How many times in the next 10 years should Penn State make the 24-team playoff?

Erial_Lion

All-American
Nov 1, 2021
4,459
5,267
113
So how many times in ten years should PSU win the natty, and is the a number they need to make the playoffs on top of that, or is one playoff acceptable if the go all the way?
I don't really set criteria like that. Making the playoffs 10 straight years and never advancing doesn't excite me. I'd personally take 1 title and 9 years of missing the playoffs over that option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mufasa94 and psu83

BUFFALO LION

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2001
1,345
2,221
113
You do know that Paterno had quite a few years that Penn State wouldn't have made the 24-team playoff. 14 of his first 45 seasons (didn't count 2011) Penn State didn't finish in the top 20. Nearly 33% he failed to finish in the top 20, and "fans, make that delusional idiots," think Penn State should finish in 24-team playoff every year.

So without looking, and apparently not taking into consideration the years he would have ranked somewhere between 21 and 24, he would have made it 69% of the time, or basically 7 out of every 10 years??? With all those bowl wins against quality teams, and 4 undefeated teams that never were awarded the Natty, I’ll take that every freaking time!!!!

Combine that with TRUE student athletes, a University that was Nationally respected for it’s successful integration of athletics and academics, and guys you personally got to know over 4 or 5 years, you have Shangri La, Utopia, Camelot, and true Paradise all locked into one!!!!

Thanks for reminding us!!!! GREAT JOB!!!!!!!!🙂
 
  • Like
Reactions: SummitLion

BUFFALO LION

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2001
1,345
2,221
113
Well, in the last 10 years Franklin coached at PSU:

PSU would have made the "playoffs" :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: 7 out of the 9 full seasons (not counting COVID year of 2020)


That was - obviously - an unacceptable performance - and neither the "excellence at the highest level" promised by Brozo, nor the expectations that PSU fans should be satisfied with.

So (let's do the math, 7 out of 9, carry the 1, divide and round off...... LionJim can check the math) something MORE than 78% of the time.

So lets round off and say that it would have to be MORE than 80% of the time.
Fair enough?

Well, if Franklin would have made it 7 out of 9, then I would expect Campbell to make it 8 out of 9. or this whole fiasco has been a complete waste of time and money. In all honesty, there is a huge chance we would have made the CFP THIS year if the boo birds wouldn’t have gotten rid of him.

If Franklin were still here, Saturday night’s game would have probably actually meant something, and been a sellout by now.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
846
926
93
The problem is Franklin shot his load and lost last year. The talent level was depleted....so if Franklin was still here we'd be in the same boat. With a 24 team playoff this team might be just 1 win short of making it. (notice I said MIGHT BE)

So without looking, and apparently not taking into consideration the years he would have ranked somewhere between 21 and 24, he would have made it 69% of the time, or basically 7 out of every 10 years??? With all those bowl wins against quality teams, and 4 undefeated teams that never were awarded the Natty, I’ll take that every freaking time!!!!

Combine that with TRUE student athletes, a University that was Nationally respected for it’s successful integration of athletics and academics, and guys you personally got to know over 4 or 5 years, you have Shangri La, Utopia, Camelot, and true Paradise all locked into one!!!!

Thanks for reminding us!!!! GREAT JOB!!!!!!!!🙂
The poster also picked 45 years when most people think he should have been been gone in 35. Since he would have only been in the top 20 4 of those years, he would have made it 27 out of 35 or 78%. And he wasn’t paying players!
 
  • Like
Reactions: BUFFALO LION

wptlion

Freshman
Jan 7, 2002
83
81
18
Well, if Franklin would have made it 7 out of 9, then I would expect Campbell to make it 8 out of 9. or this whole fiasco has been a complete waste of time and money. In all honesty, there is a huge chance we would have made the CFP THIS year if the boo birds wouldn’t have gotten rid of him.

If Franklin were still here, Saturday night’s game would have probably actually meant something, and been a sellout by now.
Based on last years team and talent there would be zero chance this game means any more than it does now. There is a huge difference between Franklins time here and CFB today. MONEY. Franklin should have been fired in 2020
 

BUFFALO LION

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2001
1,345
2,221
113
Based on last years team and talent there would be zero chance this game means any more than it does now. There is a huge difference between Franklins time here and CFB today. MONEY. Franklin should have been fired in 2020

With Grunk here, little if any fall off in team chemistry and personal, a full recruiting class, and some selective portal acquisitions, we could very easily be 5-1 in the Conference right now, and in a good spot to finish out at 8-1. That probably gets us in the BT Championship Game this year.

Right now, this once in a lifetime gift Big Ten schedule we were blessed with, has been totally wasted away. Next year, it will be back to playing a tougher schedule with lower quality recruiting classes going forward.

Welcome to Nebraska.
 

o_PSUALREADYKNOW

Sophomore
Mar 9, 2022
159
194
43
With Grunk here, little if any fall off in team chemistry and personal, a full recruiting class, and some selective portal acquisitions, we could very easily be 5-1 in the Conference right now, and in a good spot to finish out at 8-1. That probably gets us in the BT Championship Game this year.

Right now, this once in a lifetime gift Big Ten schedule we were blessed with, has been totally wasted away. Next year, it will be back to playing a tougher schedule with lower quality recruiting classes going forward.

Welcome to Nebraska.
If you’re a Penn State fan and you think getting rid of James Franklin was a smart decision, than you’re an idiot. We’d likely finish the year at 9-3, make the Big 10 championship, and the playoffs this year.
We’d have Grunk back next year with two recurring classes to work with. Most would be four star players WE recruited-not second choices, third choices, 3 stars, and flips. We went from getting Mr.Ohio for our QB to fighting tooth and nail for a back from Boston College who already flipped our QB. We likely won’t finish top 25 this year or next year. And that’s ok with most of you? When was this level of excellence so celebrated? Where is the light at the need of the tunnel?

Oh…the light WAS the privilege of being a consistent top 15 team and sometimes top 10. THAT was the reward. Big bowl games and at least making the playoffs. THAT was the reward.

When Kraft or the fans somehow said, “oh, we can do better than Franklin,” that was the first mistake. Because there’s isn’t that many. And Campbell certainly isn’t one of them.

Then you as fans have the audacity to suggest I root against PSU? For the first time in forty years I’m mad at the college football team I adored is on shambles.

S H A M B L E S

And it’s because many of you were greedy and naive. And that was never what PSU was about or had been about. Or program was NOT win at all costs-it never had been.

So why did so many of you assume it had?

You have cursed the program and we deserve to become Nebraska!

Great wasn’t good enough. You felt like you deserved better. You deserved a better coach than Franklin. You deserved a national championship even though the last had been 40 years prior! You are Icarus.

Well, I hope you’re all happy. Personally, I’m not stupid and the current situation makes me want to puke. Because I see the future. And it’s no where near as good as we had it and it may never be again.

But blame Big Game James. We paid him THAt many million to leave? It will be looked at as one of the worst decisions and business decisions of all time.

I really thought I could work this out of my system, but the scope of this failure and the constant reminder of this tragic operation oversight prevents me from getting pumped about the team and program I loved.

I guess I can understand how a few of you are lost in the sauce still…but by next year you’ll really understand how devastating this decision was.


There won’t be “the dark years” because it’s just going to be the new normal.
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,061
21,633
113
50 50 Abc GIF by The Bachelor
 

Mufasa94

All-Conference
Jan 9, 2009
1,221
1,061
113
If you’re a Penn State fan and you think getting rid of James Franklin was a smart decision, then you’re an idiot. We’d likely finish the year at 9-3, make the Big 10 championship…blah blah blah
You attempt to insult others when you make a claim like PSU would theoretically have made the Big 10 Championship with 3 conference game losses this year.

Look in the mirror when you are tossing around your disparaging labels.
 

saturdaysarebetter

All-Conference
Jun 19, 2018
1,075
1,532
131
So without looking, and apparently not taking into consideration the years he would have ranked somewhere between 21 and 24, he would have made it 69% of the time, or basically 7 out of every 10 years??? With all those bowl wins against quality teams, and 4 undefeated teams that never were awarded the Natty, I’ll take that every freaking time!!!!

Combine that with TRUE student athletes, a University that was Nationally respected for it’s successful integration of athletics and academics, and guys you personally got to know over 4 or 5 years, you have Shangri La, Utopia, Camelot, and true Paradise all locked into one!!!!

Thanks for reminding us!!!! GREAT JOB!!!!!!!!🙂
So now you changed your answer from 10 times out of 10 to 7 times out of 10. Enlightenment is a good thing no matter how late it hit you.
 

Erial_Lion

All-American
Nov 1, 2021
4,459
5,267
113
If James Franklin was a lock to make this year’s playoffs, then I can only imagine what he could have done with last year’s talent. Experienced future-NFL QB, loaded roster that’s ranked 2nd in the country preseason. And even if we lose our early test against Oregon, we’ve got two cream puffs to get right back on our feet.

Am I doing this right in assigning theoretical victories?
 

BUFFALO LION

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2001
1,345
2,221
113
So now you changed your answer from 10 times out of 10 to 7 times out of 10. Enlightenment is a good thing no matter how late it hit you.

What the crap are you talking about “10 times out of 10”??? First of all, like I said, I am going by YOUR figures. Are you saying your figures are wrong?? I never once said Joe would have made it “10 times out of 10 years”.

If it was 7 out of 10, with all the big time Bowl wins, 2 Nattys, and 4 undefeated seasons where he never got to play for a Natty, with TRUE student athletes who mostly got their degrees??? I’ll take that any day of the week.

You’re right. It’s past your bedtime. Time to give someone your keys, and get a ride home.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

wptlion

Freshman
Jan 7, 2002
83
81
18
With Grunk here, little if any fall off in team chemistry and personal, a full recruiting class, and some selective portal acquisitions, we could very easily be 5-1 in the Conference right now, and in a good spot to finish out at 8-1. That probably gets us in the BT Championship Game this year.

Right now, this once in a lifetime gift Big Ten schedule we were blessed with, has been totally wasted away. Next year, it will be back to playing a tougher schedule with lower quality recruiting classes going forward.

Welcome to Nebraska.
Grunk is 6-3 in the ACC...we are three or four plays from being 8-1 right now. Bue JF would have lost all of them as well. Remember last years roster had 1 D1 LB. If they don't fire BGJ last year we were most likely 3-9, no one was coming either.
 

wptlion

Freshman
Jan 7, 2002
83
81
18
If you’re a Penn State fan and you think getting rid of James Franklin was a smart decision, than you’re an idiot. We’d likely finish the year at 9-3, make the Big 10 championship, and the playoffs this year.
We’d have Grunk back next year with two recurring classes to work with. Most would be four star players WE recruited-not second choices, third choices, 3 stars, and flips. We went from getting Mr.Ohio for our QB to fighting tooth and nail for a back from Boston College who already flipped our QB. We likely won’t finish top 25 this year or next year. And that’s ok with most of you? When was this level of excellence so celebrated? Where is the light at the need of the tunnel?

Oh…the light WAS the privilege of being a consistent top 15 team and sometimes top 10. THAT was the reward. Big bowl games and at least making the playoffs. THAT was the reward.

When Kraft or the fans somehow said, “oh, we can do better than Franklin,” that was the first mistake. Because there’s isn’t that many. And Campbell certainly isn’t one of them.

Then you as fans have the audacity to suggest I root against PSU? For the first time in forty years I’m mad at the college football team I adored is on shambles.

S H A M B L E S

And it’s because many of you were greedy and naive. And that was never what PSU was about or had been about. Or program was NOT win at all costs-it never had been.

So why did so many of you assume it had?

You have cursed the program and we deserve to become Nebraska!

Great wasn’t good enough. You felt like you deserved better. You deserved a better coach than Franklin. You deserved a national championship even though the last had been 40 years prior! You are Icarus.

Well, I hope you’re all happy. Personally, I’m not stupid and the current situation makes me want to puke. Because I see the future. And it’s no where near as good as we had it and it may never be again.

But blame Big Game James. We paid him THAt many million to leave? It will be looked at as one of the worst decisions and business decisions of all time.

I really thought I could work this out of my system, but the scope of this failure and the constant reminder of this tragic operation oversight prevents me from getting pumped about the team and program I loved.

I guess I can understand how a few of you are lost in the sauce still…but by next year you’ll really understand how devastating this decision was.


There won’t be “the dark years” because it’s just going to be the new normal.
He's 6-3 at VT in the ACC---seems like you're the idiot. BTW JF would have lost last week, he would have kicked a FG at the end UW would have scored a TD just like IU did a number of years a go.
 

BUFFALO LION

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2001
1,345
2,221
113
Grunk is 6-3 in the ACC...we are three or four plays from being 8-1 right now. Bue JF would have lost all of them as well. Remember last years roster had 1 D1 LB. If they don't fire BGJ last year we were most likely 3-9, no one was coming either.

Are you SERIOUSLY telling me you would take Becht over Grunk???? Grunk has a better arm, better brain (reads the field and defenses better), more mobility, more speed, more accuracy, and unlike Becht, probably a much better future in the NFL.

Becht’s arm has been a question mark since he got here. Grunk, Reynolds, and the rest of the guys we had coming back, with an actual recruiting class and targeted portals thrown in, alone would have probably given us those “three or four plays” you are talking about.

Throw in a much better strength and conditioning program (rumor is the Iowa State players were pretty soft when they got here, and the S&C is below what we had before), better team chemistry (not nearly the Payton Place situation we had/have trying to mesh two teams together with numerous portal guys), and those close losses would have very likely been close wins.

3-9??????? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

P.S. Maybe it was a typo, but what does “Bue” mean?
 
  • Like
Reactions: saturdaysarebetter

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
846
926
93
Are you SERIOUSLY telling me you would take Becht over Grunk???? Grunk has a better arm, better brain (reads the field and defenses better), more mobility, more speed, more accuracy, and unlike Becht, probably a much better future in the NFL.

Becht’s arm has been a question mark since he got here. Grunk, Reynolds, and the rest of the guys we had coming back, with an actual recruiting class and targeted portals thrown in, alone would have probably given us those “three or four plays” you are talking about.

Throw in a much better strength and conditioning program (rumor is the Iowa State players were pretty soft when they got here, and the S&C is below what we had before), better team chemistry (not nearly the Payton Place situation we had/have trying to mesh two teams together with numerous portal guys), and those close losses would have very likely been close wins.

3-9??????? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

P.S. Maybe it was a typo, but what does “Bue” mean?
Rocco Becht is the reason we are a few plays from 8-1. A quarterback with a better arm and football acumen doesn’t make the bad plays he did to blow the 3 games
 
  • Like
Reactions: BUFFALO LION
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Who Is the Core of Penn State’s 2027 Tight End Room?
  2. 02 BWI Recruiting From JV to potential five-star status: Riverside coach recaps the rise of Penn State commit David Tarawallie
  3. 03 BWI Football What did Rutgers coach Greg Schiano say about Penn State, 'one of the hottest teams in the country'?
  4. 04 BWI Football Penn State TE Benjamin Brahmer announces he'll return for the 2027 season
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State Transfer Portal Preview: Four Potential Quarterback Targets to Know for 2027