How many times in the next 10 years should Penn State make the 24-team playoff?

PSUFTG

All-Conference
Nov 1, 2021
2,861
4,083
113
Well, in the last 10 years Franklin coached at PSU:

PSU would have made the "playoffs" :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: 7 out of the 9 full seasons (not counting COVID year of 2020)


That was - obviously - an unacceptable performance - and neither the "excellence at the highest level" promised by Brozo, nor the expectations that PSU fans should be satisfied with.

So (let's do the math, 7 out of 9, carry the 1, divide and round off...... LionJim can check the math) something MORE than 78% of the time.

So lets round off and say that it would have to be MORE than 80% of the time.
Fair enough?
 

SkiSkiSki

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
4,030
1,632
113
Well, in the last 10 years Franklin coached at PSU:

PSU would have made the "playoffs" :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: 7 out of the 9 full seasons (not counting COVID year of 2020)


That was - obviously - an unacceptable performance - and neither the "excellence at the highest level" promised by Brozo, nor the expectations that PSU fans should be satisfied with.

So (let's do the math, 7 out of 9, carry the 1, divide and round off...... LionJim can check the math) something MORE than 78% of the time.

So lets round off and say that it would have to be MORE than 80% of the time.
Fair enough?
How many of those hypothetical 7 seasons would PSU under Coach "Mike Tomlin" Franklin have made it out of the first round? One for sure where the matchups were favorable. Any others?
 

LionJim

Heisman
Oct 12, 2021
16,854
23,139
113
Well, in the last 10 years Franklin coached at PSU:

PSU would have made the "playoffs" :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: 7 out of the 9 full seasons (not counting COVID year of 2020)


That was - obviously - an unacceptable performance - and neither the "excellence at the highest level" promised by Brozo, nor the expectations that PSU fans should be satisfied with.

So (let's do the math, 7 out of 9, carry the 1, divide and round off...... LionJim can check the math) something MORE than 78% of the time.

So lets round off and say that it would have to be MORE than 80% of the time.
Fair enough?
7 out of 9 is .777777…., rounded up is 78%, so a little less than 78%.

Fun math fact: .999999999… is equal to 1. (If you need convincing, assume that they are not equal, then you’d have to find some number in between those two, a little thought will lead you to conclude that this cannot be done.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bob78

Erial_Lion

All-American
Nov 1, 2021
4,451
5,263
113
This is a fun exercise if the only goal is to make the playoffs. But my goal of winning a National Title trumps any goals around the % of time we make the playoffs. I've been a fan for enough seasons where we had a really good team, but not the best team.

The Florida Marlins have made the playoffs 4 times in the last 32 seasons. The Cleveland Guardians have made it 16 times. Would I rather make the playoffs 50% of the time, or 13% of the time? I guess 13%, since I'd rather be the team with 2 titles. And I'll take my chances with our current coach over the former one.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
3,434
3,350
113
This is a fun exercise if the only goal is to make the playoffs. But my goal of winning a National Title trumps any goals around the % of time we make the playoffs. I've been a fan for enough seasons where we had a really good team, but not the best team.

The Florida Marlins have made the playoffs 4 times in the last 32 seasons. The Cleveland Guardians have made it 16 times. Would I rather make the playoffs 50% of the time, or 13% of the time? I guess 13%, since I'd rather be the team with 2 titles. And I'll take my chances with our current coach over the former one.
Yeah because Campbell is killing it this year.
 
  • Love
Reactions: saturdaysarebetter

ApexLion

Heisman
Nov 1, 2021
6,590
11,115
113
8 of 10 playoff years with Franklin, with 6 soul crushing losses to well coached teams. Two other losses to poorly coached teams. Obviously.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catch1lion

PSUFTG

All-Conference
Nov 1, 2021
2,861
4,083
113
How many of those hypothetical 7 seasons would PSU under Coach "Mike Tomlin" Franklin have made it out of the first round? One for sure where the matchups were favorable. Any others?
The question was wrt a "24 Team Playoff".

Unless I "Rip Van Winkle-ed" - we have never had one of those play out.
So there is no way to even begin to approach such a question
 

wptlion

Freshman
Jan 7, 2002
81
81
18
The problem is Franklin shot his load and lost last year. The talent level was depleted....so if Franklin was still here we'd be in the same boat. With a 24 team playoff this team might be just 1 win short of making it. (notice I said MIGHT BE)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chumboshifko1

psuro

Heisman
Aug 24, 2001
9,923
21,800
113
I had a post on another thread (since buried) where I made my predictions on how often PSU (and other teams) would make the CFP with 24 teams.

The breakdown was 100%/75%/50%/25% and "once in a while".

I had PSU at 75% and I am sticking by that.
I also had USC and Indiana in that category (because Cignetti has been there such a short time, and I would like to see a greater body of work to elevate them). There were others, (Oklahoma was one).

Programs that I had at 100% include
OSU, Alabama, Georgia, Oregon, Notre Dame. There might have been a couple of others, but cannot recall which ones.

I wish I could find that particular post or recall which thread it was under.
 

Blair10

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
2,164
4,610
113
Ah, another highly realistic person.

You have asked posters to respond to your hypothetical question. Some did so respectfully. They should receive equally respectful replies even if you disagree with them. Otherwise, people will not respond to your question.

I agree with poster WDLion. The 24 team format is essentially taking CFB back to the old bowl system where even bad teams qualified. There are simply never 24 very good teams in a single year. There is no reason for a program of Penn State’s stature to miss qualifying for the playoffs in a 24 team format. To miss a 24-team playoff implies the football team is beyond bad and the coach is about to be fired.
 
Last edited:

Nitt1300

Heisman
Nov 2, 2008
8,096
15,148
113
7 out of 9 is .777777…., rounded up is 78%, so a little less than 78%.

Fun math fact: .999999999… is equal to 1. (If you need convincing, assume that they are not equal, then you’d have to find some number in between those two, a little thought will lead you to conclude that this cannot be done.)
fun fact- math isn't fun
Danica McKellar is
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: Fac and LionJim

MtNittany

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
4,167
5,765
113
This is a fun exercise if the only goal is to make the playoffs. But my goal of winning a National Title trumps any goals around the % of time we make the playoffs. I've been a fan for enough seasons where we had a really good team, but not the best team.

The Florida Marlins have made the playoffs 4 times in the last 32 seasons. The Cleveland Guardians have made it 16 times. Would I rather make the playoffs 50% of the time, or 13% of the time? I guess 13%, since I'd rather be the team with 2 titles. And I'll take my chances with our current coach over the former one.
2003 I was there in "Beer an Inning Park" (as we called Joe Robbie) for game 4 and Alex Gonzalez's home run. It's lightning in a bottle for any fan base, but for the Fish, that was an amazing night. I can honestly say it was more exciting than any PSU game I've been to, and I've been to a lot. Something about playoff/extra inning baseball that stops your breathing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Erial_Lion

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,183
4,797
113
6...parity is here to stay
The objective is to make runs when you make it because of skill...not because you were handed the easiest draw in the history of sports.
 

saturdaysarebetter

All-Conference
Jun 19, 2018
1,075
1,532
131
You have asked posters to respond to your hypothetical question. Some did so respectfully. They should receive equally respectful replies even if you disagree with them. Otherwise, people will not respond to your question.

I agree with poster WDLion. The 24 team format is essentially taking CFB back to the old bowl system where even bad teams qualified. There are simply never 24 very good teams in a single year. There is no reason for a program of Penn State’s stature to miss qualifying for the playoffs in a 24 team format. To miss a 24-team playoff implies the football team is beyond bad and the coach is about to be fired.
As recently as last year come to think of it. So it could happen.
 

1995PSUGrad

All-Conference
Nov 16, 2019
848
1,259
93
Highly realistic. Fire Campbell the first year he fails.
You can react however you want to react, but I don't think it's unrealistic to think that we should be a top 20 team every year and without knowing all of the in's and out's of who will get in and and who won't, that should just about get you into the 24 team field. And no, I am not one of the "fire the coach" posters on this board just because things don't go the way we want or think they should.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
837
921
93
This is a fun exercise if the only goal is to make the playoffs. But my goal of winning a National Title trumps any goals around the % of time we make the playoffs. I've been a fan for enough seasons where we had a really good team, but not the best team.

The Florida Marlins have made the playoffs 4 times in the last 32 seasons. The Cleveland Guardians have made it 16 times. Would I rather make the playoffs 50% of the time, or 13% of the time? I guess 13%, since I'd rather be the team with 2 titles. And I'll take my chances with our current coach over the former one.
So how many times in ten years should PSU win the natty, and is the a number they need to make the playoffs on top of that, or is one playoff acceptable if the go all the way?
 

saturdaysarebetter

All-Conference
Jun 19, 2018
1,075
1,532
131
You can react however you want to react, but I don't think it's unrealistic to think that we should be a top 20 team every year and without knowing all of the in's and out's of who will get in and and who won't, that should just about get you into the 24 team field. And no, I am not one of the "fire the coach" posters on this board just because things don't go the way we want or think they should.
You do know that Paterno had quite a few years that Penn State wouldn't have made the 24-team playoff. 14 of his first 45 seasons (didn't count 2011) Penn State didn't finish in the top 20. Nearly 33% he failed to finish in the top 20, and "fans, make that delusional idiots," think Penn State should finish in 24-team playoff every year.
 

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,119
5,806
113
Making the playoffs is for losers. Here at Paterno State, we don't settle for losers ... we deserve better. Natties every year or GTFO. Big Game Hunters only need apply. 5-4 against a bunch of nobodies is where you'll find those who wee excellence and demand the same from others.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Wrestling Penn State wrestling beats Oklahoma 41-0 to earn its first shut out of the year: Recap
  2. 02 BWI Basketball Penn State basketball cruises past New Haven behind complete effort
  3. 03 Rivals Football Recruiting Penn State offer puts Nittany Lions in strong position with DB Carlos Gordon
  4. 04 BWI Football Penn State notebook: Carson Hansen’s big night, Alex Manske’s opportunity and more
  5. 05 BWI Wrestling How to watch, follow, Penn State wrestling at Oklahoma on Sunday: New start time and streaming info, probable lineups, more