The problem with the portal

wildcatmac9999

Freshman
Jan 28, 2020
37
50
18
Lets look at the top 20 portal vs the top 20 high school players.
1. Momcilvic vs Stokes
2. Bidunga vs Smith
3. Blackwell vs Holt
4. Yessoufou vs Spears
5. Harris vs Williams
6. Haggerty vs Collins
7. Punch vs Branch
8. Murauskas vs Crowe
9. Vaaks vs Ekezie
10. Thiam vs Oladotun
With the top 10 of portal vs freshmen. Which is better. At the top we know Stokes is far far light years ahead of Momchilvic at the 2 I have to go with Smith. Since Bidunga has only played 2 of the 4 games. 3. Holt by a longshot.
Im not going to waste time looking up each player. The trend just follows.
My point in all of this. The top players arent portal players. They are not players to build a roster from. They are players to fill in the roster. Look at our teams under pope. Portal portal portal. Oh they do what Pope likes. They shoot the lights out (if left open) Well they can not get open. Pope's offense depends on a smart 5 to run the play. And then Pope's teams are always 1.5 to 2 steps slow when playing a good team. That is what most portal players lack. So you get what Pope has. A team of not atletic enough to compete. Or a glorified mid major team. I want to say it is not Popes fault but it is Popes fault. Pope just does not relate to the top players. You can say whatever makes you feel better. But facts are facts. Top talent laughs at Pope. See Stokes for example or the Michian player from last year that took less money to play there than for UK last season.
Pope is just not well liked outside the UK bubble. And that bubble has burst. Now UK doesn't even like him (for the most part) And i think Pope sees the future and knows it doesnt matter what he does between now and the end of the year. He is gone and he knows it.
I honestly think at this point the man is trying to get fired before the end of the season. Probably money. Probably would get more money if he doesn't survive the season and is fired mid season.
 

Titpwhahi2014

Senior
Feb 27, 2026
308
901
93
Small sample size. You can’t overlook the Yaxels and Claytons who have swung the last 2 titles. Or the 2023 and 2024 UConn teams that yes, had Stephon Castle—but also had transfers in Newton/Spencer that were pretty dang important.
 
Mar 16, 2026
174
463
63
Small sample size. You can’t overlook the Yaxels and Claytons who have swung the last 2 titles. Or the 2023 and 2024 UConn teams that yes, had Stephon Castle—but also had transfers in Newton/Spencer that were pretty dang important.
Well see u just named the players

think of the coaches in those games (hurley, may, golden)

i tend to think it's more of the fact that they are the top coaches in it rather than who they recruit
 
  • Like
Reactions: BMR1987

wildcatmac9999

Freshman
Jan 28, 2020
37
50
18
The hs players are by far the better players, look at last year the top 3 players were freshman

but the teams that have won it all don't have many because it's more about having good coaching in this era

currently we have neither
There are excptions. But for the most part. Portal players are the best of the best mid major players. You dont build a team with them. They are mid majors for a reason. They are better shooters sure. That is it. They can not play defense at all. They can not get their own shot. Again there is exceptions. There is very little pro talent in the portal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1773686487

wildcatmac9999

Freshman
Jan 28, 2020
37
50
18
Small sample size. You can’t overlook the Yaxels and Claytons who have swung the last 2 titles. Or the 2023 and 2024 UConn teams that yes, had Stephon Castle—but also had transfers in Newton/Spencer that were pretty dang important.
There is exceptions to everything. Willaims for Kentucky. Right now. How many portal pgs are better than he has played ??? And yes systems that coaches run does matter. Pope runs no system. So you cant really compare him in this. So i guess it was unfair to even mention WIllaims.
 

Snarks

All-American
Jan 31, 2005
8,954
8,296
93
Problem with the portal is Popes selection. He keeps overpaying 2nd and 3rd option guys to be option 1 here. Milan is a good player, but he wasn’t the best player on the team last year. He can’t create his shot enough to be a number 1 option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Reggie Noble

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,423
1,871
113
Small sample size. You can’t overlook the Yaxels and Claytons who have swung the last 2 titles. Or the 2023 and 2024 UConn teams that yes, had Stephon Castle—but also had transfers in Newton/Spencer that were pretty dang important.
This isn't the right analysis. It discounts multi-year transfers. It also leaves out highly disappointing HS players thus far like Anthony Thompson.

Better way to look at it is who are the best players in the country this year?
Fears - 4* developed
Haugh - 4* developed
Tyler Tanner - 3* developed
JT Toppin - transfer, former 4*
Silas Demary - transfer, former 4*
Mirkovic, euro

There are no quick fixes in CBB. Dusty May pulled it off last year because he has an impeccable eye for talent, yet I'll call that a major outlier. He's now thriving as an NBA coach.

Stokes is the only freshman this year that is going to make a mark. Smith isn't taking Arkansas anywhere and if AZ goes anywhere, it's because of Krivas and Karchenkov.

The way to do this is not to expect any freshman or transfer to come in and blow the doors off year one. Even Pitino is starting to recruit at the HS level again. His best player last year was a third year transfer.

The blueprint is to find HS talent that will stay multiple years and develop in your system. Find some transfers that really fit your system that will also stay multiple years, and then insert a 5* or star transfer into that core.

The key is having a great eye for talent, being highly intentional around culture and system fit. Golden went and found Haugh and Condon, found Chinyelu. He dug out Clayton, and then stuck two old transfers in there. Izzo's team has looked great so far, it's nothing but developed or first year 4 stars.

Sampson tried the 5* route last year, had one of his flatter teams in recent years. Now he's back to 4* that have been in his system and a high profile transfer like Dedan Thomas.

Scheyer is a dope and his team without a star is already spinning. His chance to win a title will deal exclusively on whether he can get the next Flagg or Boozer. So far, JBB is not that. He's a soft 7foot kid used to play in the no defense euro league.

Bottom line is you have to be intentional and you have to be able to coach, you have to have a system and culture that kids buy into, that are in your program for a couple years and new joiners can blend into.
 
Last edited:

BellyBall

Senior
Jul 18, 2020
275
627
93
Players at the level of the top high school recruits generally don't enter the portal; they go pro. There are a few exceptions, like Yaxel.

We need top high school talent, then fill out the roster with experienced portal players who fit your system. Fit is a huge part of having success in the portal. The best coaches know exactly what they need and are very intentional about who they bring in, regardless of how highly those players are ranked.

We have a coach with no clear identity and seemingly no idea what he needs. As a result, we end up with players who are overpaid and underperform. Look at Chandler, Jelavic, and Garrison. All three players we discarded are playing really good basketball elsewhere. That doesn't just happen. At some point, you have to look at the coaching and roster construction and recognize there's a problem.
 

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,423
1,871
113
Players at the level of the top high school recruits generally don't enter the portal; they go pro. There are a few exceptions, like Yaxel.

We need top high school talent, then fill out the roster with experienced portal players who fit your system. Fit is a huge part of having success in the portal. The best coaches know exactly what they need and are very intentional about who they bring in, regardless of how highly those players are ranked.

We have a coach with no clear identity and seemingly no idea what he needs. As a result, we end up with players who are overpaid and underperform. Look at Chandler, Jelavic, and Garrison. All three players we discarded are playing really good basketball elsewhere. That doesn't just happen. At some point, you have to look at the coaching and roster construction and recognize there's a problem.
He's a machine gun recruiter, throwing spaghetti and seeing what sticks. It's a terrible way to do it. As I've said here before, his best bet would have been going after kids 20-50 that he really liked, saw promise in and build them up to his system.

I really think the sauce is that you ideally want at least 3 returners in your starting lineup annually.

Jalen Lowe had 21 pts and 6 assists as GTown blew out Clemson on the road last year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BellyBall

UKBB4Ever

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
2,482
4,398
113
You just need talent. No matter where it comes from. Experienced talent is the gold standard.

A huge problem we have is that they will be whatever they are when they get here. They will not be “coached up”.

That’s a double edged sword too. The players you get don’t improve and then it affects recruiting too.
 

BellyBall

Senior
Jul 18, 2020
275
627
93
You just need talent. No matter where it comes from. Experienced talent is the gold standard.

A huge problem we have is that they will be whatever they are when they get here. They will not be “coached up”.

That’s a double edged sword too. The players you get don’t improve and then it affects recruiting too.
They are actually coached down quite a bit. Most of the guys we had last year are crushing now.
 

BluWildcatz

Senior
Jun 16, 2026
315
639
93
This isn't the right analysis. It discounts multi-year transfers. It also leaves out highly disappointing HS players thus far like Anthony Thompson.

Better way to look at it is who are the best players in the country this year?
Fears - 4* developed
Haugh - 4* developed
Tyler Tanner - 3* developed
JT Toppin - transfer, former 4*
Silas Demary - transfer, former 4*
Mirkovic, euro

There are no quick fixes in CBB. Dusty May pulled it off last year because he has an impeccable eye for talent, yet I'll call that a major outlier. He's now thriving as an NBA coach.

Stokes is the only freshman this year that is going to make a mark. Smith isn't taking Arkansas anywhere and if AZ goes anywhere, it's because of Krivas and Karchenkov.

The way to do this is not to expect any freshman or transfer to come in and blow the doors off year one. Even Pitino is starting to recruit at the HS level again. His best player last year was a third year transfer.

The blueprint is to find HS talent that will stay multiple years and develop in your system. Find some transfers that really fit your system that will also stay multiple years, and then insert a 5* or star transfer into that core.

The key is having a great eye for talent, being highly intentional around culture and system fit. Golden went and found Haugh and Condon, found Chinyelu. He dug out Clayton, and then stuck two old transfers in there. Izzo's team has looked great so far, it's nothing but developed or first year 4 stars.

Sampson tried the 5* route last year, had one of his flatter teams in recent years. Now he's back to 4* that have been in his system and a high profile transfer like Dedan Thomas.

Scheyer is a dope and his team without a star is already spinning. His chance to win a title will deal exclusively on whether he can get the next Flagg or Boozer. So far, JBB is not that. He's a soft 7foot kid used to play in the no defense euro league.

Bottom line is you have to be intentional and you have to be able to coach, you have to have a system and culture that kids buy into, that are in your program for a couple years and new joiners can blend into.
You talk a lot, but you don't know what you're talking about.
 

W1LDCAT22

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2013
1,174
1,446
113
Lets look at the top 20 portal vs the top 20 high school players.
1. Momcilvic vs Stokes
2. Bidunga vs Smith
3. Blackwell vs Holt
4. Yessoufou vs Spears
5. Harris vs Williams
6. Haggerty vs Collins
7. Punch vs Branch
8. Murauskas vs Crowe
9. Vaaks vs Ekezie
10. Thiam vs Oladotun
With the top 10 of portal vs freshmen. Which is better. At the top we know Stokes is far far light years ahead of Momchilvic at the 2 I have to go with Smith. Since Bidunga has only played 2 of the 4 games. 3. Holt by a longshot.
Im not going to waste time looking up each player. The trend just follows.
My point in all of this. The top players arent portal players. They are not players to build a roster from. They are players to fill in the roster. Look at our teams under pope. Portal portal portal. Oh they do what Pope likes. They shoot the lights out (if left open) Well they can not get open. Pope's offense depends on a smart 5 to run the play. And then Pope's teams are always 1.5 to 2 steps slow when playing a good team. That is what most portal players lack. So you get what Pope has. A team of not atletic enough to compete. Or a glorified mid major team. I want to say it is not Popes fault but it is Popes fault. Pope just does not relate to the top players. You can say whatever makes you feel better. But facts are facts. Top talent laughs at Pope. See Stokes for example or the Michian player from last year that took less money to play there than for UK last season.
Pope is just not well liked outside the UK bubble. And that bubble has burst. Now UK doesn't even like him (for the most part) And i think Pope sees the future and knows it doesnt matter what he does between now and the end of the year. He is gone and he knows it.
I honestly think at this point the man is trying to get fired before the end of the season. Probably money. Probably would get more money if he doesn't survive the season and is fired mid season.
Whats funny is the fans on here that justified Pope's roster building, saying that they did not want 5 stars from high-school and would rather have these guys from the portal. They are still in college for a reason. If you are going to put all of your cards in on the portal, you better hit.

You also got to have an alpha/star or two on your team if you want to contend for banners. Thats something that this team does not have, or every other Pope team. The closest thing we've had to that was Oweh, but that still wasnt good enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Reggie Noble

wildcatmac9999

Freshman
Jan 28, 2020
37
50
18
Whats funny is the fans on here that justified Pope's roster building, saying that they did not want 5 stars from high-school and would rather have these guys from the portal. They are still in college for a reason. If you are going to put all of your cards in on the portal, you better hit.

You also got to have an alpha/star or two on your team if you want to contend for banners. Thats something that this team does not have, or every other Pope team. The closest thing we've had to that was Oweh, but that still wasnt good enough.
You said it better than i did. Perfect example. Look at Momcilvic last year with an all American. He could stand out there and shoot open shots. He doesnt have that this year.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Sources Say goes LIVE to talk Grambling State win and take an early look at Indiana
  2. 02 KSR Podcasts 11 Personnel, No Huddle! with Kyle McAreavy from MizzouToday
  3. 03 KSR Women's Basketball Emily McDonald named SEC Freshman of the Week for record-breaking performance
  4. 04 KSR Football Kentucky Football unveils uniforms for Missouri game
  5. 05 KSR Women's Basketball Kentucky WBB has more 'opportunities to challenge' themselves with goals of playing in April