4A West 2nd Round matchups

Chopper747_2.0

All-Conference
Jul 22, 2025
869
1,143
93
Don’t know anything about Maiden, but I will say that you better be able to score against Tuscola. When it’s clicking their O can be pretty dynamic. Up until we played them our 1st string D hadn’t given up points (yes against some lesser competition). They went thru it like we were warm butter. Our offense definitely won that game for us.

the competition up in the hills is not exactly stellar right now
 

Maiden Creek

All-American
Oct 4, 2019
4,586
8,177
113
I’m gonna go out on a limb here and say most of you are underestimating Tuscola. My thought is they will beat Maiden. Obviously as previously posted, I know nothing about Maiden. Tuscola isn’t as slow as a traditional Mnt team, and they will knock your teeth in with their RB. Guess we’ll see come Friday night!
Maiden is 6 and 5…they don’t have any teeth left to knockout!😂

Please know…the Blue Devils know what they’re up against and no one from Maiden is underestimating that Tuscola bunch. No way!!
 
Last edited:

Stormsurge1

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2025
1,414
1,970
113
I’m gonna go out on a limb here and say most of you are underestimating Tuscola. My thought is they will beat Maiden. Obviously as previously posted, I know nothing about Maiden. Tuscola isn’t as slow as a traditional Mnt team, and they will knock your teeth in with their RB. Guess we’ll see come Friday night!
No under estimating here for sure. We will be glued into what is happening in Waynesville. Good luck to both teams.
 
Nov 10, 2026
14
7
3
I’m gonna go out on a limb here and say most of you are underestimating Tuscola. My thought is they will beat Maiden. Obviously as previously posted, I know nothing about Maiden. Tuscola isn’t as slow as a traditional Mnt team, and they will knock your teeth in with their RB. Guess we’ll see come Friday night!
I’m in no way underestimating Tuscola. I know all about that world from Tommy Pursley to Tyler Brosious to Coach Postell, etc. etc. But I also know the schedule and adversity Maiden had faced this year and both are up there for sure. Plus it’s not like I picked them in a blowout.
 

Captn Skully

Joined Aug 16, 2002
Feb 3, 2022
58
47
18
The Tuscola RB #21 is a bit more quick and shifty than run you over type back, the strength of Big T is the OL/DL, pretty good size and they play well together. Now if you wanna talk about a run you over back, that #36 in Franklin is a run you over back. #21 does have a nice vertical.
1794428778045.png

1794429259270.png
 
Last edited:

Lincolnton

All-Conference
Jul 8, 2025
1,031
2,828
113
Speaking for myself, I would admit that I'm underestimating them. I'm guessing that if there's a group that IS NOT underestimating Tuscola, it's the Maiden guys, probably because they know their team's weaknesses along with its strengths more so than others.
Just out of curiosity, I told AI about BiltmoreCANE's, post and that as a fan of one of the mountain teams, had said some posters were underestimating Tuscola, another mountain team. Based on the language, I took it as though he meant posters in the Piedmont area, particularly the western Piedmont. Here's the response it gave. Some things are probably accurate, and some are not, but here it is:
Question:
Tuscola will be hosting the Maiden Blue Devils from Catawba County. Why might someone from the western Piedmont underestimate the Tuscola Mountaineers?
Answer from AI:
That mountain poster has a strong argument, as Tuscola (9–1) enters Friday's NCHSAA 4A second-round playoff matchup as the No. 2 seed in the 4A West with a strong statistical profile against No. 15 Maiden (6–5). However, Western Piedmont fans often give Maiden the benefit of the doubt because of the Blue Devils' battle-tested regular-season schedule and playoff pedigree.
Season Comparison
MetricTuscolaMaiden
Overall Record9–16–5
Playoff SeedNo. 2No. 15
Points Scored Per Game42.928.1
Points Allowed Per Game13.730.7
NC 4A State RankingNo. 3No. 13
Why Mountain Fans Say Tuscola Is Underestimated
  • Dominant Defense: Tuscola allows just 13.7 points per game and has pitched shutouts in two of its last three contests, beating Pisgah 21–0 and East Henderson 49–0.
  • Workhorse Ground Game: Running back Sam Trantham averages 220.7 rushing yards and 20.4 points per game. That physical, clock-controlling offense is built for late-season playoff football.
  • The Only Blemish: Tuscola's lone loss came against unbeaten Franklin (10–0), in a shootout where the Mountaineers still scored 33 points.
  • Mountain Weather and Travel: Maiden faces roughly a two-hour bus trip west into Haywood County. Temperatures in Waynesville are expected to drop into the 30s, with northwest winds, conditions Tuscola fans might call "Mountaineer football weather."
Why Piedmont Fans Still Respect Maiden
  • A Brutal Conference Slate: Piedmont fans tend to discount 5-loss records when teams play in rugged Foothills/Catawba Valley leagues. Maiden's losses include heavyweights like East Lincoln (9–1) and Hickory (8–3), meaning the Blue Devils have already faced top-tier speed and physicality.
  • Offensive Balance: Maiden can challenge a secondary through the air behind quarterback Chaise Davis (160.0 passing yards per game) and receiver Keyahjae Smyre (88.8 receiving yards per game).
  • Playoff Experience: Maiden already survived a postseason test last week and carries a longtime reputation in Catawba County for punching above its seed in November.
The Bottom Line
Message boards across North Carolina often have a regional bias. Piedmont fans frequently view mountain conferences as softer until proven otherwise, while mountain fans feel they don't get respect until a team makes a deep November run. On paper, Tuscola's defense and rushing attack make them a legitimate favorite at home. Maiden will likely need to turn the game into a pass-heavy shootout and limit Trantham's explosive runs to pull off the road upset.
Why Piedmont Football Fans Might Underestimate Mountain Teams
Piedmont football fans sometimes underestimate mountain teams like Tuscola because of regional conference bias, historical playoff trends, and differences in offensive style. Even when a Western North Carolina team posts a 9–1 record, fans in the foothills and Piedmont may filter those numbers through decades of regional football culture.
Several factors contribute to this perception:
1. Strength of Schedule and Conference Perception
  • The "Foothills Meatgrinder" Mentality: Fans in Catawba, Lincoln, and Cleveland counties are accustomed to watching teams compete in loaded leagues. When Maiden goes 6–5 against teams like East Lincoln, Hickory, or Lincolnton, Piedmont fans view those losses as battle scars that prepare a team for November.
  • Skepticism of Mountain Leagues: Conversely, Piedmont fans sometimes view mountain conferences as top-heavy, assuming a 9–1 record in Haywood or Jackson County was built against smaller, less athletic rosters. Until a mountain team beats a respected Piedmont program in the playoffs, some posters treat its statistics with an asterisk.
2. Historical Playoff Results (Piedmont vs. Mountains)
  • Recent November Dominance: Over the last two decades, Western Piedmont and Charlotte-area programs like Shelby, Burns, Crest, East Lincoln, and Maiden have won the majority of 2A, 3A, and 4A regional titles.
  • The "I'll Believe It When I See It" Effect: Because mountain teams have historically struggled to get past the third or fourth round against Piedmont speed, fans in the foothills develop a certain mindset. Even when a mountain roster is legitimately loaded, like this year's Tuscola squad, past playoff results can influence how fans evaluate the current team.
3. Perceived Differences in Speed and Style
  • Ground-and-Pound vs. Spread Athletes: Mountain football is stereotypically associated with tough, physical, run-heavy offenses and cold-weather trench warfare. Piedmont fans often assume their local teams have an advantage in overall speed, perimeter athletes, and passing attacks.
  • Underestimating Physicality: While Piedmont fans focus on skill-position speed, they sometimes underestimate how punishing a disciplined, run-first mountain offense can be, especially when a team has a dominant feature back like Tuscola's Sam Trantham wearing down a defense for four quarters.
4. Geography and Media Echo Chambers
  • Limited Crossover Exposure: Because of the two-to-three-hour drive along I-40, Piedmont and mountain teams rarely play each other during the regular season. Without common opponents to compare, fans rely on local media coverage.
  • Hometown Bias: Local newspapers, podcasts, and message boards in the Western Piedmont naturally focus on Catawba Valley and South Fork storylines. When fans primarily read about their own conference, it's easy to overlook a powerhouse quietly rolling through opponents 100 miles west in Waynesville.
Again, this was done out of curiosity. Stats and views may be incorrect. Also had to edit some of it out as this post exceeded the maximum number of characters.
 

BiltmoreCANE

Senior
Jan 7, 2002
1,351
583
77
Speaking for myself, I would admit that I'm underestimating them. I'm guessing that if there's a group that IS NOT underestimating Tuscola, it's the Maiden guys, probably because they know their team's weaknesses along with its strengths more so than others.
Just out of curiosity, I told AI about BiltmoreCANE's, post and that as a fan of one of the mountain teams, had said some posters were underestimating Tuscola, another mountain team. Based on the language, I took it as though he meant posters in the Piedmont area, particularly the western Piedmont. Here's the response it gave. Some things are probably accurate, and some are not, but here it is:
Question:
Tuscola will be hosting the Maiden Blue Devils from Catawba County. Why might someone from the western Piedmont underestimate the Tuscola Mountaineers?
Answer from AI:
That mountain poster has a strong argument, as Tuscola (9–1) enters Friday's NCHSAA 4A second-round playoff matchup as the No. 2 seed in the 4A West with a strong statistical profile against No. 15 Maiden (6–5). However, Western Piedmont fans often give Maiden the benefit of the doubt because of the Blue Devils' battle-tested regular-season schedule and playoff pedigree.
Season Comparison
MetricTuscolaMaiden
Overall Record9–16–5
Playoff SeedNo. 2No. 15
Points Scored Per Game42.928.1
Points Allowed Per Game13.730.7
NC 4A State RankingNo. 3No. 13
Why Mountain Fans Say Tuscola Is Underestimated
  • Dominant Defense: Tuscola allows just 13.7 points per game and has pitched shutouts in two of its last three contests, beating Pisgah 21–0 and East Henderson 49–0.
  • Workhorse Ground Game: Running back Sam Trantham averages 220.7 rushing yards and 20.4 points per game. That physical, clock-controlling offense is built for late-season playoff football.
  • The Only Blemish: Tuscola's lone loss came against unbeaten Franklin (10–0), in a shootout where the Mountaineers still scored 33 points.
  • Mountain Weather and Travel: Maiden faces roughly a two-hour bus trip west into Haywood County. Temperatures in Waynesville are expected to drop into the 30s, with northwest winds, conditions Tuscola fans might call "Mountaineer football weather."
Why Piedmont Fans Still Respect Maiden
  • A Brutal Conference Slate: Piedmont fans tend to discount 5-loss records when teams play in rugged Foothills/Catawba Valley leagues. Maiden's losses include heavyweights like East Lincoln (9–1) and Hickory (8–3), meaning the Blue Devils have already faced top-tier speed and physicality.
  • Offensive Balance: Maiden can challenge a secondary through the air behind quarterback Chaise Davis (160.0 passing yards per game) and receiver Keyahjae Smyre (88.8 receiving yards per game).
  • Playoff Experience: Maiden already survived a postseason test last week and carries a longtime reputation in Catawba County for punching above its seed in November.
The Bottom Line
Message boards across North Carolina often have a regional bias. Piedmont fans frequently view mountain conferences as softer until proven otherwise, while mountain fans feel they don't get respect until a team makes a deep November run. On paper, Tuscola's defense and rushing attack make them a legitimate favorite at home. Maiden will likely need to turn the game into a pass-heavy shootout and limit Trantham's explosive runs to pull off the road upset.
Why Piedmont Football Fans Might Underestimate Mountain Teams
Piedmont football fans sometimes underestimate mountain teams like Tuscola because of regional conference bias, historical playoff trends, and differences in offensive style. Even when a Western North Carolina team posts a 9–1 record, fans in the foothills and Piedmont may filter those numbers through decades of regional football culture.
Several factors contribute to this perception:
1. Strength of Schedule and Conference Perception
  • The "Foothills Meatgrinder" Mentality: Fans in Catawba, Lincoln, and Cleveland counties are accustomed to watching teams compete in loaded leagues. When Maiden goes 6–5 against teams like East Lincoln, Hickory, or Lincolnton, Piedmont fans view those losses as battle scars that prepare a team for November.
  • Skepticism of Mountain Leagues: Conversely, Piedmont fans sometimes view mountain conferences as top-heavy, assuming a 9–1 record in Haywood or Jackson County was built against smaller, less athletic rosters. Until a mountain team beats a respected Piedmont program in the playoffs, some posters treat its statistics with an asterisk.
2. Historical Playoff Results (Piedmont vs. Mountains)
  • Recent November Dominance: Over the last two decades, Western Piedmont and Charlotte-area programs like Shelby, Burns, Crest, East Lincoln, and Maiden have won the majority of 2A, 3A, and 4A regional titles.
  • The "I'll Believe It When I See It" Effect: Because mountain teams have historically struggled to get past the third or fourth round against Piedmont speed, fans in the foothills develop a certain mindset. Even when a mountain roster is legitimately loaded, like this year's Tuscola squad, past playoff results can influence how fans evaluate the current team.
3. Perceived Differences in Speed and Style
  • Ground-and-Pound vs. Spread Athletes: Mountain football is stereotypically associated with tough, physical, run-heavy offenses and cold-weather trench warfare. Piedmont fans often assume their local teams have an advantage in overall speed, perimeter athletes, and passing attacks.
  • Underestimating Physicality: While Piedmont fans focus on skill-position speed, they sometimes underestimate how punishing a disciplined, run-first mountain offense can be, especially when a team has a dominant feature back like Tuscola's Sam Trantham wearing down a defense for four quarters.
4. Geography and Media Echo Chambers
  • Limited Crossover Exposure: Because of the two-to-three-hour drive along I-40, Piedmont and mountain teams rarely play each other during the regular season. Without common opponents to compare, fans rely on local media coverage.
  • Hometown Bias: Local newspapers, podcasts, and message boards in the Western Piedmont naturally focus on Catawba Valley and South Fork storylines. When fans primarily read about their own conference, it's easy to overlook a powerhouse quietly rolling through opponents 100 miles west in Waynesville.
Again, this was done out of curiosity. Stats and views may be incorrect. Also had to edit some of it out as this post exceeded the maximum number of characters.
Very interesting post, thank you!
 

Esah221221

Freshman
Sep 4, 2026
59
89
18
The thing about Trantham is he has crazy field vision, there won't be a hole and the next thing you know, he is in the secondary, he is fun to watch, and he breaks tackles like I've not seen in a long time. And being a Waynesville native, I concur with the food choices, my go to is Haywood Smokehouse, the Brisket is amazing as advertised.
 

Esah221221

Freshman
Sep 4, 2026
59
89
18
Everything about him is deceptive, size, speed, it's kinda crazy and hard to explain, you have to see it first hand, and he can absolutely toss the rock accurately if called upon, which throws that wrinkle into the fold, it's just hard to describe what he means to this team in all aspects, and to think he still has another year is crazy.
 

Maiden Creek

All-American
Oct 4, 2019
4,586
8,177
113
Hibriten
Lake Norman Charter
Mount Pleasant
Burns
West Iredell
West Stokes
Stuart W. Cramer
Tuscola
Tell you what…the more I look at it…I can see why you picked Lake Norman Charter.

That’s gonna be a heck of a game right there. Hoping the Hill Toppers can pull it out!

I saw Lake Norman Charter last year in the 1st round against Foard. They had some athletes but made too many mistakes and Foard didn’t. That was a great game too!

We’ll see!
 

theBatMan88

Sophomore
Sep 12, 2025
113
169
33
Maiden better have a hard hitting D to take down Trantham. Anything high, he’ll run through you, anything low, he’ll jump over you. Eyes to thighs, boys!
Maiden knows this. They're still having nightmares of West Iredell's Amario Spense dragging or running over four and five players with him in a 37-0 blowout earlier this year. Spense only carried the ball 11 times, but scored two TDs on 118 yards. Maiden keyed on him heavily, so QB Patterson shredded their secondary for 207 yards, 3 TDs, on 12 of 16 passing. The most reliable part of Maiden that night was their fans. They stayed all the way to the final horn. PLUS, head coaches of WI and Tuscola are best friends, having played together at Tuscola. That said, Tuscola by 21.
 

Maiden Creek

All-American
Oct 4, 2019
4,586
8,177
113
I’m still scratching my head over Bandys losing to Wilkes Central. Go figure!

Something I did notice about Wilkes Central….all their impact players are underclassmen….do what? They’re young!

I got to take Mt. Pleasant…but I see Wilkes Central being a daggum handful next year! 🫵
 

Maiden Creek

All-American
Oct 4, 2019
4,586
8,177
113
Maiden knows this. They're still having nightmares of West Iredell's Amario Spense dragging or running over four and five players with him in a 37-0 blowout earlier this year. Spense only carried the ball 11 times, but scored two TDs on 118 yards. Maiden keyed on him heavily, so QB Patterson shredded their secondary for 207 yards, 3 TDs, on 12 of 16 passing. The most reliable part of Maiden that night was their fans. They stayed all the way to the final horn. PLUS, head coaches of WI and Tuscola are best friends, having played together at Tuscola. That said, Tuscola by 21.
Just noticed the Rocky River conference also has all their teams still in the playoffs.

West Stanly has a great win over Forest Hills…and some tough losses to some good teams.

This should be a good challenging game for West Iredell to get their mojo back!😉
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lincolnton

Stormsurge1

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2025
1,414
1,970
113
Just noticed the Rocky River conference also has all their teams still in the playoffs.

West Stanly has a great win over Forest Hills…and some tough losses to some good teams.

This should be a good challenging game for West Iredell to get their mojo back!😉
West Stanly is hard to figure out. That win over Forest Hills is a very good win and then they have a loss to Monroe 70-0. Monroe is a load we all know that but I wonder if they were missing players or if something else was going on.
 

theBatMan88

Sophomore
Sep 12, 2025
113
169
33
Just noticed the Rocky River conference also has all their teams still in the playoffs.

West Stanly has a great win over Forest Hills…and some tough losses to some good teams.

This should be a good challenging game for West Iredell to get their mojo back!😉
I've been all over the state again this year and have watched some interesting revival. The West Iredell one is intriguing, and I've watched most of their games online, but those last three weeks was some bad football and bad coaching decisions. They better have purged bad play and the squib kick or they're out after tomorrow night. They played up and out of their league against EL and Hickory, but flat after that.
 

BurnsBulldog02

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2016
1,406
2,725
97
Burns vs BH
There are no fans on here that I am aware of but Gaither is the real deal on film. They have a ton of speed on this team. I don't think their line play is bad but it's not comparable to what we have seen this year. We will have to contain Gaither or they will go toe to toe with us. I think our offense will move the ball as long as we spread it out and use our weapons. Romelo Wells adds a great depth at receiver. Now we have Surratt, Ussery and Wells out wide to go with Max and Mari in the backfield. Dawkins has proved to step into the QB role and learn as he goes. Now, put it all together and make a run. Camp missed a good portion of the season at MLB but really showed in the Shelby game he is back to make some noise. Needed him in the Lincolnton and SC game but no better time to be healthy.
 

ImOnYourSide

Redshirt
Oct 6, 2026
18
23
2
Burns vs BH
There are no fans on here that I am aware of but Gaither is the real deal on film. They have a ton of speed on this team. I don't think their line play is bad but it's not comparable to what we have seen this year. We will have to contain Gaither or they will go toe to toe with us. I think our offense will move the ball as long as we spread it out and use our weapons. Romelo Wells adds a great depth at receiver. Now we have Surratt, Ussery and Wells out wide to go with Max and Mari in the backfield. Dawkins has proved to step into the QB role and learn as he goes. Now, put it all together and make a run. Camp missed a good portion of the season at MLB but really showed in the Shelby game he is back to make some noise. Needed him in the Lincolnton and SC game but no better time to be healthy.
I agree but I would rather deal with 1 headed running monster (1140 yards) then a 3 headed monster Dawkins 533 yards, Davis 892 yards, McKinzie 504 yards. Then add Ussery and Wells with 364 combined respectfully. That's a 2295 yard monster. People then sleep on Dawkins throwing ability and get burned by him. Dawkins is also missed at that linebacker spot.
 

notanyonesfan1

All-Conference
Nov 15, 2014
797
1,308
93
I agree but I would rather deal with 1 headed running monster (1140 yards) then a 3 headed monster Dawkins 533 yards, Davis 892 yards, McKinzie 504 yards. Then add Ussery and Wells with 364 combined respectfully. That's a 2295 yard monster. People then sleep on Dawkins throwing ability and get burned by him. Dawkins is also missed at that linebacker spot.
Dawkins is missed at LB but Davis has stepped up and played quite a bit at LB in Dawkins spot, which is honestly the only reason Max isn't over 1000 yards at this point. And you're also right about Dawkins arm, he has really gotten a good feel for throwing the ball well since having to step in as QB 3 in the 4th game of the year.

As for the game I don't think Burns will have any issues putting up 40+ tonight. Can Bunker Hill do the same against a very good Burns defense?
 
Last edited:
NC Preps

Latest

  1. 01 NC Preps Class of 2029 Versatile Prospects Ready to Shine
  2. 02 NC Preps Deana's Playoff Picks - Round 2
  3. 03 NC Preps Two Class of 2029 Playmakers to Watch
  4. 04 NC Preps Deana’s State Football Playoffs Picks
  5. 05 NC Preps Two North Carolina Class of 2028 Prospects with Edge