New Trier at Huntley - Friday NFHS

Topiarydan1

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2001
4,922
1,180
113
Gonna be a Cakeeater Bowl next week when Loyola and New Trier meet up in the semis. Don't forget to bring your Grey Poupon and cardigan
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,199
4,599
113
States Attorney should be investigating
How much of a kickback does the IHSA get from NFHS?!?!

The League Collusion GIF
 

Cross Bones

All-Conference
Aug 19, 2001
53,697
4,803
113
One game in the whole state tonight, this one never had a chance.... until some people stopped trying to watch. They should definitely move over to Youtube, pretty sure they can handle thousands of viewers.
 

Topiarydan1

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2001
4,922
1,180
113
Pretty sure cake eater is 2 words.

Ramblers still have work to do. But a state semi game with NT in football sounds strange to even say.
Us SouthSiders don't use hypens or spaces between words - I'll add Eleanor's Proper Book of Grammar in hardcover with my Grey Poupon and cardigan. Kidding aside both great schools... it's Charlton Heston/Ann Margaret/Donald Rumsfeld and Liz Phair versus The Murray Brothers/Chris O'Donnell
 
  • Like
Reactions: 80sRambler

80sRambler

Senior
Oct 28, 2022
554
635
93
Us SouthSiders don't use hypens or spaces between words - I'll add Eleanor's Proper Book of Grammar in hardcover with my Grey Poupon and cardigan. Kidding aside both great schools... it's Charlton Heston/Ann Margaret/Donald Rumsfeld and Liz Phair versus The Murray Brothers/Chris O'Donnell

I’ve always thought “cake eater” is hilarious. I will never forget the freshman coaches warning us we’d be called cake eaters before our first away game in the city. I’ll take the Murrays over Heston and Rumsfeld!!
 

DJrodey24

Sophomore
Nov 3, 2003
587
187
27
I was on the call last night, and I care about the problems viewers experienced. If you have specific concerns, send them my way so I can help get them to the right people.

I’ve worked with this crew several times and respect their work. We encountered internet access issues at Huntley that may have contributed to the problems, but I don’t have a complete technical explanation yet. People who paid deserved a reliable broadcast. That’s a fair expectation.

There’s also a hosting issue that needs to be addressed. IHSA’s published postseason press box priority list places its official broadcast ahead of radio. Yet a radio broadcast was accommodated inside while our NFHS Network crew worked from the roof. That allocation did not follow the published priority order.

Meanwhile, Huntley’s coaching staff occupied 2 press box rooms. In 30 years of broadcasting high school football, I’ve never encountered one coaching staff receiving 2 rooms while the official telecast worked outside. I anticipate that I'll be on the phone at some point this week to address this issue.

This isn’t about being cold. It wasn't bad. The view was actually wonderful. However, if schools want a professional postseason broadcast, the people producing it need appropriate access, connectivity and working space. Too often, the stream gets treated as an afterthought, even though it’s how families, alumni and fans experience the event from outside the stadium. You pay and they don't care.

Last night was an opportunity to showcase 2 outstanding programs and an incredible atmosphere to thousands of people who couldn’t attend. Those viewers mattered, too. I can’t say our location caused the technical failures, but the accommodations and connectivity deserve review.

Where I disagree with some of the criticism is the idea that charging for the broadcast is itself unreasonable.

Producing these games costs money. Broadcasters, producers and camera operators do real work. Equipment, connectivity and the operation and maintenance of automated systems cost money, too. College and professional broadcasts have those expenses as well, whether viewers support them through subscriptions, television packages or advertising.

Student broadcasting has tremendous value. I've been a teacher. I work in schools. I get it. So does having working professionals cover these athletes with the preparation and attention they deserve. I spend hours researching players, talking with coaches and preparing for these calls because these games matter. That work deserves compensation. I attached my notes so you can see for yourself.

You can decide whether a subscription is worth purchasing. You can also expect the service you purchase to work—and speak up when it doesn’t.

Both things can be true: viewers deserve quality, and the people producing these broadcasts deserve to be paid.
 

Attachments

  • New_Trier_Huntley_Quarterfinal_Notes_2026.pdf
    242.7 KB · Views: 1
  • Like
Reactions: 4Afan

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,199
4,599
113
I was on the call last night, and I care about the problems viewers experienced. If you have specific concerns, send them my way so I can help get them to the right people.

I’ve worked with this crew several times and respect their work. We encountered internet access issues at Huntley that may have contributed to the problems, but I don’t have a complete technical explanation yet. People who paid deserved a reliable broadcast. That’s a fair expectation.

There’s also a hosting issue that needs to be addressed. IHSA’s published postseason press box priority list places its official broadcast ahead of radio. Yet a radio broadcast was accommodated inside while our NFHS Network crew worked from the roof. That allocation did not follow the published priority order.

Meanwhile, Huntley’s coaching staff occupied 2 press box rooms. In 30 years of broadcasting high school football, I’ve never encountered one coaching staff receiving 2 rooms while the official telecast worked outside. I anticipate that I'll be on the phone at some point this week to address this issue.

This isn’t about being cold. It wasn't bad. The view was actually wonderful. However, if schools want a professional postseason broadcast, the people producing it need appropriate access, connectivity and working space. Too often, the stream gets treated as an afterthought, even though it’s how families, alumni and fans experience the event from outside the stadium. You pay and they don't care.

Last night was an opportunity to showcase 2 outstanding programs and an incredible atmosphere to thousands of people who couldn’t attend. Those viewers mattered, too. I can’t say our location caused the technical failures, but the accommodations and connectivity deserve review.

Where I disagree with some of the criticism is the idea that charging for the broadcast is itself unreasonable.

Producing these games costs money. Broadcasters, producers and camera operators do real work. Equipment, connectivity and the operation and maintenance of automated systems cost money, too. College and professional broadcasts have those expenses as well, whether viewers support them through subscriptions, television packages or advertising.

Student broadcasting has tremendous value. I've been a teacher. I work in schools. I get it. So does having working professionals cover these athletes with the preparation and attention they deserve. I spend hours researching players, talking with coaches and preparing for these calls because these games matter. That work deserves compensation. I attached my notes so you can see for yourself.

You can decide whether a subscription is worth purchasing. You can also expect the service you purchase to work—and speak up when it doesn’t.

Both things can be true: viewers deserve quality, and the people producing these broadcasts deserve to be paid.
Agree with all of this. I think most here would have zero issue paying to view multiple games every week if NFHS would consistently provide the same quality that YouTube and Hudl do as many get accustomed to that during the regular season only have the IHSA take those platforms away during the playoffs.

When we do experience issues who do we speak up to? Is there an email address that is actually monitored we can reach out to at either NFHS or the IHSA? If issues continue and paying customers don't have an outlet to contact, the frustration will continue when people try to watch their local team or the biggest game of the week.
 

johnndoe

Senior
Oct 19, 2019
1,281
918
113
As the Latin phrase "caveat emptor" states: "let the buyer beware." Especially true with the sorry and well-known history of NFHS broadcast problems (REGARDLESS OF THE EXCUSES) for any particular game.
Part of Rodewald's response reminds me of a Mt. Carmel home game at Gately decades ago when a young Jim Rose from local Channel 7 was setting up for a game broadcast, trying to throw his weight around for press box placement. He picked an easy target in an old-timer who worked the P.A. microphone. I and some others had words with "J.R." who had some condescending response to us. The intruder ended up in some alternative space.
 

DJrodey24

Sophomore
Nov 3, 2003
587
187
27
Agree with all of this. I think most here would have zero issue paying to view multiple games every week if NFHS would consistently provide the same quality that YouTube and Hudl do as many get accustomed to that during the regular season only have the IHSA take those platforms away during the playoffs.

When we do experience issues who do we speak up to? Is there an email address that is actually monitored we can reach out to at either NFHS or the IHSA? If issues continue and paying customers don't have an outlet to contact, the frustration will continue when people try to watch their local team or the biggest game of the week.
You should start here in terms of contact:

[email protected]

feels too basic I know! But the names I know have a lot on their plate already, so before they get bombarded, let's start here.

Here's my theory, when issues pop up, put them in writing here. When you do that, the IHSA has data they can take back to the NFHS folks to say "hey, here's what's happening." Remember, like it or not, the NFHS folks are spread very thin around the country trying to get coverage issues taken care of. So a sustained but firm level of data will get the make the most progress.

Look, I've worked with great production companies, I've worked with great people at the NFHS. On the flipside, I've worked with the Sports Broadcasting Solutions folks who struggle at the basic level of professional decor. I've worked with great AD's and some bad ones too. It's never as bad as you think it is and it's never as easy as you think it is either.

Trust me, I get hot-headed about our games getting screw up too. But we need to get off the narrative that the NFHS is out to get the IHSA or vice versa. There's no Joe Trost conspiracy theory here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4Afan

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,199
4,599
113
You should start here in terms of contact:

[email protected]

feels too basic I know! But the names I know have a lot on their plate already, so before they get bombarded, let's start here.

Here's my theory, when issues pop up, put them in writing here. When you do that, the IHSA has data they can take back to the NFHS folks to say "hey, here's what's happening." Remember, like it or not, the NFHS folks are spread very thin around the country trying to get coverage issues taken care of. So a sustained but firm level of data will get the make the most progress.

Look, I've worked with great production companies, I've worked with great people at the NFHS. On the flipside, I've worked with the Sports Broadcasting Solutions folks who struggle at the basic level of professional decor. I've worked with great AD's and some bad ones too. It's never as bad as you think it is and it's never as easy as you think it is either.

Trust me, I get hot-headed about our games getting screw up too. But we need to get off the narrative that the NFHS is out to get the IHSA or vice versa. There's no Joe Trost conspiracy theory here.
Thanks, this is great info. My only other question would be, if NFHS has these reoccurring issues and the IHSA is aware they exist then why would they continue to partner with and promote NFHS?
 
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football 8A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football 7A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football 6A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  4. 04 Edgy Tim 5A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football 4A: Semifinalist Player of the Year