AKB: Info re which compact SUV to buy and whether to buy through Sam's Club or Costco

op2

All-Conference
Mar 16, 2014
12,260
2,081
103
First of all, I've pretty much narrowed it down to

1. Subaru Forester
2. Honda CR-V
3. Toyota RAV 4
4. Nissan Rogue (which I think is considered a bit lower end than 1 thru 3)
5. Volvo XC-60 (which I think is considered a bit higher end than 1 thru 3)

Any thoughts on those five?

Also, new or used? Money isn't the point, I can afford either, but I'm not necessarily going to buy new just because I can.

And lastly, is it better to buy through Sam's Club or through Costco? Or neither?

***offers sacrifice to the AKB for its infinite wisdom***
 

ClarkstonMark

All-Conference
May 23, 2002
1,934
3,104
113
Buy the one that feels right when you are sitting in the driver's seat.
They are all good vehicles.
All vehicles made these days are good vehicles. This is why I say buy what feels right.

35+ years in the auto industry. I bought new when I worked for an OEM because it made sense. Now, Always Buy Used. Always.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13
Apr 12, 2018
291
611
93
Do not sleep on the Mazda cx5 … even better imho is the CX50 hybrid which uses the same powertrain in the RAV4 hybrid… once you get 40+ mpg you don’t want to go back, and Mazda retailers will tend to budge off MSRP whereas Honda and Toyota dealers will snicker at all but the most savvy negotiator

stay the hell away from Nissan … raw garbage that screams “MY FICO SCORE BLOWS”

spent many many miles in company Subarus from ‘12 thru my retirement in ‘24 and - even as a Subaru guy from the ‘90s-> 2000s - I can assert that they are overrated, ugly, and crude… each showed signs of oil consumption (blow-by inherent with their boxer engine layout) beginning at around 60k miles ….

My last fleet car was a ‘22 RAV4 hybrid and even in base form it was light years more-refined than the three Legacy sedans I was assigned previously (all cars were issued to me as brand new vehicles), Subaru simply keeps putting their products thru the turd-polisher and is way behind in terms of refinement imho … somehow they manage to make their Foresters and Outbacks even more bloated and grotesque … speaking of grotesque: do not even sniff Kia or Hyundai
 
Last edited:

Big_O

All-Conference
Jun 28, 2001
1,804
2,933
113
We have a 3 year old RAV 4 and have been very pleased with it, although would have liked a tiny bit more cargo space.

It replaced the Volvo XC-60 we had. Absolutely well built luxurious vehicle that had terrible software running it that required us getting rid of it, since it was incredibly unreliable as it was a drive by wire vehicle. The car left us stranded a few times due to a software glitch that locked down the vehicle. You could not even move the gear shift into neutral requiring a dolly to be placed underneath so it could be towed back to the dealership. There were constant software updates some that would cause the driver’s screen to go blank. You can read the old posts about this on the Volvo users forum. Never buy a vehicle from a company owned by the Chinese.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DaytonRickster

NEPA Lion

Junior
Nov 2, 2021
183
254
63
Do not sleep on the Mazda cx5 … even better imho is the CX50 hybrid which uses the same powertrain in the RAV4 hybrid… once you get 40+ mpg you don’t want to go back, and Mazda retailers will tend to budge off MSRP whereas Honda and Toyota dealers will snicker at all but the most savvy negotiator

stay the hell away from Nissan … raw garbage that screams “MY FICO SCORE BLOWS”

spent many many miles in company Subarus from ‘12 thru my retirement in ‘24 and - even as a Subaru guy from the ‘90s-> 2000s - I can assert that they are overrated, ugly, and crude… each showed signs of oil consumption (blow-by inherent with their boxer engine layout) beginning at around 60k miles ….

My last fleet car was a ‘22 RAV4 hybrid and even in base form it was light years more-refined than the three Legacy sedans I was assigned previously (all cars were issued to me as brand new vehicles), Subaru simply keeps putting their products thru the turd-polisher and is way behind in terms of refinement imho … somehow they manage to make their Foresters and Outbacks even more bloated and grotesque … speaking of grotesque: do not even sniff Kia or Hyundai
MM II, always gives good opinions and reviews about vehicles. I respect his opinions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fac

m.knox

All-American
Aug 20, 2003
6,374
6,170
113
First of all, I've pretty much narrowed it down to

1. Subaru Forester
2. Honda CR-V
3. Toyota RAV 4
4. Nissan Rogue (which I think is considered a bit lower end than 1 thru 3)
5. Volvo XC-60 (which I think is considered a bit higher end than 1 thru 3)

Any thoughts on those five?

Also, new or used? Money isn't the point, I can afford either, but I'm not necessarily going to buy new just because I can.

And lastly, is it better to buy through Sam's Club or through Costco? Or neither?

***offers sacrifice to the AKB for its infinite wisdom***

I use Consumer Reports to help research new cars. The RAV 4 has some stellar ratings. I was thinking about another Mazda CX5. Even though it is still recommended, the current ratings are lower than my 2020 model.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Knickslions69

JoeLion

Senior
May 29, 2001
468
778
93
I have just begun the same process. I am focusing on the honda passport because of the AWD. I need something that will better handle gravel mountain roads.
 

G3624

Senior
Feb 18, 2014
623
530
93
Subaru Crosstrek dil got one last year, it is very comfortable, wife and I usually sit in rear seat.
 

Nitt1300

Heisman
Nov 2, 2008
8,105
15,180
113
Opinions vary, but nobody builds junk anymore. (well, maybe Jeep)

If you're buying used, the service history is much more important than the brand.
 

Steve JG

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2024
1,247
2,054
113
Do not sleep on the Mazda cx5 … even better imho is the CX50 hybrid which uses the same powertrain in the RAV4 hybrid… once you get 40+ mpg you don’t want to go back, and Mazda retailers will tend to budge off MSRP whereas Honda and Toyota dealers will snicker at all but the most savvy negotiator

stay the hell away from Nissan … raw garbage that screams “MY FICO SCORE BLOWS”

spent many many miles in company Subarus from ‘12 thru my retirement in ‘24 and - even as a Subaru guy from the ‘90s-> 2000s - I can assert that they are overrated, ugly, and crude… each showed signs of oil consumption (blow-by inherent with their boxer engine layout) beginning at around 60k miles ….

My last fleet car was a ‘22 RAV4 hybrid and even in base form it was light years more-refined than the three Legacy sedans I was assigned previously (all cars were issued to me as brand new vehicles), Subaru simply keeps putting their products thru the turd-polisher and is way behind in terms of refinement imho … somehow they manage to make their Foresters and Outbacks even more bloated and grotesque … speaking of grotesque: do not even sniff Kia or Hyundai
I am just at 6 feet and the CX5 driver seat a little tight, ceiling feels very low, uncomfortable for me. My wife 5 feet tall and she loves the CX5 perfect size for her.........
 

TheBigUglies

All-Conference
Oct 26, 2021
1,498
2,430
113
Not knowing the specs on these cars. I Iike a 6 cyl over a 4cyl but mpg may be a factor for you. Also, from my experiences with new vs used. Every new car I bought lasts for 12+ years because I take care of them and do routine maint. I bough a used car once and it only lasted about 5 years and I am guessing it wasn't really taken care of before I acquired it. I tend to use my cars until I can no longer(yearly repair cost become as high as or more then a year's worth of car payments).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nitt1300

PSU Mike

All-American
Jul 28, 2001
4,915
8,684
113
I personally “didn’t get” the Mazdas when we drove them a couple years back. I’d rule the Volvo out - dollar depreciation (and even %) is absurd. I’ve found Hondas to feel a bit “tinny” over the years. I’d probably go RAV4 hybrid, Forester Hybrid, CRV, CX5, then no and no.

Full disclosure, we’re in Teslas with home charger. Not great resale but they fit us well. EVs are so much more intuitive to drive - it’s what you probably thought driving would be like as a kid before you were behind the wheel and the torque and handling give you valid confidence in most situations. I wonder if resale actually gets a bit better once there’s more data showing the battery life fears are overblown.
 

Nitt1300

Heisman
Nov 2, 2008
8,105
15,180
113
Not knowing the specs on these cars. I Iike a 6 cyl over a 4cyl but mpg may be a factor for you. Also, from my experiences with new vs used. Every new car I bought lasts for 12+ years because I take care of them and do routine maint. I bough a used car once and it only lasted about 5 years and I am guessing it wasn't really taken care of before I acquired it. I tend to use my cars until I can no longer(yearly repair cost become as high as or more then a year's worth of car payments).
every used car on the market is on the market for a reason
 

OptionBob

Senior
Oct 12, 2021
247
692
93
We bought a RAV4 last summer through the Costco Car Purchase program.
1. Called the salesman at the dealer authorized for the program.
2. Told him the features and color we wanted.He ordered it.
3. When it arrived from Japan, we received about a $3K discount from the list price plus all Toyota/dealer incentives.
4. There was no "talk to our manager" or "haggling."
5. We really like the RAV4 so far.

NOTE: Only certain local dealers are authorized to offer the Costco discount. We researched all of them. There is 1 for Subaru, 1 for Mazda, etc. The best "deal" we received was from Toyota.
 

12bflying

Freshman
Oct 2, 2006
53
79
18
If you want AWD, check out the drive trains. Some hybrids use electric motors on the rear wheels and are only effective at non-highway speeds.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nitt1300

op2

All-Conference
Mar 16, 2014
12,260
2,081
103
We bought a RAV4 last summer through the Costco Car Purchase program.
1. Called the salesman at the dealer authorized for the program.
2. Told him the features and color we wanted.He ordered it.
3. When it arrived from Japan, we received about a $3K discount from the list price plus all Toyota/dealer incentives.
4. There was no "talk to our manager" or "haggling."
5. We really like the RAV4 so far.

NOTE: Only certain local dealers are authorized to offer the Costco discount. We researched all of them. There is 1 for Subaru, 1 for Mazda, etc. The best "deal" we received was from Toyota.
The way you wrote it implies you may not have known how much your discount was until after the car arrived. Is that true? It doesn't sound right.
 

WestSideLion

All-American
May 29, 2001
5,157
5,580
113
First of all, I've pretty much narrowed it down to

1. Subaru Forester
2. Honda CR-V
3. Toyota RAV 4
4. Nissan Rogue (which I think is considered a bit lower end than 1 thru 3)
5. Volvo XC-60 (which I think is considered a bit higher end than 1 thru 3)

Any thoughts on those five?

Also, new or used? Money isn't the point, I can afford either, but I'm not necessarily going to buy new just because I can.

And lastly, is it better to buy through Sam's Club or through Costco? Or neither?

***offers sacrifice to the AKB for its infinite wisdom***
We just bought my wife the RAV4 XSE plug-in hybrid. She loves it and hasn’t touched gas in 2 mos of ownership.

It’s not cheap, but she test drove the entire set and settled on this one. It has all the features most people would want. She loves the 360 degree camera and parking guidance. It has quite a bit of pop under the hood too.
 

Catch1lion

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
4,535
7,624
113
How did Subarus become the lesbian brand of choice? It seems like a thing now.
1990’s marketing strategy. Demographic survey found outdoorsy women from Oregon , etc. bought them in disproportionate numbers. Got Martina Nav in a campaign and got double entendre ad slogans . It worked .
 
  • Like
Reactions: LMTLION

PSU Mike

All-American
Jul 28, 2001
4,915
8,684
113
How did Subarus become the lesbian brand of choice? It seems like a thing now.
There is some signaling (on average) in the choice of vehicle. I always thought Subaru signaled a pretty laid back, practical person who recognizes there are other people in the world. And they look good with asymmetric position of stickers on the back. I drove them for 11 years before going electric.

Land Rover signals “I get to pick first, and you can have what’s left over.” Science still can’t explain how the woman behind the wheel can drive with cell phone in one hand and Starbucks in the other, or why the cell phone when every model has Bluetooth calling. Also have the best lighting on the driver-side visor mirror.

Volvo signals “I bought this because it’s supposed to be safe, so I can now ignore the rules of the road because you can’t possibly accuse me of being unsafe.”

BMW. Well if I have to explain. Needs to meet lane change quota. Has yet to figure out that they aggressively pass same Subaru 14 times in 5 miles, yet end up at red light next to same Subaru near the end of the trip.

Nissan. I prefer the White Sox over the Cubs.

VW. I like that my dealer has good loaner cars, which is important when my car is in the shop for 4 weeks at a time.

Mazda. I follow this massimo guy from a Penn State board who apparently racks up 248,000 miles/year behind the wheel of cars and lawnmowers.

Who would like to go next - I’m curious if I’ll agree.
 
Last edited:
Sep 10, 2013
18,543
13,556
113
I love these boxes people put you in based on what you drive. For 5 years I had a cummins dually and a Miata in my garage at the same time. Was I a pussyy one day and the Marlboro man the next as I swapped back and forth?
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,250
4,409
112
1990’s marketing strategy. Demographic survey found outdoorsy women from Oregon , etc. bought them in disproportionate numbers. Got Martina Nav in a campaign and got double entendre ad slogans . It worked .

I had a Subaru for many years up until 2024 and never knew that was a thing until seeing stuff on social media very recently. It was a great vehicle and fantastic in the snow. In fact, I gave it to my daughter and it is still going strong heading toward 150k miles.
 

TiogaLion

All-Conference
Oct 31, 2021
1,649
2,546
113
Be sure to do the payback on Hybrid vs no-Hybrid. The hybrid had an 8-year payback at $4.00/gallon. Not worth adding an extra layer for repairs to me. Maybe if you plan to drive a lot ad expect gas to go up, but 8 years was my number.
 

GSPVik

Sophomore
Jun 21, 2018
94
114
18
Be sure to do the payback on Hybrid vs no-Hybrid. The hybrid had an 8-year payback at $4.00/gallon. Not worth adding an extra layer for repairs to me. Maybe if you plan to drive a lot ad expect gas to go up, but 8 years was my number.
Kia Sportage hybrid has a 3 year payback based on: 15,000 miles at 3.20 per gallon. Works out to 2.6 years. At 20,000 miles, less than 2 years. Hybrid has more power. Very highly rated for hybrid SUVs.

Turned in Volvo xc4 this summer for the Kia AWD. Just checked the MPG since last fill up and it was 38. Trip in town today was 50 in stop and go traffic,

As many features as the Volvo at lower cost. Worst negative is figuring out the electronics.

Not as CVT transmission. Had a catastrophic failure with a Nissan CVT. 3rd Kia in the family and have been happy with all of them.

BTW: my drive is a chevy Silverado which gets about 22 mpg over 23,000 miles.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State's Audavion Collins on his final season: 'Don't second-guess yourself'
  2. 02 BWI Football Matt Campbell on Penn State's turnaround, Senior Day and two key return announcements
  3. 03 BWI Recruiting Three 2028 Rivals300 prospects confirmed for Penn State's home finale
  4. 04 BWI Football Ben Brahmer and Kooper Ebel returning to Penn State will help 'start to accelerate a little bit of that planning' for the 2027 season
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State injury updates: Did Carson Hansen practice on Wednesday? Latest on Caleb Bacon, Jahmir Joseph