Reality (Bites)

NightKnight

All-Conference
Jul 21, 2008
3,297
1,753
68
New Haven, Bryant NJIT are a combined 2-8. Not a world beater among them. They are destined for the bottom half of their tertiary leagues. Not one player on those three teams will ever receive a fat NIL check.

One slightly above average B1G Center in Gurdak. Undersized, but very active. Plays within the game, great at the sticky switch and pedals back to position. Sets a good pick. No stupid fouls. He has polish, plenty of athletic ability -speed, strength, hops- and great anticipation. He's not the kind of player than can grab the game by the neck and take over. Solid but not a star.

Jones looks to be on about that level, but unproven.

Sydnor could get there. Needs more minutes. Not great defense. Super skinny.

Lino and JMike looked very good against this level of competition. That means nothing. As it translated to the B1G we still have guards that wander on D and dribble into blind alleys. The last thing they want to do is pass the ball. I'm with the others who think our overall shot selection is lousy and I blame these two fellas. What about an assist every once in a while? A guy like Garavaglia can't play with these guys. It's a waste.

I wonder if on Tariq's kindergarten report it said, "Does not play well with others." His offense is very match up dependent. His defense, while shaky, is okay. He's not the problem and not the solution. If we had better ball movement he would light up. But we don't. So he won't.

I haven't seen anything from Darin Smith yet that would make me think he could be the guy. He seems to get every chance and I don't see it.

Mateo? Looked good in flashes but If you can't bully the 3rd graders in the Y Youth League, how are you going to stand up against the big boys?

I don't know what Buchanan is doing out there. I doubt he could tell you. Team plays better when he is not on the court. He has the strength and shoulders but is too polite.

Coach Knight? On the third cupcake we should be congealing a 7 or 8 man rotation. Forging an identity, style of play. Everybody plays is good for Little League. Show me you can make the tough decisions. Not all of these guys are B1G ready. PT is precious and I don't see it invested wisely. I see him running a happy camp which is not the job of the HC.

That said, when this team beats Indiana in Assembly Hall this board is going to light up like the old day.
 

Zebnatto1!

Junior
Sep 6, 2025
305
271
62
New Haven, Bryant NJIT are a combined 2-8. Not a world beater among them. They are destined for the bottom half of their tertiary leagues. Not one player on those three teams will ever receive a fat NIL check.

One slightly above average B1G Center in Gurdak. Undersized, but very active. Plays within the game, great at the sticky switch and pedals back to position. Sets a good pick. No stupid fouls. He has polish, plenty of athletic ability -speed, strength, hops- and great anticipation. He's not the kind of player than can grab the game by the neck and take over. Solid but not a star.

Jones looks to be on about that level, but unproven.

Sydnor could get there. Needs more minutes. Not great defense. Super skinny.

Lino and JMike looked very good against this level of competition. That means nothing. As it translated to the B1G we still have guards that wander on D and dribble into blind alleys. The last thing they want to do is pass the ball. I'm with the others who think our overall shot selection is lousy and I blame these two fellas. What about an assist every once in a while? A guy like Garavaglia can't play with these guys. It's a waste.

I wonder if on Tariq's kindergarten report it said, "Does not play well with others." His offense is very match up dependent. His defense, while shaky, is okay. He's not the problem and not the solution. If we had better ball movement he would light up. But we don't. So he won't.

I haven't seen anything from Darin Smith yet that would make me think he could be the guy. He seems to get every chance and I don't see it.

Mateo? Looked good in flashes but If you can't bully the 3rd graders in the Y Youth League, how are you going to stand up against the big boys?

I don't know what Buchanan is doing out there. I doubt he could tell you. Team plays better when he is not on the court. He has the strength and shoulders but is too polite.

Coach Knight? On the third cupcake we should be congealing a 7 or 8 man rotation. Forging an identity, style of play. Everybody plays is good for Little League. Show me you can make the tough decisions. Not all of these guys are B1G ready. PT is precious and I don't see it invested wisely. I see him running a happy camp which is not the job of the HC.

That said, when this team beats Indiana in Assembly Hall this board is going to light up like the old day.
 

RUbyRED

Senior
Nov 14, 2025
365
977
93
I mean I think it’s fair to point out that the competition hasn’t been great and we won’t truly know what we have til we get to Vegas…but this reads more as pessimism than reality. Some truths in here — our assist numbers are worrying and our shot selection isn’t great, but c’mon man. We’re 3-0 and it’s apparent this is a deeper team than we’ve had in a few seasons. It’s not like I’m seeing people all of a sudden thinking this is a Sweet 16 bunch…just improved. We can make more definitive statements after our 3 game slate next week
 

RedTeamUpstream94

All-American
Jan 15, 2021
3,566
6,693
113
On the third cupcake we should be congealing a 7 or 8 man rotation. Forging an identity, style of play.

You write paragraph after paragraph raising criticisms and complaints about literally every player

yet somehow after playing 3 cupcakes (which “tells you nothing” as everyone says) the coach is supposed to have a crystal clear vision on an exact style of play with well defined roles for each player in a 7/8 man roster?!?

you don’t see how your post is monumentally inconsistent?
 

Zebnatto1!

Junior
Sep 6, 2025
305
271
62
I think the OP raises valid points.

I think it comes down to expectations. Against who are we measuring ourselves? Is .500 in the league the goal? If that's the case, I think it's in reach. But things, based upon our 3-0 opening, get much more shaky looking for a better result than that. Right now I'm less optimistic than I was after 'Nova/SJU.

How to frame this? I say we'd be serious contenders, probably favorites in the A10.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NightKnight

RedTeamUpstream94

All-American
Jan 15, 2021
3,566
6,693
113
I think the OP raises valid points.

I think it comes down to expectations. Against who are we measuring ourselves? Is .500 in the league the goal? If that's the case, I think it's in reach. But things, based upon our 3-0 opening, get much more shaky looking for a better result than that. Right now I'm less optimistic than I was after 'Nova/SJU.

How to frame this? I say we'd be serious contenders, probably favorites in the A10.
- no one saying this team is bound for the sweet 16 - so not sure what the point of his post is. IMHO overly (and kinda bizarrely) negative at this point.

It seems that the team gives people a little cautious optimism.

that’s it. Is that so wrong ? 😆

OP just seems to want to go out of his way to want to piss on cautious optimism. Weird if you ask me

and the complaint that the coach should have a defined style of play with a set 7/8 man rotation after 3 cupcakes is absurd (particularly absurd since he spends the first 10 paragraphs raising questions on literally every player). wtf!?
 
Jul 3, 2025
336
219
43
I think the OP raises valid points.

I think it comes down to expectations. Against who are we measuring ourselves? Is .500 in the league the goal? If that's the case, I think it's in reach. But things, based upon our 3-0 opening, get much more shaky looking for a better result than that. Right now I'm less optimistic than I was after 'Nova/SJU.

How to frame this? I say we'd be serious contenders, probably favorites in the A10.
Playing .500 in this BigTen may not be enough this year to achieve Bubble-In status but with the expanded field this year it probably will be.
 

Jerseylegends

All-Conference
Mar 15, 2023
1,761
1,914
113
He just highlighted aspects of the program that may need some work. Although I think smith is just nervous in this opening stretch. Let's see how this all plays out. Exciting times
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

Jerseylegends

All-Conference
Mar 15, 2023
1,761
1,914
113
that’s not remotely the tone of the post.
Lol I read it as "we are excited and posting all of the positives let me try and find negative things to say in order to curb the enthusiasm"...he just wanted to add a different perspective maybe he's a former coach, that's the way they usually do it, there is always something to work on..
 

RedTeamUpstream94

All-American
Jan 15, 2021
3,566
6,693
113
Lol I read it as "we are excited and posting all of the positives let me try and find negative things to say in order to curb the enthusiasm"...he just wanted to add a different perspective maybe he's a former coach, that's the way they usually do it, there is always something to work on..

of course this team needs work. Who exactly is saying otherwise?

But the tone was “hold my beer while i try and piss on any ounce of cautious pessimism you might possibly have”

and again his criticism of knight not having a defined 7/8 man roster with well defined roles after 3 games is just ridiculous (particularly since he himself points out all these criticisms/ issues with individual players).

i mean if his points about players are legit (i am not saying he is wrong about all he said in those multiple paragraphs) - doesn’t that suggest reasons WHY a precise 7/8 roster hasn’t been defined just yet after 3 friggin games!!

sorry OP just comes across as a jerk who wants to complain for the sake of it.
 

Jerseylegends

All-Conference
Mar 15, 2023
1,761
1,914
113
of course this team needs work. Who exactly is saying otherwise?

But the tone was “hold my beer while i try and piss on any ounce of cautious pessimism you might possibly have”

and again his criticism of knight not having a defined 7/8 man roster with well defined roles after 3 games is just ridiculous (particularly since he himself points out all these criticisms/ issues with individual players).

i mean if his points about players are legit (i am not saying he is wrong about all he said in those multiple paragraphs) - doesn’t that suggest reasons WHY a precise 7/8 roster hasn’t been defined just yet after 3 friggin games!!

sorry OP just comes across as a jerk who wants to complain for the sake of it.
I see that but in this era of trolls i find myself extracting what makes sense to me from someone's post and not engaging in any back and forth. Because that's why trolls post stuff like this, to piss in your Cheerios. So it's like whatever, these things will be worked on and hopefully they get better and better as the year goes on. Can't let trolls ruin your joy lol. Some may like to and want to engage in a debate, that's cool as well. But yeah he's obviously trying to rain on the parade, we will find out soon enough how it all plays out.
 

NightKnight

All-Conference
Jul 21, 2008
3,297
1,753
68
I
I see that but in this era of trolls i find myself extracting what makes sense to me from someone's post and not engaging in any back and forth. Because that's why trolls post stuff like this, to piss in your Cheerios. So it's like whatever, these things will be worked on and hopefully they get better and better as the year goes on. Can't let trolls ruin your joy lol. Some may like to and want to engage in a debate, that's cool as well. But yeah he's obviously trying to rain on the parade, we will find out soon enough how it all plays out.
I don't know how much interaction you're looking for. I responded to BAC's cryptic CIA threat. It was a long post. It's mostly from my mind for my mind. I'm a long time fan and that means ups and downs. I try to keep perspective. Rutgers is like any other girl in New Brunswick. She's just looking to break your heart and empty your wallet.
 
Last edited:

Degaz-RU

Heisman
Dec 19, 2002
23,089
28,428
88
OP makes some valid points, but this paragraph is way off base:

*****
Coach Knight? On the third cupcake we should be congealing a 7 or 8 man rotation. Forging an identity, style of play. Everybody plays is good for Little League. Show me you can make the tough decisions. Not all of these guys are B1G ready. PT is precious and I don't see it invested wisely. I see him running a happy camp which is not the job of the HC.
*****

I’d say benching two starters in the second half — including your leading returning scorer from last year — would qualify as a hard decision.

He also didn’t play everyone last night. No Powers, no Wooten, no Ware, no Tonecj. And Buca and Sydnor only played 4 minutes apiece. For all intents and purposes, we had 9-man rotation last night.
 

fatsam98

Heisman
Mar 23, 2005
44,250
40,243
113
I mean I don't necessarily disagree with most of it, but starting out referencing they're a combined 2-8, when we account for 37.5% of those losses, is amusing and smacks of an agenda
 

RUInsanityToo

All-American
May 5, 2006
9,619
9,996
113
I

I don't know how much interaction you're looking for. I responded to BAC's cryptic CIA threat. It was a long post. It's mostly from my mind for my mind. I'm a long time fan and that means ups and downs. I try to keep perspective. Rutgers is like any other girl in New Brunswick. She's just looking to break your heart and empty your wallet.

If you go in only looking for failure you'll probably find it. In sports as there is generally always a lot of individual failures to harp on even when the team wins.
 

RedTeamUpstream94

All-American
Jan 15, 2021
3,566
6,693
113
I mean I don't necessarily disagree with most of it, but starting out referencing they're a combined 2-8, when we account for 37.5% of those losses, is amusing and smacks of an agenda

even the title of the thread “reality bites” - shows he just wants to be a dick

What reality?

we played 3 cupcakes and beat each by over 20

so what “reality” is he even talking about ?

again - not a single poster is suggesting a sweet 16 run

So what’s his point ? What is he reacting to?

People saying - hey we handled the cupcakes pretty well so far (compared to previous years when we actually struggled against/ lost to a few of these type teams ) …. Maybe just maybe we won’t suck as badly this year?

That seems to be consensus on the board - that MAYBE we won’t suck too badly this year .

Is that the “reality” he is trying to correct?

Hey OP - other than just being a jerk - what the **** is your point?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Degaz-RU

BigRnj

All-American
Nov 20, 2012
5,034
6,809
63
of course this team needs work. Who exactly is saying otherwise?

But the tone was “hold my beer while i try and piss on any ounce of cautious pessimism you might possibly have”

and again his criticism of knight not having a defined 7/8 man roster with well defined roles after 3 games is just ridiculous (particularly since he himself points out all these criticisms/ issues with individual players).

i mean if his points about players are legit (i am not saying he is wrong about all he said in those multiple paragraphs) - doesn’t that suggest reasons WHY a precise 7/8 roster hasn’t been defined just yet after 3 friggin games!!

sorry OP just comes across as a jerk who wants to complain for the sake of it.
This ^^^^
even the title of the thread “reality bites” - shows he just wants to be a dick

What reality?

we played 3 cupcakes and beat each by over 20

so what “reality” is he even talking about ?

again - not a single poster is suggesting a sweet 16 run

So what’s his point ? What is he reacting to?

People saying - hey we handled the cupcakes pretty well so far (compared to previous years when we actually struggled against/ lost to a few of these type teams ) …. Maybe just maybe we won’t suck as badly this year?

That seems to be consensus on the board - that MAYBE we won’t suck too badly this year .

Is that the “reality” he is trying to correct?

Hey OP - other than just being a jerk - what the **** is your point?
This ^^^^

…. OP needs to relax… yep they were cupcakes, always are in the early OOC games. RU did what we all wanted them to do, play hard and win. Will they struggle in the BIG portion of the schedule, yes most likely. I would love to see better passing, more assists, better perimeter defense, … but I see improvement over the same period last year. More offensive options, better FT shooting, and more defensive energy. Again this means little other than the performance against the first 3 tomato cans was what we wanted to see.

You could have written your post before tip off of the first game. The reality that bites here is that You sound like a whiner that would love to say see I told you so, look at how clever and insightful I am.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RedTeamUpstream94

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,547
13,917
78
even the title of the thread “reality bites” - shows he just wants to be a dick

What reality?

we played 3 cupcakes and beat each by over 20

so what “reality” is he even talking about ?

again - not a single poster is suggesting a sweet 16 run

So what’s his point ? What is he reacting to?

People saying - hey we handled the cupcakes pretty well so far (compared to previous years when we actually struggled against/ lost to a few of these type teams ) …. Maybe just maybe we won’t suck as badly this year?

That seems to be consensus on the board - that MAYBE we won’t suck too badly this year .

Is that the “reality” he is trying to correct?

Hey OP - other than just being a jerk - what the **** is your point?

Couldn't agree more.

We certainly haven’t “proven anything” but to suggest the take away from what we’ve done so far should be concerning to this point in any way is head scratching.

Also - I’m kind of tired of hearing how terrible our cupcakes have been. I thought it too while watching the first two games, but you know what? The Ken Pom power metrics look like a hot pile of garbage right now to be honest. In actual game play, so far our opponents don’t even stand out as awful relative to other midmajors.

We thought for example, New Haven stunk balls. Maybe they will, but so far all they did since our game was beat Army by 8 who just took down a St Thomas team Ken Pom projects around 200ish. Bryant already beat a Siena team that hasn’t lost to anyone else. And NJIT beat St Peters and went Toe to Toe with Fairfield who KenPom thinks is a team in the 200s too. I’m not saying these will teams will be “good” but at the moment they are performing just the same as everyone else’s damn cupcakes.

And oh yeah - anyone tempted to defend the meaningfulness of Ken Pom and company data right now should check out Oklahoma sitting at 71 in Ken Pom (we’re 74 for perspective).
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Notre Dame Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to Notre Dame in wild Players Era 8 OT showdown
  4. 04 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  5. 05 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three