FC: Prez Bendapudi announces that campus closures are forthcoming

op2

All-Conference
Mar 16, 2014
12,260
2,080
103
Nothing wrong with the branch campuses, but If I had to do the 2 + 2 route, I might have chosen another school. I wanted to be on a large traditional campus 4 years. From my perspective there was more to it than just getting my prerequisite courses in the first two years (and I don't mean the partying....I wasn't in to that anyway) but other resources and activities.

I suspect most students would want to go to main campus from the get go because that seems cooler and more glamorous. And I suspect that while that's fine for some, such as you, there are others who would be better served by doing 2 + 2 so they can get basic education while also growing and maturing more before they go to the giant main campus, which can be overwhelming. And perhaps we can't tell in advance who would be best served by which model.

But that gets to another thing about college, which is that it's about much more than education. I mean, people say we need to have publicly funded education, which we do, but college has so much more than that and while a lot of that stuff is fun and useful, it's not actually education.

Maybe the thing to do is to not only have main campus be more selective on which freshmen it'll take but also have branch campuses be much less expensive and then the options will be more clear cut...you either go to main campus and get the main campus experience but pay more...or you go to a branch campus and pay less. I know there are some extracirriculars at the branches too but it's not like the main campus.

Maybe someone will tell me that branch campuses have been expensive than main campus all along. I don't know. I'm talking about per credit hour I mean. Paying for room & board is a whole separate issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbrown and Bison13

Bison13

All-American
May 26, 2013
3,898
6,528
113
I suspect most students would want to go to main campus from the get go because that seems cooler and more glamorous. And I suspect that while that's fine for some, such as you, there are others who would be better served by doing 2 + 2 so they can get basic education while also growing and maturing more before they go to the giant main campus, which can be overwhelming. And perhaps we can't tell in advance who would be best served by which model.

But that gets to another thing about college, which is that it's about much more than education. I mean, people say we need to have publicly funded education, which we do, but college has so much more than that and while a lot of that stuff is fun and useful, it's not actually education.

Maybe the thing to do is to not only have main campus be more selective on which freshmen it'll take but also have branch campuses be much less expensive and then the options will be more clear cut...you either go to main campus and get the main campus experience but pay more...or you go to a branch campus and pay less. I know there are some extracirriculars at the branches too but it's not like the main campus.

Maybe someone will tell me that branch campuses have been expensive than main campus all along. I don't know. I'm talking about per credit hour I mean. Paying for room & board is a whole separate issue.
I can see both sides of closing campus vs not. At some point the school needs to start cutting costs though. I agree the branch campus price should be much lower to offset the allure of getting in to UP. I dont know how much it would change the minds of students but it could help some. One issue there though is that many of the branch campuses are funding athletic programs for the sole purpose of attracting students so that they and their parents can say they have a college athlete.

They have a huge crop of potential families who will gladly fork over the $$ to say their kid was a 'Penn State _______________ player" . As a coach I hear it all the time, "yeah, my Johnny is getting recruited by Penn State" when in reality its PSU Harrisburg or Altoona or one of the branches that offer a chance to play there all 4 years.

I had 4 of my baseball players commit to various colleges so far this fall and have another whose father tells people he is getting recruited by PSU, but its really PSU Berks, a not very good D3 program. But because the father tells the story so much and people dont know about the branch campus teams, everyone thinks that his kid is some great player when he probably wont even start as a senior.
 
Last edited:

psuno1

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
1,138
1,422
113
The Branch Campuses were losing 50 million dollars a year, how did it take them so long to close some of them down? 10 years would be half a billion dollars-shut them down. So out of touch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pendal1

Rocco3

Junior
Mar 25, 2022
322
349
63
I was looking at the histories of some of the commonwealth campuses and found this on the Mont Alto wiki page....

Merger with Penn State​

In 1929 the Forest Academy merged with Pennsylvania State University, establishing Penn State Mont Alto. Students were adamantly opposed to the merger, and they protested by hanging two state officials in effigy.

Anyway, in looking at a map, it seems there are some campuses which can/should be merged. I hate to say it but I agree with the prez.
This will continue to happen all across the country. Online universities is now a real thing which sounds the death Nell for small campuses. Main campuses will also have to scale back eventually. This is just the benning.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nitt1300

taryn

Sophomore
Nov 1, 2020
221
189
43
I can see both sides of closing campus vs not. At some point the school needs to start cutting costs though. I agree the branch campus price should be much lower to offset the allure of getting in to UP. I dont know how much it would change the minds of students but it could help some. One issue there though is that many of the branch campuses are funding athletic programs for the sole purpose of attracting students so that they and their parents can say they have a college athlete.

They have a huge crop of potential families who will gladly fork over the $$ to say their kid was a 'Penn State _______________ player" . As a coach I hear it all the time, "yeah, my Johnny is getting recruited by Penn State" when in reality its PSU Harrisburg or Altoona or one of the branches that offer a chance to play there all 4 years.

I had 4 of my baseball players commit to various colleges so far this fall and have another whose father tells people he is getting recruited by PSU, but its really PSU Berks, a not very good D3 program. But because the father tells the story so much and people dont know about the branch campus teams, everyone thinks that his kid is some great player when he probably wont even start as a senior.
My son was not accepted for the main campus and started at Mont Alto for two years.He loved it and did not want to go to the main campus,but had to for his major.Long story short, he received his MS and PHD degrees and started teaching at the US NAVAL ACADEMY.(a school that he would not have been accepted or be ready for at 17 years of age) For some the small schools are needed and not closed.
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
My son was not accepted for the main campus and started at Mont Alto for two years.He loved it and did not want to go to the main campus,but had to for his major.Long story short, he received his MS and PHD degrees and started teaching at the US NAVAL ACADEMY.(a school that he would not have been accepted or be ready for at 17 years of age) For some the small schools are needed and not closed.

I didn't apply to Main Campus; I had only been back in the States for one year of HS and had no idea what to do about college. I took the SATs exactly once. My local PSU branch campus (Beaver) was an excellent option - could live at home, commute daily, and figure things out. It had a very nice college campus feel to it too - decent housing options for students, nice theater/arts spaces (including outdoor amphitheater), DIII baseball/women's volleyball for the kids who didn't want to give up the dream, solid and very active on campus clubs and professional groups, student newspaper, active art/theatre group/courses, and proximity to shopping and good food options. At the time, PSU was playing with these sort of 'Campus Hub' ideas where Beaver was supposed to leverage it's proximity to Pittsburgh and be positioned as a 'School of Communications' hub where, as a COMMS major, you would have access to different experiences with partner companies/agencies. I think it flopped in less than a year. A lot of my friends were COMMS majors (I switched to BUS after my first semester) and they were really disappointed. It was a good idea just poorly executed. They had this Hub idea for other campuses too. I knew a ton of bright kids who are doing very well now who started at Beaver and thought it was a great option for me. Of course, it primarily competed with CCBC, and there were a good number of kids who were from out of state who didn't get into UP. Problem was, at the time, the cost was very similar to UP in terms of tuition (room and board too if you didn't commute) and you clearly were not getting the same experience or access to resources. Think there is a wider gap now but back then it was in the hundreds of dollars/semester. Sad to see these go, but PSU has a spending problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbrown and Bison13

Lion84

All-Conference
Oct 7, 2021
812
1,196
93
This will continue to happen all across the country. Online universities is now a real thing which sounds the death Nell for small campuses. Main campuses will also have to scale back eventually. This is just the benning.....
Funny that they are actually expanding the Main Campus to up Freshman enrollment from 9175 to 10,000 and building more on-campus housing to accommodate the additional students.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rocco3

manatree

All-American
Oct 6, 2021
3,635
6,638
113
Funny that they are actually expanding the Main Campus to up Freshman enrollment from 9175 to 10,000 and building more on-campus housing to accommodate the additional students.

Expanding University Park enrollment is one of the things that Penn State has been very transparent about.
 

Rocco3

Junior
Mar 25, 2022
322
349
63
Funny that they are actually expanding the Main Campus to up Freshman enrollment from 9175 to 10,000 and building more on-campus housing to accommodate the additional students.
Getting ready for the students whose campuses have been closed?
 

bbrown

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
16,168
32,341
113
I didn't apply to Main Campus; I had only been back in the States for one year of HS and had no idea what to do about college. I took the SATs exactly once. My local PSU branch campus (Beaver) was an excellent option - could live at home, commute daily, and figure things out. It had a very nice college campus feel to it too - decent housing options for students, nice theater/arts spaces (including outdoor amphitheater), DIII baseball/women's volleyball for the kids who didn't want to give up the dream, solid and very active on campus clubs and professional groups, student newspaper, active art/theatre group/courses, and proximity to shopping and good food options. At the time, PSU was playing with these sort of 'Campus Hub' ideas where Beaver was supposed to leverage it's proximity to Pittsburgh and be positioned as a 'School of Communications' hub where, as a COMMS major, you would have access to different experiences with partner companies/agencies. I think it flopped in less than a year. A lot of my friends were COMMS majors (I switched to BUS after my first semester) and they were really disappointed. It was a good idea just poorly executed. They had this Hub idea for other campuses too. I knew a ton of bright kids who are doing very well now who started at Beaver and thought it was a great option for me. Of course, it primarily competed with CCBC, and there were a good number of kids who were from out of state who didn't get into UP. Problem was, at the time, the cost was very similar to UP in terms of tuition (room and board too if you didn't commute) and you clearly were not getting the same experience or access to resources. Think there is a wider gap now but back then it was in the hundreds of dollars/semester. Sad to see these go, but PSU has a spending problem.
I fooled around and took my SAT's late and only once. By the time I decided what I wanted to do I could only get into the Altoona Campus for the Winter term.
It worked out well in the end. Made some of my best friends there and got a lot of the BDR's out of the way.
I transferred to Main after 4 terms.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

PSU Mike

All-American
Jul 28, 2001
4,907
8,675
113

PSU Mike

All-American
Jul 28, 2001
4,907
8,675
113
Too lazy to read. Does Penn State own all the land and structures? Is there an estimate of the aggregate liquidation value of the Sayonara Seven?

I kinda wonder(ed) whether York College, under 2 miles from York, will(would) pick up any of the campus.
Ah, found my original question …
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catch1lion

doctornick

All-Conference
Sep 4, 2007
746
1,240
93
Expanding University Park enrollment is one of the things that Penn State has been very transparent about.

Yeah, I really don't understand it. With the demographic cliff occuring (high school graduate numbers are going to be declining due to low birth rates in 2008 and beyond) and more young people simply opting not to attend college there is going to be much fiercer competition to admissions. On top of that you also have fewer international students coming to the USA in recent years.

I don't think a school like PSU is in any impending crisis of needing to close or anything but planning to expand in upmcing years seems like a terrible idea to me. If anything I would try to shrink admission numbers in order to improve the overall competativeness and to try to reduce costs at UP by having a smaller student body to cater to. Going and building a greater number of dorms/buildings in the current climate seems foolish.
 

doctornick

All-Conference
Sep 4, 2007
746
1,240
93
I just read that York College of PA is going to buy the PSU York campus.

Seems like a good outcome. Campus will still exist as an educational opportunity (seems like it will have a specific health care focus?) and gives York College options for growth if they need it. PSU gets a cash infusion and is relieved of the burden of having to operate and upkeep the campus. Students from the York area who want to attend PSU but don't get into main can communite to Harrisburg which is relatively close.

That being said, like other campuses, the price being sold for this campus seems pretty cheap. Unless the buildings are in horrible disrepair, I do wonder why they are not being purchased for millions more.
 

PSUFTG

All-Conference
Nov 1, 2021
2,862
4,090
113
That being said, like other campuses, the price being sold for this campus seems pretty cheap. Unless the buildings are in horrible disrepair, I do wonder why they are not being purchased for millions more.
You (and most people - including, probably, just about every member of the PSU Board) don't know the 1/2 of it.

Alas :rolleyes:
 

Sharkies

Senior
Jun 14, 2013
174
493
53
Seems like a good outcome. Campus will still exist as an educational opportunity (seems like it will have a specific health care focus?) and gives York College options for growth if they need it. PSU gets a cash infusion and is relieved of the burden of having to operate and upkeep the campus. Students from the York area who want to attend PSU but don't get into main can communite to Harrisburg which is relatively close.

That being said, like other campuses, the price being sold for this campus seems pretty cheap. Unless the buildings are in horrible disrepair, I do wonder why they are not being purchased for millions more.
If you google just their student center, Penn State dropped $13.5m on renos to it back in 2015... $20m in inflation adjusted dollars today. Now, selling the whole thing for just $7m??

 

Sharkies

Senior
Jun 14, 2013
174
493
53
If you google just their student center, Penn State dropped $13.5m on renos to it back in 2015... $20m in inflation adjusted dollars today. Now, selling the whole thing for just $7m??

Interestingly... if you google who the contractor was for the reno, it was Alexander Construction Co, part of the Butz Family of Companies...

No surprise these guys are big Penn State benefactors...

 
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13

doctornick

All-Conference
Sep 4, 2007
746
1,240
93
If you google just their student center, Penn State dropped $13.5m on renos to it back in 2015... $20m in inflation adjusted dollars today. Now, selling the whole thing for just $7m??


Exactly. I actually think closing a bunch of Commonwealth campsuses actually makes a lot of sense given the future of higher education. Running many of them for literally a few hundred students at a time is pretty silly and is exactly the type of "cost cutting" that PSU should be doing to reduce their expenses (plenty of other things too though).

But I imaged that they would sell the land (etc) for those campuses for a ton more money. Like 10s of millions. Not a few million for multiple acres with existing buildings. And actually the York campus is the best one. Selling Wilkes-Barre for $5.25M and Shenango for a meesly $1M all seem insanely underpriced.
 

Nitt1300

Heisman
Nov 2, 2008
8,105
15,172
113
Exactly. I actually think closing a bunch of Commonwealth campsuses actually makes a lot of sense given the future of higher education. Running many of them for literally a few hundred students at a time is pretty silly and is exactly the type of "cost cutting" that PSU should be doing to reduce their expenses (plenty of other things too though).

But I imaged that they would sell the land (etc) for those campuses for a ton more money. Like 10s of millions. Not a few million for multiple acres with existing buildings. And actually the York campus is the best one. Selling Wilkes-Barre for $5.25M and Shenango for a meesly $1M all seem insanely underpriced.
Kind of seems like a scene from "Goodfellas", they've made all of the sweetheart deals they can get away with, then burn it all down.
 

Binder74

Senior
Nov 1, 2021
542
929
93
Exactly. I actually think closing a bunch of Commonwealth campsuses actually makes a lot of sense given the future of higher education. Running many of them for literally a few hundred students at a time is pretty silly and is exactly the type of "cost cutting" that PSU should be doing to reduce their expenses (plenty of other things too though).

But I imaged that they would sell the land (etc) for those campuses for a ton more money. Like 10s of millions. Not a few million for multiple acres with existing buildings. And actually the York campus is the best one. Selling Wilkes-Barre for $5.25M and Shenango for a meesly $1M all seem insanely underpriced.
I guess it's a buyer's market for PSU branch campuses.
 

PSU Mike

All-American
Jul 28, 2001
4,907
8,675
113
Seems like a good outcome. Campus will still exist as an educational opportunity (seems like it will have a specific health care focus?) and gives York College options for growth if they need it. PSU gets a cash infusion and is relieved of the burden of having to operate and upkeep the campus. Students from the York area who want to attend PSU but don't get into main can communite to Harrisburg which is relatively close.

That being said, like other campuses, the price being sold for this campus seems pretty cheap. Unless the buildings are in horrible disrepair, I do wonder why they are not being purchased for millions more.
Is the Pullo Center being included in the purchase? That alone cost $11.9MM to build.
 
May 11, 2012
508
703
93
The Branch Campuses were losing 50 million dollars a year, how did it take them so long to close some of them down? 10 years would be half a billion dollars-shut them down. So out of touch.
It seems with the numerous online opportunities, branch campuses are becoming obsolete. As a Land Grant University offering affordable education to individuals is required? I believe i agree with the proposal to keep some of the larger local campuses...but offer a curriculum similar to the Community College experience. The local satellite campuses should focus on entry into PSU Main with successful completion of 2 semesters....and limit the course selections to popular main degrees.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psuno1

DELion

Senior
May 23, 2020
365
758
93
Exactly. I actually think closing a bunch of Commonwealth campsuses actually makes a lot of sense given the future of higher education. Running many of them for literally a few hundred students at a time is pretty silly and is exactly the type of "cost cutting" that PSU should be doing to reduce their expenses (plenty of other things too though).

But I imaged that they would sell the land (etc) for those campuses for a ton more money. Like 10s of millions. Not a few million for multiple acres with existing buildings. And actually the York campus is the best one. Selling Wilkes-Barre for $5.25M and Shenango for a meesly $1M all seem insanely underpriced.
The PSU York campus is a little over 50 acres. The land alone is probably worth the sale price. PSU was not exactly in a strong bargaining position for this transaction. They would have ongoing carrying costs to maintain the buildings and grounds if they didn't dump the property.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State TE Benjamin Brahmer announces he'll return for the 2027 season
  2. 02 BWI Football Penn State Transfer Portal Preview: Four Potential Quarterback Targets to Know for 2027
  3. 03 BWI Football Trimmings: Penn State's Senior Day list and what we're hearing on those who could come back for 2027
  4. 04 BWI Basketball Penn State set to add international point guard Savo Drezgic
  5. 05 BWI Football Matt Campbell says Penn State became a real team, now wants to prove it for 60 minutes