Demand for Minny game still looks light

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
3,434
3,350
113
Jeremiah Smith may be “opting out” with OSU not positioned for the CFP. Who knows what’s going on with Koby ? IDK. Big time players will be making decisions based on their NFL or NIL opportunities and sit . This behavior would erode interest and ticket sales in regular season games.
Why shouldn’t Smith opt out? Consensus top player in the upcoming draft and any non-playoff bowl game is merely a “scrimmage” right Lando?
 

Bob78

All-Conference
Jul 5, 2001
2,005
4,751
113
I think this could have been accomplished by having an objective, performance-based criteria for getting into a 14-team playoff, instead of the subjective, selection committee-based criteria that we will be getting for a 24-team playoff.

For example, suppose the BIG and SEC get 3 auto bids each; the ACC and Big 12 get 2 auto bids each; the best G5 team gets an auto bid; and there are 3 wild cards. You can still have conference championship games and effective "play in" games for each conference during championship weekend. You could get rid of much of the bias associated with the selection committee approach that we are going to get.
I'm one who thinks 16 is still an ideal number for the playoffs. Not 24. 12 is ok, too.

But -- dump the conferences for football, at least for the Power schools, and move the Group Schools to their own playoff of 12 or 16 teams. Keep the "minor" bowls for that Group. Some bowls will fall out, but post-season prollegiate football bowls are still generally highly entertaining.

16 teams is just under 25% of the current Power teams plus ND. That's more than enough of a collection of eligible teams to keep the interest level very high without watering it down too much. Keep most of the "B" Tier bowls (e.g. Citrus, Outback, Gator, and that tier) for the other bowl-eligible Power schools.

If too many bowls fade away, I'd say let eligible schools set up their own post-regular season games vs. old rivals or teams with similar records, and play them on campuses. Why not? 6-6 Kansas and 6-6 Arizona State want to play one more game? Let 'em! Get those Jayhawks fans into the December sun and fun of the Phoenix area. Seriously, all the old norms should be up for reconsideration, maybe just for a couple years until sanity returns. It's a whole new world. Time to experiment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hohmadw1978

Bob78

All-Conference
Jul 5, 2001
2,005
4,751
113
"I think this could have been accomplished by having an objective, performance-based criteria for getting into a 14-team playoff, instead of the subjective, selection committee-based criteria that we will be getting for a 24-team playoff."

For years, and years, and years, EVERYONE (and their Mother) says that.
And yet, for years, and years, and years NO ONE has ever posited any such system.

Why is that?
Because there is NO SYSTEM capable of doing that - not with diverse programs and conferences playing diverse schedules of drastically different and non-overlapping composition, with no consistency or "objective criteria" that would be in any way, shape, or form possible.

Period. End of story

(If only it were "end of story", because we know that meatheads and pundits and the podcaster cult will continue to spew the same nonsense to the fanbases - but never state "how it can be done")
Getting rid of conferences for football and centralizing both scheduling (for the 10 Power games) and refereeing would be a step in the right direction. Imo.
 

NewEra 2026

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
748
1,385
93
"I think this could have been accomplished by having an objective, performance-based criteria for getting into a 14-team playoff, instead of the subjective, selection committee-based criteria that we will be getting for a 24-team playoff."

For years, and years, and years, EVERYONE (and their Mother) says that.
And yet, for years, and years, and years NO ONE has ever posited any such system.

Why is that?
Because there is NO SYSTEM capable of doing that - not with diverse programs and conferences playing diverse schedules of drastically different and non-overlapping composition, with no consistency or "objective criteria" that would be in any way, shape, or form possible.

Period. End of story

(If only it were "end of story", because we know that meatheads and pundits and the podcaster cult will continue to spew the same nonsense to the fanbases - but never state "how it can be done")
I honestly don't know what you are talking about. I just posited a system. Each conference would then decide how they determine their conference's automatic bids, which would likely be by having games on the field during championship week.

The roadblock is getting all of the conferences to agree how many teams from each conference receive automatic bids. The ACC and Big 12 won't ever agree to having fewer auto bids than the SEC and BIG. But this system is very capable of using objective criteria for determining playoff participants.
 

PSUFTG

All-Conference
Nov 1, 2021
2,861
4,083
113
I honestly don't know what you are talking about. I just posited a system. Each conference would then decide how they determine their conference's automatic bids, which would likely be by having games on the field during championship week.

The roadblock is getting all of the conferences to agree how many teams from each conference receive automatic bids. The ACC and Big 12 won't ever agree to having fewer auto bids than the SEC and BIG. But this system is very capable of using objective criteria for determining playoff participants.
A "system"? Sure.

An "objective, performance-based criteria"? (which was the contention) Obviously not.
Starting with the most obvious: How many "spots" does each conference get? There is no way, no how, no chance, no possible option as to how that can be done "objectively and performance based".
Right?
If not, one could easily outline what the "objective and performance based" criteria would be - and how those would be implemented. And in such a way that no reasonable person could "object", and there could be no reasonable or alternative process that might be "better" in their opinion. But one cannot do that.

Obviously. :rolleyes:
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,182
2,224
113
You need to go to a pure NFL model. 36 teams in the highest league of college/professional football. You decide the 36 teams on an algorithm of different metrics that is solely computer based. No human input. Things like attendance levels, won/loss record over last 30 years weighted more heavily for last 10, TV ratings of games the teams play in, etc. We all could come up with the top 36 teams in "college football" give or take 5-6. This does mean a good amount of power 4 schools and just about all the lower tier conferences will not make it.

The 36 teams can be organized by two conferences of 18 teams and 3 divisions of 6. The playoffs have the 3 division winners and the next 3 wild cards in each conference.

Since the dawn of time this flawed human judgment contaminating college fooall has been horrible. Stained the sport for decades. This committee they now have comprised of fat cat, biased, agenda driven, unethical, untrustworthy, shady characters is a joke, a bad joke or really a nightmare. Every committee has been terrible and before that, the sportswriters. What a fiasco.
 

LionJim

Heisman
Oct 12, 2021
16,854
23,139
113
I'm one who thinks 16 is still an ideal number for the playoffs. Not 24. 12 is ok, too.

But -- dump the conferences for football, at least for the Power schools, and move the Group Schools to their own playoff of 12 or 16 teams. Keep the "minor" bowls for that Group. Some bowls will fall out, but post-season prollegiate football bowls are still generally highly entertaining.

16 teams is just under 25% of the current Power teams plus ND. That's more than enough of a collection of eligible teams to keep the interest level very high without watering it down too much. Keep most of the "B" Tier bowls (e.g. Citrus, Outback, Gator, and that tier) for the other bowl-eligible Power schools.

If too many bowls fade away, I'd say let eligible schools set up their own post-regular season games vs. old rivals or teams with similar records, and play them on campuses. Why not? 6-6 Kansas and 6-6 Arizona State want to play one more game? Let 'em! Get those Jayhawks fans into the December sun and fun of the Phoenix area. Seriously, all the old norms should be up for reconsideration, maybe just for a couple years until sanity returns. It's a whole new world. Time to experiment.
Was looking for this post. Yeah, I hate the idea of first-round byes, I’d go with 16.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Binder74

Binder74

Senior
Nov 1, 2021
537
917
93
You need to go to a pure NFL model. 36 teams in the highest league of college/professional football. You decide the 36 teams on an algorithm of different metrics that is solely computer based. No human input. Things like attendance levels, won/loss record over last 30 years weighted more heavily for last 10, TV ratings of games the teams play in, etc. We all could come up with the top 36 teams in "college football" give or take 5-6. This does mean a good amount of power 4 schools and just about all the lower tier conferences will not make it.

The 36 teams can be organized by two conferences of 18 teams and 3 divisions of 6. The playoffs have the 3 division winners and the next 3 wild cards in each conference.

Since the dawn of time this flawed human judgment contaminating college fooall has been horrible. Stained the sport for decades. This committee they now have comprised of fat cat, biased, agenda driven, unethical, untrustworthy, shady characters is a joke, a bad joke or really a nightmare. Every committee has been terrible and before that, the sportswriters. What a fiasco.
But can a computer properly incorporate southern speed into the rankings?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: UncleRoyBiggins

Woodpecker

All-American
May 29, 2001
4,029
9,024
113
The stadium size is fine. The product is not.

If Penn State had an undefeated team or was a one loss playoff contending team with a few legitimate B1G stars, the stadium would be packed regardless of the opponent.

The product is what sells. Degrade the product to mostly 2nd tier players with a losing conference record, some people will lose interest or refuse to spend money for the product.
aka the Pitt model
 

MtNittany

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
4,167
5,765
113
I think there are so many investment properties in SC now that AirBB's are filling the void. But they're not cheap either.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,183
4,797
113
I can see it providing hope for teams like Missouri, Duke, Oklahoma State and Liberty but it's not going to drive attendance or TV ratings for teams like Ohio State, Oregon, Penn State or LSU. Many of the big-name teams in the 15-25 range are having conversations about the future of their programs and their head coaches.
So Penn State fans wouldn't care about making the playoff? Or Ohio State, Oregon and LSU fans?
In what world?
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,183
4,797
113
Why shouldn’t Smith opt out? Consensus top player in the upcoming draft and any non-playoff bowl game is merely a “scrimmage” right Lando?
Dear God--players aren't going to opt out of regular season games
They will and should opt out of bowl games which is merely a scrimmage.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,183
4,797
113
I'm one who thinks 16 is still an ideal number for the playoffs. Not 24. 12 is ok, too.

But -- dump the conferences for football, at least for the Power schools, and move the Group Schools to their own playoff of 12 or 16 teams. Keep the "minor" bowls for that Group. Some bowls will fall out, but post-season prollegiate football bowls are still generally highly entertaining.

16 teams is just under 25% of the current Power teams plus ND. That's more than enough of a collection of eligible teams to keep the interest level very high without watering it down too much. Keep most of the "B" Tier bowls (e.g. Citrus, Outback, Gator, and that tier) for the other bowl-eligible Power schools.

If too many bowls fade away, I'd say let eligible schools set up their own post-regular season games vs. old rivals or teams with similar records, and play them on campuses. Why not? 6-6 Kansas and 6-6 Arizona State want to play one more game? Let 'em! Get those Jayhawks fans into the December sun and fun of the Phoenix area. Seriously, all the old norms should be up for reconsideration, maybe just for a couple years until sanity returns. It's a whole new world. Time to experiment.
They want to bowls to die--there's no need for them. They'll become "week zero games" instead of a scrimmage at the end of the year
If you want two tiers then a 12 or 16 team works but, as FCS has shown, 24 works great--especially without the awful CC games
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,183
4,797
113
You need to go to a pure NFL model. 36 teams in the highest league of college/professional football. You decide the 36 teams on an algorithm of different metrics that is solely computer based. No human input. Things like attendance levels, won/loss record over last 30 years weighted more heavily for last 10, TV ratings of games the teams play in, etc. We all could come up with the top 36 teams in "college football" give or take 5-6. This does mean a good amount of power 4 schools and just about all the lower tier conferences will not make it.

The 36 teams can be organized by two conferences of 18 teams and 3 divisions of 6. The playoffs have the 3 division winners and the next 3 wild cards in each conference.

Since the dawn of time this flawed human judgment contaminating college fooall has been horrible. Stained the sport for decades. This committee they now have comprised of fat cat, biased, agenda driven, unethical, untrustworthy, shady characters is a joke, a bad joke or really a nightmare. Every committee has been terrible and before that, the sportswriters. What a fiasco.
Just to clarify--if/when this happens it will likely be 48 teams. 4 divisions of 12. 11 divisional games plus a kickoff class game for ratings. Top 4-6 in each division get a playoff spot and they'll be pre-determined bracket where everyone goes. For example, in a 16 team playoff: 1 East v 4 South; 2 West vs 3 Midwest. 48 is the magic number
 
May 11, 2016
448
262
63
How is that different than it's always been?
Did anyone truly care about being 6-6 and going to a bowl game at a program like Penn State?
It will just be called a playoff game instead of a bowl. Nothing else changes. Same crap match-ups with same results.

The 12 team playoff has already produced falling attendance with no improvement in quality.

But lets see how much more we can eff it up.
 

nittanymoops

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
857
1,511
93
Regarding hotel prices, I ran into a friend in Seattle who is familiar with the costs. He told me that the Nittany Lion Inn was now charging $1,500 per night with a two night minimum. That is clearly only the one percenters who are staying there. The hotels and inns closest to Husky Stadium were considerably less, an almost reasonable $300-500 per night. And it was homecoming. Since we were there for the Kraken, Nittany Lions and Seahawks, we stayed at the Fairfield near Seattle Center and the Needle for $140/nt. Their light rail is very good, very clean and reliable with many trains. And yet we still walked to virtually everywhere, the Pike Place Market, the ferry terminal and the needle and Seattle center.

And cheap tickets are not exclusive to PSU. In my email today was a $19 offer from UDubs for their upcoming game against the Cignettis. If they are having trouble filling seats for a top ranked team at one of the most beautiful settings for football on the planet, then everyone is in trouble.

I truly now see what some folks say about west coast thinking regarding collegiate football and other sports. They are not as clued in and don’t live and die with their teams. Some fans this weekend in the trains were barely aware of a game, one gent seemed to be surprised the Huskies were in the B1G, and many went back to their tailgates at halftime. Of course, there still were plenty of fans to be loud, and their roofing helps funnel sound down. There was a PSU pep band and many fans making a lot of noise in the first half in favor of the Lions. Courtesy of the roofing, the pep band was just as loud as the Husky band. I talked to some Husky fans and they were not “as into” their team, not the way we on this board are.

My seatmate said he thinks it changed about a decade ago or so. The kids aren’t as into it anymore, and he was even referring to students. He also thought the popularity of the Seahawks from 2002 on has hurt their attendance. There’s only so much personal expenses to go around, and it’s an NFL town since the Seahawks switched to the NFC West during the league realignment in 2002.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,183
4,797
113
It will just be called a playoff game instead of a bowl. Nothing else changes. Same crap match-ups with same results.

The 12 team playoff has already produced falling attendance with no improvement in quality.

But lets see how much more we can eff it up.
You realize if you win you advance in the playoff so it's nothing comparable to a bowl game
Ratings for the playoff have been insane--the issue with attendance is the stupidity on not having all games at the higher seed until the title game--they'll fix that.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,403
6,170
113
I honestly don't know what you are talking about. I just posited a system. Each conference would then decide how they determine their conference's automatic bids, which would likely be by having games on the field during championship week.

The roadblock is getting all of the conferences to agree how many teams from each conference receive automatic bids. The ACC and Big 12 won't ever agree to having fewer auto bids than the SEC and BIG. But this system is very capable of using objective criteria for determining playoff participants.
How about each conference has a tournament to decide their winner and the winner goes to the playoffs. That’s a four team playoff…forget the G5 since there are hardly any left.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
3,434
3,350
113
Dear God--players aren't going to opt out of regular season games
They will and should opt out of bowl games which is merely a scrimmage.
You really ought to pay attention. I was talking about Smith opting out of a bowl game. Still pounding the bowl games are mere scrimmages BS.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
3,434
3,350
113
It will just be called a playoff game instead of a bowl. Nothing else changes. Same crap match-ups with same results.

The 12 team playoff has already produced falling attendance with no improvement in quality.

But lets see how much more we can eff it up.
Wow. You and I agree on something.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
3,434
3,350
113
You realize if you win you advance in the playoff so it's nothing comparable to a bowl game
Ratings for the playoff have been insane--the issue with attendance is the stupidity on not having all games at the higher seed until the title game--they'll fix that.
Let’s see how the ratings are when they go to 24 teams. Saban was correct when he said this is a joke since there aren’t 24 teams that can win a Natty. On the other hand, expanding the playoffs to 24 may save Campbell’s job (or will he need them to go to 36 or 48).
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,183
4,797
113
Let’s see how the ratings are when they go to 24 teams. Saban was correct when he said this is a joke since there aren’t 24 teams that can win a Natty. On the other hand, expanding the playoffs to 24 may save Campbell’s job (or will he need them to go to 36 or 48).
lol--who says a 24th ranked team can't win
#17 played for the FCS title
You all can ***** all you want--what I said would happen has happened and it's amazing
 

Wilbury

Junior
Oct 28, 2021
312
393
63
So Penn State fans wouldn't care about making the playoff? Or Ohio State, Oregon and LSU fans?
In what world?
So, if there were 24 teams this year and PSU managed to get to 8-4 and squeak in at 24, how many people do you think are traveling to Texas Tech or Wake Forest? The answer is fewer than would travel to the Duke's Mayo bowl.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkiSkiSki

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,183
4,797
113
So, if there were 24 teams this year and PSU managed to get to 8-4 and squeak in at 24, how many people do you think are traveling to Texas Tech or Wake Forest? The answer is fewer than would travel to the Duke's Mayo bowl.
Some will travel but they don't need to as the other team is hosting. Why would travel for a road game matter.
And if it's true less would go then they're not very intelligent but it's their $
 

BobPSU92

Heisman
Aug 22, 2001
46,254
38,557
113
Tomorrow night:



Where the hell is everybody?

😞
 
  • Wow
Reactions: UncleRoyBiggins
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Wrestling Penn State wrestling beats Oklahoma 41-0 to earn its first shut out of the year: Recap
  2. 02 BWI Basketball Penn State basketball cruises past New Haven behind complete effort
  3. 03 Rivals Football Recruiting Penn State offer puts Nittany Lions in strong position with DB Carlos Gordon
  4. 04 BWI Football Penn State notebook: Carson Hansen’s big night, Alex Manske’s opportunity and more
  5. 05 BWI Wrestling How to watch, follow, Penn State wrestling at Oklahoma on Sunday: New start time and streaming info, probable lineups, more