Poll: Rafters, who do we want as our next coach & why?

Who do you want as our next coach and why?

  • Tommy Lloyd (Arizona)

    Votes: 43 25.6%
  • Nate Oats (Bama)

    Votes: 66 39.3%
  • Ben McCollum (Iowa)

    Votes: 19 11.3%
  • T.J. Otzelberger (Iowa St)

    Votes: 18 10.7%
  • Grant McCasland (Texas Tech)

    Votes: 14 8.3%
  • Josh Schertz (Saint Louis)

    Votes: 44 26.2%
  • Jai Lucas (Miami)

    Votes: 34 20.2%
  • Mark Byington (Vanderbilt)

    Votes: 10 6.0%
  • Ryan Odom (Virginia)

    Votes: 22 13.1%
  • Scott Drew (Baylor)

    Votes: 4 2.4%

  • Total voters
    168

LakeLifeCat

Sophomore
May 9, 2026
37
122
33
Rafters, who would you realistically want as UK's next basketball coach, and why? I'm not talking about making a rushed hire. I'm curious who you hope Batt is already quietly putting feelers out to and who you believe could actually get us back to competing for Final Fours and national championships.
 

LakeLifeCat

Sophomore
May 9, 2026
37
122
33
I kind of figured Batt would call Oats first due to their connection at Bama. BUT I just read that Oats' buyout at the end of this season (April 2027) is 12 million...but in April 2028 it drops to ZERO. Do you think there's a chance Batt hangs on to Pope next season too just to get Oats with no buyout? Or, he could call one of these other guys if fans/media demand action sooner. Lloyd's buyout is 9 mil and Schertz is 5 mil for example. Everyone knows we have to have a home run hire next though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MichaelGray

Johnnie Africa

All-Conference
Feb 27, 2003
1,198
3,689
113
I kind of figured Batt would call Oats first due to their connection at Bama. BUT I just read that Oats' buyout at the end of this season (April 2027) is 12 million...but in April 2028 it drops to ZERO. Do you think there's a chance Batt hangs on to Pope next season too just to get Oats with no buyout? Or, he could call one of these other guys if fans/media demand action sooner. Lloyd's buyout is 9 mil and Schertz is 5 mil for example. Everyone knows we have to have a home run hire next though.

This will be Popes last year
 

Catastic5

All-Conference
Sep 12, 2026
959
2,445
93
I kind of figured Batt would call Oats first due to their connection at Bama. BUT I just read that Oats' buyout at the end of this season (April 2027) is 12 million...but in April 2028 it drops to ZERO. Do you think there's a chance Batt hangs on to Pope next season too just to get Oats with no buyout? Or, he could call one of these other guys if fans/media demand action sooner. Lloyd's buyout is 9 mil and Schertz is 5 mil for example. Everyone knows we have to have a home run hire next though.
Just eat the price. Someone will be willing to pay it for a sure thing like Oats.
 

BBNinSCar

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2013
1,878
3,537
81
What would cause more traffic on this site?
Kentucky in a Final Four, or
Kentucky firing Pope and the new coach search
 

MachineHead

All-Conference
Oct 20, 2009
1,317
2,902
77
I kind of figured Batt would call Oats first due to their connection at Bama. BUT I just read that Oats' buyout at the end of this season (April 2027) is 12 million...but in April 2028 it drops to ZERO. Do you think there's a chance Batt hangs on to Pope next season too just to get Oats with no buyout? Or, he could call one of these other guys if fans/media demand action sooner. Lloyd's buyout is 9 mil and Schertz is 5 mil for example. Everyone knows we have to have a home run hire next though.
You can’t keep Pope on for another year. You can’t. We are borderline Indiana now as it is.
 

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,430
1,886
113
You can’t keep Pope on for another year. You can’t. We are borderline Indiana now as it is.
C'mon. Indiana hasn't been in a F4 since 2002. Not close.

You do wonder if moving on him now open up the chance to go to market for his replacement in advance. Probably lose Hampton & Millogo is the downside, along with any current player you'd like to retain.
 

MachineHead

All-Conference
Oct 20, 2009
1,317
2,902
77
C'mon. Indiana hasn't been in a F4 since 2002. Not close.

You do wonder if moving on him now open up the chance to go to market for his replacement in advance. Probably lose Hampton & Millogo is the downside, along with any current player you'd like to retain.
Combine the three Pope years with Cal’s last four years, and we are working on close to a decade of irrelevance and mediocrity. We are closer than you think.
 

Eagles_Ball_69

All-American
Dec 19, 2003
5,212
7,105
82
C'mon. Indiana hasn't been in a F4 since 2002. Not close.

You do wonder if moving on him now open up the chance to go to market for his replacement in advance. Probably lose Hampton & Millogo is the downside, along with any current player you'd like to retain.
But Indiana has been this level of Indiana for quite some time. Pretending we aren’t in the beginning stages of being Indiana is, well, just pretending. We are basically there. Just haven’t been there as long. We are the laughingstock of college basketball.
 

UKCowboys

Heisman
Oct 14, 2019
5,888
11,268
113
I don't know if we could get him, but for where we are right now, I would take Grant Mccasland over anyone. He is only 50. He is a tough, hard nosed dude. His teams play great defense, everything starts with defense. He is a good recruiter but passes on kids that are me first for kids that will run through a wall, he wouldn't be a cap on a table for someone. BBN would love the change from the country club we have going right now
 

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,430
1,886
113
Combine the three Pope years with Cal’s last four years, and we are working on close to a decade of irrelevance and mediocrity. We are closer than you think.
Not sure you realize how dire it's been in Bloomington.

Since Cal joined UK, they've had 4 coaches.

Since the 2003-2004 season, only made it to tourney 9/23 seasons, haven't gotten past the S16, which Crean did 3x. 10 total tourney wins.

Funny looking back, as the brass there had such a big ego they moved off Crean, who after cleaning up the Sampson fiasco (which was BS in retro), finished off his last 6 seasons with 3 S16s and 4 strong seasons. It's been a disaster ever since. The NCAA has some blame with Indiana going down, as we know now if Sampson stuck, Indiana would have been a winner.

These coaching hires matter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,430
1,886
113
But Indiana has been this level of Indiana for quite some time. Pretending we aren’t in the beginning stages of being Indiana is, well, just pretending. We are basically there. Just haven’t been there as long. We are the laughingstock of college basketball.
Why UK is a laughing stock has more to do with the effusive fanbase * the pushing out of Cal * the total dingleberry that is Mark Pope. Together it has a ringling bros car crash dynamic that makes everyone want to look.
 

CrimsonCats_rivals

All-Conference
Mar 22, 2022
1,817
3,759
61
If the goal is for this to be a list of realistic candidates, then I don’t know why Lloyd, Otzelberger, and McCollum are here after they said no to UNC a few months ago. You can come up with whatever argument you want about how we outrank them historically, but they’re still a blue blood program that currently has every resource we do and possibly a bit more because of the Jordan connection. We aren’t getting any of those guys.

For the record Schertz would be my choice. He’s been a winner everywhere he coaches, and we would be a big step up in resources from St. Louis, where he has no special connections that I know of. He’d probably take the job if offered.
 

The Ganner

All-Conference
Nov 21, 2009
497
1,359
93
I don't know if we could get him, but for where we are right now, I would take Grant Mccasland over anyone. He is only 50. He is a tough, hard nosed dude. His teams play great defense, everything starts with defense. He is a good recruiter but passes on kids that are me first for kids that will run through a wall, he wouldn't be a cap on a table for someone. BBN would love the change from the country club we have going right now
He's one of my top names
 
  • Like
Reactions: UKCowboys

The Ganner

All-Conference
Nov 21, 2009
497
1,359
93
If the goal is for this to be a list of realistic candidates, then I don’t know why Lloyd, Otzelberger, and McCollum are here after they said no to UNC a few months ago. You can come up with whatever argument you want about how we outrank them historically, but they’re still a blue blood program that currently has every resource we do and possibly a bit more because of the Jordan connection. We aren’t getting any of those guys.

For the record Schertz would be my choice. He’s been a winner everywhere he coaches, and we would be a big step up in resources from St. Louis, where he has no special connections that I know of. He’d probably take the job if offered.
I do like Otzelberger and McCollum but yeah, I don't know that they'd leave where they are. I'd still call put out feelers to their agents though.

Schertz and as just mentioned McCasland are gettable guys who've both won at multiple lower levels and are having success where they are now.

I don't understand Jai Lucas or Mark Byington being on anybody's list. They've not proven anything. Drew turned us down once and I wasn't sold on him to begin with. Odom would be a meh hire.
 

Eagles_Ball_69

All-American
Dec 19, 2003
5,212
7,105
82
Why UK is a laughing stock has more to do with the effusive fanbase * the pushing out of Cal * the total dingleberry that is Mark Pope. Together it has a ringling bros car crash dynamic that makes everyone want to look.
I don’t believe that about Cal. A good portion knew it was time. But THE WAY it was done…without a hire already made…was Barney level stupidity. Pope and his just idiocy and incompetence are why we are the laughingstock. 99.9% of it. Arguably the greatest program in the history of the sport has a complete beta goofball dbag leading it. That’s what everyone sees.
 

Drogon

All-Conference
Mar 14, 2017
2,161
3,137
113
Loooooooooongest of longshots. The guy I'd like to see is just pure projection on my part. I'm a huge believer that Will Hardy, currently of the Utah Jazz, could come to Kentucky and absolutely crush it. He's a great offensive mind and a tremendous talent developer(theyve been devastated by injuries during his tenure). If he could come here and get the hang of NIL I think he'd be an absolute slam dunk. Unfortunately, even if he does get let go eventually by the Jazz he will likely be called within 5 seconds with NBA teams trying to get him.


From this list, I'd be fine with Lloyd, McCasland, or Oats. That's alphabetical and not in a particular order.
 

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,430
1,886
113
I don’t believe that about Cal. A good portion knew it was time. But THE WAY it was done…without a hire already made…was Barney level stupidity. Pope and his just idiocy and incompetence are why we are the laughingstock. 99.9% of it. Arguably the greatest program in the history of the sport has a complete beta goofball dbag leading it. That’s what everyone sees.
If you don't think the way Cal was handled w/him walking down the street to a neighbor isn't part of this, don't know what to tell you. It's part of the fan base factor.
Loooooooooongest of longshots. The guy I'd like to see is just pure projection on my part. I'm a huge believer that Will Hardy, currently of the Utah Jazz, could come to Kentucky and absolutely crush it. He's a great offensive mind and a tremendous talent developer(theyve been devastated by injuries during his tenure). If he could come here and get the hang of NIL I think he'd be an absolute slam dunk. Unfortunately, even if he does get let go eventually by the Jazz he will likely be called within 5 seconds with NBA teams trying to get him.


From this list, I'd be fine with Lloyd, McCasland, or Oats. That's alphabetical and not in a particular order.
Show me the last time an NBA coach came into the college ranks and did much.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: SenseMaker_Cats

SenseMaker_Cats

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,523
7,051
113
If you don't think the way Cal was handled w/him walking down the street to a neighbor isn't part of this, don't know what to tell you. It's part of the fan base factor.

Show me the last time an NBA coach came into the college ranks and did much.
“Fan base factor” 🤣

Anybody ever notice know it alls like this a hole never talk about the jaggoff coach factor?
 

MichaelGray

All-Conference
Jan 13, 2026
1,293
2,098
113
It’s gonna be Oats. His NIL will be doubled here. He’s friends with Batt. I can’t ******* wait.
Nate Oats would kill it here in recruiting, he'd get the absolute quickest, best shooting players out there & make Kentucky basketball fun again, also bring our brand back as the "it" school, I hate to say it but Duke is the "it" school right now, players know they'll get immediate exposure there & the chick they have in charge of NIL is smart as hell marketing those kids.
 

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
30,636
74,077
113
Nate Oats would kill it here in recruiting, he'd get the absolute quickest, best shooting players out there & make Kentucky basketball fun again, also bring our brand back as the "it" school, I hate to say it but Duke is the "it" school right now, players know they'll get immediate exposure there & the chick they have in charge of NIL is smart as hell marketing those kids.
I’ve been saying it since 2023. Glad the fanbase is finally catching up to me. Most layup hire since Calipari in 2009.
 

Omega_X

Senior
Sep 7, 2026
374
671
93
C'mon. Indiana hasn't been in a F4 since 2002. Not close.

You do wonder if moving on him now open up the chance to go to market for his replacement in advance. Probably lose Hampton & Millogo is the downside, along with any current player you'd like to retain.
I really don’t give two craps about our recruits if it means dumping Pope. Get Oats and he will have better guys anyway. Same with Will Wade.

As for firing Pope now, I don’t know that it’d really help. Nobody is gonna leave their job early. Best case is you get your guy on a handshake deal but that could easily fall apart if that coach makes a run and has a change of heart. I would fire Pope as soon as the buzzer sounds on the final regular season game though. You get a head start on everybody looking for a coach and coaches will be more willing to talk.
 

Omega_X

Senior
Sep 7, 2026
374
671
93
I’m telling you guys that these names like MacCasland, McCollum, Shertz, Cheeseburger and Lucas is just asking for Gillespie/Pope part 2. They’ve done nothing to prove they can win at UK at the level expected here. They also don’t have the attitude needed to be here either IMO. They would get chewed up and spit out by this place just like Pope. The next guy has got to have that same arrogance/ego that Pitino and Cal had when they came.

The only guys that have the attitude and winning track record that would be homeruns are Hurley, Oats, Golden.

Lloyd has proven he can win but I’m not sure how he’d react to the pressure here. Will Wade definitely has the attitude needed and while he hasn’t been to a final four it’s likely only a matter of time. If the 3 above are all out then I’d be satisfied with Lloyd or Wade.

After those 5 I think you have to go after an older guy for a shorter term stopgap that would get the program back on track and ready for hopefully a top name to take over in 5 years or so. Those names would be Pearl, Billy and possibly even Rick.

Get past those 8 and you’re left with Sean Miller, Beard and the unproven guys I listed in my first sentence. You’re playing Russian roulette at that point. Next hire MUST be a homerun. It really needs to be a grand slam. We are 15 years removed from our last title. If the next hire is another dud then are going to be right there next to IU/UCLA or Nebraska in football.
 

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,658
36,387
113
I’m telling you guys that these names like MacCasland, McCollum, Shertz, Cheeseburger and Lucas is just asking for Gillespie/Pope part 2. They’ve done nothing to prove they can win at UK at the level expected here. They also don’t have the attitude needed to be here either IMO. They would get chewed up and spit out by this place just like Pope. The next guy has got to have that same arrogance/ego that Pitino and Cal had when they came.

The only guys that have the attitude and winning track record that would be homeruns are Hurley, Oats, Golden.

Lloyd has proven he can win but I’m not sure how he’d react to the pressure here. Will Wade definitely has the attitude needed and while he hasn’t been to a final four it’s likely only a matter of time. If the 3 above are all out then I’d be satisfied with Lloyd or Wade.

After those 5 I think you have to go after an older guy for a shorter term stopgap that would get the program back on track and ready for hopefully a top name to take over in 5 years or so. Those names would be Pearl, Billy and possibly even Rick.

Get past those 8 and you’re left with Sean Miller, Beard and the unproven guys I listed in my first sentence. You’re playing Russian roulette at that point. Next hire MUST be a homerun. It really needs to be a grand slam. We are 15 years removed from our last title. If the next hire is another dud then are going to be right there next to IU/UCLA or Nebraska in football.
I agree on the unproven guys. I’m really shocked at how many people I’ve seen wanting Jai Lucas. He may turn out great but he’s coached all of ONE season in college.

Mind you I made the same argument about Todd Golden 2 years ago. But that’s the thing, you just don’t know until they’ve proven themselves. For every Todd Golden there are about 10 Shaka Smart’s. I’d much rather someone of the caliber of Oats, Lloyd, or Wade (who did actually take NC State to the final four this past year)
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Kentucky cranks up energy, leans into competition at practice after consecutive losses
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Zoom Action: What's going right/wrong for Kentucky + previewing Indiana
  3. 03 KSR Football Recruiting 4-Star Kentucky Commit Makes Surprise Visit to Louisville
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Jerone Morton nears Kentucky debut, Trent Noah officially week-to-week
  5. 05 KSR Volleyball Brooklyn DeLeye is SEC Player of the Year, Tuozzo Tabbed Libero of the Year