OT: Rutgers gonna Rutgers, graduation speaker cancelled

Status
Not open for further replies.

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
88,851
86,867
113
I don't even remember who ours was because as soon as we walked, we all went right to Old Queens before it was even done
It was so brutally hot during our graduation, all I remember was thinking I can't wait to get out of this robe/hat and get on with my life. Don't remember who the speaker was or what he/she talked about.
 

RUBob75

All-Conference
Feb 5, 2003
1,005
1,196
113
My year it was Linus Pauling. We thought he would be fascinating. He went on and on about Vitamin C! Yawn!
 

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
48,600
59,622
113
I don't even remember who ours was because as soon as we walked, we all went right to Old Queens before it was even done

Ditto. We were in the RAC, and I believe we were passing a bottle around. Couldn't tell you a damn thing that was said there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUTGERS95

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
248,460
178,073
113
It was so brutally hot during our graduation, all I remember was thinking I can't wait to get out of this robe/hat and get on with my life. Don't remember who the speaker was or what he/she talked about.
It was better then. It was just college by college..ours at Voorhees Mall. Who wants a massive graduation
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
48,600
59,622
113
It was better then. It was just college by college..ours at Voorhees Mall. Who wants a massive graduation

Agreed. When I went to Tyler's graduation last year at UVA, they had this massive ceremony for all the graduates. What a colossal waste of time. Later on in the day they had a separate graduation for the engineering school. At least that one was inside.
 
Aug 11, 2025
513
409
63
I have no idea who mine was…don’t care to remember as I’m sure it it quite likely boring and inconsequential.
Poor little snowflakes get to miss out on a speech they would not remember hours later! 😂😂😂
 

RUPete90

Senior
Jul 3, 2025
588
833
93
Odd post? Pro Israel???
How so? Just making a point that I don’t care what was unearthed on his social media account. Think it’s a bad move to cancel this speaker. Successful grad worth a ton of money. You know, the folks we should be trying to cultivate as donors. Do you honestly think he was going to focus on Palestine at this event?
 
  • Like
Reactions: NotInRHouse

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
248,460
178,073
113
How so? Just making a point that I don’t care what was unearthed on his social media account. Think it’s a bad move to cancel this speaker. Successful grad worth a ton of money. You know, the folks we should be trying to cultivate as donors. Do you honestly think he was going to focus on Palestine at this event?
Its about all the other stuff that happens at the periphery

His comments are disqualifying. I dont care how much $$$ he has
 

RUPete90

Senior
Jul 3, 2025
588
833
93
Its about all the other stuff that happens at the periphery

His comments are disqualifying. I dont care how much $$$ he has
I’ll review them again but not sure they were egregious enough for cancellation. Excuse my ignorance, but what is “all the other stuff that happens on the periphery?”
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
248,460
178,073
113
I’ll review them again but not sure they were egregious enough for cancellation. Excuse my ignorance, but what is “all the other stuff that happens on the periphery?”
Protests on both sides..did u pay attention to incidents at RU
 

RUTGERS95

Heisman
Sep 28, 2005
32,132
46,645
113
How so? Just making a point that I don’t care what was unearthed on his social media account. Think it’s a bad move to cancel this speaker. Successful grad worth a ton of money. You know, the folks we should be trying to cultivate as donors. Do you honestly think he was going to focus on Palestine at this event?
I feel sorry for you that you have no moral compass. You would prostitute yourself and yours for the sake of coin over what is right?

I don't care if he would fund NIL for the next decade, he doesn't belong as the speaker.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

RUPete90

Senior
Jul 3, 2025
588
833
93
I feel sorry for you that you have no moral compass. You would prostitute yourself and yours for the sake of coin over what is right?

I don't care if he would fund NIL for the next decade, he doesn't belong as the speaker.
You know me so well, 95! You got me! 😂
 

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,220
44,296
113
Should be on the Rutgers Issues board, but, oh well.

Rutgers cancels graduation speech over speaker’s pro-Palestinian posts



Sounds similar to what happened with Condoleezza Rice, although she voluntarily chose to withdraw because of student and faculty protests.

In both cases I really disagree with this happening. We're a nation born on free speech, and muzzling people because they may have opposing views violates that.
Agreed. There will always be positions well-known people take that some will dislike and in both this case and Rice's case, neither one said anything so extreme as to be disqualifying, IMO. I know Dean Cuitino decently well, being involved in several School of Eng'g activities, and have thought he's pretty good in his job, but I'm disappointed in this decision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NotInRHouse

50 yd line RR

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2012
2,618
3,161
108
What is most puzzling to me is that they champion me for my humanitarian views and now they’re canceling me for them,” Elghandour told the Guardian in an exclusive interview.
I think they got it wrong with this guy.
In today’s world it’s just par for the course.
 

LETSGORU91

Senior
Jul 9, 2025
497
515
93
Too bad Mr. Rodgers is dead. He would have been a lock as an RU speaker to coddle and stroke the testicles of those easily offended.

Tom Hanks Sony GIF by A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood
 

fg7321

All-American
Nov 29, 2009
4,292
5,171
48
This isn’t a free speech issue, nor does it have anything to do with “pro humanitarian involvement” whatever that means. It is about choosing how best to create a memorable graduation commencement experience for a group of RU students.

If this incredibly successful RU grad was going to use the occasion to feed them this narrative:

“I think [Palestine] is the moral issue of our time and I believe it’s been used to undermine democratic institutions in the US,”

then it’s better RU finds someone else.

Palestine isn’t the moral issue of our time, it is an IQ test or more accurately a litmus test of how deeply flawed and narrative driven our higher educational institutions have become. How they have sacrificed truth for ideological bias and how this has led to decades of unnecessary suffering around the world.

I am a strong supporter of the state of Israel but not a blind one. My support is based on historically accurate facts reinforced by statistical facts.

For example, when the UN General Secretary said in 2021,

“If there is a hell on earth, it is the lives of children in Gaza today.”

I didn’t just nod my head and say Israel bad but rather I looked to see whether this was true because if it was true then my lived experience in Israel and understanding of the history of the conflict would need to be revisited. So, here is the reality. I’ll use 2022 statistics (pre October 7th Hamas attack) as a basic measuring stick.

In 2022 Palestinians had a higher life expectancy by nearly four years than the world average, an infant mortality rate that was less than 1/2 the world average and a literacy rate that nearly universal and that exceeded the world average by 10 points.

Life Expectancy:
Palestine: 76.7 Gaza 75.7; WB: 76.6
World Avg: 73.0
Arab Avg: 72.4
OIC Avg: 69.2

Infant Mortality Rate (per 1,000 live births): Palestine: 12.3 Gaza 13.0; WB 11.8
World Avg: 28.0
Arab Avg: 23.0
OIC Avg: 35.0

Literacy Rate: Palestine 97.8%
World Avg: 87.2% Gaza 98.1; WB 97.5
Arab Avg: 75.0%
OIC Avg: 73.0%

Added context:

Egypt: 70.2 life expectancy, 16.7 infant mortality, 72.0% literacy
Yemen: 63.8 years, 35.7 infant mortality, 55.0% literacy
Sub-Saharan Africa: 61.2 years, 46.5 infant mortality, 64.0% literacy

Lots of numbers, I know but bear with me.

Based on these numbers, if Yemen had an equivalent infant mortality rate as Gaza, 82k additional babies would have survived infancy in Yemen since 10.7.23. That equals roughly the entire death toll in the Israel/Gaza conflict.

So, explain to me how in 2022, Palestinians received $700 per capita in Humanitarian aid and Yemen received $100.

The hyper focus on Palestinians defies any logic other than the cesspool of Postmodernist, Deconstructionist, anti-western thought our higher institutions of learning are propagandizing our kids with.

The numbers hold true in every other historical measurement of human flourishing related to the Palestinians. If you look at the statistical achievements of Israeli Arabs in healthcare fields in Israel, particularly Arab Christians, the Apartheid narrative is so easily debunked but that doesn’t stop Western academics and NGO’s (yes, including Israelis) from spewing this garbage.

I don’t care whether this guy speaks at RU but is he some beacon of truth or paragon of virtue? A champion of Human Rights activism? If he is saying that Palestine is the moral issue of time, then the answer is no.
My daddy always said Figures Lie and Liars Figure. I guess you missed the pictures of Gaza bombed back to the stone age. Starving population Aid workers bombed and killed. You might want to redo those life expectancy numbers since 50000 people were killed.

I can tell you this you cant bomb your way to a solution. See Ukraine, Iran, and Gaza, . Lebanon is next on that list. Drones and Man pads have changed everything.
 

RU206

All-American
Jan 23, 2015
5,119
5,170
113
Its about all the other stuff that happens at the periphery

His comments are disqualifying. I dont care how much $$$ he has
I never expected you to be a part of cancel culture. I always viewed you as a free speech advocate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MCRU93

FoxRU

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2012
942
1,265
58
Has anyone ever been banned for making pro Israel statements?
Banned in what way? Speakers canceled? Harassment, Vandalism? Are you seriously asking whether Pro-
Yes. I work in NB and was on-call in my capacity as a precaution and nothing was nearly as bad as you may have been led to believe.

My daddy always said Figures Lie and Liars Figure. I guess you missed the pictures of Gaza bombed back to the stone age. Starving population Aid workers bombed and killed. You might want to redo those life expectancy numbers since 50000 people were killed.

I can tell you this you cant bomb your way to a solution. See Ukraine, Iran, and Gaza, . Lebanon is next on that list. Drones and Man pads have changed everything.
Your “daddy” never said that. Your Marxist intro to the dialectics of the constructs of power as a tool of oppression Professor taught you how to reverse engineer cause and effect to support a narrative.
 

NotInRHouse

Senior
Jul 29, 2025
580
452
63
This isn’t a free speech issue, nor does it have anything to do with “pro humanitarian involvement” whatever that means. It is about choosing how best to create a memorable graduation commencement experience for a group of RU students.

If this incredibly successful RU grad was going to use the occasion to feed them this narrative:

“I think [Palestine] is the moral issue of our time and I believe it’s been used to undermine democratic institutions in the US,”

then it’s better RU finds someone else.

Palestine isn’t the moral issue of our time, it is an IQ test or more accurately a litmus test of how deeply flawed and narrative driven our higher educational institutions have become. How they have sacrificed truth for ideological bias and how this has led to decades of unnecessary suffering around the world.

I am a strong supporter of the state of Israel but not a blind one. My support is based on historically accurate facts reinforced by statistical facts.

For example, when the UN General Secretary said in 2021,

“If there is a hell on earth, it is the lives of children in Gaza today.”

I didn’t just nod my head and say Israel bad but rather I looked to see whether this was true because if it was true then my lived experience in Israel and understanding of the history of the conflict would need to be revisited. So, here is the reality. I’ll use 2022 statistics (pre October 7th Hamas attack) as a basic measuring stick.

In 2022 Palestinians had a higher life expectancy by nearly four years than the world average, an infant mortality rate that was less than 1/2 the world average and a literacy rate that nearly universal and that exceeded the world average by 10 points.

Life Expectancy:
Palestine: 76.7 Gaza 75.7; WB: 76.6
World Avg: 73.0
Arab Avg: 72.4
OIC Avg: 69.2

Infant Mortality Rate (per 1,000 live births): Palestine: 12.3 Gaza 13.0; WB 11.8
World Avg: 28.0
Arab Avg: 23.0
OIC Avg: 35.0

Literacy Rate: Palestine 97.8%
World Avg: 87.2% Gaza 98.1; WB 97.5
Arab Avg: 75.0%
OIC Avg: 73.0%

Added context:

Egypt: 70.2 life expectancy, 16.7 infant mortality, 72.0% literacy
Yemen: 63.8 years, 35.7 infant mortality, 55.0% literacy
Sub-Saharan Africa: 61.2 years, 46.5 infant mortality, 64.0% literacy

Lots of numbers, I know but bear with me.

Based on these numbers, if Yemen had an equivalent infant mortality rate as Gaza, 82k additional babies would have survived infancy in Yemen since 10.7.23. That equals roughly the entire death toll in the Israel/Gaza conflict.

So, explain to me how in 2022, Palestinians received $700 per capita in Humanitarian aid and Yemen received $100.

The hyper focus on Palestinians defies any logic other than the cesspool of Postmodernist, Deconstructionist, anti-western thought our higher institutions of learning are propagandizing our kids with.

The numbers hold true in every other historical measurement of human flourishing related to the Palestinians. If you look at the statistical achievements of Israeli Arabs in healthcare fields in Israel, particularly Arab Christians, the Apartheid narrative is so easily debunked but that doesn’t stop Western academics and NGO’s (yes, including Israelis) from spewing this garbage.

I don’t care whether this guy speaks at RU but is he some beacon of truth or paragon of virtue? A champion of Human Rights activism? If he is saying that Palestine is the moral issue of time, then the answer is no.

You didn't point out anything he said even remotely controversial, that hasn't been said by talking heads and pols on both sides for a long time now.

Also, Palestine is a moral issue of our time here in the US. My tax dollars don't go to support China, Burma, Russia or other genocidal regimes. I certainly don't agree with giving 40BN to Argentina or UAE, but at least those countries are not bombing churches (to speak of Christians); murdering American citizens (and Israel has killed several in the West Bank in the last year alone); nor walking into the Situation Room and demanding the government join them in yet ANOTHER failed Middle Eastern war it promised not to have (and accused the opposition of wanting).

We live in a country where "medical bankruptcy" is a thing, and yet my tax dollars are funding FREE healthcare for all Israelis while their government is destroying Christian villages in Lebanon, causing starvation in Gaza, and arresting its own citizens who complain. Then that government has the temerity to walk into the PEOPLE'S HOUSE and demand we spend American LIVES on their struggle, a war against a country that couldn't reach us with any weapons on its best day. While our country plunges into poverty, our safety net collapses, and we are told we have money for nothing? I wonder how it feels to pay $2000 for an ambulance ride while their taxes are going to Israel. Pretty darn bad I bet.

That's a moral issue, it's a really big one, and it's why most Jewish congresspeople voted against funding the Israeli military, why most Americans don't support Israel no matter their politics, etc. Other than perhaps AI, there is no greater issue uniting Americans of all faiths and political stripes than Israel getting no US taxpayer funds.

The pinkwashing of "oh they have Arab pharmacists" or "Tel Aviv is gay friendly" ain't going to cut it in the age of the Israeli government laughing off the loss of American money and citizenry.

When Xi or Putin strut into the White House with a Powerpoint urging bombing Taiwan and Ukraine, I'll be right with you demanding college students protest that, but you darn well it isn't happening and that's the simple difference.
 

RUforJERSEY

Heisman
Jul 29, 2001
24,868
10,069
113
You didn't point out anything he said even remotely controversial, that hasn't been said by talking heads and pols on both sides for a long time now.

Also, Palestine is a moral issue of our time here in the US. My tax dollars don't go to support China, Burma, Russia or other genocidal regimes. I certainly don't agree with giving 40BN to Argentina or UAE, but at least those countries are not bombing churches (to speak of Christians); murdering American citizens (and Israel has killed several in the West Bank in the last year alone); nor walking into the Situation Room and demanding the government join them in yet ANOTHER failed Middle Eastern war it promised not to have (and accused the opposition of wanting).

We live in a country where "medical bankruptcy" is a thing, and yet my tax dollars are funding FREE healthcare for all Israelis while their government is destroying Christian villages in Lebanon, causing starvation in Gaza, and arresting its own citizens who complain. Then that government has the temerity to walk into the PEOPLE'S HOUSE and demand we spend American LIVES on their struggle, a war against a country that couldn't reach us with any weapons on its best day. While our country plunges into poverty, our safety net collapses, and we are told we have money for nothing? I wonder how it feels to pay $2000 for an ambulance ride while their taxes are going to Israel. Pretty darn bad I bet.

That's a moral issue, it's a really big one, and it's why most Jewish congresspeople voted against funding the Israeli military, why most Americans don't support Israel no matter their politics, etc. Other than perhaps AI, there is no greater issue uniting Americans of all faiths and political stripes than Israel getting no US taxpayer funds.

The pinkwashing of "oh they have Arab pharmacists" or "Tel Aviv is gay friendly" ain't going to cut it in the age of the Israeli government laughing off the loss of American money and citizenry.

When Xi or Putin strut into the White House with a Powerpoint urging bombing Taiwan and Ukraine, I'll be right with you demanding college students protest that, but you darn well it isn't happening and that's the simple difference.
Is that for real? That they get free healthcare that our government pays for? Please tell me that's not the case.
 

Rutgers Chris

All-American
Nov 29, 2005
5,153
6,028
97
You didn't point out anything he said even remotely controversial, that hasn't been said by talking heads and pols on both sides for a long time now.

Also, Palestine is a moral issue of our time here in the US. My tax dollars don't go to support China, Burma, Russia or other genocidal regimes. I certainly don't agree with giving 40BN to Argentina or UAE, but at least those countries are not bombing churches (to speak of Christians); murdering American citizens (and Israel has killed several in the West Bank in the last year alone); nor walking into the Situation Room and demanding the government join them in yet ANOTHER failed Middle Eastern war it promised not to have (and accused the opposition of wanting).

We live in a country where "medical bankruptcy" is a thing, and yet my tax dollars are funding FREE healthcare for all Israelis while their government is destroying Christian villages in Lebanon, causing starvation in Gaza, and arresting its own citizens who complain. Then that government has the temerity to walk into the PEOPLE'S HOUSE and demand we spend American LIVES on their struggle, a war against a country that couldn't reach us with any weapons on its best day. While our country plunges into poverty, our safety net collapses, and we are told we have money for nothing? I wonder how it feels to pay $2000 for an ambulance ride while their taxes are going to Israel. Pretty darn bad I bet.

That's a moral issue, it's a really big one, and it's why most Jewish congresspeople voted against funding the Israeli military, why most Americans don't support Israel no matter their politics, etc. Other than perhaps AI, there is no greater issue uniting Americans of all faiths and political stripes than Israel getting no US taxpayer funds.

The pinkwashing of "oh they have Arab pharmacists" or "Tel Aviv is gay friendly" ain't going to cut it in the age of the Israeli government laughing off the loss of American money and citizenry.

When Xi or Putin strut into the White House with a Powerpoint urging bombing Taiwan and Ukraine, I'll be right with you demanding college students protest that, but you darn well it isn't happening and that's the simple difference.
“Other than perhaps AI, there is no greater issue uniting Americans of all faiths and political stripes…”

Couldn’t agree more. His NIL and coaching takes unite the masses
 
  • Haha
Reactions: NotInRHouse

FoxRU

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2012
942
1,265
58
Is that for real? That they get free healthcare that our government pays for? Please tell me that's not the case.
Candace Owens level drivel in the previous post. No, it’s not for real. I work for a living but will address the 8 zillion accusations later. Again Candace 101. And Red/Green propaganda talking points in full effect here with the emphasis now on driving a wedge between Christians and Jews.
 

RU206

All-American
Jan 23, 2015
5,119
5,170
113
It’s 2 separate facts:

1. Israel has universal healthcare. Basic healthcare needs are covered by the government. Primary care visits, hospitalization, medication etc.

2. The US sends Israel Billions a year for military.

I don’t think the US pays directly for Israel Healthcare. But if Israel didn’t receive Billions from US for military and had to 100% to fund their own military, they would have to cut funding to other areas, (possibly healthcare).
 

scarletnewyorker2006

All-American
Sep 2, 2012
3,888
7,442
58
Free speech being suppressed for political reasons.
Just like Spanky pointed out using Condoleezza Rice;s speaking engagement not happening.
Students need to be aware of the issues and hear the conservative, moderate and Liberal POV and not just the opinions they want the public to agree with .,
You don’t understand what free speech is.

The right to free speech means he can speak his mind without force being used against him. He is not entitled to have Rutgers amplify his voice or give him exposure. If he wants RU’s bullhorn, he does so on their terms, including editing or limiting what he says. If he doesn’t like it, he’s free to voice his thoughts on his property or any property where the property owner wants to hear it. The property owner makes the rules on his property.

Don’t react emotionally like everyone here does. Just think on it. I’m not trying to be condescending even though I am criticizing you.
 

50 yd line RR

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2012
2,618
3,161
108
Candace Owens level drivel in the previous post. No, it’s not for real. I work for a living but will address the 8 zillion accusations later. Again Candace 101. And Red/Green propaganda talking points in full effect here with the emphasis now on driving a wedge between Christians and Jews.
It’s more than Candice Owen’s. Basically the whole world condemns Israel for the hostility.
Everyone but us. We promote it by supplying
Military aid for them to do the job.
Bad news for you Fox, the American people are waking up. Enough is enough.
 

csphi

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
17,832
20,106
102
It’s more than Candice Owen’s. Basically the whole world condemns Israel for the hostility.
Everyone but us. We promote it by supplying
Military aid for them to do the job.
Bad news for you Fox, the American people are waking up. Enough is enough.
The whole world blames Israel for the hostilities?
What an ignorant and totally inaccurate statement….guess you feel Israel “deserved it” on 10/7

Tell us all what happened in 2006 and how we got here today
 

50 yd line RR

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2012
2,618
3,161
108
Sorry dude not getting into an argument with you or anyone else here. Life’s to short.
Alls I’ll say is if you look for the truth you’ll find it.
 
Last edited:

csphi

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
17,832
20,106
102
Sorry dude not getting into a with argument with you or anyone else here. Life’s to short.
Alls I’ll say is if you look for the truth you’ll find it.
So basically you can’t answer 2 simple questions
Did Israel deserve what happened on 10/7?

What happened in 2006?

if you are gonna thrown out ignorant accusations at least have the balls to try and back it up in stead of being a pu$$y

I’ll take your non answers as a yes to question one and have no idea about question 2

figures
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,735
19,018
113
Sorry dude not getting into a with argument with you or anyone else here. Life’s to short.
Alls I’ll say is if you look for the truth you’ll find it.

Isn't 10/7 the truth? People here seem to believe that 100% of the blame goes to one side or the other. There's blame on BOTH sides and probably has been since 1947, or perhaps 1972.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac
Status
Not open for further replies.