Hypothetical Jai Lucas Question for Those Opposed

kydmb99

Senior
Mar 8, 2009
102
586
93
How does Lucas move the needle for coaching at UK?

no one is looking for "well he'd be better than Pope". That's not an acceptable answer.

Look at his schedule with w/l's last year and see if you'd be satisfied with what his team did.

There are alot of assumptions about what he *can* do, not much about what he has done.
He's an ace recruiter and he's turned Miami from a 7 win team to a team that won a tournament game his first year and will be pre-season top 15-20 his 2nd season. He also was an assistant here so he knows what it's like. In this era, where blue bloods can't just pick who they want, I don't know what else you could ask for..
 

RedwoodHigh

All-Conference
Nov 18, 2025
795
1,117
93
8 ACC teams made the NCAA tournament last year. Miami also won their 1st round tournament game and gave Purdue a good scare in the 2nd round.
Lucas has Miami a clear top 20 team this year and it would be fool's gold for a blue blood to not scoop him up in the next couple years.
This year’s tournament is expanding & 10 teams will get in from ACC.
 

AllBall

All-American
May 5, 2015
4,874
6,391
93
4th place in the ACC probably doesn’t make the NCAA tournament. That conference is not very good. A closer look at Miami’s schedule last season shows 10 games against non-power 4 conference schools. Lucas may be a good young coach, but the Hurricanes were fool’s gold last year.
Sure it does. Heck there's 76 teams now lol. Even Pope should accomplish that.
Miami will be fringe top 25-30. Lucas added Acaden Lewis, Somto Cyril, Desean Goode, Brett Bland, and McDonald's freshman Caleb Gaskins.
 

Rosie66

Sophomore
Jan 12, 2026
100
179
33
Many have pointed out they wouldn’t want Jai Lucas because they don’t think he has the resume. If things don’t work out with Pope and we are back on the hunt, what would Lucas have needed to accomplish in the 2027 season to convince you he’s ready?

My Premise: UNC situation suggests bluebloods no longer just pick their man, so risk taking could be necessary. Lucas is young, can recruit, is hungry and his specific style could find the brand name attractive. I think a Final Four would be bad for us, as it would make it likely he gets a super contract to stay put. I’m already on the Lucas bandwagon, assuming Pope is relieved before next year.

What do you need from Jai? Would he even come here?
Lucas will never be the coach at the University of Kentucky, and it has nothing to do with his resume.
 

Phil_The_Music2

Heisman
Nov 29, 2010
3,274
13,110
113
How does Lucas move the needle for coaching at UK?

no one is looking for "well he'd be better than Pope". That's not an acceptable answer.

Look at his schedule with w/l's last year and see if you'd be satisfied with what his team did.

There are alot of assumptions about what he *can* do, not much about what he has done.
People said "anyone but Calipari!" Now they say "anyone but Pope!" You would think they would learn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdluk1

Goingfor9

All-Conference
Jan 27, 2003
16,259
3,113
113
Many have pointed out they wouldn’t want Jai Lucas because they don’t think he has the resume. If things don’t work out with Pope and we are back on the hunt, what would Lucas have needed to accomplish in the 2027 season to convince you he’s ready?

My Premise: UNC situation suggests bluebloods no longer just pick their man, so risk taking could be necessary. Lucas is young, can recruit, is hungry and his specific style could find the brand name attractive. I think a Final Four would be bad for us, as it would make it likely he gets a super contract to stay put. I’m already on the Lucas bandwagon, assuming Pope is relieved before next year.

What do you need from Jai? Would he even come here?
Chill! He’s been a head coach all of one season. He hasn’t accomplished anything yet. This season will shake out who is a good coach possible to run UK. Maybe it’s Lucas but the man needs an elite eight run to be considered. He doesn’t stay in one place for any meaningful period of time. That matters. Cals assistants usually blow it big time. Someone at a mid major will make a run this season and BBN will pine for that guy. Sean millers gonna get some run as a name too if Texas is above expectations this season. I don’t like it but he’s coaching on a reset and a f he gets to a ff there will be a big push for him.
 

LexCats859

Junior
Jan 14, 2026
214
304
63
Lucas, Schertz, Odom, Miller, McCollum. If things go south here I think it might come down to which of those guys has the best year next year.
 
Jan 14, 2002
815
520
93
Many have pointed out they wouldn’t want Jai Lucas because they don’t think he has the resume. If things don’t work out with Pope and we are back on the hunt, what would Lucas have needed to accomplish in the 2027 season to convince you he’s ready?

My Premise: UNC situation suggests bluebloods no longer just pick their man, so risk taking could be necessary. Lucas is young, can recruit, is hungry and his specific style could find the brand name attractive. I think a Final Four would be bad for us, as it would make it likely he gets a super contract to stay put. I’m already on the Lucas bandwagon, assuming Pope is relieved before next year.

What do you need from Jai? Would he even come here?
Gate health checkup. Unreal!
 

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,053
8,822
97
He’d have to make the final four. On the fence regarding an Elite 8. Anything less than that and no thank you. Hes just too much of a gamble for the situation we are in. Next guy has to be a top guy, period. They took their chance on Pope and it failed. They can’t afford to do that a second straight time. Especially coming over 6+ bad years of Cal even before that.

If he makes the FF and signs long term with Miami then oh well.
 

Im The Village Idiot

All-Conference
Sep 7, 2025
428
1,255
93
Gate health checkup. Unreal!
Music Video Wtf GIF
 

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,053
8,822
97
Indiana used this model to find Cignetti-find a coach who wins. Schertz is the winningest college basketball coach on any level over the past 10 seasons.
Indiana was also the biggest loser football program in D1. You make those type moves with IU or UK football. You don’t do that with UK or KU basketball.
 

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,053
8,822
97
Pope not going anywhere for at least 2 more years & if he gets to another Sweet 16 it will be 5 more years. Reality & Perception are 2 entirely different things.
5 in 5 will save Pope from his lack of recruiting successes.
This program will be absolutely dead if Pope is here past next year.
 

kyhankypanky

All-American
Mar 21, 2004
4,435
7,746
113
Many have pointed out they wouldn’t want Jai Lucas because they don’t think he has the resume. If things don’t work out with Pope and we are back on the hunt, what would Lucas have needed to accomplish in the 2027 season to convince you he’s ready?

My Premise: UNC situation suggests bluebloods no longer just pick their man, so risk taking could be necessary. Lucas is young, can recruit, is hungry and his specific style could find the brand name attractive. I think a Final Four would be bad for us, as it would make it likely he gets a super contract to stay put. I’m already on the Lucas bandwagon, assuming Pope is relieved before next year.

What do you need from Jai? Would he even come here?
Quit reading after the 2nd sentence, sort of?!

The next coach should be contacted and arranged as soon as as AD is in place. Waiting until season is over to interview folks is too late. Prevent the folly. So I reject the premise of your question. Instead, lock up Billy D asap
 
  • Like
Reactions: PastorofMuppets82

kfwa

Senior
Oct 12, 2014
528
977
93
He's an ace recruiter and he's turned Miami from a 7 win team to a team that won a tournament game his first year and will be pre-season top 15-20 his 2nd season. He also was an assistant here so he knows what it's like. In this era, where blue bloods can't just pick who they want, I don't know what else you could ask for..
maybe beating some ranked teams
 

kfwa

Senior
Oct 12, 2014
528
977
93
People said "anyone but Calipari!" Now they say "anyone but Pope!" You would think they would learn.
I remember when Shaka Smart was the guy, lots of Jai Lucas vibes from people wanting him to be a coach. He went to a final four with VCU and hasn't been talked about since.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phil_The_Music2
Apr 12, 2026
185
263
63
I notice you went prior as Pope went to the S16 year one here and Jai won one game. Nice spin
Because pope was HIRED at Kentucky BEFORE he won a game. The conversation was about credentials for getting hired at Kentucky.i compared jai Lucas 1 season as head Coach vs popes 9 BEFORE Kentucky. But nice spin dip ****. Do you think Mitch hired him because Mitch can see the future abd knew he would make the sweet 16 year 1?
 

UKCowboys

All-American
Oct 14, 2019
4,054
7,177
113
I wouldn't know why Mitch hired him. Just commenting on your spinning post **** for brains
 

BBNinSCar

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2013
1,457
2,408
81
Indiana was also the biggest loser football program in D1. You make those type moves with IU or UK football. You don’t do that with UK or KU basketball.
It’s all on the hiring person to identify talent and just as importantly, the toughness needed to be a successful Kentucky coach. We have to get the right AD.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Feral Manatee

Ukbrassowtipin

Heisman
Aug 12, 2011
82,260
90,195
113
How does Lucas move the needle for coaching at UK?

no one is looking for "well he'd be better than Pope". That's not an acceptable answer.

Look at his schedule with w/l's last year and see if you'd be satisfied with what his team did.

There are alot of assumptions about what he *can* do, not much about what he has done.
What did todd golden do before he was at florida? Did he move their needle?

Also, his work as an assistant isnt bad:
Coaching
2016–2020
Texas (assistant)
2020–2022
Kentucky (assistant)
2022–2023
Duke (assistant)
2023–2025
Duke (associate HC)
2025–present
Miami (FL)
 

kfwa

Senior
Oct 12, 2014
528
977
93
What did todd golden do before he was at florida? Did he move their needle?

Also, his work as an assistant isnt bad:
Coaching
2016–2020
Texas (assistant)
2020–2022
Kentucky (assistant)
2022–2023
Duke (assistant)
2023–2025
Duke (associate HC)
2025–present
Miami (FL)
so the logic is, he looks like he is the guy but he hasn't proven yet, and because of that he has earned the right to be the coach at Kentucky.
 

CatManFromCa

Sophomore
Jan 8, 2026
77
128
32
Pope inherited nothing, built a coherent system, and now finally has continuity. The data says the real jump happens in Years 2–3, and Year 4 is when you see the full payoff of stability.

This isn’t blind faith…it’s how modern college basketball actually works. With the yearly chaotic changes in the NCAA…you can’t have the same chaos in your program. You need to build stability!