It's a good question. Was Goodale a deterrent? I think it's more that Donny's reputation was tainted by the program and not enough of a draw on his own. Now might be different for him.
Yes, and all four should have developed into AA-caliber wrestlers (during normal seasons). What does it say for the program when talent does come and not perform up to expectations? All were very good wrestlers out of the gate, but did they improve?
It's nice to think so, but is Ashnault that much of a draw? Hahn might be, and Burroughs would be. Head coach opportunity missed. Let's watch and see if another accomplished coach gets added.
Why would Donny’s reputation was tainted and now might be diff for him but not for Ash? Don’t think you are giving Ash enough credit.. and for not drawing the top guys I think it has more to do with $$ raised/available and how $$ is spent on roster construction which falls more on the HC.
Out of those 4 I would only consider Soldano a 5 star recruit(top 10 p4p) Peterson and Poz 4 stars(like C. Harer as they were in teens and mid 20s recruit), Olivieri as a 3 star(he was in the 30-50s?). So as a group they slightly underperformed relative to generic recruiting rankings but having a loaded staff isn’t going to magically turn recruits into AA/NC. What’s your excuse why Soldano/Peterson didn’t AA at their new programs either?? The most important part of recruiting is getting the right guys relative to rankings imo and we haven’t been best at that.. I do agree with ya that’s it’s concerning how the staff couldn’t help w how Poz just burnt out mentally.
I’ve said it all along how a recruit does their freshman year is generally how their career goes.. I mean look at how people been saying Iowa “hasn’t been able to develop guys recently” and been needing to rely on portal.. it’s not that they haven’t been able to develop it’s they haven’t gotten the top p4p guys like Psu/OSU.
Burroughs and Hahn represents this big change and hope so no one should really be compared to them.. especially Burroughs imo. You question Ash but look at Okie State’s associate HC.. Jimmy Kennedy 3x AA. Caldwell on staff too there, few times AA.. Kevin Ward and Pearsall both NQs.