At what point does keeping Lebby become financially counterproductive in portal recruiting?

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,824
8,259
113
Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon understand that.
 

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,967
3,191
113
Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon understand that.
The problem is it doesn't matter. Lebby has proven he sucks at player eval and recruiting. You could give him 80 million in NIL and I believe he would still whiff.
 

RiceDawg

Sophomore
Aug 13, 2017
386
194
43
Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon understand that.
The answer is Kamario Taylor
 

ckDOG

All-American
Dec 11, 2007
10,556
7,033
113
Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon understand that.
If the statements that we spent good money this year on our roster are true, then we've long passed that point. We look like sunbelt talent without Kamario leading the offense.
 
Last edited:

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,674
13,490
113
So, literally nothing will change with our current roster profile if we keep Lebby?

I agree. Is anyone OK with that?
Well, it's not complete unchanged. Literally the whole thing will be back and one year older save for these:

Cannon Boone
Will Whitson
Jaray Bledsoe
Jardin Gilbert
Marcus Williams

I think you also have to assume Kelley Jones is gone.

I think it's safe to assume that if you are bringing 16 starters back, you'll get a little better. Age is huge in football, especially on the OL.

But either way I still don't think we have the name cache, even with Taylor, to sign any big stars. Need to hope to get 'solid'.
 

civildawg88

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
2,896
1,904
102
If the statements that we spent good money this year on our roster then we've long passed that point. We look like sunbelt talent without Kamario leading the offense.
Can you imagine being a big time booster and spending millions on a roster and thinking Jeff Lebby is the man to lead that roster? I thought rich people were smart, but I digress
 

The Cooterpoot

Heisman
Sep 29, 2022
7,723
13,517
113
Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon understand that.
We didn't keep Lebby to save money, & we've got a huge amount of money to spend and we'll get guys we couldn't in the past.
 

GiantInternetAsshole

All-Conference
Sep 22, 2026
1,203
1,111
113
That's two, plus you. How about all the empty seats this season and the ones that will be empty next season. You ok w/ that?
Hell no I’m not lol. I want Lebby gone more than most and wanted him gone after last season. I referenced this in another thread, but there are several in my group that are not renewing season tickets even after the KT announcement because Jeff Lebby’s still head coach.

We’ve mortgaged the future of the cash cow of our athletic department and the biggest advertising billboard for the university on 1 year with a generational talent and a coach that isn’t capable of competing at a high level in this league without having generational talent on the roster.
 

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,824
8,259
113
The problem is it doesn't matter. Lebby has proven he sucks at player eval and recruiting. You could give him 80 million in NIL and I believe he would still whiff.
I think it’s impossible to know how much is Lebby whiffing, vs. how much of it is that we couldn’t afford who we really wanted. We don’t really know if who we wound up with were our first, second, or third choices (or lower). But the key thing is that there really isn’t much recruiting anymore. You rank who you want in some order, and hope that you can afford the ones higher up on the list.

Obviously, we were in the game and were allegedly the runner-up for the Colorado LT that went to LSU. Nobody thinks that was a bad pursuit. The back-up QB’s? Now those were definitely mistakes this year. But was Kromenhoek really that bad of a pull last year, considering he was the 3rd QB? I don’t really think so. Fluff was a great pull. And we seem to be batting 1.000 on WR’s.

But as far as OL/DL, those are the most expensive positions outside of QB. You need a lot of good ones. If you’re even just 1.5 deep with SEC talent, that’s 12-13 total that you need, and in our case I don’t think we have even 3 on campus right now who will be here next year. So we need like 10.

The underlying problem is the cycle of losing making it more expensive to eventually win, unless you make a change at HC. It’s his own doing, but Lebby is not giving himself much of a chance in the portal with our budget, even if his evaluations are perfect. There’s only one way to remedy that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 60sdog

Howiefeltersnstch

All-Conference
Dec 28, 2019
3,218
3,934
98
I have not read anywhere or heard anywhere that we were keeping Lebby to save the buyout money, except a few people here. He has a pretty low buyout so if we cant afford that its a pitiful situation. I think.the administration has faith in him and believes he needs more pieces. Obviously if K1 had not got hurt nobody would be crying about Lebby. Obviously he screwed up the backup QB situation but he will be here a couple more years minimum. Also Loadholt aint getting fired this year either.
 

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,520
3,096
113
I have not read anywhere or heard anywhere that we were keeping Lebby to save the buyout money, except a few people here. He has a pretty low buyout so if we cant afford that its a pitiful situation. I think.the administration has faith in him and believes he needs more pieces. Obviously if K1 had not got hurt nobody would be crying about Lebby. Obviously he screwed up the backup QB situation but he will be here a couple more years minimum. Also Loadholt aint getting fired this year either.
I think I’m going to go stick my head in the oven. 🤦
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,864
3,327
113
Obviously if K1 had not got hurt nobody would be crying about Lebby.
That really depends on what our record was with a healthy KT. I think we would have gone 0 for October, with at least one of those losses directly caused by Lebby being a bonehead. So, yeah, we WOULD still be pitching about Lebby.

And when K1 gets hurt in the middle of next season?
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

Called3rdstrikedawg

All-Conference
May 7, 2016
2,693
2,331
113
If the statements that we spent good money this year on our roster are true, then we've long passed that point. We look like sunbelt talent without Kamario leading the offense.
You WISH State looked like Sunbelt Talent. I’m not sure this State team could compete in the CUSA let alone the Sunbelt!
 

Darryl Steight

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
4,989
8,306
113
That really depends on what our record was with a healthy KT. I think we would have gone 0 for October, with at least one of those losses directly caused by Lebby being a bonehead. So, yeah, we WOULD still be pitching about Lebby.

And when K1 gets hurt in the middle of next season?
You don't think we would have beaten Oklahoma with a healthy KT?

That seems a bit confabulatory.
 

Howiefeltersnstch

All-Conference
Dec 28, 2019
3,218
3,934
98
That really depends on what our record was with a healthy KT. I think we would have gone 0 for October, with at least one of those losses directly caused by Lebby being a bonehead. So, yeah, we WOULD still be pitching about Lebby.

And when K1 gets hurt in the middle of next season?
Automatic losses
 

Anon1727472510

Redshirt
Sep 27, 2024
54
38
17
Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon understand that.
Do you simply ignore the impact Taylor had on this team and the potential for next year? I understand the post Taylor games negativity. There is validity to it; however, I would counter this team was clicking and so many were talking CFP. It’s amazing how one player could be so impactful to a program. He’s back and that hope for next year is back. It’s amazing the **** on everything ours fan can create. The football staff is the lowest in the SEC by a mile and this is the final year of Lebby’s contract, so the buyouts would be minimal by historical SEC standards. We can cross that KT will be gone off the list. Next should be the coaches buyout excuse. Just more of the mob mentality of this board. Yall love feeding the best and great at it. Kudos.
 

TPIPER36

Senior
May 19, 2023
770
980
93
Our best hope is that Lebby recognizes the issues at the O line and he gets a decent O Line coach and lets the O line coach takeover. Then go gets after it in the portal. Is Lebby really idiotic enough not to go get this done?
 

Indndawg

Senior
Nov 16, 2005
7,286
815
113
Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon understand that.
We got to get a new S and C trainer/coach. Get these weaklings in and work them
 

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
12,209
8,660
113
Nobody really seems to be talking about this. If the argument for keeping Lebby is that we save money on staff buyouts, is anyone considering that the result is we have a coach with a 3-22 SEC record going out and trying to land big fish on the OL / DL?

Say we are going head to head for a premier DL with Auburn. We’re both offering whatever amount. Just call it $1 million. One school has a head coach that just went 7-5, and showed major progress in Year 1. The other just wrapped up year 3 with a dreadful winning percentage, at a rural school with comparatively few cultural advantages over any other SEC or B1G locales.

We’re not winning that battle, unless we substantially overpay for that player. And if we have to overpay for that guy and for several other guys, including some that we hope we never see take any meaningful snaps (like a good backup QB), then how much are we really saving overall?

This idea that firing Lebby is more expensive than not firing him, within the context of the 2027 season, just doesn’t hold water. There is certainly going to be a hidden cost to keeping him, and I really hope our big money folks and Selmon understand that.
At what point does the constant bitching, when given KT's statement Lebby will obviously be back, become financially counterproductive? I'm not sold on Lebby, but it's time to shut the hell up about it and get behind the program. We have a multigenerational QB who just committed his future to us. This is a historic opportunity, and he obviously believes in Lebby. This is no time for a change. I predicted 2-10 this year, that should tell you what I thought, without me spelling it out. Before ALL the injuries, not just KT, we looked surprisingly good. If you can't say anything good right now. Just shut your damn mouth, for the good of the program.
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,864
3,327
113
You don't think we would have beaten Oklahoma with a healthy KT?

That seems a bit confabulatory.
We certainly could have. With Lebby at the helm you don't know what might happen.

After the Mizzou game, and before we knew KT was hurt, I said the only games I felt were comfortable with going forward were Vandy and TN Tech. We had a team with obvious weaknesses, that was over performing. Particularly on the defensive side of the ball. KT gave us a chance to hang with anybody, but we also could have been blown out by anybody.

It's all hypothetical, so we don't have to convince each other of anything. Its unanswerable. I just think the weaknesses were going to cost us. We have no idea what Oklahoma might have thrown at us with KT in the mix.

I didn't think Auburn could beat UGA, either.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Tennessee Tech Players to Know
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 86-83 UCF: Bulldogs earn road win in fight from start to finish with Golden Knights
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 88-46 Alabama State: Bulldogs beat the Hornets in annual Kids' Day game
  4. 04 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State at UCF: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball on the road
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Sanfrisco Magee's "detail" and consistency carrying Mississippi State offense through tough times