Cal.

Regardless of season, Cal created a pretty impressive machine. Top recruiting class hype. Some panned out some didn’t. Mattered not because at least UK was in the spotlight.

Pro camps, draft night, nba players coming to town to play pick up games, etc…

NIT year…so what we got dudes going pro and we got pros coming in. Sports illustrated and all the popular basketball culture loves Cal and us.

I understood all the reasons for Cal’s departure but knew deep down, the second things got a little squirrelly with the next guy fans would bail because nobody was going to replicate the machine that Cal had.

So really after 2 years it’s not about lack of titles. It’s about lack of cultural relevance and hype.

There’s one guy who can do that in short order. Oh yeah…I’m saying it.

Let’s get the band back together. Cal did say players first would pay dividends. Well 2-3% of a billion dollars worth of max contracts makes for a nice little NIL bump.

Let’s get world wide wes back here to run the front office.

Let’s get all “la familia” back in town. Let’s start up the pro combines and “greatest nights in program history” ceremonies on draft night.

Seth Greenberg and the boys will gush and UK fans will be riding high once again.
 

TFCat11

Heisman
Mar 25, 2019
6,471
12,086
108
I didn’t pick, because if the NIL isn’t competitive enough to win recruiting battles with our rivals, and I’m not fully convinced that it is, it’s not going to make .10 cents difference who the next coach is.

And we will soon find out if UK’s recruiting woes were a Pope problem, or a NIL problem once and for all.
 

Winston Wolf

Sophomore
Aug 15, 2004
2,253
138
48
I didn’t pick, because if the NIL isn’t competitive enough to win recruiting battles with our rivals, and I’m not fully convinced that it is, it’s not going to make .10 cents difference who the next coach is.

And we will soon find out if UK’s recruiting woes were a Pope problem, or a NIL problem once and for all.
You strike me as a Bruce Pearl guy.
 

Cleatortoises

Heisman
Dec 24, 2018
3,259
10,831
113
Most of the above mentioned names are just as unproven as Pope and none of them are going to do anything in 2 years.

The guys who are more accomplished don’t really need this gig.

I think what people are most pissed about is that we don’t have the 24/7/365 hype infrastructure.

Knew that would be the hardest change post Cal.

Regardless of season, Cal created a pretty impressive machine. Top recruiting class hype. Some panned out some didn’t. Mattered not because at least UK was in the spotlight.

Pro camps, draft night, nba players coming to town to play pick up games, etc…

NIT year…so what we got dudes going pro and we got pros coming in. Sports illustrated and all the popular basketball culture loves Cal and us.

I understood all the reasons for Cal’s departure but knew deep down, the second things got a little squirrelly with the next guy fans would bail because nobody was going to replicate the machine that Cal had.

So really after 2 years it’s not about lack of titles. It’s about lack of cultural relevance and hype.

There’s one guy who can do that in short order. Oh yeah…I’m saying it.

Let’s get the band back together. Cal did say players first would pay dividends. Well 2-3% of a billion dollars worth of max contracts makes for a nice little NIL bump.

Let’s get world wide wes back here to run the front office.

Let’s get all “la familia” back in town. Let’s start up the pro combines and “greatest nights in program history” ceremonies on draft night.

Seth Greenberg and the boys will gush and UK fans will be riding high once again.
🤮
Hey Brad, this job should be earned, not given.
 

UKCowboys

Heisman
Oct 14, 2019
5,871
11,228
113
It’s gonna be Oats. His NIL will be doubled here. He’s friends with Batt. I can’t ******* wait.
Oats is a good coach and would do well here. My pick was Mccasland if I could have anyone, but I would be fine with either. Problem as I see it is, Popes buyout is around $17M, Oats buyout is $18M. So now we are $35M in and we will need to pay Oats $8-10M per on top of that. Plus Stein will need a raise if we don't want to lose him.
UK spent $22M in basketball and $25M in football on NIL. By comparison, Texas spent $52M in football NIL alone. I cant see us spending north of $50M in buyouts and coaches salaries and then getting an increase on our $50M or so NIL. So I think the realistic thing is a coach without a buyout. Which brings me back to Pearl. Added bonus for Pearl....he could be here by the time we lace em up against Indiana
 

dynastydreamuk

All-Conference
Nov 18, 2010
1,941
1,616
113
I agree on the unproven guys. I’m really shocked at how many people I’ve seen wanting Jai Lucas. He may turn out great but he’s coached all of ONE season in college.

Mind you I made the same argument about Todd Golden 2 years ago. But that’s the thing, you just don’t know until they’ve proven themselves. For every Todd Golden there are about 10 Shaka Smart’s. I’d much rather someone of the caliber of Oats, Lloyd, or Wade (who did actually take NC State to the final four this past year)
Wade wasn't the coach at NC state when they went to that final four, I liked your post anyway haha.
But yea we need as close to a sure thing as we can, somebody who is proven recruiter with proven NCAA success or multiple conference championships/30 win seasons.
 

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,651
36,371
113
Wade wasn't the coach at NC state when they went to that final four, I liked your post anyway haha.
But yea we need as close to a sure thing as we can, somebody who is proven recruiter with proven NCAA success or multiple conference championships/30 win seasons.
Oh I’m an idiot. I was looking at his coaching record on Wikipedia and misread FIRST four as Final Four 😂 Those are a little bit different aren’t they?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: dynastydreamuk

CorbinComet

Sophomore
Jan 17, 2026
58
116
33
Bruce Pearl is a sleazeball of the highest order but if you want to win and win big, Pearl would absolutely kill it here. He is made for a job like this. He's probably itching to get back on the court and in the biggest spotlight possible. I despise him but he would would win and win huge in Lexington. Only drawback is that we might have to see his bare chest painted blue. Oh, and maybe some program probation a few years down the road.
 

UKCowboys

Heisman
Oct 14, 2019
5,871
11,228
113
Bruce Pearl is a sleazeball of the highest order but if you want to win and win big, Pearl would absolutely kill it here. He is made for a job like this. He's probably itching to get back on the court and in the biggest spotlight possible. I despise him but he would would win and win huge in Lexington. Only drawback is that we might have to see his bare chest painted blue. Oh, and maybe some program probation a few years down the road.
Rick was a sleezeball of the highest order too.....bring on Pearl
 

UKCowboys

Heisman
Oct 14, 2019
5,871
11,228
113
Such misguided click whores on this site. Just read popes contract now. If he he gets to Sweet 16 he gets auto extension. So smoke on that a while
100% fact. Which means....if this club makes the S16, there is a 0.00% chance he gets the axe. The reason no one is worrying about the extention clause is you have to make the Big Dance in order to make the S16, so its irrelevant
 

Cleatortoises

Heisman
Dec 24, 2018
3,259
10,831
113
Bruce Pearl is a sleazeball of the highest order but if you want to win and win big, Pearl would absolutely kill it here. He is made for a job like this. He's probably itching to get back on the court and in the biggest spotlight possible. I despise him but he would would win and win huge in Lexington. Only drawback is that we might have to see his bare chest painted blue. Oh, and maybe some program probation a few years down the road.
How can you get on probation now?
You can have all the BBQ's you want and hand out 100's if you feel like it. 🍖🥩💸💰
 

warrior-cat

Hall of Famer
Oct 22, 2004
192,379
158,185
113
For me, I want an up-and-coming hungry coach. Don't watch enough of other programs right now to know who that might be, but the powers that run the program should be all over it to make it happen. No guys over 60. Regardless of who we get though, he would have to be tough and thick skinned because this fan base is ready to riot if we don't have an immediate winner (meaning contender).
 

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,651
36,371
113

T.J. Otzelberger​


First off, we could get him. Second, won tourney games with South Dakota State and had consistently made Iowa State good in a good basketball conference. And he’s not even 50.
There’re a few I’d prefer first, but he’d be on my list too. I’d just have to figure out how to pronounce his name right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dynastydreamuk

Drcatfan

All-Conference
Apr 14, 2015
1,452
1,705
61
One thing is for sure, Pope was a colossally bad hire. We went from a bad situation to an absolute dumpster fire. The longer we keep Pope, we are doing more damage to the program.

If there is any positive, it's that in the current landscape of NIL a homerun coach can turn a program around in one year.
 

MaysviileKY

Senior
Jul 17, 2025
562
672
93
Schertz wins with the talent he has. He has an uptempo offense and can adapt as needed. He schemes shooters open!

And even though it was at the D2 level, he has multiple final 4 and championship game experience.

And he’s great with media and boosters! With a higher level of talent (which I’m confident he can get), he can get UK back to the elite level. Unfortunately, I think he may have an agreement with UT and is why he turned down NC State last year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dynastydreamuk

Reggie Noble

Senior
Jul 5, 2025
287
457
63
I agree on the unproven guys. I’m really shocked at how many people I’ve seen wanting Jai Lucas. He may turn out great but he’s coached all of ONE season in college.

Mind you I made the same argument about Todd Golden 2 years ago. But that’s the thing, you just don’t know until they’ve proven themselves. For every Todd Golden there are about 10 Shaka Smart’s. I’d much rather someone of the caliber of Oats, Lloyd, or Wade (who did actually take NC State to the final four this past year)

"For every Todd Golden there are about 10 Shaka Smart’s."

Shaka Smart took VCU to the Final four, he wasn't some unproven, had done nothing coach.
 

HipTer

All-Conference
Apr 11, 2012
1,206
1,069
113

T.J. Otzelberger​


First off, we could get him. Second, won tourney games with South Dakota State and had consistently made Iowa State good in a good basketball conference. And he’s not even 50.
I might prefer Grant McCasland, but it would be close. I think both get their guys to play with intensity, defend and rebound; and while I think Otzelberger has shown better offense lately, I think McCasland's offenses have been better consistently.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dynastydreamuk

Reggie Noble

Senior
Jul 5, 2025
287
457
63
Why take a chance on someone like Schertz? He has never recruited at this level, hell Pope had recruited higher level players than Schertz while at BYU, got here and can't level up. We thought Pope would recruit better here because of NIL he didn't. Why take a chance on "he'll recruit better here"? Get someone that's proven to recruit at this level. Talent is our number 1 issue. Jimmies and Joes are the most important thing.
 

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
30,605
74,023
113
Why take a chance on someone like Schertz? He has never recruited at this level, hell Pope had recruited higher level players than Schertz while at BYU, got here and can't level up. We thought Pope would recruit better here because of NIL he didn't. Why take a chance on "he'll recruit better here"? Get someone that's proven to recruit at this level. Talent is our number 1 issue. Jimmies and Joes are the most important thing.
Agree 300%. Recruiting turns average bench coaches into greats.
 

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,651
36,371
113
"For every Todd Golden there are about 10 Shaka Smart’s."

Shaka Smart took VCU to the Final four, he wasn't some unproven, had done nothing coach.
That’s a fair point actually. He did well at VCU. Taking them to a final four was really impressive. But on the flipside, I remember being very happy when he got signed at Texas because it would be a perfect place for him to show if he could have sustained success at a bigger school, which, of course he decided he did not.

But that’s why I would strongly prefer someone like Tommy Lloyd or Nate Oats who have been at a major school for a while and have shown they didn’t just catch lightning in a bottle.
 

HeismanWinner

All-Conference
Sep 12, 2025
1,504
3,608
113
One thing is for sure, Pope was a colossally bad hire. We went from a bad situation to an absolute dumpster fire. The longer we keep Pope, we are doing more damage to the program.

If there is any positive, it's that in the current landscape of NIL a homerun coach can turn a program around in one year.
He wasn't on any of our lists of even being a possibility until the night it said that he would be hired.

He is undeniably the least accomplished coach to take the reigns here since well before Rupp. At least Gillispie made a Sweet 16 before being hired.
 

MaysviileKY

Senior
Jul 17, 2025
562
672
93
Why take a chance on someone like Schertz? He has never recruited at this level, hell Pope had recruited higher level players than Schertz while at BYU, got here and can't level up. We thought Pope would recruit better here because of NIL he didn't. Why take a chance on "he'll recruit better here"? Get someone that's proven to recruit at this level. Talent is our number 1 issue. Jimmies and Joes are the most important thing.
Then why did Cal get run off?
 

entropy13

All-American
Apr 27, 2010
3,941
7,493
113
Are there any up and coming greaseball Italian coaches who've had some level of postseason success? We seem to do well with those.

I'm talking some real 💯 goomba-a(s)s wop who sweats olive oil and bleeds marinara sauce.

Anyone like that available?
 

Anon1739778738

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2025
827
1,163
93
C'mon. Indiana hasn't been in a F4 since 2002. Not close.

You do wonder if moving on him now open up the chance to go to market for his replacement in advance. Probably lose Hampton & Millogo is the downside, along with any current player you'd like to retain.
Let them go a good recruiter can get better than both
 

Anon1739778738

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2025
827
1,163
93
Bruce Pearl is a sleazeball of the highest order but if you want to win and win big, Pearl would absolutely kill it here. He is made for a job like this. He's probably itching to get back on the court and in the biggest spotlight possible. I despise him but he would would win and win huge in Lexington. Only drawback is that we might have to see his bare chest painted blue. Oh, and maybe some program probation a few years down the road.
No body gives a hoot about a barbecue he would kill it here and have us going in no time
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Sources Say goes LIVE to talk Grambling State win and take an early look at Indiana
  2. 02 KSR Podcasts 11 Personnel, No Huddle! with Kyle McAreavy from MizzouToday
  3. 03 KSR Women's Basketball Emily McDonald named SEC Freshman of the Week for record-breaking performance
  4. 04 KSR Football Kentucky Football unveils uniforms for Missouri game
  5. 05 KSR Women's Basketball Kentucky WBB has more 'opportunities to challenge' themselves with goals of playing in April