IHSA By-Law Proposals Posted

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
830
588
93
All of those things are subjective and based on what each family feels. Parents aren't going to pull their kids out of LWW and send them to Provi just because they're no longer in the IHSA.
Mostly no.

Example:
Doesn't matter what your feelings are, Loyola is a better school and football program than Lisle.
 
Jun 29, 2020
335
331
63
Mostly no.

Example:
Doesn't matter what your feelings are, Loyola is a better school and football program than Lisle.
But is Loyola a better instiution than New Trier, Glenbrook South, Glenbrook North? Loyola gets city kids and kids that grew up going to Catholic Elementary Schools.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4Afan

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
830
588
93
I am understanding. These donor are already giving money to schools. They most likely already are providing scholarhips to these schools (yes academic and needs based ones which are alowed).

Alumni and families are already paying tuition under the table for athletes.

You dont think if this Private State League gets set up that they wont have scholarship rules? You dont think these Religious institutions run by Priests/Pastors/Nuns will want to keep their standards?

Have you worked at a private school? I know for a fact some donors are off hands from athletics. These institutions rely on their money to go to the instution not athletics that is not going to change.

The IHSA, its schools, coaches, athletes and families would be just fine without the Private Schools.
Yes, I have loads of experience at private schools both at the HS and college levels. The bad ones dictate that the money has to go to the institution and not athletics.

North Central and Mt. Carmel don't operate this way.
 
Jun 29, 2020
335
331
63
Yes, I have loads of experience at private schools both at the HS and college levels. The bad ones dictate that the money has to go to the institution and not athletics.

North Central and Mt. Carmel don't operate this way.
So you are a bad institution if you focus on the institution and not athletics?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4Afan

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,199
4,599
113
I am understanding. These donor are already giving money to schools. They most likely already are providing scholarhips to these schools (yes academic and needs based ones which are alowed).

Alumni and families are already paying tuition under the table for athletes.

You dont think if this Private State League gets set up that they wont have scholarship rules? You dont think these Religious institutions run by Priests/Pastors/Nuns will want to keep their standards?

Have you worked at a private school? I know for a fact some donors are off hands from athletics. These institutions rely on their money to go to the instution not athletics that is not going to change.

The IHSA, its schools, coaches, athletes and families would be just fine without the Private Schools.
Don't you dare try to talk logic and reasoning around here!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spartanfball9

good_nocall

Freshman
Jun 29, 2001
119
86
27
Are you saying the quality of HS sports is much lower than what it was 20 years ago? If so, It's the exact opposite.
Yes, that is what I'm saying, and I could not disagree with you more ... again, I might make an exception for football. Basketball, it's not even close. And I have intimate knowledge of the past 30 years in it.
 

OnVikings!

Senior
Nov 15, 2024
364
562
87
I'm not sure I understand this statement. Are you saying that nobody will be drawn to the IHSA events if the private schools aren't part of it?
Im saying the IHSA and its members stand to lose ALOT of attention, revenue, followers, referees, fans, athletes, parents, etc. if the private schools leave and do their own thing. To be clear, that’s not what I want to happen or what I think will happen. The IHSA and its voting members are aware of this regardless of how loud the crying gets.
 
Aug 7, 2024
1,211
757
113
This may be the one of the few proposals that I don't hate beside the common sense one on flag football. No way a soccer team should be playing 25 regular season games, and most don't.

It only makes sense if you win a ton of blowouts and can give a ton of minutes to 2nd string. Good rule to protect against unscrupulous coaches.
I can see the proposal but if Baseball can play 30+ games why can soccer play 25?
 
Aug 7, 2024
1,211
757
113
This is an expense reduction action especially now that shot clock operators also have to be paid in basketball. And the suburban conferences can no longer collude to fix the cost they pay officials across the board.

Secondarily, it's a way to relieve the difficulty in finding officials (just because officials might be on every game doesn't mean there isn't a shortage).

As an official, I'd like to see teams take more practice time and get better by having fewer games as well. The quality of the game may improve.
So whats happening today that didnt happen in the 80s when teams played 25-30 basketball games? Athletes are obviously not the same as the Boomer generation but they are better physically, maybe not mentally... So reducing games makes them better how?
 
Aug 7, 2024
1,211
757
113
Not necessarily. Those private schools are going to end up somewhere, and that somewhere is in the upper third of all tournament brackets. There’s a reason that this stuff usually gets shut down. I’ve got a friend that’s an A.D. at a larger public school. Do you think the majority of 6A, 7A, and 8A football schools want to have their bracket flooded with more private schools? Same thing for 3A and 4A in all other sports. Not to mention the large number of public schools that run competent athletic programs and compete just fine. Not every private school is Mount Carmel, Loyola, etc. Most athletic administrators with a brain are able to realize that.
This is just one more chance to keep pubs/privates playing together. I think its a waste of time... Just separate now and move forward!~
 

good_nocall

Freshman
Jun 29, 2001
119
86
27
So whats happening today that didnt happen in the 80s when teams played 25-30 basketball games? Athletes are obviously not the same as the Boomer generation but they are better physically, maybe not mentally... So reducing games makes them better how?
Well, using basketball as the example, I think it gives an opportunity for teams to be fundamentally better ... free throw shooting, ability to handle the ball, set screens properly (and use the screen properly). Things that often there isn't practice time for currently once the season gets started, and things that aren't taught at all at the club and AAU level that used to be taught in the offseason at team and individual camps which are not as highly attended (because of club and AAU).
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlabamaTimberwolf
Aug 7, 2024
1,211
757
113
Well, using basketball as the example, I think it gives an opportunity for teams to be fundamentally better ... free throw shooting, ability to handle the ball, set screens properly (and use the screen properly). Things that often there isn't practice time for currently once the season gets started, and things that aren't taught at all at the club and AAU level that used to be taught in the offseason at team and individual camps which are not as highly attended (because of club and AAU).
But why are kids today lacking? We had to make 7 of 10 free throws or run sprints for every FT missed... On top of our normal conditioning. Playing defense was like breathing... Today's game lacks but changing things will not be easy mainly due to the weak mentality of the kids. I believe the product is forever going to weaker.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 4Afan
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football Watch Live Tonight: WJOL Pigskin Preview
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football Video: EDGY Thoughts on Class 8A
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football Video: EDGY Thoughts on Class 7A
  4. 04 Edgy Tim Football Video: EDGY Thoughts on Class 6A
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football Video: EDGY Thoughts on Class 5A