Rank Mitch Barnhart's Most Stupid, and, or Corrupt Decisions:

MdWIldcat55

Heisman
Dec 9, 2007
21,310
85,088
113
There have been so many idiotic, corrupt, naive decisions by Kentucky's AD that they are hard to rank.

Here's my attempt:
1. Hiring Billy Clyde Gillispie. This showed an almost complete lack of understanding of the Crown Jewel of Kentucky athletics. Almost any AD would be fired for this. At Kentucky, it was seen as just a warm up for nearly two more decades of stupidity.
2. Naming Joker Phillips "Coach In Waiting." Football is not as important as basketball at Kentucky. But this decision, for sheer imbecility, rivals BCG's hiring.
3. Locking Kentucky into a ruinous deal with JMI. This could be No. 1 if some competent sports journalist does link Mitch to undisclosed personal gain from this deal. For now, it is simply another example of gross incompetence to inhibit Kentucky's ability to compete for stars in the NIL era by limiting their options to profit.
4. Hiring Mark Pope. It is still possible Pope turns it around. Possible. But even if he does, hiring a coach without an NCAA tournament win to take over the sport's most prestigious program was the act of a moron.
5. Giving John Calipari a lifetime contract. When he was hungry for several years, Calipari was on top of the sport. What could go wrong? Kill his motivation. Only a half-wit jackass could accomplish turning Calipari into a lethargic cypher. Well done Mitch!
6. Giving Mark Stoops a gigantic buyout. Stoops' record was always a bit of a mirage: If you only looked at SEC results he was never top tier. But if there was a way to make sure he failed, Mitch found it by removing his incentive to improve. Paying a guy like Stoops a $38 million buyout would rank as the all-time most foolish move by many ADs. For Millionaire Mitch it doesn't crack the Top Five.
 

Anon1776024529

Freshman
Apr 12, 2026
52
66
18
On court and recruiting and success before Kentucky, hiring BCG was a way better decision than Pope. Off court stuff makes it equal for me.
 

CatBearPig

All-Conference
Apr 26, 2024
725
1,537
93
Driving a wedge through the UK fan base by getting rid of things that made UK sports special and corporatizing it. (eg big blue camp out). Splitting up long time season ticket holders at football and tailgate. Furthering the narrative UK fans are a bunch of dumb rednecks by treating us like a bunch of dumb rednecks. Barnhart took the heart out of UK sports. Cal took the soul of UK basketball. They are both to blame for this. But it’s ALL on Mitch.
 

kyhankypanky

All-American
Mar 21, 2004
4,348
7,527
113
There have been so many idiotic, corrupt, naive decisions by Kentucky's AD that they are hard to rank.

Here's my attempt:
1. Hiring Billy Clyde Gillispie. This showed an almost complete lack of understanding of the Crown Jewel of Kentucky athletics. Almost any AD would be fired for this. At Kentucky, it was seen as just a warm up for nearly two more decades of stupidity.
2. Naming Joker Phillips "Coach In Waiting." Football is not as important as basketball at Kentucky. But this decision, for sheer imbecility, rivals BCG's hiring.
3. Locking Kentucky into a ruinous deal with JMI. This could be No. 1 if some competent sports journalist does link Mitch to undisclosed personal gain from this deal. For now, it is simply another example of gross incompetence to inhibit Kentucky's ability to compete for stars in the NIL era by limiting their options to profit.
4. Hiring Mark Pope. It is still possible Pope turns it around. Possible. But even if he does, hiring a coach without an NCAA tournament win to take over the sport's most prestigious program was the act of a moron.
5. Giving John Calipari a lifetime contract. When he was hungry for several years, Calipari was on top of the sport. What could go wrong? Kill his motivation. Only a half-wit jackass could accomplish turning Calipari into a lethargic cypher. Well done Mitch!
6. Giving Mark Stoops a gigantic buyout. Stoops' record was always a bit of a mirage: If you only looked at SEC results he was never top tier. But if there was a way to make sure he failed, Mitch found it by removing his incentive to improve. Paying a guy like Stoops a $38 million buyout would rank as the all-time most foolish move by many ADs. For Millionaire Mitch it doesn't crack the Top Five.
Hard to rank those. All look ridiculously stupid, and not simply because of hindsight bias. Agree on adding Elzy (I blasted this immediately) and the swim scandal.

MB is like a corrupt college ref - seemingly allowed to do whatever and be terrible at his job but have no accountability. None.
 

Goingfor9

All-Conference
Jan 27, 2003
16,101
2,905
113
There have been so many idiotic, corrupt, naive decisions by Kentucky's AD that they are hard to rank.

Here's my attempt:
1. Hiring Billy Clyde Gillispie. This showed an almost complete lack of understanding of the Crown Jewel of Kentucky athletics. Almost any AD would be fired for this. At Kentucky, it was seen as just a warm up for nearly two more decades of stupidity.
2. Naming Joker Phillips "Coach In Waiting." Football is not as important as basketball at Kentucky. But this decision, for sheer imbecility, rivals BCG's hiring.
3. Locking Kentucky into a ruinous deal with JMI. This could be No. 1 if some competent sports journalist does link Mitch to undisclosed personal gain from this deal. For now, it is simply another example of gross incompetence to inhibit Kentucky's ability to compete for stars in the NIL era by limiting their options to profit.
4. Hiring Mark Pope. It is still possible Pope turns it around. Possible. But even if he does, hiring a coach without an NCAA tournament win to take over the sport's most prestigious program was the act of a moron.
5. Giving John Calipari a lifetime contract. When he was hungry for several years, Calipari was on top of the sport. What could go wrong? Kill his motivation. Only a half-wit jackass could accomplish turning Calipari into a lethargic cypher. Well done Mitch!
6. Giving Mark Stoops a gigantic buyout. Stoops' record was always a bit of a mirage: If you only looked at SEC results he was never top tier. But if there was a way to make sure he failed, Mitch found it by removing his incentive to improve. Paying a guy like Stoops a $38 million buyout would rank as the all-time most foolish move by many ADs. For Millionaire Mitch it doesn't crack the Top Five.

Not hiring Rick pitino to replace tubby is the all time blunder.

That was a no brainer. And I promise that crap that happened t UL would not have happened at UK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wildcatjedi

TheBlueMist

All-American
Feb 5, 2004
2,072
5,018
113

You mean this goofball made stupid and corrupt decisions? The notion!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Wildcatjedi

CatBearPig

All-Conference
Apr 26, 2024
725
1,537
93
Let’s also not forget about having a basketball coach for a full season with a contract written on a napkin. How many times have you seen that happen?
 
  • Like
Reactions: -UKGrad93-

Resignmarkpope

Sophomore
Mar 13, 2026
222
187
43
There have been so many idiotic, corrupt, naive decisions by Kentucky's AD that they are hard to rank.

Here's my attempt:
1. Hiring Billy Clyde Gillispie. This showed an almost complete lack of understanding of the Crown Jewel of Kentucky athletics. Almost any AD would be fired for this. At Kentucky, it was seen as just a warm up for nearly two more decades of stupidity.
2. Naming Joker Phillips "Coach In Waiting." Football is not as important as basketball at Kentucky. But this decision, for sheer imbecility, rivals BCG's hiring.
3. Locking Kentucky into a ruinous deal with JMI. This could be No. 1 if some competent sports journalist does link Mitch to undisclosed personal gain from this deal. For now, it is simply another example of gross incompetence to inhibit Kentucky's ability to compete for stars in the NIL era by limiting their options to profit.
4. Hiring Mark Pope. It is still possible Pope turns it around. Possible. But even if he does, hiring a coach without an NCAA tournament win to take over the sport's most prestigious program was the act of a moron.
5. Giving John Calipari a lifetime contract. When he was hungry for several years, Calipari was on top of the sport. What could go wrong? Kill his motivation. Only a half-wit jackass could accomplish turning Calipari into a lethargic cypher. Well done Mitch!
6. Giving Mark Stoops a gigantic buyout. Stoops' record was always a bit of a mirage: If you only looked at SEC results he was never top tier. But if there was a way to make sure he failed, Mitch found it by removing his incentive to improve. Paying a guy like Stoops a $38 million buyout would rank as the all-time most foolish move by many ADs. For Millionaire Mitch it doesn't crack the Top Five.
1a elzy/joker
1b pope
2 Billy Clyde
3 stoops deal
4 coach Cal’s deal
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wildcatjedi

catfanlou

All-Conference
Jul 6, 2005
3,555
1,108
41
Top two have to be keeping Joker an extra year and Stoops 37 million buyout .
we used to be 70,000 strong . Twenty thousand fans left the next year and we were never the same Fanwise . Reduced stadium seating to save face . Agree with the above comments about making tailgating more difficult. They lost twelve season tickets when they refused to renew the blue pass of the guy who put up our tent . Even tough ours was renewed we decided not to renew because of ghe tent problem. Twelve season tickets lost because they favored money over loyal fans .

Stoops buyout was unlike any other contract in the nation . Never should have been signed . Reason for it was Cal made that dumb statement about us being a basketball school . MB panicked . Gave Stoops a two million plus raise and the buyout WITHOUT any set off for earnings at other schools . Really really dumb .