Gurdak is much more complete than Ace

mugrat86

Heisman
Dec 11, 2014
8,788
11,655
82
Let's face it. Ace Bailey was extremely raw when he played here and one dimensional. Gurdak is a much more complete player and will be much more valuable than Ace was to us
 

mugrat86

Heisman
Dec 11, 2014
8,788
11,655
82
Why are we comparing a freshman wing to our transfer center?
Just pointing out to people who got on Pike for not producing with 2 NBA first rounders how hard it is to win without rebounding and defense. Ace was certainly a great athletic specimen but he was not a good rebounder and defender. If we had Gurdak on that team we probably would've been a really good team. This is not an indictment to Ace just a compliment to how Gurdsk is a really good complete player.

If we had Keli Zinn then instead of Hobbs, we likely advance deep into tournament
 

Jerseylegends

All-Conference
Mar 15, 2023
1,760
1,907
113
Just pointing out to people who got on Pike for not producing with 2 NBA first rounders how hard it is to win without rebounding and defense. Ace was certainly a great athletic specimen but he was not a good rebounder and defender. If we had Gurdak on that team we probably would've been a really good team. This is not an indictment to Ace just a compliment to how Gurdsk is a really good complete player.

If we had Keli Zinn then instead of Hobbs, we likely advance deep into tournament
Ace was the top rebounder and defender on that Rutgers team..they were bad because ace and Dylan were the only players. Ace was that teams big man..
 

mugrat86

Heisman
Dec 11, 2014
8,788
11,655
82
Ace was the top rebounder and defender on that Rutgers team..they were bad because ace and Dylan were the only players. Ace was that teams big man..
Agree! Ogbole was a disaster. I am really impressed with how good Gurdak is. He has great hands, can pass, defend, rebound and shoot. Probably the best portal pickup ever here
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jerseylegends

Jerseylegends

All-Conference
Mar 15, 2023
1,760
1,907
113
the fact that they aren’t the same position is only the start of how this comparison is weird

Gurdack is a very skilled (but athletically limited) smallish 5 whereas Ace is an athletic FREAK wing (who had great skills for his age as a wing - not as a 5)

they almost couldnt be more different
I think he couldn't find the right words to say that this years team is depending on experienced players. While ace and Dylan were freshmen expected to lead a team of d3 caliber players..
 

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,545
13,917
78
This post is ridiculous.

Dylan Grant cracked the starting line up on that Rutgers team - as a frosh. That’s how bad the surrounding cast was.

Here’s the perspective. Currently, Dylan Grant is averaging 12.8 minutes of playing time on a 2-2 Charlotte roster AS A JUNIOR. There are 8 players averaging more minutes that Grant right now on that Charlotte roster. We’re talking about a Charlotte team that just lost at home to Appalachian State.
 

RedTeamUpstream94

All-American
Jan 15, 2021
3,556
6,680
113
I think he couldn't find the right words to say that this years team is depending on experienced players. While ace and Dylan were freshmen expected to lead a team of d3 caliber players..

maybe

but his post was limited to directly comparing the two players, saying zero about the teams they were on so….

It was also factually inaccurate - saying ace was one dimensional (implying no defense or rebounding) which is revisionist history. Just not true

While ace may have not been the best defender or rebounder he was not completely lacking in that regard and, in fact, it could very well be argued that ace was a better rebounder and defender at his position than Gurdack is at his position (as gurdack is hardly a top notch defender or rebounder)

so frankly I still have absolutely no idea what the point of the OP was.

Gurdack is great but considering that he is NOT a top notch defender or rebounder even his premise of him being a “better all around player” than ace is, frankly, just totally wrong
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: -RUFAN4LIFE-

RUbyRED

Senior
Nov 14, 2025
334
917
93
Just pointing out to people who got on Pike for not producing with 2 NBA first rounders how hard it is to win without rebounding and defense. Ace was certainly a great athletic specimen but he was not a good rebounder and defender. If we had Gurdak on that team we probably would've been a really good team. This is not an indictment to Ace just a compliment to how Gurdsk is a really good complete player.

If we had Keli Zinn then instead of Hobbs, we likely advance deep into tournament
Not sure why people bag on Ace. He was a top 5 talent in the country who decided to forge his own path and commit to a non-blue blood. He led that team in rebounding and blocks as a wing. Sure you can question the defensive intensity at times but he was the lone offensive hub on that team for long stretches (especially when Dylan was out).

Also a weird comparison because I’m not even sure Gurdak is a good defender. His post-defense has been average against 3 300+ Kenpom teams. Obviously a great addition and certainly would’ve been a big plus to have on that Ace / Dylan ‘24 team, but the basis for this comparison is non-sensical
 

satnom

All-American
Jun 28, 2002
7,502
9,671
88
Let's face it. Ace Bailey was extremely raw when he played here and one dimensional. Gurdak is a much more complete player and will be much more valuable than Ace was to us
You take your meds yesterday?

I think I get a point somewhere in your dopey comparison. Yes. Having an effective offensive spoke in the middle of the offense is great.

Hopefully you took a nap after posting.

GO RU
 

biazza38

Heisman
Nov 18, 2012
14,696
18,145
81
I can’t take posts like this seriously. Just because the surrounding cast on the Ace/Dylan team was not B1G quality and forced them to do way more than any two players should have been asked, does not mean they weren’t unbelievably good. Ace could take over a game at any moment. He could score from anywhere on the court. And in case you forgot, here you go. For some context, Harper didn’t play in this game and he still put up 39 despite the defense being locked in on him. Please tell me you thing Gurdak is a more complete player after watching this lol

 
Last edited:

mugrat86

Heisman
Dec 11, 2014
8,788
11,655
82
maybe

but his post was limited to directly comparing the two players, saying zero about the teams they were on so….

It was also factually inaccurate - saying ace was one dimensional (implying no defense or rebounding) which is revisionist history. Just not true

While ace may have not been the best defender or rebounder he was not completely lacking in that regard and, in fact, it could very well be argued that ace was a better rebounder and defender at his position than Gurdack is at his position (as gurdack is hardly a top notch defender or rebounder)

so frankly I still have absolutely no idea what the point of the OP was.

Gurdack is great but considering that he is NOT a top notch defender or rebounder even his premise of him being a “better all around player” than ace is, frankly, just totally wrong
The fact that you think Ace was a better rebounder and defender shows me everything I need to know about your sports knowledge.
I can’t take posts like this seriously. Just because the surrounding cast on the Ace/Dylan team was not B1G quality and forced those to do way more than any two players should have been asked, does not mean they weren’t unbelievably good. Ace could take over a game at any moment. He could score from anywhere on the court. And in case you forgot, here you go. For some context, Harper didn’t play in this game and he still put up 39 despite the defense being locked in on him. Please tell me you thing Gurdak is a more complete player after watching this lol


funny you never showed one defensive highlight like a blocked shot or great rebound. He was a physical freak, and we were fortunate to have him. There is no doubt he was a great offensive threat, and I never disputed that, however he was far from a complete player.
 

Jerseylegends

All-Conference
Mar 15, 2023
1,760
1,907
113
The fact that you think Ace was a better rebounder and defender shows me everything I need to know about your sports knowledge.

funny you never showed one defensive highlight like a blocked shot or great rebound. He was a physical freak, and we were fortunate to have him. There is no doubt he was a great offensive threat, and I never disputed that, however he was far from a complete player.
You do know he lead the team in rebounding and shot blocking as a wing player? I'm trying to understand what you're trying to achieve with this post, ace is 2 years removed from Rutgers but you single him out to say Gurdak is better than him? As if aces rebounding is why that team wasn't good? Of all the deficiency of the team, you choose ace Bailey as the problem there? Everyone has been saying this years team is much deeper than any Rutgers team in recent memory, with players up and down the roster. We know pike didn't have the players to make that team work. No need to try and 💩 on ace to praise gurdak just say what you have to say about gurdak..
 
  • Like
Reactions: satnom and biazza38

Jerseylegends

All-Conference
Mar 15, 2023
1,760
1,907
113
Those D3 caliber players already had success on the D1 level.
I don't understand what you're saying here...lol if I'm remembering this screen name correctly I'm guessing you are here to agree that ace Bailey held that team back and to add that Brandin Knight doesn't know how to coach. 🙄 I didn't think we would see you until they lose the first game..I see you're warming up for the season lol hopefully they don't give you too many opportunities to make your case..time will tell
 

RedTeamUpstream94

All-American
Jan 15, 2021
3,556
6,680
113
You do know he lead the team in rebounding and shot blocking as a wing player? I'm trying to understand what you're trying to achieve with this post, ace is 2 years removed from Rutgers but you single him out to say Gurdak is better than him? As if aces rebounding is why that team wasn't good? Of all the deficiency of the team, you choose ace Bailey as the problem there? Everyone has been saying this years team is much deeper than any Rutgers team in recent memory, with players up and down the roster. We know pike didn't have the players to make that team work. No need to try and 💩 on ace to praise gurdak just say what you have to say about gurdak..

the fact that this moron is doubling down on his assinine OP……
 
Last edited:

mugrat86

Heisman
Dec 11, 2014
8,788
11,655
82
You do know he lead the team in rebounding and shot blocking as a wing player? I'm trying to understand what you're trying to achieve with this post, ace is 2 years removed from Rutgers but you single him out to say Gurdak is better than him? As if aces rebounding is why that team wasn't good? Of all the deficiency of the team, you choose ace Bailey as the problem there? Everyone has been saying this years team is much deeper than any Rutgers team in recent memory, with players up and down the roster. We know pike didn't have the players to make that team work. No need to try and 💩 on ace to praise gurdak just say what you have to say about gurdak..
Just commenting that we haven't had a complete big man in a very long time. Leading that team in rebounds is not saying much as someone had to lead them. This is meant as defending Pike not getting on Ace as he obviously was not the problem. The problem was we had no money and no GM to build around Dylan and Ace. To put things in perspective, Ogbole would be the water boy on this team.
 

biazza38

Heisman
Nov 18, 2012
14,696
18,145
81
The fact that you think Ace was a better rebounder and defender shows me everything I need to know about your sports knowledge.

funny you never showed one defensive highlight like a blocked shot or great rebound. He was a physical freak, and we were fortunate to have him. There is no doubt he was a great offensive threat, and I never disputed that, however he was far from a complete player.
He single handedly won us games when Harper was out. Gurdak would not have done that with the same team. It’s hilarious that you think Gurdak is a more complete player based off of (checks notes) playing against a bunch of scrubs. Just stop the nonsense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: -RUFAN4LIFE-

S.W.A.I.N

All-American
Nov 23, 2004
4,658
5,005
81
Agree! Ogbole was a disaster. I am really impressed with how good Gurdak is. He has great hands, can pass, defend, rebound and shoot. Probably the best portal pickup ever here
Cam Spencer is a part time starter in the NBA. Keith Hughes got drafted. Gurdak has had decent games against Bryant and NJIT. God each post is worse than the next.
 

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,545
13,917
78
Just commenting that we haven't had a complete big man in a very long time. Leading that team in rebounds is not saying much as someone had to lead them. This is meant as defending Pike not getting on Ace as he obviously was not the problem. The problem was we had no money and no GM to build around Dylan and Ace. To put things in perspective, Ogbole would be the water boy on this team.

Sorry man. Nothing you said in the OP makes any sense. Gurdak is a massive upgrade over what we’ve had offensively at center. So far, he hasn’t hurt us on D against 3 cupcakes which is good, but has nothing whatsoever to do with Ace Bailey, who was one of our best wings ever playing on a team with no options at the 4 or 5 (it if you put Ace at the 4, no good option at the 3 - take your pick). Again - frosh Dylan Grant broke the starting line up, that’s how poor our options were. Grant is a junior who is 9th man now on Charlotte.

Also - there’s no need to rag on Ogbole in the context you did. It certainly appears he wouldn’t have been worth the cost to keep around but to state that he’d be a “water boy” right now compared to Miteo, Buca and Ware is just silly. What have they done that says they are so much better than him? The answer is - right now, nothing, but it’s exciting that we have 3 back ups who look like they might at least be comparable to him. That’s all. Centers are expensive. If we have 3-4 of them that are playable against high majors that would be incredible.
 

RedTeamUpstream94

All-American
Jan 15, 2021
3,556
6,680
113
Sorry man. Nothing you said in the OP makes any sense. Gurdak is a massive upgrade over what we’ve had offensively at center. So far, he hasn’t hurt us on D against 3 cupcakes which is good, but has nothing whatsoever to do with Ace Bailey, who was one of our best wings ever playing on a team with no options at the 4 or 5 (it if you put Ace at the 4, no good option at the 3 - take your pick). Again - frosh Dylan Grant broke the starting line up, that’s how poor our options were. Grant is a junior who is 9th man now on Charlotte.

Also - there’s no need to rag on Ogbole in the context you did. It certainly appears he wouldn’t have been worth the cost to keep around but to state that he’d be a “water boy” right now compared to Miteo, Buca and Ware is just silly. What have they done that says they are so much better than him? The answer is - right now, nothing, but it’s exciting that we have 3 back ups who look like they might at least be comparable to him. That’s all. Centers are expensive. If we have 3-4 of them that are playable against high majors that would be incredible.

Spot on
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Almost Six Years Later, Rutgers - Houston Signifies a Pivotal Moment Once Again
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Albany Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball topples Albany with dominant second half
  4. 04 The Knight Report Three-Star DL Jeremiah Joseph decommits from Rutgers Football
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Men's Soccer earns NCAA Tournament berth for first time since 2022