OT: Washington is going to have a hard time with NIL

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
88,574
86,594
113
The problem is that you're not "dunking" --your statements are challengeable as well. So really all you're doing is contributing to the "flame war." It's much better to do what I did -- to point out that the incontrovertible facts contract the OP. You'll notice that no one has tried to get into a flame war with *me.*
Nor should they. You are a gentleman and a scholar. As to the one you are "debating," best to put that person on ignore.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BossNJ

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,971
10,149
58
Nor should they. You are a gentleman and a scholar. As to the one you are "debating," best to put that person on ignore.
Thank you for the nice compliment. I resist putting people on ignore unless they personally insult me. At that point, I smile: the best way to prove someone correct is to insult him personally -- that's a proof that the insulter knows he doesn't have a leg to stand on.
 

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,971
10,149
58
Yeah, he taxed toilet paper in NJ for the first time.
If you look closely enough, you can still see Flush Florio stickers on traffic light poles and street signs. Ahh, the memories.
FWIW, the vast majority of states with sales taxes impose sales tax on toilet paper -- NJ and Pa. are among the exceptions. But Florio did a terrible job convincing the electorate that the taxes were needed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
88,574
86,594
113
FWIW, the vast majority of states with sales taxes impose sales tax on toilet paper -- NJ and Pa. are among the exceptions. But Florio did a terrible job convincing the electorate that the taxes were needed.
I was young, but in my memory, Florio and Whitney were two of the worst Governors in my lifetime. This great State could use another Brendan Byrne or Tom Kean Sr as Governor again.
 

NotInRHouse

Senior
Jul 29, 2025
559
416
63
So, a $50 billion dollar a year company is going to give Oregon less in your theory because of corporate taxes. Really? You've debunked nothing.

I'm sure FSU does and they've spent poorly the last two years no one is debating that, but do any of them own a $50 billion dollar a year company? There's not too many of those guys out there so I'd say, no.

Cal last winning season before last year's, 7-6 was 8-5 in 2019. FSU was still in the National Title talks after the last game, just two years ago.

Are you seriously suggesting that the reason FSU is their current position is lack of donations? Don't most of their alums live in Florida?

Most Oregon alums live in Oregon and have no issue.
 

NotInRHouse

Senior
Jul 29, 2025
559
416
63
The problem is that you're not "dunking" --your statements are challengeable as well. So really all you're doing is contributing to the "flame war." It's much better to do what I did -- to point out that the incontrovertible facts contract the OP. You'll notice that no one has tried to get into a flame war with *me.*

Not really. OR and CA have the highest taxation. FL has among the lowest. The football results speak for themselves.
 

NotInRHouse

Senior
Jul 29, 2025
559
416
63
Merrill Kelly flat out said his people ran the numbers and he signed with the DBacks instead of the Padres because of the California taxes. Period. Who cares if it is called NIL or salary? Not Kelly.

The Dodgers have a massive payroll and have found ways to skirt the salary cap with deferred payments.

Seahawks... uhh, yeah, they won the Super Bowl before this proposed law. It is not a relevant data point.

Back to the OP, I do think the tax law is not likely to be a huge factor in Washington college NIL. We are not talking about guys with huge payments. Even for someone getting 2 million from Husky football, that's "only" a 200k hit max. But to ignore that it could be a factor for some guys (again, Merrill Kelly just admitted it) is to be 100% partisan.

Do Dodgers players not pay the same taxes as Padres players?

Seems absolutely ridiculous.
 

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
37,299
58,594
113
Are you seriously suggesting that the reason FSU is their current position is lack of donations? Don't most of their alums live in Florida?

Most Oregon alums live in Oregon and have no issue.
How do you get "lack of donations" from "spent poorly"?

You seriously think Oregon alums are footing the bill? Try one alum in Phil Knight, who has given Oregon over $1 billion dollars and just recently $500 mil. to their NIL and basically said, there's more where that came from.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Caliknight

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,971
10,149
58
How do you get "lack of donations" from "spent poorly"?

You seriously think Oregon alums are footing the bill? Try one alum in Phil Knight, who has given Oregon over $1 billion dollars and just recently $500 mil. to their NIL and basically said, there's more where that came from.
Taxes or not, Oregon is going to be at an advantage from having Knight as a donor. NIL deals with third parties are OK if there is (a) a valid business purpose related to the endorsement and marketing of products and (b) compensation commensurate with the work. Knight, as owner of a maker of athletic equipment, will be more able to meet those requirements than most other boosters trying to get NIL deals past the College Sports Commission.
 
  • Like
Reactions: koleszar

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,971
10,149
58
Nike is headquartered in....drumroll please...Oregon.

All their execs are subject to Oregon taxation. The company is taxed in Oregon.

If we're to believe the idiotic argument being posited...U of Oregon would have less money to take from Nike in the first place....

Also, are we to believe that UF and FSU don't have rich donors?

So the theory "taxation matters in NIL, except when the school has big donors" is also debunked.

On to your next theory.

Yes I'd love to talk about Cal.

Cal and FSU are in the same conference.

Last season Cal was 7-5.

FSU was 5-7.

There goes that.

Any more talking points that can be debunked in seconds?
You obviously love cherries -- you pick them a lot! Ask *anybody* at Cal if they would prefer their football record over the past decade to FSU's, and they won't be able to stop laughing.
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,672
18,961
113
Do Dodgers players not pay the same taxes as Padres players?

Seems absolutely ridiculous.

Depends how the deal is structured. If there's deferred comp that hits after retirement the tax hit might well be lower. Not exempt because is related to employment. Isn't there a former Met who gets deferred comp years after he retired?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rutgers Chris

Rutgers Chris

All-American
Nov 29, 2005
5,051
5,909
97
Depends how the deal is structured. If there's deferred comp that hits after retirement the tax hit might well be lower. Not exempt because is related to employment. Isn't there a former Met who gets deferred comp years after he retired?
July 1, Bobby Bonilla Day. They deferred the money to have more liquid cash to invest with Madoff

The details of how the dodgers deferred Ohtani’s contract are pretty crazy. Not surprising given how they operate that the padres couldn’t figure out something similar.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BossNJ

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,971
10,149
58
July 1, Bobby Bonilla Day. They deferred the money to have more liquid cash to invest with Madoff

The details of how the dodgers deferred Ohtani’s contract are pretty crazy. Not surprising given how they operate that the padres couldn’t figure out something similar.
Another reason why the compensation is deferred is precisely to allow Ohtani to evade California income tax (with a top rate of 13.3%) by moving out of California when his playing career is over. (This link *may* be behind a paywall.) https://www.forbes.com/sites/nathan...advantaged-contract-appears-to-be-paying-off/
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,672
18,961
113

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,971
10,149
58
Actually California has a shot to tax that, at least partially, as connected to employment within the state.
Maybe, but I can tell you that at least one California legislator is nervous enough to have introduced a bill to limit deferred compensation deals like this one. I wonder where Bobby Bonilla is living and whether he is paying New York income tax on what he receives on Bobby Bonilla day every July 1.
 

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
6,804
7,569
113
Maybe, but I can tell you that at least one California legislator is nervous enough to have introduced a bill to limit deferred compensation deals like this one. I wonder where Bobby Bonilla is living and whether he is paying New York income tax on what he receives on Bobby Bonilla day every July 1.
Looks like he was smart and moved to a no tax state.

Former MLB star Bobby Bonilla lives in Sarasota, Florida. He moved to Florida, which has no state income tax, allowing him to keep more of his annual $1.19 million deferred payments from the New York Mets. These payments, celebrated annually on "Bobby Bonilla Day," continue through 2035
 
  • Like
Reactions: Caliknight

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,672
18,961
113
Maybe, but I can tell you that at least one California legislator is nervous enough to have introduced a bill to limit deferred compensation deals like this one. I wonder where Bobby Bonilla is living and whether he is paying New York income tax on what he receives on Bobby Bonilla day every July 1.

Good question on Bonilla. And I'm sure California will try to stop it. What I do know (not personally) is if you worked in NY and then retire to Florida with employee stock options unexercised NY will get to tax them when you do exercise them. It gets complicated if you lived in NJ worked in NY and then retire to Florida. 30 years ago NY did that with pensions until Congress stopped it legislatively.
 

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,971
10,149
58
Good question on Bonilla. And I'm sure California will try to stop it. What I do know (not personally) is if you worked in NY and then retire to Florida with employee stock options unexercised NY will get to tax them when you do exercise them. It gets complicated if you lived in NJ worked in NY and then retire to Florida. 30 years ago NY did that with pensions until Congress stopped it legislatively.
I *think* that stock options are different because the employee can choose when to exercise them -- that is, the employee could have exercised them while working at the NY job. With Ohtani's contract, he doesn't have the right to receive the money until the year of payment and so his state of residence in that year is the key to state taxation. That may be why Bonilla is living in Sarasota, Florida. But I'm not going to pretend to be an expert on tax law.
 
Jun 7, 2001
35,848
43,305
113
As it happens, U. Florida and Florida State have far higher U.S. news rankings than U. Oregon . In fact, U. Florida has a higher U.S. News ranking than, Rutgers-New Brunswick, and Florida State isn't far behind. The reason is that Florida has scholarship programs that give a lot of aid to Florida high school graduates that stay in-state. In addition, in-state tuition at these schools is substantially less than at Rutgers. When I was a high school kid in Florida almost sixty years ago, Florida's public universities weren't good at all, but clearly that's changed.

(I have a low opinion of U.S. news rankings, but since everybody else relies on them, I feel free to cite them here.)

As you pointed out, Floridas scholarships and savings programs have helped keep a good portion of the best and brightest home. One of my friends chose Florida over Duke.
 

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,971
10,149
58
As you pointed out, Floridas scholarships and savings programs have helped keep a good portion of the best and brightest home. One of my friends chose Florida over Duke.
And I can tell you that your friend is not the only Floridian who has done that. It's very hard to turn down a good education at a very reasonable price and choose instead to pay oodles at a private college, as excellent as Duke is.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
196,388
148,423
113
Maybe, but I can tell you that at least one California legislator is nervous enough to have introduced a bill to limit deferred compensation deals like this one. I wonder where Bobby Bonilla is living and whether he is paying New York income tax on what he receives on Bobby Bonilla day every July 1.
CA is so desperate Newsome openly spoke of taxing people even after they leave the state. It's dire times out here. A poster in this thread used to crow about the alleged surplus Ca had. I told him it was nothing but smoke and mirrors and what they truth was, but he wasn't smart enough to figure it out. Now look at him lol #PudgyJoker
 

RUKen1

Redshirt
Jul 5, 2025
19
23
2
Good question on Bonilla. And I'm sure California will try to stop it. What I do know (not personally) is if you worked in NY and then retire to Florida with employee stock options unexercised NY will get to tax them when you do exercise them. It gets complicated if you lived in NJ worked in NY and then retire to Florida. 30 years ago NY did that with pensions until Congress stopped it legislatively.
I know from personal experience regarding deferred income. It’s is taxed in the state where you currently reside when it’s becomes current year income.
 

NotInRHouse

Senior
Jul 29, 2025
559
416
63
How do you get "lack of donations" from "spent poorly"?

You seriously think Oregon alums are footing the bill? Try one alum in Phil Knight, who has given Oregon over $1 billion dollars and just recently $500 mil. to their NIL and basically said, there's more where that came from.

And in what state does Knight live?
 

NotInRHouse

Senior
Jul 29, 2025
559
416
63
May I ask how you know that your first sentence is true?

Most people here know my actual name, and you can google the results from July the year I graduated. The NY ones leaked online. And then you can also check my status with the state bar.

He tried this before and was humiliated. You'd think that his status, leaving the board and trying to start his own venture that imploded, would chasten him...but...
 
  • Like
Reactions: BossNJ

NotInRHouse

Senior
Jul 29, 2025
559
416
63
Depends how the deal is structured. If there's deferred comp that hits after retirement the tax hit might well be lower. Not exempt because is related to employment. Isn't there a former Met who gets deferred comp years after he retired?

The taxation is the same in LA as it is in SD though. The bottom line is, if CA taxation is ruining teams there, then surely there isn't a CA team that won back to back World Series...oh...
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Caliknight

RUforester72

All-Conference
Jul 23, 2014
3,596
2,352
112
How do you get "lack of donations" from "spent poorly"?

You seriously think Oregon alums are footing the bill? Try one alum in Phil Knight, who has given Oregon over $1 billion dollars and just recently $500 mil. to their NIL and basically said, there's more where that came from.
Knight did NOT give $500 million for NIL at UO.

"Phil Knight, co-founder of Nike, and his wife Penny have made multiple, distinct $500 million pledges to the University of Oregon(UO) for scientific research. These historic, record-breaking gifts established and expanded the Phil and Penny Knight Campus for Accelerating Scientific Impact, designed to fast-track research
and boost economic development in Oregon. "
 

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
6,804
7,569
113
Knight did NOT give $500 million for NIL at UO.

"Phil Knight, co-founder of Nike, and his wife Penny have made multiple, distinct $500 million pledges to the University of Oregon(UO) for scientific research. These historic, record-breaking gifts established and expanded the Phil and Penny Knight Campus for Accelerating Scientific Impact, designed to fast-track research
and boost economic development in Oregon. "


A simple Phil Knigh NIL search found a this. Both things can be true. Phil did give to cancer research and NIL. Been quoted as saying he wants to see 2 things before he dies. Cancer cured and the ducks win a national championship.
Nike co-founder Phil Knight is a major proponent of University of Oregon athletics, significantly funding Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) efforts through the Division Street Collective to secure top talent. Knight’s "unlimited" funding approach aims to win a national title, often directly engaging in recruiting high-profile prospects.

Key Aspects of Phil Knight's NIL Role:
  • Division Street Collective: Knight co-founded this organization to facilitate NIL opportunities specifically for Oregon athletes.
  • "Unlimited" Funding: He has been described as providing nearly unlimited NIL resources in his pursuit of a national championship.
  • Direct Recruiting: Knight has actively assisted in recruiting, playing a significant role in flipping top prospects, such as 5-star cornerback Na'eem Offord.
  • Impact on Oregon Football: His financial influence has helped Oregon maintain a top-tier recruiting class in 2025.
  • "Uncle Phil" Persona: Players and coaches often refer to him affectionately as "Uncle Phil," highlighting his close relationship with the program.
  • Rivalries & Influence: Despite Ohio State being a major Nike partner, Knight’s efforts are squarely focused on Oregon, leading to intense competition between the schools, such as when Oregon beat Ohio State for key recruits.
 

Attachments

  • 1773939488080.png
    1773939488080.png
    2 KB · Views: 1
  • 1773939488089.png
    1773939488089.png
    1.6 KB · Views: 1
  • 1773939488098.jpeg
    1773939488098.jpeg
    10.5 KB · Views: 1
  • 1773939488105.png
    1773939488105.png
    1.1 KB · Views: 1

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
196,388
148,423
113
The taxation is the same in LA as it is in SD though. The bottom line is, if CA taxation is ruining teams there, then surely there isn't a CA team that won back to back World Series...oh...
Failed attorney gets dumber with every post
 

NotInRHouse

Senior
Jul 29, 2025
559
416
63
Poor valet now calls himself "failed attorney" after promising to leave the board to create his own, which shocker, failed MISERABLY.
 

BossNJ

All-American
Oct 6, 2020
9,903
8,762
113
The odd thing is that Whitman barely beat Florio, as disliked as he was. It has been reported that her husband and brother fought incessantly about how to run the campaign. Finally they turned to an experienced Republican campaign manager who told her to promise a tax cut (duh!!). She still didn't win by much. What is even odder to me is that Florio (who, actually, I worked with when he was a Congressman and I was a Capitol Hill staffer, and who was not a dumb guy) was never repentant either about the tax increases or even about the way he presented them.

For whatever reason, Bradley chose not to run for re-election in 1996. Apparently three terms in the Senate were enough.
As he aged, Florio bore a striking resemblance to Cesar Romero..😂😂
 

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,971
10,149
58
As he aged, Florio bore a striking resemblance to Cesar Romero..😂😂
Not a surprise. As you may know, Florio was an amateur middleweight boxer when serving in the United States Navy before going to college. His left cheekbone was permanently sunken as a result.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CollegeSenior