I’m Granting Greg Schiano a Mulligan for 2026
- Thread starter rutgersal_rivals139582
- Start date
There are no more collectives, NIL comes from businesses only now. Another swing and miss.
UMass had a quality quarterback because they paid up for one from the portal. We raided the bargain bin. QB play was the biggest difference in the game, as theirs was 10x better than ours.
I have a very fulfilling social life and am not lonely.
I’m here because I love Rutgers and I love Coach Schiano and I hate seeing a good coach get railroaded because the fanbase isn’t motivated enough to support success.
I’m just getting started
he hasn’t been getting enough NIL support which is the biggest reason we don’t win.
Sure it is. We don’t have a quality we yet and that was the biggest difference in those games,
Yet UMass had a quality quarterback, which was the biggest difference in the game.
Everyone else has a quality indoor facility but us. That’s why the best in jersey go elsewhere. Kai Pritchard, recruited since freshman year, flees as soon as he gets an Illinois offer. Lookup their facility on YouTube. Every other place is serious. This place is Amateur Hour.
When things are going bad, every sin you’ve committed will be held against you.
Greggy had 25 million
He went got Gavin worst QB ever at RU
He went and got Lonerghan
He had Surace for 3 years
Your point on QB is correct but Greggy is just god awful at his job that’s why we don’t have one.
Plant post by Keli to see the reactions? Lol.
Forget about the lack of talent that GS brought in, we got out coached in the 1st 2 games.
JH had his team prepped. We looked like we showed up to a final exam without any studying or knowledge of the subject against UMASS.
Forget about the lack of talent that GS brought in, we got out coached in the 1st 2 games.
JH had his team prepped. We looked like we showed up to a final exam without any studying or knowledge of the subject against UMASS.
You live in an alternate reality
over $20M NIL, one of the most highly paid staffs, “vertical alignment” and manhandled by teeny Umass and outplayed by woeful BC.
but you are right, it is we fans who are the problem
Their DL manhandled our OL
Their OL manhandled our DL
Their coaches out schemed us
They players were more physical
They recrutied their QB, we recruited ours
They had seemingly better portal adds with way less money
OK- that kind of proves the point. If UMass could afford this QB - I am sure he is getting less than our 2 starting QB's. And what about them having WR's our DB's could not stay withing 5 yards of- and both of their lines domination ours?
What says $25M to you?
- The portal DBs who can’t cover
- The portal LBs who lack range
- The portal DEs who can’t set the edge or rush the passer
- The portal OL who barely sees the field
- The portal QB who keeps throwing the ball to the other team.
if this were a $25M roster, we’d be 2-0.
Beat me to it. What does it say that UMass with their lack of financial support, NIL, resources, facilities etc…can go out and not only attract a better qb candidate but be able to turnover their entire roster in 1 year? That their coaches can evaluate better talent through the same portal process we have access with less manpower and support.
Very few players are getting the payday that is reported. Very few teams are spending the money that was reported prior. UMass qb is getting a fraction of what Rutgers is paying our QB’s. Greg had access to the same people over the years at the same price. His evaluation process obviously prioritizes different metrics, people and things. He chose to maintain the false premise of “developmental program.”
Crediting them for signing Watson? Didn't RU sign Lonergan instead? What am I missing? Wouldn't this mean RU went after the wrong QB in the offseason? How is that not Schiano's fault?
Their qb significantly outplayed ours. Their WR was a transfer from Wisconsin. Our DB who couldn’t cover him was from South Dakota. Whom do you think is worth more.
Virginia signed Beau Pribula for $1.5M because that’s what serious teams do. Schiano worked within the budget constraints and obviously was not successful, so it’s his fault. It’s easier to make mistakes with a smaller budget. Had Schiano signed Beau Pribula instead, we’d be 2-0.
You are just plain wrong here sorry. We have a lot of losses for our $20M and how can you actually say that going from $20M to $25M makes us better when Umass was clearly better with $3M. ND State would beat us easily with practically no money or facilities and year 1 in FBS.
BC and UMass were a combined 2-22 last year with considerably fewer resources. Losing those games is a coaching problem.
Not necessarily. We'd still have these coaches. The Rockne Of The Raritan was thoroughly outclassed by Harysmiak and O'Brien.
Exactly where was this analysis pre season? Where was this analysis when he was making his bold predictions? Crazy!!! Was saying a couple of months ago now that Greg has the support and money to build a roster there will be noticeable difference. Now denying the money being reported by everyone involved even Kelli.
I was got by GS, and his mulligan was last season. This off-season, he looked relaxed, and ready for the season, had vibes of '05, with TJ saying the right things also, but currently sitting at 0-2. We should be 2-0 atm, we knew we had to replace AK, but AJS is still on roster, AR in the backfield and the OL coming back, not sure why he got DL. The defenses under his watch are usually very solid, wtf happened? Why are we getting players from FCS/1-AA, while UMass is getting players from P4 benches? By all metrics, we should at least be a 7-9 win program annually, with chances at double digit wins. This past off-season, it sucked watching Chesney go to UCLA to be the hc, Nate Woody go to Cincinnati to be the dc, watching a few of our players go to other schools like UVa and Cal.
We have too many coaches, like 100+, while most others have between 50-70 staff max. Where is the NIL going? Why are his sons on staff? What are their qualifications by this point? That meme picture of GS talking to junior GS, had the vibes of GS telling him he's grounded and not a hc ripping into his QB coach. Instead of cosplaying as a P2 team, he should worry about actually being one. I have more but don't want to lose my cool and possibly get banned. Why should I even get a sub to this forum when RU and it's HC are not serious about winning? This program is pathetic right now. $18 million buyout and RU can't afford that, that's sad. Until GS won 8+ games, he should not have been extended. Can we get JH to come back as hc? Are we able to lure in a coach like Bob Chesney? I would take Dabo if Clemson got rid of him. Last season seemed like the perfect time to strike, but we left at least 3 wins on the field, mainly due to atrocious defense. I like GS, he actually graduates players, and brought us back twice, but he is like burning it down right now. Maybe he would do better next year, don't know, but some changes have to be made. I want to see what Mrs. Zinn, our LSU transfer AD, will have him do to start making changes in the program. This program has no fire, no focus, and no desire to rise up. GS had nothing but his grin on Friday night, and I was not impressed. At the very least we outscored our opponents in the 2nd half, there's that.
I follow USC for my buddy from the Corps, and I wanted to tell him about a competitive game, that's out the freaking window. I don't give up, but doing the same thing expecting different results is the very definition of insanity. I believe Einstein said that, could be wrong.
Al, while I appreciate your enthusiasm, please, STFU and open your eyes. The forest hasn't been this thick in decades, you don't appreciate how much chopping has to be done. UMass beat us with 6-7x less NIL than we have, inexcusable, and those players showed up this past off-season while GS was chasing 1-AA make a wish players. This ain't right
We have too many coaches, like 100+, while most others have between 50-70 staff max. Where is the NIL going? Why are his sons on staff? What are their qualifications by this point? That meme picture of GS talking to junior GS, had the vibes of GS telling him he's grounded and not a hc ripping into his QB coach. Instead of cosplaying as a P2 team, he should worry about actually being one. I have more but don't want to lose my cool and possibly get banned. Why should I even get a sub to this forum when RU and it's HC are not serious about winning? This program is pathetic right now. $18 million buyout and RU can't afford that, that's sad. Until GS won 8+ games, he should not have been extended. Can we get JH to come back as hc? Are we able to lure in a coach like Bob Chesney? I would take Dabo if Clemson got rid of him. Last season seemed like the perfect time to strike, but we left at least 3 wins on the field, mainly due to atrocious defense. I like GS, he actually graduates players, and brought us back twice, but he is like burning it down right now. Maybe he would do better next year, don't know, but some changes have to be made. I want to see what Mrs. Zinn, our LSU transfer AD, will have him do to start making changes in the program. This program has no fire, no focus, and no desire to rise up. GS had nothing but his grin on Friday night, and I was not impressed. At the very least we outscored our opponents in the 2nd half, there's that.
I follow USC for my buddy from the Corps, and I wanted to tell him about a competitive game, that's out the freaking window. I don't give up, but doing the same thing expecting different results is the very definition of insanity. I believe Einstein said that, could be wrong.
Al, while I appreciate your enthusiasm, please, STFU and open your eyes. The forest hasn't been this thick in decades, you don't appreciate how much chopping has to be done. UMass beat us with 6-7x less NIL than we have, inexcusable, and those players showed up this past off-season while GS was chasing 1-AA make a wish players. This ain't right
How is that a money problem?
UMass certainly didnt have more money to get a QB than Rutgers.
Plus we have Surace - who is an excellent QB and arguably should have been ready last year.
At least according to some posters.
That's a talent evaluation problem.
Or a QB development problem.
Basically, its everything except money regarding UMass and BC.
Surace - Forums
Looking forward to how he develops but curious to know from those that went to the spring game, how tall does he look? On tv he looked on the short side like he’s under 6 feet. Am I far off? GO RU
"Surace is going to be our Doug Flutie"
"
People are sleeping on AJ Surace, but not RutgersAl. I think he’s going to be our best Quarterback EVER, though this year, he will hold a clipboard and acclimate to this level of football, as the league he played in wasn’t that great. He’ll have plenty of time to watch film, learn the playbook, develop chemistry with his wide receivers on the scout team, get stronger, and get used to the speed of the game. He’s already on campus training.
Next year, he’ll be ready to go."
(Note this is from 2024. Meaning he should be ready to go for 2026)
"Love Wimsatt.
Wimsatt is Wimsatt, but Surace is going to be the GOAT.
"
Last edited:
It sounds like you’re saying the Athletic Director is lying?
Judging from Lonergan's performance, he chose the wrong QB to be the starter, though I doubt Surace would have been any better. If Watson was here, he would have been as bad as Lonergan was. His running ability certainly wouldn't have been utilized. The bad performance of both RU QBs is a coaching problem.
Last edited:
I have heard about the singing video as well in passing, but thankfully have never seen it
Come on Al, you are getting silly even for you. Watson had attempted only 63 passes and 54 rush attempts at Virginia Tech before going to UMass. His NIL deal is $123.7K. Your argument would be better if you claimed they had no tape or scouting report and UMass chose to sign him because they had nothing to lose. You just keep blathering nonsense that nobody but you believes.
"William Watson III is a 6' 0" 210 lbs Senior Quarterback for Massachusetts and is listed by ESPN from Springfield, MA. William Watson III ranks 1st within the current Massachusetts football roster. The modeled value is $123.7K, with $321K allocated to reconcile the sport pool."
William Watson III NIL Value $153K | Massachusetts
William Watson III, a 6' 0" 210 lbs Senior Quarterback at Massachusetts: season stats, career and transfer history, recent games, news, recruiting background, and a $94K to $153K NIL market estimate.
thesideline.co
rumarine:
did the marines teach you to repeat the same mistakes? Obviously not.
What you’re saying is true, but we don’t play BC or UMass anymore. we need to make sure we have an adequate NIL budget, so we don’t repeat the mistakes of the past. We need a Big Ten NIL budget because we need players good enough for the Big Ten. We need to be competitive with PSU, Maryland, Wisconsin, Michigan, USC, and Nebraska.
if we don’t have budget, it’s not worth to make the change. You only make the change if you are going to end up better off then you were before. That takes money.
Come to me with facts. The estimate you provided means nothing to me.Come on Al, you are getting silly even for you. Watson had attempted only 63 passes and 54 rush attempts at Virginia Tech before going to UMass. His NIL deal is $123.7K. Your argument would be better if you claimed they had no tape or scouting report and UMass chose to sign him because they had nothing to lose. You just keep blathering nonsense that nobody but you believes.
"William Watson III is a 6' 0" 210 lbs Senior Quarterback for Massachusetts and is listed by ESPN from Springfield, MA. William Watson III ranks 1st within the current Massachusetts football roster. The modeled value is $123.7K, with $321K allocated to reconcile the sport pool."
William Watson III NIL Value $153K | Massachusetts
William Watson III, a 6' 0" 210 lbs Senior Quarterback at Massachusetts: season stats, career and transfer history, recent games, news, recruiting background, and a $94K to $153K NIL market estimate.
Here is your problem Al.
Your arguments comparing to the rest of the Big Ten make at least minimal sense.
People (many) may disagree but nobody can say more money wouldnt make us more competitive.
The problem is when you apply that to UMass and BC.
Saying they have more talent and blaming money (overall roster spend: revenue share + NIL) for the talent disparity.
Any talent disparity is 100% on Schiano and poor talent evaluation.
They have better QBs? That's because Schiano poorly selected Lonergan and poorly developed Surace.
No matter how much you only want "facts" on spending - even you can't believe UMass and BC "spent" more than Rutgers on their football rosters.
Latest
-
01
The Knight Report Football
College Football 27 Sim - Rutgers Football versus USC Trojans
-
02
The Knight Report
Join The Knight Report TODAY for $1 and get 50% off!
-
03
The Knight Report Football
Rutgers ranks 14th in Big Ten in estimated roster spending, 46th nationally
-
04
The Knight Report
The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: September 16th Edition
-
05
The Knight Report Football
ESPN FPI projects Rutgers Football's 2026 schedule - Week Two