Beamer vs Spurrier: first 72 games

Mar 29, 2012
147
156
43
But Wolfie was using Hunt's recruits. OL recruits take 2-3 seasons to develop. With transfers, you can get immediate results. What were Wolfie's stats when he was here from '17-'20? He's currently Kiffen's OL coach @ LSU & was Saban's OL coach @ Bama - Saban's last 2 seasons.

The improvements in stats for '10 shows the influence of Lattimore and integrating the zone blocking/running game.
Credit goes back to Steve Spurrier for adding this to his offense. Shawn Elliott and G.A. Mangus are the main influencers of this.
Steve would have never went with a dual threat QB until he was forced to evolve. Connor Shaw was Mangus' recruit.

And maybe even Hunt's OL would have done much better with a different scheme? I saw some clips of Cory Boyd tearing up the CFL with zone running plays. One has to wonder what could have been.

Im not sure if the stats those years tell us the full story. There were 3 different offensive coordinators for those seasons (Kurt Roper, Bryan McClendon, and Mike Bobo) so its not like the offense performance was going great as evidenced by so much turnover. Bobo has been successful at UGA as OC, however I think anyone could be successful with the level of talent he has had to work with. I think McClendon and Roper were guilty of offensive coordinator malpractice here, but Will Muschamp teams at South Carolina and Florida were always hot garbage on offense. I think it was evidence of a team effort to suck.

Anyway, here are the offensive stats from 2017-2020:
2017, 12th in total yards
2018, 9th in total yards
2019, 12th in total yards
2020, 10th in total yards
 
  • Like
Reactions: Go Gamecocks

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
Im not sure if the stats those years tell us the full story. There were 3 different offensive coordinators for those seasons (Kurt Roper, Bryan McClendon, and Mike Bobo) so its not like the offense performance was going great as evidenced by so much turnover. Bobo has been successful at UGA as OC, however I think anyone could be successful with the level of talent he has had to work with. I think McClendon and Roper were guilty of offensive coordinator malpractice here, but Will Muschamp teams at South Carolina and Florida were always hot garbage on offense. I think it was evidence of a team effort to suck.

Anyway, here are the offensive stats from 2017-2020:
2017, 12th in total yards
2018, 9th in total yards
2019, 12th in total yards
2020, 10th in total yards
But at least we couldn't tackle
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
Probably already said, but I'll say it again: when Beamer has won 11 games three times and has whipped the taters five consecutive years, we'll start making comparisons.

You're comparing the entirety of Spurrier's time here to only Beamer's first 5+ years. That's not the point. The simple point is through the same time point in their respective careers here, there's not much difference. As noted above, through the first 5+ years, here fans were starting to get a little antsy about SOS. The cock n fire never materialized. We had some tough stretches (losing 5 straight to end a season, getting skunked by Uconn of all schools in a bowl game, losing to UK after beating #1 Bama, about half of Spurrier's seasons here we had a losing conference record).

Believe it or not...now, this may shock you...there's more to the SOS tenure than '11-'13. The only real difference in their first 6 years is that SOS was doing it with decades of experience under his belt. Beamer was learning on the fly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
When people try to compare Beamer and Spurrier, they need to remember that they are 2 different types. Spurrier could coach and make decisions in a game, with credibility, on his own. Beamer is dependent on the abilities of his coordinators. Thus, if Beamer makes a poor hire, we suffer for the long-term.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
When people try to compare Beamer and Spurrier, they need to remember that they are 2 different types. Spurrier could coach and make decisions in a game, with credibility, on his own. Beamer is dependent on the abilities of his coordinators. Thus, if Beamer makes a poor hire, we suffer for the long-term.

Who cares how you get there, though? The record is all that matters. And that's all this thread is about.

And, SOS I know for sure, made some bad game calls. We just wrote them of b/c he was the HBC. He could get up and say "Aw, shucks, we thought their guy would go this and he went that way. We did a lousy job. toothsuck" and that was good enough for us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
Who cares how you get there, though? The record is all that matters. And that's all this thread is about.
And records are deceiving. Opponents are not equal from year-to-year. Where did Spurrier's teams nationally compare to Beamer's? Where did a "past his prime" Spurrier compare to a 40 something Beamer?
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
All of this banter above is vintage Botman trolling.

He knows comparison between the two eras is ridiculous.

If you want to make sure not to get wrapped up in meaningless conversations, take note ot the accounts in play.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
You're comparing the entirety of Spurrier's time here to only Beamer's first 5+ years. That's not the point. The simple point is through the same time point in their respective careers here, there's not much difference.

Then ill say again, the comparison shows that Beamer is almost as good as Spurrier was at his absolute worst run of his career.

And as the next few years unfold, that comparison will only get worse for one of them. Much like the "best record after 3 years" and "best record after 4 years" did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,771
1,542
113
Who cares how you get there, though? The record is all that matters. And that's all this thread is about.

And, SOS I know for sure, made some bad game calls. We just wrote them of b/c he was the HBC. He could get up and say "Aw, shucks, we thought their guy would go this and he went that way. We did a lousy job. toothsuck" and that was good enough for us.
18 you got your work cut out for you lol.

Good thread though, the nonsense aside.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
18 you got your work cut out for you lol.

Good thread though, the nonsense aside.
Believe it or not, while some of us think it's ridiculous trying to equate Beamer with Spurrier, we are all pulling for Beamer and USC. We all want Beamer to make South Carolina a nationally respected football program. If he can start that at age 49 instead of when Spurrier did at age 66, then you and I (who are about the same age) can live out the twilight of our years enjoying college football glory. Wouldn't that be great?
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
Believe it or not, while some of us think it's ridiculous trying to equate Beamer with Spurrier, we are all pulling for Beamer and USC. We all want Beamer to make South Carolina a nationally respected football program. If he can start that at age 49 instead of when Spurrier did at age 66, then you and I (who are about the same age) can live out the twilight of our years enjoying college football glory. Wouldn't that be great?

Based on your premise, Spurrier had a grand total of 3 years of having South Carolina a nationally respected football program,

Most all of that was due to Top 5/10 recruiting that Beamer isn't going to get unless you cash in some of that Stock.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
Based on your premise, Spurrier had a grand total of 3 years of having South Carolina a nationally respected football program,

Most all of that was due to Top 5/10 recruiting that Beamer isn't going to get unless you cash in some of that Stock.
As I recall, SOS had only one Top 10 recruiting class and that was very early in his time at USC.

We have never been a recruiting powerhouse machine. Our most successful Head Coaches had strength more in "coaching" than as recruiters. I assume you are referring to contributing to NIL. Winning football games is not THAT important to me.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
As I recall, SOS had only one Top 10 recruiting class and that was very early in his time at USC.

We have never been a recruiting powerhouse machine. Our most successful Head Coaches had strength more in "coaching" than as recruiters. I assume you are referring to contributing to NIL. Winning football games is not THAT important to me.
He had a No. 6 and No. 12 to setup those 3 years of glory you pine for.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
He had a No. 6 and No. 12 to setup those 3 years of glory you pine for.
I went back and looked. He brought in the #7 class in 2007. He produced Top 10 teams in 2011, 12 and 2013. Gator fans used to complain about Spurrier's recruiting. The fact is that Spurrier was never lauded for his recruiting prowess. It was always for his "x's and o's", his "coaching", "doing more with less", not his recruiting. We have never been a recruiting juggernaut. I suspect we will never be.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
I went back and looked. He brought in the #7 class in 2007. He produced Top 10 teams in 2011, 12 and 2013. Gator fans used to complain about Spurrier's recruiting. The fact is that Spurrier was never lauded for his recruiting prowess. It was always for his "x's and o's", his "coaching", "doing more with less", not his recruiting. We have never been a recruiting juggernaut. I suspect we will never be.

All facts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,771
1,542
113
I went back and looked. He brought in the #7 class in 2007. He produced Top 10 teams in 2011, 12 and 2013. Gator fans used to complain about Spurrier's recruiting. The fact is that Spurrier was never lauded for his recruiting prowess. It was always for his "x's and o's", his "coaching", "doing more with less", not his recruiting. We have never been a recruiting juggernaut. I suspect we will never be.
Nonsense. Spurrier was very much lauded for his recruiting prowess at Florida; common saying during that time was that his teams both sides of the ball were first rounders. For his glory years here, he didn’t HAVE to ‘recruit’; Stephon Gilmore. Devonte Holloman, Alshon Jeffrey, DJ Swearinger, Damario Jeffrey, Marcus Lattimore, AJ Cann, Kelcey Quarles, Victor Hampton, Jadaveon Clowney, Brandon Shell, Gerald Dixon; all generational in-state guys that fell into his lap. THAT is what fueled his 11 win seasons and doesn’t even include the out of state guys. Rankings are according to service; those were some bumper classes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
Rankings are according to service; those were some bumper classes.

If one wanted to argue the other side, they'd argue the rankings were real and the staff made the players better, putting them in the right place to succeed, etc. Depends on if we're attacking or defending Spurrier that day.

In reality, Spurrier hated recruiting, and said as much. What he did though, was outcoach other teams. He had a staff recruit for him, but after a time, playing for Spurrier was the recruiting sell.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
Nonsense. Spurrier was very much lauded for his recruiting prowess at Florida; common saying during that time was that his teams both sides of the ball were first rounders. For his glory years here, he didn’t HAVE to ‘recruit’; Stephon Gilmore. Devonte Holloman, Alshon Jeffrey, DJ Swearinger, Damario Jeffrey, Marcus Lattimore, AJ Cann, Kelcey Quarles, Victor Hampton, Jadaveon Clowney, Brandon Shell, Gerald Dixon; all generational in-state guys that fell into his lap. THAT is what fueled his 11 win seasons and doesn’t even include the out of state guys. Rankings are according to service; those were some bumper classes.
I guess we have read different things about his recruiting reputation. I would say that he could identify talent that maybe the recruiting gurus overlooked. Connor Shaw comes to mind. I agree though with you that he had some good in-state talent that were here that helped fueled those 11 win seasons. Regardless, Spurrier was known more for his coaching ability than his recruiting throughout his career. After all. he won a football conference championship at academic-first Duke. And that was not because he had better players over the other teams.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
If one wanted to argue the other side, they'd argue the rankings were real and the staff made the players better, putting them in the right place to succeed, etc. Depends on if we're attack8ng or defending Spurrier that day.

In reality, Spurrier hated recruiting, and said as much. What he did though, was outcoach other teams. He had a staff recruit for him, but after a time, playing for Spurrier was the recruiting sell.
Absolutely. It was common knowledge what Spurrier's feelings were about recruiting. He did not hide it. Spurrier was never known to outwork others on the recruiting trail.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
Absolutely. It was common knowledge what Spurrier's feelings were about recruiting. He did not hide it. Spurrier was never known to outwork others on the recruiting trail.

I went searching for old rankings and they were surprisingly hard to find. I found one UT site that had top 10's from the 90's, and UF was in there often, usually around 7 or 8. But that was far from an official ESPN site.

There was also an article on how their "disapointing" 99 class actually outperformed their 2000 #1 ranked class.

I do find it interesting that people that lived through his time at UF and watched i live can have such different recollections of Spurrier. I thought it was common knowledge he disliked recruiting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
I went searching for old rankings and they were surprisingly hard to find. I found one UT site that had top 10's from the 90's, and UF was in there often, usually around 7 or 8. But that was far from an official ESPN site.

There was also an article on how their "disapointing" 99 class actually outperformed their 2000 #1 ranked class.

I do find it interesting that people that lived through his time at UF and watched i live can have such different recollections of Spurrier. I thought it was common knowledge he disliked recruiting.
I agree. I do remember reading that some Gator fans were critical of his recruiting. Spurrier's reputation was that of a "coach", not a recruiter. For him to win a conference championship at Duke was remarkable. I was reading something on Duke's current Head Coach, Manny Diaz. This quote stood out to me about Diaz: "If you can win at Duke, you can win anywhere".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

SouthernBelly

Senior
Sep 16, 2024
1,050
799
113
Nonsense. Spurrier was very much lauded for his recruiting prowess at Florida; common saying during that time was that his teams both sides of the ball were first rounders. For his glory years here, he didn’t HAVE to ‘recruit’; Stephon Gilmore. Devonte Holloman, Alshon Jeffrey, DJ Swearinger, Damario Jeffrey, Marcus Lattimore, AJ Cann, Kelcey Quarles, Victor Hampton, Jadaveon Clowney, Brandon Shell, Gerald Dixon; all generational in-state guys that fell into his lap. THAT is what fueled his 11 win seasons and doesn’t even include the out of state guys. Rankings are according to service; those were some bumper classes.
Pretty sure you have used the term generational a few times to describe players from that time frame, would really like your understanding of that term. Also, they didn't fall into his lap, I know you've said as much before too. That's just not true. These "generational players" are widely and heavily recruited. Some sort of effort and sales job is made to all of them by all who are after them.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
I went back and looked. He brought in the #7 class in 2007. He produced Top 10 teams in 2011, 12 and 2013. Gator fans used to complain about Spurrier's recruiting. The fact is that Spurrier was never lauded for his recruiting prowess. It was always for his "x's and o's", his "coaching", "doing more with less", not his recruiting. We have never been a recruiting juggernaut. I suspect we will never be.
It was ranked #4 from what I saw. Look how many 5th year seniors were on the 2011 team. The #12 class was in the heart of the run. And they stuck around for 4-5 years.

But I'm really enjoying watching different parts of the same brain dissect a coach's 3 years who hasn't been here in over a decade.

It happens at least once a month.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
It was ranked #4 from what I saw. Look how many 5th year seniors were on the 2011 team. The #12 class was in the heart of the run. And they stuck around for 4-5 years.

But I'm really enjoying watching different parts of the same brain dissect a coach's 3 years who hasn't been here in over a decade.

It happens at least once a month.
I looked back on this site's recruiting rankings that had them ranked 7th. Spurrier's 2012 and 2013 teams also finished in the Top 10, a little higher than the 2011 team and without any of the 2007 recruits. And he did it with worse than Top 10 recruiting classes. He obviously did ""more with less". It can obviously be done without Top 10 recruiting classes.
 

Go Gamecocks

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2021
1,884
1,558
113
Yes I agree. To Spurrier's and Mangus' credit, they recognized that Shaw could win in the SEC.
I remember reading a practice report from one of those spring practices when Shaw first arrived on campus. He enrolled early.
He took off on a run and Mangus was all excited because they could see how fast he was. Steve never had a QB that was that fast, with the possible exception of Syvelle Newton.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
I went searching for old rankings and they were surprisingly hard to find. I found one UT site that had top 10's from the 90's, and UF was in there often, usually around 7 or 8. But that was far from an official ESPN site.

There was also an article on how their "disapointing" 99 class actually outperformed their 2000 #1 ranked class.

I do find it interesting that people that lived through his time at UF and watched i live can have such different recollections of Spurrier. I thought it was common knowledge he disliked recruiting.
I asked AI what was Steve Spurrier best known for being, a X's and O's coach or a recruiter? The answer: :"Steve Spurrier was overwhelmingly best known as an X's and O's genius rather than a relentless recruiter. His reputation in college football was built on revolutionary play-calling, quarterback development, and turning underdog or stagnant programs into offensive powerhouses. Spurrier maximized the talent of quarterbacks who were not always five-star recruits. He coached Danny Wueerffel to the 1996 Heisman Trophy and turned players like Shane Matthews and Connor Shaw into record-breaking conference stars. Spurrier proved his scheme worked anywhere by winning an ACC title at Duke in 1989 and leading South Carolina to three straight 11-win seasons from 2011 to 2013 --- unprecedented heights for both programs. "

"His Reputation as a Recruiter. A Dislike for the Grind. Spurrier openly disliked the year-round glad-handing and travel required for modern recruiting, famously preferring to spend his off-season afternoons on the golf course. While he landed superstars like Jadeveon Clowney at South Carolina, his rosters were rarely built on hoarding top-ranked recruiting classes the way coaches like Nick Saban or Kirby Smart operated. Critics often point to relaxed recruiting habits during his final years at South Carolina as a primary reason the roster depth collapsed, leading to his abrupt resignation in 2015."

The following is me, not AI, writing:
There were some pretty good talented players in the state when Spurrier was here. It helped Spurrier and SC that there were. BUT that does not mean there were not some, pretty good talented players at Georgia, Alabama, Tennessee, Florida, Auburn, LSU, etc also. There usually are. His strength and reputation was the X's and O's , NOT as a recruiter. He maximized the talent he had on hand. Not all coaches are able to do that.
 
Last edited:

Go Gamecocks

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2021
1,884
1,558
113
"His Reputation as a Recruiter. A Dislike for the Grind.
Steve got into coaching to find something to do after his 10 yrs in the NFL. That explains a lot.

He could have probably played golf the rest of his life.

Interesting....how many former NFL players were as successful as Spurrier? Jim Harbaugh had a good run at UM.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
I asked AI what was Steve Spurrier best known for being, a X's and O's coach or a recruiter? The answer: :"Steve Spurrier was overwhelmingly best known as an X's and O's genius rather than a relentless recruiter. His reputation in college football was built on revolutionary play-calling, quarterback development, and turning underdog or stagnant programs into offensive powerhouses. Spurrier maximized the talent of quarterbacks who were not always five-star recruits. He coached Danny Wueerffel to the 1996 Heisman Trophy and turned players like Shane Matthews and Connor Shaw into record-breaking conference stars. Spurrier proved his scheme worked anywhere by winning an ACC title at Duke in 1989 and leading South Carolina to three straight 11-win seasons from 2011 to 2013 --- unprecedented heights for both programs. "

"His Reputation as a Recruiter. A Dislike for the Grind. Spurrier openly disliked the year-round glad-handing and travel required for modern recruiting, famously preferring to spend his off-season afternoons on the golf course. While he landed superstars like Jadeveon Clowney at South Carolina, his rosters were rarely built on hoarding top-ranked recruiting classes the way coaches like Nick Saban or Kirby Smart operated. Critics often point to relaxed recruiting habits during his final years at South Carolina as a primary reason the roster depth collapsed, leading to his abrupt resignation in 2015."

The following is me, not AI, writing:
There were some pretty good talented players in the state when Spurrier was here. It helped Spurrier and SC that there were. BUT that does not mean there were not some, pretty good talented players at Georgia, Alabama, Tennessee, Florida, Auburn, LSU, etc also. There usually are. His strength and reputation was the X's and O's , NOT as a recruiter. He maximized the talent he had on hand. Not all coaches are able to do that.

Kudos Botman. This is one of your best troll threads to date. :)

If Steve was such a great Xs and Os guy, why after 6 years was he neck and neck with a coach you seem to despise?

The recruiting push and a weak SEC East was the catalyst for the 11-2 run.

The teams were loaded. It was a great period in a different era of college football.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
Kudos Botman. This is one of your best troll threads to date. :)

If Steve was such a great Xs and Os guy, why after 6 years was he neck and neck with a coach you seem to despise?

The recruiting push and a weak SEC East was the catalyst for the 11-2 run.

The teams were loaded. It was a great period in a different era of college football.
You are now back where you deserve to be troublemaker: add me to a long list of those here putting you on "IGNORE". Have fun responding to anything I comment on. I won't know what nonsense you post. LMAO@ YOU.
 

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,771
1,542
113
Kudos Botman. This is one of your best troll threads to date. :)

If Steve was such a great Xs and Os guy, why after 6 years was he neck and neck with a coach you seem to despise?

The recruiting push and a weak SEC East was the catalyst for the 11-2 run.

The teams were loaded. It was a great period in a different era of college football.
Thought that was common knowledge. I find Stock a bit more palatable than the others in that group, but it’s obvious their focus is throwing shade on Beamer more so than rational discourse; hence whiffing on the OP to start with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
You are now back where you deserve to be troublemaker: add me to a long list of those here putting you on "IGNORE". Have fun responding to anything I comment on. I won't know what nonsense you post. LMAO@ YOU.

Nice try. You're not playing this right.

Me referring to you as the Botman shouldn't cause you anything but laughter unless it's true. :)

I do like the Stock character. Unlike Lurker, you put some decent thought into him.

Wish he would answer that question though?
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
Thought that was common knowledge. I find Stock a bit more palatable than the others in that group, but it’s obvious their focus is throwing shade on Beamer more so than rational discourse; hence whiffing on the OP to start with.

100%. I just wanted to see if he would come back with anything other than what he did.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 GamecockCentral Football Details you may have missed: South Carolina vs. Arkansas
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Football Insider Mailbag Vol. 12: Briles and Sellers, what's next for South Carolina
  3. 03 GamecockCentral Football South Carolina remains in College Football Playoff rankings after Arkansas loss
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Womens Basketball Photos: Gamecocks roll past FGCU in home opener
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Womens Basketball South Carolina women's basketball: Rapid Reaction - FGCU