Forget Cal Poly - When Does Nelson Brands Sue to Get His Eligibility Back?

vhsalum

All-Conference
Nov 14, 2002
1,366
3,213
113
Great, lawyerly breakdown here. F'ing incredible that this judge isn't hung and quartered immediately.

 

DPJ1

Junior
Sep 15, 2017
129
380
63
Great, lawyerly breakdown here. F'ing incredible that this judge isn't hung and quartered immediately.

This judge has to be a Texas Tech alum, what a joke. Hopefully his ruling gets overturned when the NCAA appeals, but it's in Texas so who knows how that'll go.
 

vhsalum

All-Conference
Nov 14, 2002
1,366
3,213
113
This judge has to be a Texas Tech alum, what a joke. Hopefully his ruling gets overturned when the NCAA appeals, but it's in Texas so who knows how that'll go.
Alas, no.

UT at Arlington and Houston Law Center.

A complete quack acting like this is a typical job (where you can't fire people for mental health issues as long as they are seeking treatment).
 

Wrestleknownothing

All-American
Oct 30, 2021
1,933
5,048
113
Alas, no.

UT at Arlington and Houston Law Center.

A complete quack acting like this is a typical job (where you can't fire people for mental health issues as long as they are seeking treatment).
But all four judges in the court where they appealed ARE Texas Tech law school grads. So the NCAA has that to look forward too.
 
Last edited:

Wrestleknownothing

All-American
Oct 30, 2021
1,933
5,048
113
Weird times when I'm actually rooting for the NCAA to win a court case. College athletics are a mess and I don't think things are going to get any better unfortunately.
I agree, but there is also a degree of "chickens coming home to roost" here. The NCAA has fought long and hard to both treat sports as big business and deny that athletes are employees. If they were employees then these things would be collectively bargained (like they are in pro sports) and thereby not subject to state court litigation.
 

FanInBlack

All-Conference
Nov 9, 2001
2,164
4,615
113
I agree, but there is also a degree of "chickens coming home to roost" here. The NCAA has fought long and hard to both treat sports as big business and deny that athletes are employees. If they were employees then these things would be collectively bargained (like they are in pro sports) and thereby not subject to state court litigation.
yep.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wrestleknownothing

vhsalum

All-Conference
Nov 14, 2002
1,366
3,213
113
I agree, but there is also a degree of "chickens coming home to roost" here. The NCAA has fought long and hard to both treat sports as big business and deny that athletes are employees. If they were employees then these things would be collectively bargained (like they are in pro sports) and thereby not subject to state court litigation.
Yup.

And now they want Congress to save them. Which isn't likely to happen because the SEC and Big Ten vehemently oppose congressional oversight and want conferences to make their own decisions. Which... makes NO SENSE.
 

SpacemanSpifff

Sophomore
Jul 18, 2025
65
199
32
I agree, but there is also a degree of "chickens coming home to roost" here. The NCAA has fought long and hard to both treat sports as big business and deny that athletes are employees. If they were employees then these things would be collectively bargained (like they are in pro sports) and thereby not subject to state court litigation.
I don’t know. You could have an arbitrator make a bad decision under a CBA too.

To me, the chickens coming home to roost are the embrace by sports leagues of gambling. You push that stuff and you will have problems.
 

chipackhawk

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2018
601
1,530
93
Yup.

And now they want Congress to save them. Which isn't likely to happen because the SEC and Big Ten vehemently oppose congressional oversight and want conferences to make their own decisions. Which... makes NO SENSE.
At some point when chaos abounds and there are cries that college sports is dead, there will be this bright idea that an organization must be formed to govern it all. One that sets the rules that all must follow in order to be part of this organization. It will have its flaws, but somehow it will be better than this. The current version of the NIL will be re-worked so players get something for their name/image/likeness. Yes, the NCAA will be back and most will be better for it. Except the agents and lawyers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vhsalum

Corby2

All-American
Jul 14, 2025
3,855
8,565
113
I heard that yesterday as well. Insane.
Also read that the 7th district which will handle the appeal is backed up 9-12 months . They put in an accelerated appeal but those are 6-9 months so he's gonna get to play the season minus the 2 games to start the season
 

PinkShizzle

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
1,630
3,711
113
And then sue the cop for hindering his sobriety?
Sean Flanagan Fah GIF by Foil Arms and Hog
 
  • Like
Reactions: el dub