Beamer vs Spurrier: first 72 games

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
I contend that his 2nd season ('06 @ 8-5) was successful. We had some glaring personnel weaknesses, but that team closed with 3 straight wins including beating the favored taters. It not how you start, but how you finish.

I agree, his second season was a good one. Beamer's second season was actually slightly more successful, though. He was also 8-5, but a game better in SEC play at 4-4 vs 3-5 for SOS. Their 3rd seasons were not much different either 6-6 (3-5) for SOS vs 5-7 (3-5) for Beamer. Beamer got to 9 wins in year 4, where it took SOS until Year 6. Really, the only blemish compared to SOS in the first 6 years is last year's 4-8 disaster.

None of this is to suggest that Beamer is better than SOS, but for a rookie head coach, his accomplishments thus far have been roughly on par with a seasoned, title winning veteran.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Go Gamecocks

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
Infuriating! One of their young assistants figured out which plays we were going to run by watch film & doing his own stats. :mad:

Yeah. That was a game I figured we had in the bag. I was totally relaxed. All my snacks laid out. Just ready to enjoy seeing us waltz passed UConn. I mean, it was UConn. Just a dismal, dismal day.
 

Go Gamecocks

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2021
1,884
1,558
113
None of this is to suggest that Beamer is better than SOS, but for a rookie head coach, his accomplishments thus far have been roughly on par with a seasoned, title winning veteran.
I don't think Shane has struggled with OL issues like Steve did, with some of that being Steve's own doing.
Back in those days, you had to recruit 6-7 OL every year in hopes 1 or 2 would work out. Steve was not without his blind spots.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
I don't think Shane has struggled with OL issues like Steve did, with some of that being Steve's own doing.
Back in those days, you had to recruit 6-7 OL every year in hopes 1 or 2 would work out. Steve was not without his blind spots.
I loved SOS, but when fans think of him here, they only think of the 11-win seasons. It was a pretty slow start. He was 7-6 (3-5) in Year 5. I mean, that's good enough by our historical standards, but nothing to get excited about. The only thing that gave excitement was that UF and UT were slumping, so we started mixing in some wins there, which was a novelty. And there was the tease that SOS would eventually get his offense going here, which never really transpired. Our best teams were defense-first.

He started 1-4 in bowl games. Had the infamous 5-game losing streak after we were ranked in the top 10. He's the only coach to lose consecutive games to Vandy. We went through an OL spell so bad that he had to start pulling players from games if they got a false start. He had a losing conference record through 6 seasons. 5 out of 11 seasons he had a losing conference record.

Just pointing out that things weren't all as great as some fans remember. Frankly, people dump on Beamer having the job only b/c of his name, but if it wasn't for Spurrier's name, fans would have plenty antsy after 5 years of mediocre results.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
I loved SOS, but when fans think of him here, they only think of the 11-win seasons. It was a pretty slow start. He was 7-6 (3-5) in Year 5. I mean, that's good enough by our historical standards, but nothing to get excited about. The only thing that gave excitement was that UF and UT were slumping, so we started mixing in some wins there, which was a novelty. And there was the tease that SOS would eventually get his offense going here, which never really transpired. Our best teams were defense-first.

He started 1-4 in bowl games. Had the infamous 5-game losing streak after we were ranked in the top 10. He's the only coach to lose consecutive games to Vandy. We went through an OL spell so bad that he had to start pulling players from games if they got a false start. He had a losing conference record through 6 seasons. 5 out of 11 seasons he had a losing conference record.

Just pointing out that things weren't all as great as some fans remember. Frankly, people dump on Beamer having the job only b/c of his name, but if it wasn't for Spurrier's name, fans would have plenty antsy after 5 years of mediocre results.


Okay, this the point I think some people, including myself are trying to make.

Spurrier had an awesome career, but his first handful of seasons here were "nothing to get excited about" as you said.

The issue comes in with the comparison. If we were honest, we'd say that Beamer (and Muschamp before him) kept pace with the early years of Spurrier, which was pretty much his worst 5/6 year run.

They compare with him at his worst, not in least do they compare with Spurrier overall.

Does that make sense 18, or am I not articulating it well? When this comparison was first thrown around with Muschamp and then Beamer, it was something like "Spurrier is a HOF coach, and this guy is doing just as well as him". That is what i object to. They aren't doing as well as Spurrier, they are doing as well as Spurrier at his worst.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
Just pointing out that things weren't all as great as some fans remember. Frankly, people dump on Beamer having the job only b/c of his name, but if it wasn't for Spurrier's name, fans would have plenty antsy after 5 years of mediocre results.

Wanted to separate this. But going off my memory, fwiw, I do remember a lot of angst around this time of Spurrier's run. Part of it was Spurrier's history. A lot of people thought they were hiring the fun'n'gun guy. What did we call it on the boards? The cock'n'fire offense. And a lot of people were looking around saying "this is it?"
 

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,874
3,739
113
Spurrier dealt with an overall weak SEC East
Im not sure why this idea has suddenly become popular among Gamecock fans to diminish Spurrier's accomplishments here.

In 2011, UGA went 7-1 in the conference (losing only to us before losing the SECCG)

In 2012, both UGA and Florida went 7-1 in the conference. Georgia finished that season 12-2, losing only to us and to eventual national champion Bama by 4 in an SECCG that ended with UGA inside the Bama 5 yard line.

In 2013, Missouri went 7-1 in the conference, losing only to us.

It's true that Beamer has faced some brutal schedules in the conference, especially since the entire conference's schedule has gotten more difficult with the arrival of TX and OU, but Spurrier's good teams at Carolina were legitimately good, no asterisks needed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
Im not sure why this idea has suddenly become popular among Gamecock fans to diminish Spurrier's accomplishments here.

In 2011, UGA went 7-1 in the conference (losing only to us before losing the SECCG)

In 2012, both UGA and Florida went 7-1 in the conference. Georgia finished that season 12-2, losing only to us and to eventual national champion Bama by 4 in an SECCG that ended with UGA inside the Bama 5 yard line.

In 2013, Missouri went 7-1 in the conference, losing only to us.

It's true that Beamer has faced some brutal schedules in the conference, especially since the entire conference's schedule has gotten more difficult with the arrival of TX and OU, but Spurrier's good teams at Carolina were legitimately good, no asterisks needed.

The SEC East was very weak overall during that time. SEC West was strong. I've posted the figures before. I'm not trying to diminish -- it was just a fact.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
Okay, this the point I think some people, including myself are trying to make.

Spurrier had an awesome career, but his first handful of seasons here were "nothing to get excited about" as you said.

The issue comes in with the comparison. If we were honest, we'd say that Beamer (and Muschamp before him) kept pace with the early years of Spurrier, which was pretty much his worst 5/6 year run.

They compare with him at his worst, not in least do they compare with Spurrier overall.

Does that make sense 18, or am I not articulating it well? When this comparison was first thrown around with Muschamp and then Beamer, it was something like "Spurrier is a HOF coach, and this guy is doing just as well as him". That is what i object to. They aren't doing as well as Spurrier, they are doing as well as Spurrier at his worst.
Yeah, that all makes sense.

Here's my thinking, though. Spurrier came in as a 17-year coaching veteran, national title winner, 8x SECE champ, 6x SEC champ, 7x SEC coach of the year, sure-fire first ballot HOFer. Beamer came in with 0 years of head coaching experience, and not even coordinator experience. And he's fared about as well up this point in his career compared to SOS. SOS had all the credentials and experience to be successful from Day 1. Beamer, as many have pointed out, has been learning on the job. But there's not much that distinguishes one from the other, record-wise.

All we can do is judge them based on a comparable time period. Things didn't really hit for SOS until Year 7. But we can't judge Beamer on a Year 7 yet.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
Okay, this the point I think some people, including myself are trying to make.

Spurrier had an awesome career, but his first handful of seasons here were "nothing to get excited about" as you said.

The issue comes in with the comparison. If we were honest, we'd say that Beamer (and Muschamp before him) kept pace with the early years of Spurrier, which was pretty much his worst 5/6 year run.

They compare with him at his worst, not in least do they compare with Spurrier overall.

Does that make sense 18, or am I not articulating it well? When this comparison was first thrown around with Muschamp and then Beamer, it was something like "Spurrier is a HOF coach, and this guy is doing just as well as him". That is what i object to. They aren't doing as well as Spurrier, they are doing as well as Spurrier at his worst.

Botman will talk about this same subject with his BOTs to the end of the earth and never reference recruiting which 90%+ success is pegged to. This is what trolling looks like.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
Botman will talk about this same subject with his BOTs to the end of the earth and never reference recruiting which 90%+ success is pegged to. This is what trolling looks like.
Yes, it is a totally different recruiting landscape now than when SOS was coaching. SOS never had to deal with anything like rebuilding your roster every single year. Accounting for player attrition through the portal.

High school recruiting is now just one small piece of the puzzle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
Yeah, that all makes sense.

Here's my thinking, though. Spurrier came in as a 17-year coaching veteran, national title winner, 8x SECE champ, 6x SEC champ, 7x SEC coach of the year, sure-fire first ballot HOFer. Beamer came in with 0 years of head coaching experience, and not even coordinator experience. And he's fared about as well up this point in his career compared to SOS. SOS had all the credentials and experience to be successful from Day 1. Beamer, as many have pointed out, has been learning on the job. But there's not much that distinguishes one from the other, record-wise.

All we can do is judge them based on a comparable time period. Things didn't really hit for SOS until Year 7. But we can't judge Beamer on a Year 7 yet.

Beamer and Muschamp got about the same start as Spurrier, I agree. I'm coming from the angle that it isn't a thing to brag about.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
Beamer and Muschamp got about the same start as Spurrier, I agree. I'm coming from the angle that it isn't a thing to brag about.

I concur. Some, though, paint Beamer as a complete and utter disaster as a head coach. Objectively, he hasn't been. It hasn't been a roaring success, but no coach here has ever been a roaring success.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
I concur. Some, though, paint Beamer as a complete and utter disaster as a head coach. Objectively, he hasn't been. It hasn't been a roaring success, but no coach here has ever been a roaring success.

Agreed. Not an utter disaster. Wildly inconsistent with dizzying highs sandwiched between losing seasons.....etc
 

Swifty

Junior
Jan 21, 2022
404
338
53
I contend that his 2nd season ('06 @ 8-5) was successful. We had some glaring personnel weaknesses, but that team closed with 3 straight wins including beating the favored taters. It not how you start, but how you finish.
Three of those losses were by 7 or less to teams I believe were all ranked in the Top 10 at the time, also. What I meant by 2010 being his first successful season was winning the East. Of course he followed that with the three straight 11-2 seasons.
 

Go Gamecocks

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2021
1,884
1,558
113
Three of those losses were by 7 or less to teams I believe were all ranked in the Top 10 at the time, also.
And if you remember, shortly after we won that bowl game v UH, Steve proclaimed we were going to "challenge for the SEC".
His confidence was up at that time, with his entire starting backfield coming back. Then within a short time Rice declared for the NFL. That hurt us. Rice was exception in the HBC's offense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski

Swifty

Junior
Jan 21, 2022
404
338
53
And if you remember, shortly after we won that bowl game v UH, Steve proclaimed we were going to "challenge for the SEC".
His confidence was up at that time, with his entire starting backfield coming back. Then within a short time Rice declared for the NFL. That hurt us. Rice was exception in the HBC's offense.
Yep and we had Garcia coming in and Smelley was so highly rated. Boyd, Davis in the backfield, Cook and McKinley. 6-1, whooped Kentucky on a Thursday night and then went poopy in the jock straps the last five games.
 

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,874
3,739
113
Agreed. Not an utter disaster. Wildly inconsistent with dizzying highs sandwiched between losing seasons.....etc
Yes, it's somewhat maddening. I'm sure its not unprecedented, but I can't think of another coach off the top of my head who has had the good-year/bad-year alternating pattern. And the good years all had slow starts! Lol.

But as I said in another thread, the 24-team playoff era changes the paradigm of what it means to have a good/great college football season. And I'm thinking it may play well into Beamer's pattern. Teams who finish the season playing as well as anybody in the country may be well poised to make a playoff run, despite losing 3 games earlier in the season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
Yes, it's somewhat maddening. I'm sure its not unprecedented, but I can't think of another coach off the top of my head who has had the good-year/bad-year alternating pattern. And the good years all had slow starts! Lol.

But as I said in another thread, the 24-team playoff era changes the paradigm of what it means to have a good/great college football season. And I'm thinking it may play well into Beamer's pattern. Teams who finish the season playing as well as anybody in the country may be well poised to make a playoff run, despite losing 3 games earlier in the season.
It's because he's the first coach to deal with the NIL. Our NIL contributations started off weak but are improving so hopefully you'll see more consistency moving forward.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
Agreed. Not an utter disaster. Wildly inconsistent with dizzying highs sandwiched between losing seasons.....etc

In case there was any doubt this is a troll account.

One game separates them:

Spurrier: 40-32
Beamer: 39-33

Whether he's trolling about Beamer, the WNBA, etc -- it's best not to waste time with this frog.

I will enjoy watching him have to eat the upcoming extension.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
In case there was any doubt this is a troll account.

One game separates them:

Spurrier: 40-32
Beamer: 39-33

Whether he's trolling about Beamer, the WNBA, etc -- it's best not to waste time with this frog.

I will enjoy watching him have to eat the upcoming extension.
How is it trolling to merely point out that Beamer hasn't been as bad as some posters like to claim?
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
We got Spurrier when he was past his prime. During that 3-year Top 10 stretch, we were respected nationally.

We are getting Beamer around his prime.
 
Mar 29, 2012
147
156
43
I don't think Shane has struggled with OL issues like Steve did, with some of that being Steve's own doing.
Back in those days, you had to recruit 6-7 OL every year in hopes 1 or 2 would work out. Steve was not without his blind spots.
both Beamer and Spurrier have struggled with ****** oline coaches. Spurrier had John Hunt and Eric Wolford from 2005-2009. Beamer had Greg Adkins and Lonnie Teasley from 2021 to 2025.

Beamer keeping Teasley after the 2023 season almost cost him his job.

We finally have a decent offensive line this year, and that started with having most of the starters from last year transfer out of the program. Randy Clements deserves as much credit for our offensive turnaround as Kendal Briles.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
both Beamer and Spurrier have struggled with ****** oline coaches. Spurrier had John Hunt and Eric Wolford from 2005-2009. Beamer had Greg Adkins and Lonnie Teasley from 2021 to 2025.

Beamer keeping Teasley after the 2023 season almost cost him his job.

We finally have a decent offensive line this year, and that started with having most of the starters from last year transfer out of the program. Randy Clements deserves as much credit for our offensive turnaround as Kendal Briles.
He's been worth his weight in gold?
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
both Beamer and Spurrier have struggled with ****** oline coaches. Spurrier had John Hunt and Eric Wolford from 2005-2009. Beamer had Greg Adkins and Lonnie Teasley from 2021 to 2025.

Beamer keeping Teasley after the 2023 season almost cost him his job.

We finally have a decent offensive line this year, and that started with having most of the starters from last year transfer out of the program. Randy Clements deserves as much credit for our offensive turnaround as Kendal Briles.
What you say about Clements is true. But, I also credit Briles for bringing him to SC. Obviously, Briles has an eye for coaching talent, which will be a huge plus when he becomes a Head Coach.
 

SouthernBelly

Senior
Sep 16, 2024
1,050
799
113
What you say about Clements is true. But, I also credit Briles for bringing him to SC. Obviously, Briles has an eye for coaching talent, which will be a huge plus when he becomes a Head Coach.
It’s assumed Briles will be a head coach somewhere. I’m assuming he would try to tale Clements with him. I hope this is already on Beamer & Donati’s minds.
 

Go Gamecocks

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2021
1,884
1,558
113
both Beamer and Spurrier have struggled with ****** oline coaches. Spurrier had John Hunt and Eric Wolford from 2005-2009. Beamer had Greg Adkins and Lonnie Teasley from 2021 to 2025.

Beamer keeping Teasley after the 2023 season almost cost him his job.

We finally have a decent offensive line this year, and that started with having most of the starters from last year transfer out of the program. Randy Clements deserves as much credit for our offensive turnaround as Kendal Briles.
Wolfie was a good coach for us and made a big impact.

Steve's earlier problems came a lot from poor OL recruiting & holding on to Hunt.
Just take a look at '07. A highly rated class with only 2 OL...and neither became starters. 😒
You can't build a program without the bodies.

In contrast, Shane brought in 9 brand new & experienced OL via the portal this past season.
That's 2 incoming FR ('07) v. 9 ('26) experienced OL that they have film on.
8 out of 10 of our current 2 deep are transfers.
Steve never had anything like this to work with and neither did anyone else in that era. Indiana is the poster child for what's changed.

I'm delighted we have Clements, but recruiting transfers has to be given some credit as well.

 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
It’s assumed Briles will be a head coach somewhere. I’m assuming he would try to tale Clements with him. I hope this is already on Beamer & Donati’s minds.
He has such an established track record as OC that his last name is probably the only reason he hasn't been giving a HC shot yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
He has such an established track record as OC that his last name is probably the only reason he hasn't been giving a HC shot yet.

He's gotten more attention here than at his last couple of stops. I would think that when he leaves here, whenever that is, its for a HC job.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock
Mar 29, 2012
147
156
43
Wolfie was a good coach for us and made a big impact.
Its hard to say if he was a good coach or not since he was only there one year and roster building was drastically different from what it is today. The 2010 recruiting class he was credited with bringing in some starters like AJ Cann, Corey Robinson, and Ronald Patrick.

If you look at the conference rankings by offensive category I think you see an improvement in offensive output that would correlate with Shawn Elliot being a much better offensive line coach:

2007 South Carolina with John Hunt as offensive line coach
  • 8th in points per game
  • 12 in rushing yards
  • 3rd in passing yards
  • 8th in total yards
2008 South Carolina during John Hunt's last year as offensive line coach
  • 8th in points per game
  • 12th in rushing yards
  • 3rd in passing yards
  • 7th in total yards
2009 South Carolina with Wolford as offensive line coach:
  • 11th in the conference in points per game
  • 12th in Rushing
  • 4th in passing
  • 9th in total yards
2010 South Carolina with Shawn Elliot as offensive line coach
  • 6th in points per game
  • 8th in rushing
  • 6th in passing
  • 7th in total yards
2011 South Carolina with Shawn Elliot as offensive line coach
  • 5th in points per game
  • 3rd in rushing
  • 7th in pasing
  • 4th in total yards
With Wolford as oline coach, to me the numbers say slight decrease in points per game overall, but pretty similar in other results to when John Hunt was the o line coach. When Shawn Elliot came in the offense output became more balanced between running and passing and the overall points per game and total yards improved signaling a better overall offense.
 

Go Gamecocks

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2021
1,884
1,558
113
With Wolford as oline coach, to me the numbers say slight decrease in points per game overall, but pretty similar in other results to when John Hunt was the o line coach. When Shawn Elliot came in the offense output became more balanced between running and passing and the overall points per game and total yards improved signaling a better overall offense.
But Wolfie was using Hunt's recruits. OL recruits take 2-3 seasons to develop. With transfers, you can get immediate results. What were Wolfie's stats when he was here from '17-'20? He's currently Kiffen's OL coach @ LSU & was Saban's OL coach @ Bama - Saban's last 2 seasons.

The improvements in stats for '10 shows the influence of Lattimore and integrating the zone blocking/running game.
Credit goes back to Steve Spurrier for adding this to his offense. Shawn Elliott and G.A. Mangus are the main influencers of this.
Steve would have never went with a dual threat QB until he was forced to evolve. Connor Shaw was Mangus' recruit.

And maybe even Hunt's OL would have done much better with a different scheme? I saw some clips of Cory Boyd tearing up the CFL with zone running plays. One has to wonder what could have been.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 GamecockCentral Football Details you may have missed: South Carolina vs. Arkansas
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Football Insider Mailbag Vol. 12: Briles and Sellers, what's next for South Carolina
  3. 03 GamecockCentral Football South Carolina remains in College Football Playoff rankings after Arkansas loss
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Womens Basketball Photos: Gamecocks roll past FGCU in home opener
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Womens Basketball South Carolina women's basketball: Rapid Reaction - FGCU