1.65 multiplier to 2.5

Snetsrak61

Senior
Aug 16, 2008
1,215
685
113
I'm a downstate public school guy. But can acknowledge this is a convoluted issue. I'm sure the IHSA doesn't want to split the private schools out into their own playoff unless they can figure out a way to put that $ in their own coffers.

But privates/non boundaried schools can & sometimes do have an advantage when they can go into a neighboring town to get a few highly skilled players. The trick is not all private schools do that.

One thought I have had is why couldn't this work sort of like the co-op enrollments work. I believe in a co-op, once you co-op you combine the 2 enrollments to form the total for IHSA purposes. Someone correct if I am wrong.

Assuming I am correct on the above, could not a similar logic be applied where the private gets a designated area within their boundaries to operate (3 miles, city limits, etc would need to be negotiated) but once that school picks up a player from "out of district" that schools enrollment is combined. This would effectively put the schools that bring in the most out of district players into a much higher classification than a similar sized school that doesn't get their QB from the next town down the road. Not perfect I am sure but it would have an element of flexibility to it based on how much a given school takes in from outside their boundaries.

And I know some could play chicanery with addresses to try to get around the rules but we all know there are public schools that do that today.

Just a thought I have had. No dog in the fight just a fan of high school football & basketball.
This would be a pretty cumbersome and timely process for schools and ADs to take on and IHSA to enforce. Not that it couldn't be done, but there isn't zero cost to implement something so thorough.

Ohio basically does track every player down to a "feeder school" level. Which tracks from 7th grade on. However public schools are included in this and get the same ding for high transfer rates. So it can be done but everyone shares in it and I presume that helps the enforcement since each and every school has a burden to track these feeder relationships.

So I'd be for that. It will help highlight the public powers who benefit from their success and attract talent into their districts.

I don't think Ohio does this either but no reason a school with a high transfer out rate couldn't get a divisor (public or private). Might help some underperforming public programs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RobertS68

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
720
361
51
l disagree frankly. Each private school plays under same base constraints and benefits. While some schools succeed more or less they have the same
I’ll mark that down as naive, uninformed and unknowing. To put it simply, if they could they would. But they can’t or they won’t. Let’s leave it at that
 

mc140

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
8,912
3,004
113
I’ll mark that down as naive, uninformed and unknowing. To put it simply, if they could they would. But they can’t or they won’t. Let’s leave it at that
The remarkable thing about Chicago Christian winning a few years is ago was how they did it without any real "recruiting" or transfers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colin2299

Anon232446

Redshirt
Sep 30, 2026
25
34
13
And this should be the last year for a couple for SF or PC or maybe both
Only to be replaced by JCA and maybe Naz bumping back down to 5A to continue the private domination of that class.


Again I said 5A is a weird one. And with PR and C-G being not as good as they have been over 10 years hurts. The public schools in 5A are not that good when you strip out those two historically strong teams. I know C-G had been 6A and is now in 5A. Heck one of the public champions in 5A was from Rochester who isn't landing in 5A anymore. 5A just seems like a class that sets up for private schools to have success in for multitude of reasons. But is that a reason to enact a 2.5 multiplier? I don't know.
2.5 multiplier is extreme. Keep the 1.65, bring the auto waiver back for anyone without a playoff win in 3 years. Keep success factor and expand it. If a team is originally 4A and they get success factored up to 5A if they win 2 trophies in 3 years in 5A they should keep going up to the next class. For teams that get success factored up, they stay up for 3 years and if they get 3 wins in those three years (3-3 or better) then they stay up in that class. Great programs will adapt and find a way to win in the higher class. Stop letting teams that can clearly compete in the higher class bounce back down to a lower class just to dominate weaker competition.
 

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
720
361
51
The remarkable thing about Chicago Christian winning a few years is ago was how they did it without any real "recruiting" or transfers.
It truly was. Were they 1A? Maybe that helped. Wasn’t that the year that caused the IHSA to rewrite the multiplier and enrollment rules? Chicago Christian comes out of know where to win 1A. Altof has insane talent of a lifetime and unmultiplied (is that a word?) takes 2A. Montini coming off a couple of 3-6 seasons, also unmultiplied takes 3A. DePaul, following a few, maybe a lot,of bad years comes in without a multiplier and a 6A enrollment because IHSA was using three year old figures. Can’t remember 5A, Naz, JCA? That one was legit. Then MC , LA of course. Boom! Perfect storm, 7 of 8? IHSA goes nuts starts using more current enrollment (good thing), but caves on the multiplier rules assuring that average to mediocre privates will not win a playoff game. Might have missed a few. Please feel free to correct
 

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,272
2,608
93
So, Mater Dei, we are going to move you up to 3A, where you will be "competitive," but we won't let you have a shot at winning your first football title ever in the class where most schools with your actual enrollment are playing. Move along now.
You are way smarter than that! Way smarter. To suggest that Mater Dei deserves a shot a title WITHOUT putting in the work simply because they are private is crazy sauce. They have the ability to go thirty miles if they choose to. They have the ability to recruit everyone on Central team and grab from neighboring towns. The fact they don’t or can’t is irrelevant. That’s like saying a school with 8000 students should play 4a because they can only get 30 kids out for football. Why can’t Oswego East go down to 5A and compete with St Francis and PC?

Even LA wanted fair competition so they petitioned to 8A instead of laying in 7A where the path would have been garaunteed.
You are making excuses for people not working hard by asking them to be place where they could win. A little disappointed in a LA guy making this argument.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 618account

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,272
2,608
93
Isn't that the point of all of this, for teams to be in a class they are competitive in? You want to move the dominate ones up not the ones that are competative.
I don’t want to do anything. CCL highlighted those teams to suggest they are the reason for the discussion. My point is ALL teams should challenge tbemselves versus look for handouts. SF got 10 plus transfers which is something Kaneland could never do yet people are proud that they beat them. Crazy work. Best Richards, Geneva, or WWS and then you would have respect. Let’s be realistic in the discussion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: flyer4life

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,272
2,608
93
Again I said 5A is a weird one. And with PR and C-G being not as good as they have been over 10 years hurts. The public schools in 5A are not that good when you strip out those two historically strong teams. I know C-G had been 6A and is now in 5A. Heck one of the public champions in 5A was from Rochester who isn't landing in 5A anymore. 5A just seems like a class that sets up for private schools to have success in for multitude of reasons. But is that a reason to enact a 2.5 multiplier? I don't know.
Add Althoff winning 1a and DePaul winning 4a along with IC and Montini winning lower classes. Yes, that’s enough to make schools question is it fair competition. Simply put, what 3a public school can compete with LA?? IC did. That alone helps you understand the concern.
 
  • Like
Reactions: USD24

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
720
361
51
Actually IC didn’t make the playoffs that year. It was Montini that took 3A and because they were coming off consecutive 3-6 seasons, under the old rules they were not multiplied. Byron should have won 3A

but back to your point, or my point, if these teams are that good that the can reach the finals, move em up and keep moving them up. If there not that good, let them be
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,683
4,419
113
Add Althoff winning 1a and DePaul winning 4a along with IC and Montini winning lower classes. Yes, that’s enough to make schools question is it fair competition. Simply put, what 3a public school can compete with LA?? IC did. That alone helps you understand the concern.
Althoff/DePaul/STL all got weird placements in that odd year when they used wrong enrollments etc... That was an anomaly year with how those schools were placed, at least for sure DePaul and STL. We can talk about that year but it was wrong and it was corrected the year after.
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,683
4,419
113
Actually IC didn’t make the playoffs that year. It was Montini that took 3A and because they were coming off consecutive 3-6 seasons, under the old rules they were not multiplied. Byron should have won 3A

but back to your point, or my point, if these teams are that good that the can reach the finals, move em up and keep moving them up. If there not that good, let them be
But that rule is in place for moving up. If the schools that get moved up reach finals then they keep moving up. If you disagree with the mechanics of the rule, ok but it is in place.
 

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
720
361
51
But that rule is in place for moving up. If the schools that get moved up reach finals then they keep moving up. If you disagree with the mechanics of the rule, ok but it is in place.
Right. I was just pointing that out to those that feel the SF is not enough of a restriction. Basically they don’t want those school to be able to even win a single playoff game let alone reach the finals
 
Jul 3, 2025
800
770
93
l disagree frankly. Each private school plays under same base constraints and benefits. While some schools succeed more or less they have the same opportunity.
This can't even begin to be true. Population within the radius is what directly and mostly impacts a private school's ability to enjoy what you call "benefits."

It may be true for Montini and Chicago Christian in a sense, I guess, but it is not even remotely close to true with (one example) SHG and Routt.

"Each private school" may play under the same constraints, but they do not all benefit the same from them... This to me is yet another example of the lumping together of all private schools that seems to be done every time this topic arises. Again, as said by many every year... just as public school districts vary around the state, those variations exist amongst the private schools as well. Most notably, and importantly, by way of population within the radius they draw students from.

I understand most public school folks don't care... but you all use the word "fair" and "fairness" at nauseum... so in regards to privates, don't mind them keeping you in check with how "unfair" the rules, and proposals, tend to be in their direction, most especially to those private schools not reaping the same benefits as those causing the outrage to begin with.
 
Last edited:

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,683
4,419
113
Right. I was just pointing that out to those that feel the SF is not enough of a restriction. Basically they don’t want those school to be able to even win a single playoff game let alone reach the finals
Got it.
 

RobertS68

Redshirt
Oct 26, 2026
3
1
0
This would be a pretty cumbersome and timely process for schools and ADs to take on and IHSA to enforce. Not that it couldn't be done, but there isn't zero cost to implement something so thorough.

Ohio basically does track every player down to a "feeder school" level. Which tracks from 7th grade on. However public schools are included in this and get the same ding for high transfer rates. So it can be done but everyone shares in it and I presume that helps the enforcement since each and every school has a burden to track these feeder relationships.

So I'd be for that. It will help highlight the public powers who benefit from their success and attract talent into their districts.

I don't think Ohio does this either but no reason a school with a high transfer out rate couldn't get a divisor (public or private). Might help some underperforming public programs.
Don't disagree it would be cumbersome. One of the issues around this ongoing debate is some private/non boundaried get kids from all over & others kind of stick to their home territory. A multiplier is a one size fits all solution for a problem that isn't one size fits all. Something that forces the schools who acquire talent from a broader area outside their defined home base are "punished" more than a small private who just takes in the 150 kids that walk thru their doors.

Any real solution would be hard to enforce. As I mentioned the IHSA at times has questionable public school transfers happening & those rules don't always get enforced. That is probably why this issue has always been handled in a one size fits all multiplier type approach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Snetsrak61

ramblinman reborn

Sophomore
Aug 15, 2025
184
192
43
You are way smarter than that! Way smarter. To suggest that Mater Dei deserves a shot a title WITHOUT putting in the work simply because they are private is crazy sauce. They have the ability to go thirty miles if they choose to. They have the ability to recruit everyone on Central team and grab from neighboring towns. The fact they don’t or can’t is irrelevant. That’s like saying a school with 8000 students should play 4a because they can only get 30 kids out for football. Why can’t Oswego East go down to 5A and compete with St Francis and PC?
No, it is most definitely not irrelevant. It is the whole point. The ABILITY to enroll students within a 30-mile radius does not automatically translate to athletic success, period! If it did, ALL the private schools would be excellent, and none of them would ever lose to public schools, and YOU are way smarter than that to think otherwise. To deny a private school like Mater Dei the chance to first demonstrate that they deserve to be multiplied because they are dominating in their actual size classification is discriminatory.

Why shouldn't Mater Dei be able to have the same chance to win a title in their actual size class like ALL public schools of their size? Because they compose their enrollment differently? You cannot empirically prove that the ability to do that translates to an unfair athletic advantage in each and every case. For every Loyola, or Mt Carmel or IC or whoever you come up with as examples, I have a private school that has never won squat.

Even LA wanted fair competition so they petitioned to 8A instead of laying in 7A where the path would have been garaunteed.
Are you really comparing Loyola's football success and petitioning to play up from the class they were multiplied into to Mater Dei being multiplied up from their actual size class where they never won a single title?

When you start clamoring for public schools like Rochester, LWE, Maine South, and others that have experienced extraordinary football success to petition to play up like ESL does, then you might start acquiring some credibility in this matter.

You are making excuses for people not working hard by asking them to be place where they could win. A little disappointed in a LA guy making this argument.
What a crock of crap.
 

618account

Redshirt
Aug 17, 2025
24
48
13
You are way smarter than that! Way smarter. To suggest that Mater Dei deserves a shot a title WITHOUT putting in the work simply because they are private is crazy sauce. They have the ability to go thirty miles if they choose to. They have the ability to recruit everyone on Central team and grab from neighboring towns. The fact they don’t or can’t is irrelevant. That’s like saying a school with 8000 students should play 4a because they can only get 30 kids out for football. Why can’t Oswego East go down to 5A and compete with St Francis and PC?
I like that people use Mater Dei as a "woe is me" example. 4 of the last 5 years their QB has been from out-of-district. Up until the last couple years, they were in 4A and competed. Their biggest issue is that their coach left for Centralia around 2010 and Stiebel came in and slowly cratered their program, which also coincided with Central getting better. They also lost their stud OC in the early 2010s, who is now the head coach at Highland and was bringing in quite a few Highland athletes to MD. Now most of the in-district kids ,who are on the fence between the schools, are ending up at Central, which wasn't the case until the last 10 or so years, and the Highland kids are staying with Warnecke in Highland.

They've taken more than their fair share of multi-sport athletes from Carlyle, Wesclin, Highland, and even schools like Triad, Centralia and Mt. Vernon etc.
D1 volleyball player transferred in from Edwardsville this year, best basketball player this year lives in O'Fallon, QB from Carlyle, most of the softball team from OOD just to give examples. 20 years ago when I was in high school, most of their athletes were in-district kids with a sprinkling from Wesclin/Carlyle. Not the case anymore.
 
Last edited:

Snetsrak61

Senior
Aug 16, 2008
1,215
685
113
That’s like saying all publics have the same constraints and benefits
There's wider tails on the public side, but yes they also have same "base" constraints and benefits.

Now of course there are constraints/benefits beyond how they enroll students but pretty much no one is actually digging into what those are and only focusing on backwards looking success. And that's the dumb part.
 

Snetsrak61

Senior
Aug 16, 2008
1,215
685
113
This can't even begin to be true. Population within the radius is what directly and mostly impacts a private school's ability to enjoy what you call "benefits."

It may be true for Montini and Chicago Christian in a sense, I guess, but it is not even remotely close to true with (one example) SHG and Routt.

"Each private school" may play under the same constraints, but they do not all benefit the same from them... This to me is yet another example of the lumping together of all private schools that seems to be done every time this topic arises. Again, as said by many every year... just as public school districts vary around the state, those variations exist amongst the private schools as well. Most notably, and importantly, by way of population within the radius they draw students from.

I understand most public school folks don't care... but you all use the word "fair" and "fairness" at nauseum... so in regards to privates, don't mind them keeping you in check with how "unfair" the rules, and proposals, tend to be in their direction, most especially to those private schools not reaping the same benefits as those causing the outrage to begin with.
I can definitely appreciate the specific example brought up about population. Of course I think even that constraint is nuanced. A school like Rice/Marist pulling from the same neighborhood cuts into the density they benefit from in that radius. If you accounted for both density and competition within that radius I suspect it would even out a bit in most cases.

I'm all for exploring what systemic advantages exist, but almost always the solution is merely success based. And that I'll never agree with.

Granted I root for a successful football school, but I also feel that way about the sports they aren't successful about. And I felt that about them when we weren't successful. Opportunity existed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roamin' Catholic
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football FREE Video 2A: Wilmington 49 Peotone 27
  2. 02 The Wolverine Football Recruiting From The Road: Intel on Michigan's top Chicagoland recruits
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football Video 8A: Mount Carmel 21 LW East 16
  4. 04 Edgy Tim Football Week 14 EDGYTIM Chicagoland Top 30
  5. 05 SpartanMag Football Michigan State HC Pat Fitzgerald gives health update on Alessio Milivojevic