Sorry for the long post here, but I hope some will read my thoughts...
Usually, when there are at least 2 sides to every story and situation, the truth lies "somewhere in between" the two most polar opposites.
We're all very passionate about Kentucky basketball. We want to succeed at the highest level. That said, when CCC left like a thief in the night, I was happy. Happy that a$$ clown was gone and took his attitude and philosophy that was dragging us down was finally gone, it had to end.
The vast majority of fans can plainly see CCC isn't what he used to be and had to go for what he was doing here at Kentucky. Fair enough. It was well overdue by the time it happened in my book, and he's gone - thankfully. So we had to move on.
But to go from CCC and having an A.D. who turns around and hires ...... Mark Pope ?!?! I mean, seriously you go from CCC and your first thought and hire is - Mark Pope ?!?!??
Disturbingly alarming, red flags waving and, just holy begeebuz, batman.....
I mean, c'mon. That decision ( and all subsequent blame / anger ) needs to be directed at Barney.
Coach Pope inherited the most difficult coaching situation imaginable here. That he has even had us competitive considering the injuries he has had to deal with over the past 2 years is a small miracle.
I'm not saying Coach Pope doesn't deserve criticism, I think he would be the first one to honestly appraise his situation here as unsustainable, and that this year is definitely a make or break season for him.
Personally, he has held up pretty well, considering everything. Criticism is deserved, but not going overboard with it. The main things to concern oneself here is :
1. Everything begins with recruiting and obtaining talent thru the portal that is a good fit and provides good chemistry. Pope has had a disturbing problem getting top tier 5 star talent from the high school ranks which should never be the case here at Kentucky. He's done pretty well working the portal. But is struggling closing 5 star players.
So from this perspective, he needs to really do a much better job in order to stay coach here. Period.
2. Results. His first two teams surely would have had much better results if injuries hadn't derailed everything. The problem is, two seasons in a row is an unsustainable trajectory, along with the results in his recruiting.
Both of these things need to change and NOW - this season. Otherwise, we're not going anywhere in the immediate future - just maintaining the status quo.
So here we are waiting on seeing what his third year will produce.
I know everyone is hoping we will have a good year, can we finish with LESS than 10+ losses and finish with a better ending than a sweet sixteen appearance?
This team should - at the very least - make the sweet sixteen this year. Ten+ losses ? Maybe, maybe not. If it's 8 - 9 and a deep run in March to an elite eight ?
Is that enough to keep him?
It's a tall ask but it is doable.
If it doesn't happen, we need to move on, but for God's sakes, I hope J Batt can clearly see we need a better option than to immediately turn to a Mark Pope level coaching change.
I say rally the wagons and support the team, quit the incessant bickering and hateful arguing. Make a positive contribution if you are going to criticize, then let it be in a constructive manner instead of merely venting. And I'm not directing anything to anyone at all here.....
If the results of the ensuing season aren't satisfactory, then we need to move on once again. It's not time to cut and bail now, but at some point, we need to cinch up our belt and pick ourselves up by the bootstraps and get it done here. Now is that time.
This is Kentucky. Basketball is what we do.
Have faith, try to stay positive, keep a good perspective and hold the AD and Coach to the highest standards that will bring us back to the success we have always had here.
We will see soon enough.