Thoughts on Playoff 1st Round Byes

drop_tables

All-Conference
Aug 14, 2004
4,817
1,850
113
I've heard multiple people say it. Every year, it seems like the HS Football season goes by faster and faster..
So, what do you think of the top seeds getting Byes in the first round?
Personally, I hate it. It gives fans 1 less week to enjoy watching their team on an already seemingly short season.
If one of the idea's of going 8 classes was to give more schools a chance to make the playoffs, then just fully flesh out the first round.
 

portcity FB

Senior
Nov 8, 2004
5,335
969
62
I do not like the bye week. In 8A you have the 5-12 seeds playing this week to have the right to play the top 4 seeds. They will usually come into that game as a big underdog and probably a bit more banged up and worn down, and on the road. The reward for being a high seed is home field advantage and playing lower seeds. That should be enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 80prepster

80prepster

Sophomore
Sep 26, 2025
193
193
43
I do not like the bye week. In 8A you have the 5-12 seeds playing this week to have the right to play the top 4 seeds. They will usually come into that game as a big underdog and probably a bit more banged up and worn down, and on the road. The reward for being a high seed is home field advantage and playing lower seeds. That should be enough.
As a 2A school fan, I do not like byes! It breaks up momentum and the rhythm of the season. Schools with 1-3 wins at best should not be in the state playoffs, as winning should be a requisite for participation not a guarantee.
 

portcity FB

Senior
Nov 8, 2004
5,335
969
62
This weeks bye may really hurt Millbrook. They win by forfeit last week now they have a bye and they will play either Laney or PC next week. I have seen both of those teams and that game will be over by halftime. Millbrook may be entering their third round game against Rolesville with their starters playing maybe 2 quarters over the past 3 weeks. They may be a bit rusty. Now, if Millbrook is banged up then the time off may help them.
 

BallKnower1995

Freshman
Jul 11, 2025
95
67
18
This weeks bye may really hurt Millbrook. They win by forfeit last week now they have a bye and they will play either Laney or PC next week. I have seen both of those teams and that game will be over by halftime. Millbrook may be entering their third round game against Rolesville with their starters playing maybe 2 quarters over the past 3 weeks. They may be a bit rusty. Now, if Millbrook is banged up then the time off may help them.
Their defense will show up and be ready to play regardless
 

Anon1778766900

Redshirt
May 14, 2026
17
21
3
The only way to not have byes is to cut the field to 32 teams (East and West 16 team brackets). In order for matchups to happen each week there has to be someone to play. If all 24 teams played week 1 the bracket would be all messed up. Brackets have to be either 4, 8, 16, or 32. It wouldn't line up otherwise. Because it's 24 you have to run a 32 team bracket which gives top 8 a bye.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CPC4LIFE3

sec2011

Redshirt
Nov 4, 2011
173
24
18
This weeks bye may really hurt Millbrook. They win by forfeit last week now they have a bye and they will play either Laney or PC next week. I have seen both of those teams and that game will be over by halftime. Millbrook may be entering their third round game against Rolesville with their starters playing maybe 2 quarters over the past 3 weeks. They may be a bit rusty. Now, if Millbrook is banged up then the time off may help them.
Think Millbrook takes it a little different approach then others when it comes to games being over at halftime with the running clock. Late in the Wakefield game during the 3rd Millbrook up 52-0 and starters still in. Got to get those stats in I guess.
 

Goldendomer10

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2022
1,038
1,897
86
The only way to not have byes is to cut the field to 32 teams (East and West 16 team brackets). In order for matchups to happen each week there has to be someone to play. If all 24 teams played week 1 the bracket would be all messed up. Brackets have to be either 4, 8, 16, or 32. It wouldn't line up otherwise. Because it's 24 you have to run a 32 team bracket which gives top 8 a bye.
Reducing the field and removing the byes is what they should do.

I guarantee you 99% of the 2-8, 1-9 teams that get in are ready to move onto wrestling, basketball, winter track. The last “cherry on top” they want for their season is a 2-3 hour ride for - 50 point loss.
 

Mr Honda

All-Conference
Nov 12, 2012
2,496
1,379
113
The only way to not have byes is to cut the field to 32 teams (East and West 16 team brackets). In order for matchups to happen each week there has to be someone to play. If all 24 teams played week 1 the bracket would be all messed up. Brackets have to be either 4, 8, 16, or 32. It wouldn't line up otherwise. Because it's 24 you have to run a 32 team bracket which gives top 8 a bye.
Then cut the field.
 

CPC4LIFE3

Senior
Jul 31, 2010
2,154
809
113
Do you guys realize that the NChSAA has 3 teams in this years 2026 playoffs that went 0-10…They made the playoffs in 1A. How dumb is that?

8A actually has it right with the 24 team field with only 4 byes for the East and the West. 8A just needs some of those 7A teams to move up In the future. Games start getting really good in the 2nd Rd… the 1st rd. has a couple interesting games.

2A- 7A fields have way too many byes( terrible matchups in 1st & 2nd Rd) I will say the 3rd, and 4th Rd of 7A is better than any other division.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vik-Val 86

K84

Junior
Jul 7, 2025
383
377
63
Do you guys realize that the NChSAA has 3 teams in this years 2026 playoffs that went 0-10…They made the playoffs in 1A. How dumb is that?

8A actually has it right with the 24 team field with only 4 byes for the East and the West. 8A just needs some of those 7A teams to move up In the future. Games start getting really good in the 2nd Rd… the 1st rd. has a couple interesting games.

2A- 7A fields have way too many byes( terrible matchups in 1st & 2nd Rd) I will say the 3rd, and 4th Rd of 7A is better than any other division.
Weldon one of the 1A teams who hadn’t won a game all year won their playoff game last night. 16-8
 
  • Like
Reactions: Naquedskwirrels

Vik-Val 86

All-American
May 20, 2020
10,277
8,784
113
Does anyone know how many schools will be built in the next 4 years. I know Weathers Creek will open in fall of 2027. But with that South Iredell and Lake Norman will lose some students. This most likely will change up how the conference will look.
 

Kylar24

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2003
5,968
1,338
113
Mooresville, Lake Norman, and South Iredell will be impacted by the new school. Heck even Statesville will lose a few students to the new school. I can see all 3 dropping to 6A-5A line while Weathers Creek would be a 5A or 6A school
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vik-Val 86
NC Preps

Latest

  1. 01 NC Preps Two Class of 2028 Quarterbacks to Watch
  2. 02 NC Preps Three Class of 2028 X-Factors to Know
  3. 03 NC Preps Deana's Playoff Picks - Round 3
  4. 04 NC Preps Class of 2029 Versatile Prospects Ready to Shine
  5. 05 NC Preps Deana's Playoff Picks - Round 2