Slightly off topic...a rule change idea

93hawkeye

Senior
Sep 19, 2004
438
692
93
Forget all the controversy when a QB is hit and the question is "was his arm moving forward" "Is that thing a fumble or incomplete pass"?
Lets think about pump fakes and apply that to the question...a forward arm motion that is clearly not a pass. We don't know the QB's intention. Let's change the rule to say, loose ball from hitting the QB is always a fumble whether his arm was moving or not.
 

Outbackbowl2017

All-Conference
Dec 4, 2016
1,949
3,263
113
Tom Brady says incomplete pass…..



But it was a fumble
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,738
5,403
113
Forget all the controversy when a QB is hit and the question is "was his arm moving forward" "Is that thing a fumble or incomplete pass"?
Lets think about pump fakes and apply that to the question...a forward arm motion that is clearly not a pass. We don't know the QB's intention. Let's change the rule to say, loose ball from hitting the QB is always a fumble whether his arm was moving or not.
That would make it a less subjective ruling but then comes the replays to see if the ball was still in the QB's hand or maybe one or two digits were touching it.

But it does sound logical that The Ball is not PassED until the ball LEAVES the hand. That would cut down on a lot of iffy situations and messed up replay calls.

Other examples, when is the handoff completed, sure when the Rbacks have the ball all by themselves

When is a player down or out of bounds. Those are pretty easy demarcations but it is a little harder to say when the QB's arm starts forward
 

Trakker

All-Conference
Jan 1, 2023
1,082
2,960
113
Forget all the controversy when a QB is hit and the question is "was his arm moving forward" "Is that thing a fumble or incomplete pass"?
Lets think about pump fakes and apply that to the question...a forward arm motion that is clearly not a pass. We don't know the QB's intention. Let's change the rule to say, loose ball from hitting the QB is always a fumble whether his arm was moving or not.
So an incomplete pass thrown as the qb is getting hit would be considered a fumble by your definition?
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Basketball Live from the Press Box
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Basketball Ben McCollum on the win over Xavier
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Basketball Hawkeye players talk win over Xavier
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Basketball Iowa rolls past Xavier
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Olympics Iowa women face #6 King in high-powered home opener