New Brunswick Plan Seeks to Spur More Student Housing Near Rutgers

Leonard23

Heisman
Feb 2, 2006
30,397
12,640
113

SF88

All-Conference
Aug 6, 2001
1,619
2,180
113
The City has always held the parking requirements over your head and tied it to the number of bedrooms, not the number of occupants. I always felt that was short sighted. I don't see that being addressed here. I wouldn't want to give up my street permits. Many of the lots shown are only 25 ft wide. The limiting factor is the cost of construction. You simply can't build something big enough on a 25ft wide lot to justify the cost to buy/demolish/build. Putting a few properties together might give you the density needed to justify the cost of it all. As a FYI, a guy bought 3 lots on Senior St for close to 3 Million. He got approved for over 100 beds for the apartment bldg he proposed. He will make lots of $$. My pockets aren't that deep, so I go single lot and try and build a nice house with nice size singles, or improve my properties with new kitchens/baths.

The FAR can help a little if you've got a 5000 sq ft lot. The city wants 3-4 units, but they cost more to construct, cost more to insure and then fall under NJ regulations and inspections as well. All of a sudden you need to provide handicap accessibility if 3 family or more ( thank you Murphy ). I had a property recently that was 3 family plan as city suggested. The needed handicap stuff would have eliminated 2 parking spots and reduced bedrooms since new entrances would also be needed. Went back to drawing board and have a beautiful 2-family that fits more tenants and has more parking. That's government getting in its own way. It can make the difference in a project being doable or not.

However, the City recognizing it can do more to encourage getting rid of the old, obsolete housing stock is a big positive.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,533
61,857
113
The City has always held the parking requirements over your head and tied it to the number of bedrooms, not the number of occupants. I always felt that was short sighted. I don't see that being addressed here. I wouldn't want to give up my street permits. Many of the lots shown are only 25 ft wide. The limiting factor is the cost of construction. You simply can't build something big enough on a 25ft wide lot to justify the cost to buy/demolish/build. Putting a few properties together might give you the density needed to justify the cost of it all. As a FYI, a guy bought 3 lots on Senior St for close to 3 Million. He got approved for over 100 beds for the apartment bldg he proposed. He will make lots of $$. My pockets aren't that deep, so I go single lot and try and build a nice house with nice size singles, or improve my properties with new kitchens/baths.

The FAR can help a little if you've got a 5000 sq ft lot. The city wants 3-4 units, but they cost more to construct, cost more to insure and then fall under NJ regulations and inspections as well. All of a sudden you need to provide handicap accessibility if 3 family or more ( thank you Murphy ). I had a property recently that was 3 family plan as city suggested. The needed handicap stuff would have eliminated 2 parking spots and reduced bedrooms since new entrances would also be needed. Went back to drawing board and have a beautiful 2-family that fits more tenants and has more parking. That's government getting in its own way. It can make the difference in a project being doable or not.

However, the City recognizing it can do more to encourage getting rid of the old, obsolete housing stock is a big positive.
I haven’t been licensed for real estate in New Jersey in about a year and a half now, however, 25 feet wide is plenty of space.Not sure what the issue is here? As a matter of fact, in my 9-years as a licensed realtor, probably 75% of the lots I either rented or sold properties at were definitely not wider than 25 feet.

The parking permit thing, I agree, completely different situation. What they should do is require “X” amount of parking for all new construction, whether it be a complete rebuild or innovation. The first floor, essentially, should be garage space.

The building I currently live in - the apartment I’m renting, which I sold to a friend of mine in 2020 - is 27’ wide, however, has unit units on either side of the hallway (and the units are plenty wide). If you’re erecting new construction or renovating something that only has units on one side of the hallway 27’ is huge.
 
Last edited:

SF88

All-Conference
Aug 6, 2001
1,619
2,180
113
Show your math. A crappy old house in New Brunswick is going to cost at least $500,000 anywhere near RU, probably more. Maybe $50,000 to demo in a tight spot. Spend $50-75,000 on soft costs with architects-engineers-lawyers to...maybe..get approved. Don't forget your carrying costs of mortgage for your crappy purchase and the taxes while doing all of this for 1-2 years. Figure out how to provide parking, on a 25' wide lot that's not on a corner. The city will max your height at 3 levels. If you're using ground level for parking, now you've only got 2 levels for bedrooms. Now show how many bedrooms you're shoe horning into that new bldg with the required front-back-side setbacks. It's not 1986 where people are living in triples. LMK how many students you're fitting in there and what the new rent will be. It's 2027, what's the construction cost to build your new house? Now show how you're losing $$ each month. Great that you once were a real estate agent though. Hope for appreciation and equity I guess. My $$ has better places to go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fat Koko

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,533
61,857
113
Show your math. A crappy old house in New Brunswick is going to cost at least $500,000 anywhere near RU, probably more. Maybe $50,000 to demo in a tight spot. Spend $50-75,000 on soft costs with architects-engineers-lawyers to...maybe..get approved. Don't forget your carrying costs of mortgage for your crappy purchase and the taxes while doing all of this for 1-2 years. Figure out how to provide parking, on a 25' wide lot that's not on a corner. The city will max your height at 3 levels. If you're using ground level for parking, now you've only got 2 levels for bedrooms. Now show how many bedrooms you're shoe horning into that new bldg with the required front-back-side setbacks. It's not 1986 where people are living in triples. LMK how many students you're fitting in there and what the new rent will be. It's 2027, what's the construction cost to build your new house? Now show how you're losing $$ each month. Great that you once were a real estate agent though. Hope for appreciation and equity I guess. My $$ has better places to go.
What are you getting all mad about? Nobody is forcing you to buy anything. Geeesh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fat Koko

Fat Koko

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2022
4,689
4,136
73
Good to see New Brunswick is moving to make it easier to build housing near campus.

Maybe scrap parking requirements altogether. Clearly, these mandates are an obstacle to building new housing near the College Ave Campus.

In 2022, California banned municipalities from imposing parking requirements on residential developments near transit stations. A similar bill in Trenton went nowhere.

Let the housing developers decide whether parking is needed to attract tenants paying enough rent so the financials make sense.

The market will sort itself out here. I lived in that neighborhood during senior year without a car and life was fine. After graduation, I stuck around and two roommates didn't have cars but commuting to Seton Hall Law School in Newark (Hobbs was dean) was possible because of the train. Summer between junior and senior year, I lived on Huntington Street, had internship in Newark, and rode bike to train for three months.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Leonard23

SF88

All-Conference
Aug 6, 2001
1,619
2,180
113
location
singles/doubles
condition ( nice kitchen etc )
parking
cost

parking is a non-starter for many tenant groups. It's the same GenZ that wants a single, with their own flat screen in bedroom and parking spot for their car, that door dashes dinner from a block away and wonders why the sidewalk didn't shovel itself.
 

RU206

All-American
Jan 23, 2015
5,300
5,417
113
Both of my kids live near college Ave in off campus housing. They share a car. Parking is very hard to find. Last year they got a bunch of parking tickets. So far none this year (as far as I know).
 

Fat Koko

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2022
4,689
4,136
73
location
singles/doubles
condition ( nice kitchen etc )
parking
cost

parking is a non-starter for many tenant groups. It's the same GenZ that wants a single, with their own flat screen in bedroom and parking spot for their car, that door dashes dinner from a block away and wonders why the sidewalk didn't shovel itself.
Is a housing unit between College Ave and Somerset unrentable or only rentable at a large discount if the unit lacks onsite parking?

That would be a change from when I lived there in late 1990s, early 2000s. Lived in two places on Huntington, two on Hamilton, and one on Guilden. Then, housing vacancy was zero, not just in that neighborhood but in Highland Park and in the apartment buildings on Livingston Ave in New Brunswick, so renters couldn't be picky. I wrote a paper on this. The Rutgers Off-Campus Housing office was very helpful. I interviewed for a job there as an undergrad but didn't get it.
 

SF88

All-Conference
Aug 6, 2001
1,619
2,180
113
For some, parking is not an issue. IMO, my houses are in good locations and in good condition, so I have no problem renting them. 98% rented for June right now! I don't try to squeeze the last nickel out of people. I'm often dealing in the sorority girl world where they like their conveniences. Typically very nice young ladies that pay the rent. That piece of mind is worth the extra $ for not charging the highest rents. RU has been increasing enrollment so the demand is high off campus. Verve-Standard-Vue-Bookend-Hub on Morrell-44 Courtland-12 Bartlett-191 Hamilton-100 Hamilton-several apt bldgs on Union St are all filled with students. I'd say it's a zero vacancy rate in the shaded areas from first post with almost all students
 

Fat Koko

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2022
4,689
4,136
73
For some, parking is not an issue. IMO, my houses are in good locations and in good condition, so I have no problem renting them. 98% rented for June right now! I don't try to squeeze the last nickel out of people. I'm often dealing in the sorority girl world where they like their conveniences. Typically very nice young ladies that pay the rent. That piece of mind is worth the extra $ for not charging the highest rents. RU has been increasing enrollment so the demand is high off campus. Verve-Standard-Vue-Bookend-Hub on Morrell-44 Courtland-12 Bartlett-191 Hamilton-100 Hamilton-several apt bldgs on Union St are all filled with students. I'd say it's a zero vacancy rate in the shaded areas from first post with almost all students
Thanks for market update. Seems like a landlord's market.

Try to buy 199 Hamilton. Was POS when I lived there 25 years ago and is still standing. 50' x 250' lot, one of deepest in the neighborhood. Maybe the 191 Hamilton developer tried to buy it but owner held out.
 

NotInRHouse

Senior
Jul 29, 2025
827
647
63
At least with a strong student neighborhood, kids are likely having a fun experience.

Had a great time in that neighborhood during GS 1.0 lol.

I believe rent was $1130 for a 2 BR which was high at the time. My roommate and I each had our own rooms, parking, and we had a backyard deck. Now the house is demolished and there's a big building covering a bunch of lots.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Notre Dame Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to Notre Dame in wild Players Era 8 OT showdown
  4. 04 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  5. 05 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three