If Spencer has any interest in coaching

blcoach80

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2018
343
1,777
93
I'm not a Carl fan and recruiting has definitely been his strongest attribute but to pretend he and his staff aren't also developing incredible college wrestlers is asinine. They've raised the bar when it comes to scrambling, chain wrestling, strength and conditioning, versatile offensive attacking, match strategizing etc... He's getting the recruits he is now bc of the results prior wrestlers have had.
It is really a vicious cycle. Get the best wrestlers year after year, have those wrestlers have success. The next generation of young studs see your success, get the best wrestlers again. Good coaching with the best talent up and down your lineup is the key. Only way to stop the PSU machine imo is to start out recruiting Carl somehow someway. Do that for 3 or 4 years, upset the apple cart, and start getting the larger share of the best wrestlers. That is the only way to do it. That is a lot harder than it sounds and it takes lots of money. When PSU has a team with 6 or 7 number one ranked wrestlers it is pretty tough to overtake them unless you start getting those #1 P4P guys on your team.
 

Cali_Nittany1

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2019
738
3,183
93
It is really a vicious cycle. Get the best wrestlers year after year, have those wrestlers have success. The next generation of young studs see your success, get the best wrestlers again. Good coaching with the best talent up and down your lineup is the key. Only way to stop the PSU machine imo is to start out recruiting Carl somehow someway. Do that for 3 or 4 years, upset the apple cart, and start getting the larger share of the best wrestlers. That is the only way to do it. That is a lot harder than it sounds and it takes lots of money. When PSU has a team with 6 or 7 number one ranked wrestlers it is pretty tough to overtake them unless you start getting those #1 P4P guys on your team.

Well, that's happing right now at Oklahoma State.
 

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
1,121
2,970
113
It is really a vicious cycle. Get the best wrestlers year after year, have those wrestlers have success. The next generation of young studs see your success, get the best wrestlers again. Good coaching with the best talent up and down your lineup is the key. Only way to stop the PSU machine imo is to start out recruiting Carl somehow someway. Do that for 3 or 4 years, upset the apple cart, and start getting the larger share of the best wrestlers. That is the only way to do it. That is a lot harder than it sounds and it takes lots of money. When PSU has a team with 6 or 7 number one ranked wrestlers it is pretty tough to overtake them unless you start getting those #1 P4P guys on your team.
Yep, program building 101. Combine it with strong development and you have the making of a dynasty.
 

johnstownsteel

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2025
598
3,561
93
??? He is 13 of 16 at PSU and 13 of 19 as a head coach. Throwing a year off his record is not needed to make him look better. Everyone knows he is doing very well.
Why are you people counting a National Championship that wasn't even contested? I know you want to count that year as Cael not winning a championship but don't you think he should have at least been given the chance?
 

johnstownsteel

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2025
598
3,561
93
So, Covid basically means they weren't the best team those 2 seasons? Got it. Great logic for PSU to find a way to have it only be about them. Makes sense why you post here...
Says the guy trying to count 2020 as a non championship year for Cael even though his team wasn't even given the chance to compete for it. That's about as dumb as you people claiming Iowa was the 2020 champion. When Unicef gets into the wrestling game ...let me know. I'll gift the 2020 championship to those kids in Iowa..
 
Last edited:

MSU158

All-Conference
Nov 20, 2014
1,327
3,512
113
He didn't have nearly the level of recruits at ISU top to bottom he did later at psu. Not even close. And as I stated, recruiting is clearly his #1 attribute. We all know this. But guys are going from really damn good to historically good in that room. It's undeniable they're combining recruiting and development at a level no one has since prime Gable years Iowa.
He started off with the Paulsons and Backes right before he became "special assistant". He would then add Fanthorpe, Gallick, Cyler(brother), Mueller, Fanthorpe, VARNER, ZABRISKIE, READER, Sebolt, Clark, Jensen, Carr Jr., BROWN, Long, Spangler, Thompson, TAYLOR.

That is a lot of high end recruits in a very short time frame...
 

MSU158

All-Conference
Nov 20, 2014
1,327
3,512
113
Why are you people counting a National Championship that wasn't even contested? I know you want to count that year as Cael not winning a championship but don't you think he should have at least been given the chance?
Hypocrisy at its best. Every PSU fan on here LOVES to count that year as Iowa NOT winning a championship, wouldn't the same thing then apply to PSU???
 
  • Like
Reactions: HellerballFTW

johnstownsteel

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2025
598
3,561
93
Hypocrisy at its best. Every PSU fan on here LOVES to count that year as Iowa NOT winning a championship, wouldn't the same thing then apply to PSU???
Wtf are you talking about? You can't count a win OR loss for any program in 2020 BECAUSE IT WAS NEVER CONTESTED. The NCAA doesn't count the year so why would you or anyone else count it as a loss for PSU or Iowa? This is getting dumb real quick like...
 

JoeBagobagels

Senior
Jun 24, 2025
807
979
92

Hypocrisy at its best. Every PSU fan on here LOVES to count that year as Iowa NOT winning a championship, wouldn't the same thing then apply to PSU???
What ? No one won it that year. In case you're not counting that was six years ago.
 

johnstownsteel

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2025
598
3,561
93
So, the year 2020 never happened? Interesting. I guess I haven't turned 50 yet then...Awesome!
My bad. Didn't know I needed to be most specific in my reply to all those on here that may not easily understand or feel the need to use their brain when being addressed. The 2020 National Championships DID NOT HAPPEN. There....hope this helps.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mcpat

JoeBagobagels

Senior
Jun 24, 2025
807
979
92
It is really a vicious cycle. Get the best wrestlers year after year, have those wrestlers have success. The next generation of young studs see your success, get the best wrestlers again. Good coaching with the best talent up and down your lineup is the key. Only way to stop the PSU machine imo is to start out recruiting Carl somehow someway. Do that for 3 or 4 years, upset the apple cart, and start getting the larger share of the best wrestlers. That is the only way to do it. That is a lot harder than it sounds and it takes lots of money. When PSU has a team with 6 or 7 number one ranked wrestlers it is pretty tough to overtake them unless you start getting those #1 P4P guys on your team.
You don't need money , you need to find an all-time great wrestling coach before anyone knows he's at that level. Then hire the guy and wait a few years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: District 4

MSU158

All-Conference
Nov 20, 2014
1,327
3,512
113
Could be totally wrong here but I think he's living in a fantasy world in that noggin of his in that Iowa really was the 2020 National Champion and PSU wasn't. I'm not gonna criticize tho.... maybe it helps him sleep at night.
I know math is hard for some but that year happened regardless of the NCAA tournament being cancelled so no one won it and that would make him 13 of the last 16 years. Ignoring it only works because they were major underdogs that year. But, I am sure you know that part…
 
  • Like
Reactions: 741225

blcoach80

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2018
343
1,777
93
You don't need money , you need to find an all-time great wrestling coach before anyone knows he's at that level. Then hire the guy and wait a few years.
You absolutely do need money. How are you going to afford this all-time great unproven coach without it? You also are not getting these recruits to come without paying them handily. Do you really think PSU, Okie St., and Iowa are getting stud recruits to come for free just for the coaching?! You can't honestly believe that?!
 

Comment123

Sophomore
Feb 26, 2019
44
116
33
I know math is hard for some but that year happened regardless of the NCAA tournament being cancelled so no one won it and that would make him 13 of the last 16 years. Ignoring it only works because they were major underdogs that year. But, I am sure you know that part…
You’re being so slow. It doesn’t count in the numerator, or denominator, for any coach when calculating their championship winning percentage because the tournament was canceled. 2020 as a year happened, but the tournament didn’t. If you wanna be obtuse about their phrasing & intent you do you.
 

chipackhawk

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2018
582
1,447
93
Could be totally wrong here but I think he's living in a fantasy world in that noggin of his in that Iowa really was the 2020 National Champion and PSU wasn't. I'm not gonna criticize tho.... maybe it helps him sleep at night.
Oh for F' sake - try rephrasing it to NCAA Finals actually held versus total years. And by the way, Iowa did win the Big Ten's that year and that was a pretty solid indicator of what would have happened if the Finals actually took place.
 

johnstownsteel

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2025
598
3,561
93
Oh for F' sake - try rephrasing it to NCAA Finals actually held versus total years. And by the way, Iowa did win the Big Ten's that year and that was a pretty solid indicator of what would have happened if the Finals actually took place.
Yeah and Iowa was your 2022 National Champion until they weren't. And Spencer Lee was your first 4 time national champ until he wasn't.

Please forgive me if I don't feel compelled to gift the Hawkeyes anything...
 

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
1,121
2,970
113
He started off with the Paulsons and Backes right before he became "special assistant". He would then add Fanthorpe, Gallick, Cyler(brother), Mueller, Fanthorpe, VARNER, ZABRISKIE, READER, Sebolt, Clark, Jensen, Carr Jr., BROWN, Long, Spangler, Thompson, TAYLOR.

That is a lot of high end recruits in a very short time frame...
Brown and Reader wouldn't crack the lineup at today's psu. You think either are beating out Mess or Haines? They have multiple guys exceeding Varner and Zabriske college accomplishments on every roster. Hell, they're bringing in a Taylor or two every year now.
The rest wouldn't even see the mat much less get recruited to psu. To pretend his recruiting didn't jump SIGNIFICANT levels with the move to PSU is laughable.
 

MSU158

All-Conference
Nov 20, 2014
1,327
3,512
113
Brown and Reader wouldn't crack the lineup at today's psu. You think either are beating out Mess or Haines? They have multiple guys exceeding Varner and Zabriske college accomplishments on every roster. Hell, they're bringing in a Taylor or two every year now.
The rest wouldn't even see the mat much less get recruited to psu. To pretend his recruiting didn't jump SIGNIFICANT levels with the move to PSU is laughable.
An undefeated 39-0 at a weight with studs like Mack Lewnes could absolutely beat Haines. The same can be said for Brown. He was a staple at a super deep 174. Then you diminish how good Varner was? CTFO…
 
  • Like
Reactions: 741225

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
1,121
2,970
113
An undefeated 39-0 at a weight with studs like Mack Lewnes could absolutely beat Haines. The same can be said for Brown. He was a staple at a super deep 174. Then you diminish how good Varner was? CTFO…
You can't be serious. Haines has gone 2, 1, 3, 1 with what 4 total losses? Not to mention age group world gold and senior world silver.
Varner was a stud no doubt. But on current psu roster he'd just be another one of many. How many guys has PSU had in the past 10 years win 2 titles? Hell Barr is on track to exceed Varner and he wasn't even expected to be the guaranteed guy at 97 for all 4 years.
Your take was bad. Admit it and move on FOR ONCE.
 

MSU158

All-Conference
Nov 20, 2014
1,327
3,512
113
You can't be serious. Haines has gone 2, 1, 3, 1 with what 4 total losses? Not to mention age group world gold and senior world silver.
Varner was a stud no doubt. But on current psu roster he'd just be another one of many. How many guys has PSU had in the past 10 years win 2 titles? Hell Barr is on track to exceed Varner and he wasn't even expected to be the guaranteed guy at 97 for all 4 years.
Your take was bad. Admit it and move on FOR ONCE.
Recency bias is a terrible thing. Reader was an absolute stud at a very talented weight class. Only a moron dismisses a guy that went 39-0. I am sorry but that is plain stupid.
 

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
1,121
2,970
113
Recency bias is a terrible thing. Reader was an absolute stud at a very talented weight class. Only a moron dismisses a guy that went 39-0. I am sorry but that is plain stupid.
Who was the better collegiate wrestler, Levi Haines or Jon Reader?
I'll help you out, one lost 4 matches in 4 years, the other 23.
Let's see if you have the ability to answer honestly.
 

MSU158

All-Conference
Nov 20, 2014
1,327
3,512
113
Who was the better collegiate wrestler, Levi Haines or Jon Reader?
I'll help you out, one lost 4 matches in 4 years, the other 23.
Let's see if you have the ability to answer honestly.
One had two years battling significant injuries and then got healthy and DOMINATED his senior year. Hell, I am not even saying he is better, just that he was absolutely a recruit at that level, which was the entire point of the list…
 

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
1,121
2,970
113
One had two years battling significant injuries and then got healthy and DOMINATED his senior year. Hell, I am not even saying he is better, just that he was absolutely a recruit at that level, which was the entire point of the list…
Can't even answer a simple black and white question. And you wonder why people give you crap.
 

Libertylover

All-Conference
Dec 17, 2020
1,025
1,735
113
You absolutely do need money. How are you going to afford this all-time great unproven coach without it? You also are not getting these recruits to come without paying them handily. Do you really think PSU, Okie St., and Iowa are getting stud recruits to come for free just for the coaching?! You can't honestly believe that?!
Let’s not forget the brilliant money laundering PSU used in the early days to start the stockpiling of blue chip recruits. This was important when you had to work with 9.9 scholarships, no nil, no revenue sharing. Of coarse as Bob said, there is still the under the table shady ways to funnel money to guys in addition to the allowable ways.
 

Fencepost

Freshman
Oct 23, 2021
48
50
18
I think every wrestler that strives to be an Olympic Champion has a "me me me first" attitude. I think it is a necessity. I do not think Spencer would be a coach anywhere near the likes of Cael or Gable or even TnT. I think he would be more of a Kolat type coach with that type of success - which is impressive, but not legendary.
I will say that I prefer the persona of SL to that of a Bo Bassett. SL has always seemed humble and considerate of others and has never really seemed like the kind of guy who wants the spotlight. He seems like a class act to me.
Hmmm.... made me think of Spencer being the Head Coach at Pitt. It might be more fun to build a program of your own than to tend to Gable's program.
 

mcpat

All-American
Mar 12, 2021
1,922
7,785
113
My bad. Didn't know I needed to be most specific in my reply to all those on here that may not easily understand or feel the need to use their brain when being addressed. The 2020 National Championships DID NOT HAPPEN. There....hope this helps.
But Ohio State has 2020 National Champion banners hanging for Luke Pletcher and Kollin Moore. Are you saying Pletcher and Moore weren’t national champions?
 

mcpat

All-American
Mar 12, 2021
1,922
7,785
113
Let’s not forget the brilliant money laundering PSU used in the early days to start the stockpiling of blue chip recruits. This was important when you had to work with 9.9 scholarships, no nil, no revenue sharing. Of coarse as Bob said, there is still the under the table shady ways to funnel money to guys in addition to the allowable ways.
Pre-NIL, with all the in-state PA wrestling talent, Cael should have calculated all 9.9 scholarships on the out of state tuition rate and then used the money on in-state PA recruits.
 
Last edited:

grapplefan

Senior
Oct 3, 2010
220
482
63
We are talking about before they became head coaches there, genius.




Talking about before they became head coaches. How is it possible you did not understand that’s what I was talking about? Lol. The point was, none of those three guys made you think “man this guy is gonna be a great head coach!” a few years after they finished college.

And if you don’t think Tom Brands is a good wrestling coach, I have news for you. There are a number of gold NCAA team trophies in the trophy case that disagree with you on this. Has his time come and gone? I believe yes. But you can’t claim he’s not a legendary coach. You would be an idiot for doing so.
When will these Nits "unlearn" to be such jerks? Never.
 

sstark46

Senior
Mar 20, 2013
202
827
93
But Ohio State has 2020 National Champion banners hanging for Luke Pletcher and Kollin Moore. Are you saying Pletcher and Moore weren’t national champions?
To me, that is the most ridiculous thing lol. I'm fully on board with recognition of the AA honors awarded that year, like Iowa putting the names on the wall of All Americans for it, but trying to recognize individual or team national championship awards doesn't make any sense for an event that was never contested