Hines enters portal

joeyklings

Junior
Jan 27, 2024
380
283
63
Sha has now lost his best returning player 3 years in a row. Richmond, Coleman, & now Hines.

For those you think Clark is better I guarantee if both go into the portal, Hines will have more high majors & more $
 
  • Like
Reactions: shu67

NCAAsorBust

Senior
Jan 14, 2026
513
419
63
With the stupidity of the rules, there is no good reason to not enter the portal. You can do your own market research and still come back to the same school if you want if they are willing to take you back. And I have to believe most coaches want guys that have been in their system before, so it's not a tough sell for the coach to take you back. The sad part is these young people will never experience the community that so many college players had been a part of in the past and you'll have few names synonymous with a school. It makes a player like Karaban easy to root for.
 

Fishjam

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2016
674
2,353
93
Can't blame him. I wonder what Sha offered? Hines is going to get $3M+ and it's just too much for us.

We have a weak budget and Sha doesn't like spending big on individual players. I can't see Sha offering a player more than he makes.
 

HALL85

Heisman
Jul 5, 2001
29,858
11,032
113
Can't blame him. I wonder what Sha offered? Hines is going to get $3M+ and it's just too much for us.

We have a weak budget and Sha doesn't like spending big on individual players. I can't see Sha offering a player more than he makes.
Exactly. If I’m Hines, and can make $12-15 million in four years by “portaling” every year vs staying “loyal” for $6-8 million, I know what I’m doing. That’s FU money IF he is smart.
 

HallGuy2323

Senior
Jun 3, 2020
684
468
63
Good thing we rested him so much. He’ll be nice and healthy for Pitino or Cooley. When are we going to learn. Run these dudes into the ground. 1 year of service calls for maximum usage.
 

Konica Guy

Freshman
Jul 17, 2002
53
58
18
Good thing we rested him so much. He’ll be nice and healthy for Pitino or Cooley. When are we going to learn. Run these dudes into the ground. 1 year of service calls for maximum usage.
Sha thought Payne was better lmao. Tells you all you need to know about his talent evaluation. Coach is beyond clueless and just got a big raise and extended. The misery never ends
 
  • Like
Reactions: SHUS1516 and shu09

bornApirate

Redshirt
Apr 17, 2017
6
7
3
High rated college players have always wanted to showcase their skills to be drafted in the NBA. Throw in that they are now showcasing their skills to earn my money each season while still playing in college, I don’t see how this is a surprise to anyone.

These types of players will never stay to play for a coach that has players use all their energy on defense leaving them no legs for offense. This hurts future earning potential.

Throw in the awful SHU offensive sets and I don’t see any true offensively skilled player wanted to come regardless of money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PirateBlue08

Jerry1992

Redshirt
Sep 20, 2013
59
46
18
Has any better than average player entered portal and returned to Seton Hall? Probably only a handful if that. Say goodbye.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hall-O-Daze

ivyhillpark63

Junior
Feb 4, 2012
366
368
62
I loved hines and but le
6 points 5 rebounds per game I think we will be ok.
yes I would love for him to stay and develop into a monster but it’s just not reality in our world.
Take a deep breath everyone.
Was just gonna say same thing...yes he has potential but outside of 5 feet from the basket cant score or defend on the perimeter....
 
  • Like
Reactions: The SHUttle

PirateBlue08

Senior
Jul 25, 2025
419
410
63
Go ahead. Go into the ham, take the carving knife, and stab me here. Right here!

Frankly, I’m depressed and ashamed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HallLine69

HallGuy2323

Senior
Jun 3, 2020
684
468
63
6 points 5 rebounds per game I think we will be ok.
yes I would love for him to stay and develop into a monster but it’s just not reality in our world.
Take a deep breath everyone.
Got a better option hiding out in the A-Sun or Patriot league? Because that’s where we shop. Oh that’s right, our GM knows every hidden gem in America. We’re saved!
 
  • Like
Reactions: shu67

JTSHU

Senior
Feb 9, 2015
526
443
63
This is all on the coach. He had him riding pine all year for a bum like Payne. He’s not leaving bc of the money, he’s leaving bc the way he was used, which was terribly. Coach needs to wake up fast this is ridiculous
Hines was really out of shape, slow on D and couldnt go out to the perimeter
 

JTSHU

Senior
Feb 9, 2015
526
443
63
Good thing we rested him so much. He’ll be nice and healthy for Pitino or Cooley. When are we going to learn. Run these dudes into the ground. 1 year of service calls for maximum usage.
Thats what i said. Get ur $$ worth
 

joeyklings

Junior
Jan 27, 2024
380
283
63
Hines was really out of shape, slow on D and couldnt go out to the perimeter
We watched different games. I didn’t see “really out of shape”, or slow on d. I saw a freshman big who was our best player at times, scored easily, shot decent from the ft line, and blocked shots at a high clip.
 

Gritty5837

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2021
1,753
3,737
113
For a quaint fanbase like Seton Hall, losing your best player every year really hurts. They needed to maintain momentum going into next season and give the fanbase reasons for excitement / to stay engaged. Keeping Hines and Clark would do that.

But there's not much they can do if Hines gets a big pay increase and the opportunity to potentially compete for a natty.

It will be a massive groin kick if he ends up at St. Johns though. Total embarrassment if so.