All else remaining the same, if we traded coaching staffs with Indiana, who thinks they would be in the playoffs and we would be 2-8?
Clueless as usual. Rutgers spent millions on a study which said otherwise. We need a Fieldhouse to be competitive. Every other Big Ten School has one, especially UCLA. We do not, which makes it more difficult to recruit. Even Maryland has one, as does Penn State.More lies from SpectrumAl. SC’s football facility was $200M not $300M. Rutgers facilities blow UCLAs away. Rutgers has invested way more facilities than UCLA. The Hale center blows away what they just built. It’s comical. They don’t even have a stadium and their practice field is 50 yards lol. The have nominal more NIL. UCLAs success blows SpectumAls entire narrative out of the water.

Schiano is the worst HC in college football! Incompetent, inept, bad human, and now putting kids lives and bodies at risk.Everyone was in favor of joining the Big Ten, unequivocally. This is a choice we freely made. It wasn’t forced on us. No one was of the opinion to remain in the American Conference, even though that is where our level of support was.
So it’s incumbent upon us to provide the support so that the team can be successful. This year we will finally have the NIL support to get the players we need to get, to be successful. We should have had this support last year, but better late than never. Basketball was finally able to get the needed support this past year, and they landed the players needed to be successful. They made no staff changes. Football will have the opportunity to do the same in January, and I’m sure they’ll make the most of the opportunity.
Clueless as usual. Rutgers spent millions on a study which said otherwise. We need a Fieldhouse to be competitive. Every other Big Ten School has one, especially UCLA. We do not, which makes it more difficult to recruit. Even Maryland has one, as does Penn State.
View attachment 1535250
Coaching doesn’t matter if you don’t have enough talent. Money does all the recruiting these days, so we are at a huge disadvantage. The difference buys a lot of incremental talent for our opponents.
- At least $6 M NIL gap with Wisconsin
- At least $8M NIL gap with Nebraska
- At least $13M NIL gap with Michigan
- At least $14M NIL gap with USC
- At least $6M NIL gap with Penn State
- At least a $13M NIL gap with Indiana
- As much as a $2M NIL gap with Northwestern
- As much as a $2M NIL gap with MSU
- As much as a $2M NIL gap with Maryland
View attachment 1534769
Too many think this way and it’s not true. UCLA and Indiana were ready to win. Rutgers is not ready to win as we need to improve facilities and need better NIL support. There is no way any good coach is touching this job, because it’s too much work. If this job comes open, it’s going to be aAll else remaining the same, if we traded coaching staffs with Indiana, who thinks they would be in the playoffs and we would be 2-8?
Wrong. We’re going to have competitive NIL in January.No one is donating money to NIL in large amounts unless we have a competitive coach. Schiano is an average coach on his best day and his worst days are like this year. Just like anything in the world, no one is going to put money into a product that has no chance to be successful. Hire a competent coach and the money will follow. There is enough money out there, but no one in their right mind is going to donate to Schiano.
Coach is awful and pathetic. It won’t matter . Save the money!Wrong. We’re going to have competitive NIL in January.
To the best of anybody’s understanding,Everyone was in favor of joining the Big Ten, unequivocally. This is a choice we freely made. It wasn’t forced on us. No one was of the opinion to remain in the American Conference, even though that is where our level of support was.
So it’s incumbent upon us to provide the support so that the team can be successful. This year we will finally have the NIL support to get the players we need to get, to be successful. We should have had this support last year, but better late than never. Basketball was finally able to get the needed support this past year, and they landed the players needed to be successful. They made no staff changes. Football will have the opportunity to do the same in January, and I’m sure they’ll make the most of the opportunity.
To the best of anybody’s understanding,Everyone was in favor of joining the Big Ten, unequivocally. This is a choice we freely made. It wasn’t forced on us. No one was of the opinion to remain in the American Conference, even though that is where our level of support was.
So it’s incumbent upon us to provide the support so that the team can be successful. This year we will finally have the NIL support to get the players we need to get, to be successful. We should have had this support last year, but better late than never. Basketball was finally able to get the needed support this past year, and they landed the players needed to be successful. They made no staff changes. Football will have the opportunity to do the same in January, and I’m sure they’ll make the most of the opportunity.
When was this study conducted?Clueless as usual. Rutgers spent millions on a study which said otherwise. We need a Fieldhouse to be competitive. Every other Big Ten School has one, especially UCLA. We do not, which makes it more difficult to recruit. Even Maryland has one, as does Penn State.
View attachment 1535250
No doubt more money correlates to more wins based on competent coaching. Will more money make us look more competitive maybe. Will Greg ever win here?There are exceptions to every rule. Cignetti and now Chesney are miracle workers. It's amazing what they've done and very hard to duplicate. Conversely Texas AM has brutally underperformed based on reported NIL figures.
Using the chart above from The Athletic, the top 20 NIL schools have a 71% winning percentage. the bottom 20 schools have a 55% winning percentage. That's not a wash, that's a huge statistical difference.
Yes, coaching matters. Yes, GS has made some bad mistakes. $$ doesn't guarantee you success, but there is a huge correlation here and a much much better chance of success if you're spending over 30 mil on the roster. I think Al's point is simply if you spend more, in relation to your peers, your chance of success is much greater. The above stats prove that. Also, if you're spending in the bottom 20-25% you can't miss on any of the evals or portal moves. There's much less margin for error. That seems to be where we are. Prior to this year GS typically had a high floor. Utah/Wake are the exceptions, not the rule.
Must be nice to have Dylan Riaola waiting of the bench in case your Heisman candidate Dante Moore goes down. But also amazing that UCLA-Wisc-Michigan can start untested freshman QB's that still outperform anyone on our roster. Is that development? Is that evaluation? Is that NIL?
$$$ is a huge part of this equation. For GS and for all of our coaches. It seems like Keli is working hard and the rumors of a$$i$tance for our teams are starting to show. WBB is killing recruiting ( her first hire ). MBB just signs a top 20 class. Wrestling adds a top 5 guy in the nation. Someone mentioned MSOC getting help and we're beating 5 ranked teams on the way to the tourney. This is the same coaches with more resources. Those resources matter.
The only thing that UCLA changed in between being 10-0 this season and the prior seasons is the coach. To further the point, once they fired their head coach and put somebody else in as interim, they upset PSU using some creative thinking and risk taking.Too many think this way and it’s not true. UCLA and Indiana were ready to win. Rutgers is not ready to win as we need to improve facilities and need better NIL support. There is no way any good coach is touching this job, because it’s too much work. If this job comes open, it’s going to be ashow like we’ve never seen before. Chris Ash spent four years trying to figure out how to recruit at Rutgers and he never did.
Yeap, and the OP is surely an incompetent who strews his BS daily.No doubt more money correlates to more wins based on competent coaching. Will more money make us look more competitive maybe. Will Greg ever win here?
He was the DC at OSU with Young Boss etc. he coached them to the worst statistical defense in OSU history.
Money will not cure incompetence.
Everybody understands that a larger budget directionally will get you better talent. That isn’t really the debate.There are exceptions to every rule. Cignetti and now Chesney are miracle workers. It's amazing what they've done and very hard to duplicate. Conversely Texas AM has brutally underperformed based on reported NIL figures.
Using the chart above from The Athletic, the top 20 NIL schools have a 71% winning percentage. the bottom 20 schools have a 55% winning percentage. That's not a wash, that's a huge statistical difference.
Yes, coaching matters. Yes, GS has made some bad mistakes. $$ doesn't guarantee you success, but there is a huge correlation here and a much much better chance of success if you're spending over 30 mil on the roster. I think Al's point is simply if you spend more, in relation to your peers, your chance of success is much greater. The above stats prove that. Also, if you're spending in the bottom 20-25% you can't miss on any of the evals or portal moves. There's much less margin for error. That seems to be where we are. Prior to this year GS typically had a high floor. Utah/Wake are the exceptions, not the rule.
Must be nice to have Dylan Riaola waiting of the bench in case your Heisman candidate Dante Moore goes down. But also amazing that UCLA-Wisc-Michigan can start untested freshman QB's that still outperform anyone on our roster. Is that development? Is that evaluation? Is that NIL?
$$$ is a huge part of this equation. For GS and for all of our coaches. It seems like Keli is working hard and the rumors of a$$i$tance for our teams are starting to show. WBB is killing recruiting ( her first hire ). MBB just signs a top 20 class. Wrestling adds a top 5 guy in the nation. Someone mentioned MSOC getting help and we're beating 5 ranked teams on the way to the tourney. This is the same coaches with more resources. Those resources matter.
Show your work. Reported on here close to 2mm. I didn’t believe it either. And BC reported offering 1.5 to keep.Lonergan is making a lot less, not even close
Before this season, whatever is true about UCLA regarding their campus academics was also true.
Why were they bad before this year? What changed to explain the good season they are having?
Then how come teams with less NIL constantly and consistently beat teams with more NIL?Coaching doesn’t matter if you don’t have enough talent. Money does all the recruiting these days,
I’ll say it again: Greg comes nowhere close to sniffing a national championship within Indiana’s roster last year.The Sideline has 9 Big Ten schools within a range of $18M to $23M for their football rosters. Purdue and Iowa have the lowest NIL compensation at $18M and $19M respectively. Rutgers, Minnesota, Washington, NW, Illinois, Michigan State and Maryland are all in the range of $20M to $23M with Rutgers at the half-way point at $21.5M (Washington, NW and Maryland spend an additional $1.5M compared to Rutgers and Michigan State, Minnesota and Illinois spend less than Rutgers).
If anyone thinks an additional $1.5M spent on the football roster is going to elevate Rutgers above these 8 schools, then I have a bridge to sell them. Not only can't Schiano and Staff coach football, they also have no clue how to construct a compensated football roster.
Al has never addressed the inability to pull an upset which is inexplicably not related to NIL and is related to coaching. Upsets happen constantly where a team that would get beaten nine 9 of 10 times pulls off a win. Every weekend.Then how come teams with less NIL constantly and consistently beat teams with more NIL?
STFU
I’ll say it again: Greg comes nowhere close to sniffing a national championship within Indiana’s roster last year.
The ‘NIL is Everything’ manifesto leads him to look at the results and then work backward to spin a web that identifies NIL as the cause of all outcomes.OP continently ignores teams with less NIL than RU that are better, teams that are near our NIL and are better, and the fact that we literally are the worst P4 team, Ash level bad, yet our NIL is easily above dozens of P4 teams.
AbsolutelyThe ‘NIL is Everything’ manifesto leads him to look at the results and then work backward to spin a web that identifies NIL as the cause of all outcomes.
There are always going to be anomalies. Way before NIL, the big metric was recruiting rankings, and of course, there was a positive correlation where the higher rankings correlated to more winning, but it wasn’t absolute and some programs just were terrible, regardless of how much talent they brought in. So there is nothing new to see here.Absolutely
And NIL doesn’t guarantee success. Look at LSU, Clemson, Oregon and there are others being outperformed by programs with less NIL such as Utah, Arizona, UCLA, Wake, and on
But high NIL combined with great coaching typically does mean success: GA, IU, OSU (pre QB injury) are good examples.There are always going to be anomalies. Way before NIL, the big metric was recruiting rankings, and of course, there was a positive correlation where the higher rankings correlated to more winning, but it wasn’t absolute and some programs just were terrible, regardless of how much talent they brought in. So there is nothing new to see here.
Al is resistant to the idea that Schiano is a low level coach that has a strength in program building but that this is a totally different skill than winning games versus mid level or better teams.
Of course, and that is why everybody is trying to get the best coaches they can that cost 5-10 million dollars a year combined with the most NIL possible. Before NIL, it was trying to combine the best coaches with Fieldhouses and fancy amenities.But high NIL combined with great coaching typically does mean success: GA, IU, OSU (pre QB injury) are good examples.
Sometimes great coaches can lead to success even without high NIL such as IU before the big Cuban check, Boise, Wake, Utah
Problem for RU is we have average NIL and probably below average coaching so neither the talent nor the coaching can make a difference
In the absence of top recurring classes and NIL, you need something else. The theory of what Greg wants to do works with a good to great coach- run the football, great defense and special teams, get teams in the mud and beat them. It’s called Iowa. Greg just isn’t a good to great coach so it doesn’t work.But high NIL combined with great coaching typically does mean success: GA, IU, OSU (pre QB injury) are good examples.
Sometimes great coaches can lead to success even without high NIL such as IU before the big Cuban check, Boise, Wake, Utah
Problem for RU is we have average NIL and probably below average coaching so neither the talent nor the coaching can make a difference
This.Of course, and that is why everybody is trying to get the best coaches they can that cost 5-10 million dollars a year combined with the most NIL possible. Before NIL, it was trying to combine the best coaches with Fieldhouses and fancy amenities.
But no program wants to hang onto a coach that is below average once that has been identified. And as much as I’d like to fight to argue that Schiano is average, I honestly think it is a clearly a losing proposition. The evidence just is not there to argue that point. Beat some of Illinois 2024, Nebraska 2024, PSU 2025, UCLA 2024, Iowa the year (2023?) they had 3 WRs out, Nebraska the one year (2022?) they fired Frost mid season, Iowa 2025, Minny 2025, and at least we are in position to try to argue that he is an average head coach. Beyond that pile of highly winnable games, there’s another list of big potential upsets in which we won zero.
Washington went 6-7 that season and while they indeed looked bigger, they were not a good football team. Bigger does not automatically mean better.This.
Good coaches win games you shouldn’t and that is extremely rare for Greg
I think the Wash win a couple years ago was one we shouldn’t have won based on talent. They looked bigger, stronger, faster then us but committed more penalties and TOs and we out executed them so I give that one to Greg. Now Wash has a terrible season so terrible coaching for a high talent team.
But that is the only example I can think of in GS2.0. One example.
And if 1.0 there were very few wins where we shouldn’t have won based on talent.
Of course, the answer is that they now have better coaching. So you're totally right.Before this season, whatever is true about UCLA regarding their campus academics was also true.
Why were they bad before this year? What changed to explain the good season they are having?
Yes but UCLA is 10-0 so if we want to handicap Rutgers due to campus and academics, most Rutgers fans would be happy with 7-3 or even 6-4 with 2 winnable games to go. We are nowhere near that and that’s the issue. Al continues to make binary arguments that he can win, meaning ‘UCLA has better academics and campus and this explains the situation’.Of course, the answer is that they now have better coaching. So you're totally right.
It may be a lot easier to improve a program at UCLA with its beautiful campus, great academics, and record of athletic success than at most schools. Still, Schiano has had plenty of time to achieve similar success here, and instead the program is going backward.
See how hard it is to find a good example?Washington went 6-7 that season and while they indeed looked bigger, they were not a good football team. Bigger does not automatically mean better.
Does Schiano get credit for an ‘upset’? IDK and considering it was by way of unforced errors, I’m going to argue ‘no’. It was a fun night though.
You don’t need to tell me. I’ve been saying this since 1.0.See how hard it is to find a good example?
Wash had a bunch of NFL prospects and widely were viewed To have way underperformed (bad coaching)
they weren’t just bigger. They looked faster, quicker and stronger . They had dudes on that roster
YepYou don’t need to tell me. I’ve been saying this since 1.0.
I guess Fisch in year 1 had some disarray and that’s the point. Schiano can’t pull a true upset. Even in 1.0, when UNC had something like 7 starters suspended, he couldn’t do it. Every time he played an elite team, blown out except for 2006.
The reason I would not consider the Rutgers win an upset is because Washington lost every road game that season and won every home game at Huskey Stadium. True to form Washington lost on the road in Piscataway. The story of the 2024 Washington season is not 1 win away from Home.Washington went 6-7 that season and while they indeed looked bigger, they were not a good football team. Bigger does not automatically mean better.
Does Schiano get credit for an ‘upset’? IDK and considering it was by way of unforced errors, I’m going to argue ‘no’. It was a fun night though.
The Knight Report
Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener
The Knight Report
Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano talks Penn State game week
The Knight Report
Almost Six Years Later, Rutgers - Houston Signifies a Pivotal Moment Once Again
The Knight Report
Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Albany Press Conference
The Knight Report
Rutgers Women's Basketball topples Albany with dominant second half