Is El-Sayed the most intelligent senator we have ever had?

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,611
3,661
113
He's a perfectly bright guy, but... credentials =/= intelligence.

And candidly, whenever I meet docs who stop practicing medicine, for me personally, they're sitting on strike 2, as they're usually either a bad doctor or a bad person
 

m.knox

All-American
Aug 20, 2003
6,410
6,207
113
He's a perfectly bright guy, but... credentials =/= intelligence.

And candidly, whenever I meet docs who stop practicing medicine, for me personally, they're sitting on strike 2.

Anyone who claims that "hurt people hurt people" is a total idiot. He's making excuses for violence. Typical intersectional nonsense. It's almost like blaming a rape victim for looking too good. And that's going to be a senator........
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fasteddie24

SB_SB

All-Conference
Dec 17, 2022
2,422
3,893
113
You realize that public schools, police, highways, mail, libraries are all socialist policies, right? Do you want to get rid of all those?

So your argument is that we're not a Democracy but rather we're already a Socialist government so going farther left is a good thing?

You're argument is stupid and follows all the BS that's been stated by MAGA for the last 10 years. I'm against going far right and I'm also against going far left. You're trying to justify being far left.
 

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,718
7,582
113
He's a perfectly bright guy, but... credentials =/= intelligence.

And candidly, whenever I meet docs who stop practicing medicine, for me personally, they're sitting on strike 2, as they're usually either a bad doctor or a bad person

Well in Sayed's case he never started practicing medicine,.. So where does that land him?
 

SB_SB

All-Conference
Dec 17, 2022
2,422
3,893
113
Well in Sayed's case he never started practicing medicine,.. So where does that land him?

If you're a doctor who wants free medical for all, wouldn't you start by providing free medical yourself. Or is it a case where he wants me to pay for free medical for all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fasteddie24

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,611
3,661
113
Well in Sayed's case he never started practicing medicine,.. So where does that land him?
Probably, thrown out of the game for giving the ump the stinkeye as you step into the batters box, without even getting to see strikes one and two.

It's sort of like being a student who gets trained on nothing but AI, and so is never exposed to the outliers of the human condition that help one develop judgment that an actual doctor (or lawyer, or any other profession) exercises. As much as we might think someone who has learned the median to be "smart", they're not generally the people you want handling your affairs.

All that said, there are no job qualifications for house or senate, other than citizenship, residence, and age.
 

ClemsonInAtlanta

All-Conference
Jan 20, 2019
1,285
2,071
113
Cool? He was crying a week ago about how mommy and daddy didn’t wuv on him.
So? It’s cool to be in tune with your emotions. When you can’t handle your emotions we end up with people like Trump who throw tantrums by terrorizing the American public and ordering a Gestapo force to murder innocent citizens in broad daylight and kidnap immigrants
 

SB_SB

All-Conference
Dec 17, 2022
2,422
3,893
113
Probably, thrown out of the game for giving the ump the stinkeye as you step into the batters box, without even getting to see strikes one and two.

It's sort of like being a student who gets trained on nothing but AI, and so is never exposed to the outliers of the human condition that help one develop judgment that an actual doctor (or lawyer, or any other profession) exercises. As much as we might think someone who has learned the median to be "smart", they're not generally the people you want handling your affairs.

All that said, there are no job qualifications for house or senate, other than citizenship, residence, and age.

Remember 20 years ago when a few people took flying lessons but didn't care about learning to land. Why would someone go through medical school and never intend to land a job in that field.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fasteddie24

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
If you're a doctor who wants free medical for all, wouldn't you start by providing free medical yourself. Or is it a case where he wants me to pay for free medical for all.
Oh no no no. That’s the taxpayers responsibility. They never put their money or services where their virtue signaling mouths are.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,063
5,730
113
Remember 20 years ago when a few people took flying lessons but didn't care about learning to land. Why would someone go through medical school and never intend to land a job in that field.

There are plenty of researches who have MD+PHD's, as an example. Or people who go into public policy.
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,611
3,661
113
Remember 20 years ago when a few people took flying lessons but didn't care about learning to land. Why would someone go through medical school and never intend to land a job in that field.
it's kind of a form of masturbation - you have to really get off on people calling you 'doctor'
 

SB_SB

All-Conference
Dec 17, 2022
2,422
3,893
113
There are plenty of researches who have MD+PHD's, as an example. Or people who go into public policy.

Doing research is part of the field. I do not believe there is plenty of people.

Let me ask you something. Does it raise a red flag when someone wants flying lessons but doesn't care to learn to land?

Does it raise a red flag when someone wants to learn about the study of biology (cells, DNA, etc) and then has a PHD in Epidemiology (study of diseases, biological agents, social conditions, etc) and then has a M.D.. And at the end of all of that, they choose to never actually put it to use to help others (landing the plane). But instead decided to go into politics to gain access to the cockpit. Maybe that's not a red flag, I'll let you decide.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,063
5,730
113
Doing research is part of the field. I do not believe there is plenty of people.

Let me ask you something. Does it raise a red flag when someone wants flying lessons but doesn't care to learn to land?

Does it raise a red flag when someone wants to learn about the study of biology (cells, DNA, etc) and then has a PHD in Epidemiology (study of diseases, biological agents, social conditions, etc) and then has a M.D.. And at the end of all of that, they choose to never actually put it to use to help others (landing the plane). But instead decided to go into politics to gain access to the cockpit. Maybe that's not a red flag, I'll let you decide.

This metaphor is too tortured for me to engage with, sorry.
 

dpic73

Heisman
Jul 27, 2005
37,327
35,109
113
Well in Sayed's case he never started practicing medicine,.. So where does that land him?
It lands him as a qualified, respected public health official. Are you claiming he must be suspect because he didn't choose to become licensed to practice medicine? He still has excellent credentials, so what are you implying? He has a hella lot more medical qualifications than our current top public health official who has NONE.

"El-Sayed holds an MD, or doctor of medicine degree, from Columbia University. He also holds a doctorate in public health from Oxford University.

After completing his degree at Columbia, El-Sayed opted to enter the public health field instead of pursuing a medical residency, which is a requirement for obtaining a license to practice medicine.

El-Sayed served as the director of Detroit’s health department and later as the director of Wayne County’s health department."


 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,063
5,730
113
Simply asked a question, do you see it as a red flag? But instead you don't want to think about it. That''s your choice.

Do I see it as a red flag that someone got a degree that they didn't use the way you want? Not especially. I don't look back at a person's history with the expectation they did everything precisely how I personally would want them to. He's a lot closer to me than the Republican was so I'm glad he won that Senate race. Beyond that, I don't think I'm going to think too much more about the particulars of this guy's resume unless he runs for President.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,063
5,730
113
It lands him as a qualified, respected public health official. Are you claiming he must be suspect because he didn't choose to become licensed to practice medicine? He still has excellent credentials, so what are you implying? He has a hella lot more medical qualifications than our current top public health official who has NONE.

"El-Sayed holds an MD, or doctor of medicine degree, from Columbia University. He also holds a doctorate in public health from Oxford University.

After completing his degree at Columbia, El-Sayed opted to enter the public health field instead of pursuing a medical residency, which is a requirement for obtaining a license to practice medicine.

El-Sayed served as the director of Detroit’s health department and later as the director of Wayne County’s health department."



Oh wow, so he's an MD-PHD just look I suggested as a viable path earlier. @SB_SB and @Aardvark86, I hope you're catching this.
 

SB_SB

All-Conference
Dec 17, 2022
2,422
3,893
113
Oh wow, so he's an MD-PHD just look I suggested as a viable path earlier. @SB_SB and @Aardvark86, I hope you're catching this.

I already said he was a PHD and that was part of my point. Maybe you're having a problem reading. As I used to say to the MAGA's about trump, Don't Look Up.
 

PapaGanoush

All-Conference
Dec 7, 2025
732
1,029
93
So? It’s cool to be in tune with your emotions. When you can’t handle your emotions we end up with people like Trump who throw tantrums by terrorizing the American public and ordering a Gestapo force to murder innocent citizens in broad daylight and kidnap immigrants
Holy Celine Dion dramatic.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,063
5,730
113
I already said he was a PHD and that was part of my point. Maybe you're having a problem reading. As I used to say to the MAGA's about trump, Don't Look Up.

And what I'm getting at is that MD-PhDs exist and it's a very grueling path to do precisely what AES seems to have done. So no, not red flag at all on this topic.
 

coldbud1994

All-American
Jan 18, 2005
4,008
6,493
112
Well in Sayed's case he never started practicing medicine,.. So where does that land him?
He went into public health. Not everyone with a medical degree practices medicine. Some are researchers, academics, public health administrators, etc:

Career in public health​

Public health professor​

In 2014, El-Sayed joined the faculty at the Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health as an assistant professor in the epidemiology department. He served as director of Columbia's Systems Science Program and Global Research Analytics for Population Health.[32] He created and taught the Mailman School's first course on systems science and population health.[26] El-Sayed and Sandro Galea co-edited a textbook on the topic, Systems Science and Population Health, published in 2017 by Oxford University Press.[33]

Health director of Detroit​

In August 2015, Mayor Mike Duggan appointed El-Sayed Health Officer and Executive Director of the Detroit Health Department, making him, at 30 years old, the youngest health officer in a major U.S. city at the time. In that role, he was charged with rebuilding the Detroit Health Department after government public health activities were provided by a nonprofit when the city went bankrupt in 2013.[32]

In his first year as director, he led efforts to oppose increases in sulfur dioxide emissions by Marathon Petroleum's Southwest Refinery, which resulted in reductions in overall emissions.[34] He also led efforts to test Detroit schools for lead in the wake of the Flint water crisis and to increase funding for the city's Animal Control department.[35][36][37][38]

El-Sayed was appointed to the governor's statewide Childhood Lead Elimination Board.[39] He also served on the State of Michigan's Public Health Advisory Commission and the advisory committee to the US Secretary of Health and Human Services for the Healthy People program.[40][41]
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Evening Clemson Football Insider
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Clemson Football Insider
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Graham Neff: 'What drives winning is different now'
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Basketball Thursday Dillon Hunter Update
  5. 05 On3 Football House working on small revisions of Protect College Sports Act before vote