At what point does keeping Lebby become financially counterproductive in portal recruiting?

Darryl Steight

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
4,994
8,315
113
Were any of them big signees? Nope
Fair enough, what I meant was Lebby does get some good players... even if they aren't big name guys. Mullen wasn't great at that either.

I got over star ratings a long time ago, which is what I was trying to say.


*And allow me to counter my own argument by saying, Lebby doesn't appear to be a "development" guy, whereas Mullen was. So he also can't afford to ONLY recruit the 3-stars who could become NFL players like Dan could either.
 

Darryl Steight

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
4,994
8,315
113
We certainly could have. With Lebby at the helm you don't know what might happen.

After the Mizzou game, and before we knew KT was hurt, I said the only games I felt were comfortable with going forward were Vandy and TN Tech. We had a team with obvious weaknesses, that was over performing. Particularly on the defensive side of the ball. KT gave us a chance to hang with anybody, but we also could have been blown out by anybody.

It's all hypothetical, so we don't have to convince each other of anything. Its unanswerable. I just think the weaknesses were going to cost us. We have no idea what Oklahoma might have thrown at us with KT in the mix.

I didn't think Auburn could beat UGA, either.
🤷‍♂️ I can get with that.
 

triton28

Junior
Dec 18, 2009
1,505
284
78
That Ferrari you refer to seemed to be fine before the flat tire beating two teams in the current top 25 and demolished a Big Ten school on the road. The amnesia of what this team did pre injury is 17’ing delusional.
Are you saying we need a new strength coach?
 

prdubya

Freshman
Nov 29, 2017
183
88
28
Whatever we do... we CANNOT extend him 4 years if KT brings us to whatever "the promised land" is with KT.

The worst case would be for KT to bring us to the playoffs and make a bit of noise (but no title), then get Lebby the classic 4-year extension only to return to 2-10 the year after KT leaves and needing a big buyout...
 
  • Like
Reactions: We Men

Anon1727472510

Redshirt
Sep 27, 2024
54
38
17
Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon understand that.

Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon
Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon understand that.
You are a 17’ing idiot. Lebby is in his last year of his contract and the staff is the lowest paid in the SEC by a mile. Congrats on being in contention for who can **** on the program.
 

TPIPER36

Senior
May 19, 2023
771
983
93
I’m really not sure what to think on this whole KT deal. I was pretty convinced Lebby needed to be let go before we knew for sure KT was going to come back.

KT is 100 percent a super talented QB. Easily the most talented the schools ever seen, and a wonderful asset to the problem. I have a feeling just his presence, will bring some talent.
On the flip side, I’m just not a fan of Lebby and really don’t think he’s HC material at all. He was so close to losing the entire fanbase before KT re signed. This whole thing feels like such a bail out. If we didn’t have KT all this time, I don’t think he would survive as coach after tomorrow’s beating. Without KT we would maybe be at 1 or 2 wins. Reality is we’re really only keeping this guy because we re signed KT. Not a great feeling at all in the coaching aspect. It feels like we’re banking on next year, and not looking much into the future of the program.
 

TPIPER36

Senior
May 19, 2023
771
983
93
With all that said, I feel like all are issues are super easy fixes. Doesn’t seem like at lot to ask to find some guys that can fill a decent O line. Then go out and get a real back up QB that will be able to get the job done enough if KT gets hurt (which hopefully will not happen). Then you got to retain most of the skill guys, and fill holes where needed. That doesn’t seem like that big of an ask. Guess we shall see if Lebby can get the job done. Then we’re looking at about 9 wins IMO .

From there it’s really simple, if this fails miserably Lebby is gone after the Egg Bowl. If we get a run at the playoffs Lebby stays. Say we lose KT after next year, then it’s time for Lebby to prove he’s improved as a coach. If 2028 is a major drop off and we go m back to like 4 wins then we cut ties with Lebby.
 
Last edited:

MississippiTexan

Sophomore
Jun 11, 2014
149
135
43
You are a 17’ing idiot. Lebby is in his last year of his contract and the staff is the lowest paid in the SEC by a mile. Congrats on being in contention for who can **** on the program.
You keep saying that but you might want to do some research. Everything I see says Lebby is in year 3 of a 5 year contract, meaning he's signed for 2 more seasons. So not close to being in the last year of his contract.
 

Anon1727472510

Redshirt
Sep 27, 2024
54
38
17
You keep saying that but you might want to do some research. Everything I see says Lebby is in year 3 of a 5 year contract, meaning he's signed for 2 more seasons. So not close to being in the last year of his contract.
You can not sign a contract as a State employee longer than 4 years. It’s State law and he has not been renewed in any year.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,480
33,343
113
I’m really not sure what to think on this whole KT deal. I was pretty convinced Lebby needed to be let go before we knew for sure KT was going to come back.

KT is 100 percent a super talented QB. Easily the most talented the schools ever seen, and a wonderful asset to the problem. I have a feeling just his presence, will bring some talent.
On the flip side, I’m just not a fan of Lebby and really don’t think he’s HC material at all. He was so close to losing the entire fanbase before KT re signed. This whole thing feels like such a bail out. If we didn’t have KT all this time, I don’t think he would survive as coach after tomorrow’s beating. Without KT we would maybe be at 1 or 2 wins. Reality is we’re really only keeping this guy because we re signed KT. Not a great feeling at all in the coaching aspect. It feels like we’re banking on next year, and not looking much into the future of the program.
Dak is the best QB we’ve ever had and it’s not close. KT had the potential to get close but at best he’ll have only 1 good season to Dak’s 3.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blitz83

MississippiTexan

Sophomore
Jun 11, 2014
149
135
43
You can not sign a contract as a State employee longer than 4 years. It’s State law and he has not been renewed in any year.
Coaches sign two separate agreements, one with the school and one with the athletic foundation. This allows them to give a contract longer than 4 years. Again, a quick google search will tell you this.

Even if it is just 4 years then he is still not in the last year of his contract since he is in year 3 with us. Next would year would be the final year. Meaning if we keep him and KT stays healthy and we do well next year then we have to resign him to a new contract with a new (probably bigger) buyout.
 

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,968
3,192
113
That Ferrari you refer to seemed to be fine before the flat tire beating two teams in the current top 25 and demolished a Big Ten school on the road. The amnesia of what this team did pre injury is 17’ing delusional.
Well if KT makes that much of a difference then he could do the same with a monkey at HC and don't need lebby. Don't forget Lebby didn't sign KT. Even if we do well with KT next season, despite lunkhead lebby, we will be right back where we are now in 28 and another season beyond. Fire him now and we will STILL be good in 27.
 

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,825
8,259
113
You can not sign a contract as a State employee longer than 4 years. It’s State law and he has not been renewed in any year.
He has a 5 year deal. Four years through MSU and the 5th year through the Bulldog Club. Same thing Kiffin did at OM.

Try to keep up with the times before you just start going off on people without thinking.
 

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,825
8,259
113
You are a 17’ing idiot. Lebby is in his last year of his contract and the staff is the lowest paid in the SEC by a mile. Congrats on being in contention for who can **** on the program.
WTF?

First, he’s not in the last year of his contract.

Second, what does any of that have to do with what I wrote in my post, anyway?
 
Last edited:
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 On3 Football Mississippi State RB Fluff Bothwell re-signs with Bulldogs for 2027
  2. 02 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout
  3. 03 Maroon and White Chris Jans proud of Mississippi State's "must-win" performance on the road at UCF
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Injury Update: QB AJ Swann and S Isaac Smith to miss Senior Day game
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Tennessee Tech Players to Know