Why are older people so opposed to bringing back Rick Pitino?

rivercatinfl

All-Conference
Nov 21, 2012
1,977
1,874
97
I'm 33

But...

The Resume speaks for itself
  • 2× NCAA National Champion head coach
  • 7× Final Four appearances as a head coach
  • 10+ conference tournament championships
  • 10+ regular season conference championships
  • Led three different programs to the Final Four (first coach to accomplish this)
  • Led five different programs to the NCAA Tournament
  • One of the few coaches to reach the Final Four at three different schools
  • Over 800 career coaching wins (college level)
  • Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame inductee (2013)
  • Multiple National Coach of the Year awards
  • Known for pioneering full-court pressing defenses and high-tempo offenses
  • Developed dozens of NBA players and first-round draft picks
  • Successfully rebuilt multiple struggling programs into national contenders within a few seasons

Alot of older people I've talked to laugh at me when I propose this. I was a child when he won here and a teenager during the Louisville scandal. So I don’t really understand why someone with this resume who wants to coach here is opposed by a lot of older UK fans.

We're the 9th best basketball team in the SEC. How are we above bringing him back? Please help me understand
I'd love to get Pitino back with a coach in training under his wing.
I'm older than dust but I remember well what it was like during Camelot.
I'd still get Prince as the GM. Much needed if that has any legs at all.
 

BBNinSCar

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2013
1,365
2,155
81
One thing I'm amazed by are guys in their 80s that coach. Two names that come to mind are Bobby Bowden and (notwithstanding the pedo scandal) Joe Paterno.
and both of them were mush at the end of their careers, obviously someone else in their programs was pulling the strings. They were just figure heads.
If Kentucky needs a basketball coach in the future, I hope we can identify a younger guy that’s ready to win big at a blue blood.
It has nothing to do with ageism, but a coach that’s climbing the ladder will have a fire to succeed and ignorance to work hard.
Pitino has been there, he’s seen it all and he’s a millionaire and he wouldn’t be for long here.
Duke found Josh Scheyer, Kansas found a young Bill Self 23 years ago, Arizona found Lloyd. Kentucky needs to find our guy for the future and the long term.
We will not maintain our level of greatness by changing coaches every few seasons.
I’m all for sticking with Pope and fully supporting him another season. But, if we have another year like this one- hire Josh Shertz, he’s the next big time winner, IMO.
 

Eight_Banners

Junior
Feb 22, 2016
140
219
43
Are you serious? Pitino might be a scummy person but he is one of the best coaches ever.
Thanks for answering my question. He couldn't beat Calipari, he lost to Pope this year. I don't care if he's one of the best coaches ever if he has done nothing against UK's last coach and current coach, so I would not take him over either.

Bill Self has been the best coach over the last twenty-five years (debatable with Coach K and Few), significantly ahead of Pitino, and I wouldn't take him as our coach (or the other two in parenthesis).
 

megablue

Heisman
Oct 2, 2012
15,508
15,544
113
One thing I'm amazed by are guys in their 80s that coach. Two names that come to mind are Bobby Bowden and (notwithstanding the pedo scandal) Joe Paterno.
Football has far more coaching delegation than basketball, but I get your point.
 

Jp1542

Junior
Feb 15, 2026
182
237
43
I'm 33

But...

The Resume speaks for itself
  • 2× NCAA National Champion head coach
  • 7× Final Four appearances as a head coach
  • 10+ conference tournament championships
  • 10+ regular season conference championships
  • Led three different programs to the Final Four (first coach to accomplish this)
  • Led five different programs to the NCAA Tournament
  • One of the few coaches to reach the Final Four at three different schools
  • Over 800 career coaching wins (college level)
  • Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame inductee (2013)
  • Multiple National Coach of the Year awards
  • Known for pioneering full-court pressing defenses and high-tempo offenses
  • Developed dozens of NBA players and first-round draft picks
  • Successfully rebuilt multiple struggling programs into national contenders within a few seasons

Alot of older people I've talked to laugh at me when I propose this. I was a child when he won here and a teenager during the Louisville scandal. So I don’t really understand why someone with this resume who wants to coach here is opposed by a lot of older UK fans.

We're the 9th best basketball team in the SEC. How are we above bringing him back? Please help me understand
I’m 76 and I’m fine with it.
 

harlanking

Redshirt
Mar 15, 2026
12
27
13
Thanks for answering my question. He couldn't beat Calipari, he lost to Pope this year. I don't care if he's one of the best coaches ever if he has done nothing against UK's last coach and current coach, so I would not take him over either.

Bill Self has been the best coach over the last twenty-five years (debatable with Coach K and Few), significantly ahead of Pitino, and I wouldn't take him as our coach (or the other two in parenthesis).


Idk anyone who is legit CBB fan who would take Pope over Pitino. This seems like an emotional response vs a logical one.

Its not even close on which coach is better
 

K_TIME

Heisman
Jan 2, 2003
18,370
25,644
113
who said older people objected to bringing back Rick over Pope?

I think it’s more like Mitch wants only clean off court of field coaches…I don’t pin this on fans

but id argue Ky doesn’t need to settle for 70 year old coach …go get the next Pitino
 
  • Like
Reactions: UKCatNnc

Eight_Banners

Junior
Feb 22, 2016
140
219
43
Idk anyone who is legit CBB fan who would take Pope over Pitino. This seems like an emotional response vs a logical one.

Its not even close on which coach is better
You're saying that a coach who went 2-9 v. Coach Cal in the eight years their tenures overlapped, and is now 0-1 v. Mark Pope is clearly the better coach of the three, logically?

Apart from head to head wins, what is a better way of comparing coaching abilities?

Enlighten me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pidgie

Anon1751575442

Redshirt
Jul 3, 2025
9
6
3
B/c we remember when he took the job at our biggest rival when other jobs were available. B/c he flipped off the fan base in rupp arena like a middle school kid would… not to mention all the morally bankrupt shenanigans such as adultery and supplying hookers to young and some underaged boys. Just to mention a few good reasons.
 

sk73

All-Conference
Feb 16, 2013
3,183
3,234
113
He has performed one of his very best coaching jobs this year. St. Johns is so much better than they were in early season. I thought they would be a 500 team after watching them play us. If anything it magnifies the different levels of coaching ability between Pitino and Pope. We have regressed significantly and they have improved so ,so much. I still do want want Pitino, in his mid seventies, to return. .
 
  • Like
Reactions: wildcatdon

BigBlue1992

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2011
1,960
3,596
81
My biggest thing is whether or not we can believe him on if he truly wants UK to succeed like he portrays.

Remember when he was pushing for us to hire Travis Ford or John Pelphrey? And now Mark Pope? Did he do it because he was truly happy for Pope or did he do it for his own pleasure due to his hatred for John Calipari? My guess is most of what Pitino does is for his own pleasure and not for others.
 

BlueSince92

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
10,458
2,795
230
I'm 33

But...

The Resume speaks for itself
  • 2× NCAA National Champion head coach
  • 7× Final Four appearances as a head coach
  • 10+ conference tournament championships
  • 10+ regular season conference championships
  • Led three different programs to the Final Four (first coach to accomplish this)
  • Led five different programs to the NCAA Tournament
  • One of the few coaches to reach the Final Four at three different schools
  • Over 800 career coaching wins (college level)
  • Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame inductee (2013)
  • Multiple National Coach of the Year awards
  • Known for pioneering full-court pressing defenses and high-tempo offenses
  • Developed dozens of NBA players and first-round draft picks
  • Successfully rebuilt multiple struggling programs into national contenders within a few seasons

Alot of older people I've talked to laugh at me when I propose this. I was a child when he won here and a teenager during the Louisville scandal. So I don’t really understand why someone with this resume who wants to coach here is opposed by a lot of older UK fans.

We're the 9th best basketball team in the SEC. How are we above bringing him back? Please help me understand
Bring back Ricky P.

And b1tch slap every single person who wants Cal back, who will have Arkansas in the top 15 next week and wasted at least six years of our time, over Pitino, who will have fricking Saint John’s in the top 10 next week and wasted zero years of our time.
 

AllBall

All-American
May 5, 2015
4,361
5,545
93
At 73? Love him and what he did here. But he's too old. We just need to find the next Pitino. But first, we need an AD that can recognize talented coaches. And get JMI out the picture.
But you'll vote for a president who's almost 80. Our views are so skewed.
 

wildcat111

All-Conference
Dec 9, 2020
1,533
1,727
113
I'm 33

But...

The Resume speaks for itself
  • 2× NCAA National Champion head coach
  • 7× Final Four appearances as a head coach
  • 10+ conference tournament championships
  • 10+ regular season conference championships
  • Led three different programs to the Final Four (first coach to accomplish this)
  • Led five different programs to the NCAA Tournament
  • One of the few coaches to reach the Final Four at three different schools
  • Over 800 career coaching wins (college level)
  • Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame inductee (2013)
  • Multiple National Coach of the Year awards
  • Known for pioneering full-court pressing defenses and high-tempo offenses
  • Developed dozens of NBA players and first-round draft picks
  • Successfully rebuilt multiple struggling programs into national contenders within a few seasons

Alot of older people I've talked to laugh at me when I propose this. I was a child when he won here and a teenager during the Louisville scandal. So I don’t really understand why someone with this resume who wants to coach here is opposed by a lot of older UK fans.

We're the 9th best basketball team in the SEC. How are we above bringing him back? Please help me understand
I am 78 years old and have been wanting to bring him back since he left.
 

Ukbrassowtipin

Heisman
Aug 12, 2011
82,218
90,140
113
I’d certainly take him back for 4-5 years if he wanted to come. Let him transition into another coach if next time we can’t get one of the elite guys to move. Only as a last resort but he would keep us relevant and recruit well enough for sure.
Pitino isnt recruiting, hes already said at his age hes just going to utilize the portal
 
  • Like
Reactions: Monday Nitro

Dead Cat Bounce

All-Conference
Jan 8, 2003
2,745
4,833
113
He’s too old, he hired prostitutes for underage children in attempt to stop Calipari from kicking his teeth in year after year, he left on his own free will, he gave us the middle finger in Rupp, he just got smacked in the mouth by Pope THIS season. I mean idk, could be a few reasons. 🤷🏼‍♂️

This list is like Enigma.
Typography Decipher GIF
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Pygmy Sasquatch

Ash Williams

Heisman
Aug 3, 2022
8,047
26,068
113
I gotta ask, do posters still want Hurley since he was the one blown out? How about Oats and Golden? My point is that we can't just take a coach because he had a good run of a year or two. Or, do posters disagree with that?
"Good run" = Back to back titles.

Man you really try hard, dontcha.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Austin Gator

Ash Williams

Heisman
Aug 3, 2022
8,047
26,068
113
Thanks for answering my question. He couldn't beat Calipari, he lost to Pope this year. I don't care if he's one of the best coaches ever if he has done nothing against UK's last coach and current coach, so I would not take him over either.

Bill Self has been the best coach over the last twenty-five years (debatable with Coach K and Few), significantly ahead of Pitino, and I wouldn't take him as our coach (or the other two in parenthesis).
You wouldn't take Self? He won the title the same year we blew them out at their place. You think KU fan or KU alum or Self give one single thought to that loss that year? You're delusional.
 
Jan 14, 2002
746
483
63
I'm 33

But...

The Resume speaks for itself
  • 2× NCAA National Champion head coach
  • 7× Final Four appearances as a head coach
  • 10+ conference tournament championships
  • 10+ regular season conference championships
  • Led three different programs to the Final Four (first coach to accomplish this)
  • Led five different programs to the NCAA Tournament
  • One of the few coaches to reach the Final Four at three different schools
  • Over 800 career coaching wins (college level)
  • Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame inductee (2013)
  • Multiple National Coach of the Year awards
  • Known for pioneering full-court pressing defenses and high-tempo offenses
  • Developed dozens of NBA players and first-round draft picks
  • Successfully rebuilt multiple struggling programs into national contenders within a few seasons

Alot of older people I've talked to laugh at me when I propose this. I was a child when he won here and a teenager during the Louisville scandal. So I don’t really understand why someone with this resume who wants to coach here is opposed by a lot of older UK fans.

We're the 9th best basketball team in the SEC. How are we above bringing him back? Please help me understand
He is the max getting social security
 

Goingfor9

All-Conference
Jan 27, 2003
16,036
2,811
113
Don’t include this older person in your statement. I was all for bringing him back a long time ago and again last year instead of Pope. Another huge blunder by Mitch.


When Barney was whip up a fury over pitino and wanting to pick a coach that beat him in Rupp. Instead he should have had a positive narrative about Rick and hired him. Heck even if Barney couldn’t change the narrative (and it’s evident now Barney worked to put out his propaganda at various times. A real leader would have hired pitino in 2007. Should have never looked past him because he was at the rival. What a stupid move
 
  • Love
Reactions: Wildcatjedi

-BBH-

All-American
Mar 13, 2004
10,515
6,850
73
He just doesn’t seem to have the years in the tank that this position requires. St. John’s is a perfect place for him. Some of the guys mentioned on this thread who coached into their 80’s were long term coaches at their respective colleges and it was a different landscape in college sports.
 

JonathanW2

Senior
Aug 6, 2025
414
614
93
Because he is old, and will very likely retire himself in 2-3 years, and we don't want to have to get a new coach so soon again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pidgie

Pidgie

Senior
Jul 4, 2025
131
439
63
I'm 33

But...

The Resume speaks for itself
  • 2× NCAA National Champion head coach
  • 7× Final Four appearances as a head coach
  • 10+ conference tournament championships
  • 10+ regular season conference championships
  • Led three different programs to the Final Four (first coach to accomplish this)
  • Led five different programs to the NCAA Tournament
  • One of the few coaches to reach the Final Four at three different schools
  • Over 800 career coaching wins (college level)
  • Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame inductee (2013)
  • Multiple National Coach of the Year awards
  • Known for pioneering full-court pressing defenses and high-tempo offenses
  • Developed dozens of NBA players and first-round draft picks
  • Successfully rebuilt multiple struggling programs into national contenders within a few seasons

Alot of older people I've talked to laugh at me when I propose this. I was a child when he won here and a teenager during the Louisville scandal. So I don’t really understand why someone with this resume who wants to coach here is opposed by a lot of older UK fans.

We're the 9th best basketball team in the SEC. How are we above bringing him back? Please help me understand
He's old and he's a slut........low moral character..........her bought prostitutes for recruits that were under age.......he should be in jail!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1751575442

Pidgie

Senior
Jul 4, 2025
131
439
63
I thought all the girls were 18. The only articles I can see with underage girls have the term "allegations" attached to it.

Seems like an old school rupprafters rumor that has never been proven true.
The prostitutes were legal age women.....the boys were not legal age......one was only 15-16 yrs old...........I have often wondered how much that cost the university in hush money.........according to the story one kid didn't want to participate and the assistant coach pushed him back into room with the ***** and told him to be a mam.............I would've had someone's *** in jail......
 

Pidgie

Senior
Jul 4, 2025
131
439
63
Whatever he did at UL, he would have done here eventually. He won here, but the pressure would have eaten him.
His moral character is what it is.......his time in Louisville showed his low morals..........I mean who has sex with a woman in a restaurant with onlookers?
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlueVelvetFog

CoachBrownfield

Redshirt
Oct 8, 2018
30
44
18
I am nearing 40 years old. I have memories of the late Pitino years and remember the coach who was so revered in and around my home that it undoubtedly laid the foundation for my love of the game and my desire to become a coach and work in interscholastic athletics. I'm thankful that Kentucky-Pitino was able to do that for me.

That being said - It is a hard pass for me. The Louisville scandals are enough, whether they happened under your watch or unknowingly by people you are directly supervising, for me to no longer need you around my favorite team nor your opinions about my favorite team. 🤷‍♂️
 
  • Like
Reactions: megablue

MegaBlue05

Heisman
Mar 8, 2014
10,740
21,047
66
I am not necessarily opposed, but be warned that second stints don’t usually yield first stint results in any sport.

Also, we always like to bag on IU for living perpetually in the past, yet we can’t let go of the 1990s, which was 30+ years ago.
 

SlowWalkerSTL

Freshman
Jun 12, 2023
63
81
18
If you have to have someone answer this, their reasons would not be reasons in your book. Would you want your kid being mentored by him? That’s where the discussion starts and ends with me.
 
Feb 3, 2013
436
918
93
I would have had 0 issues if they would have hired Rick Pitino when Cal left. Rick has always been the greatest UK Coach in my lifetime. I still lament him leaving after 1997 more than Cal leaving. With the talent Cal brought thru Lexington 2010 thru 2024 it was criminal he only won 1 Natty. He could have been and should have been the Nick Saban of college Basketball. I do not think he ever wins a Natty again. Rick Pitino won a Natty after leaving here. UK won 2 Natty's after he left but had he stayed I think UK would have won at least 5 between 1998 and 2025 that I am quite certain.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: wildcatdon

TNCatfanforever

Heisman
Apr 3, 2003
21,972
13,696
62
I'm 33

But...

The Resume speaks for itself
  • 2× NCAA National Champion head coach
  • 7× Final Four appearances as a head coach
  • 10+ conference tournament championships
  • 10+ regular season conference championships
  • Led three different programs to the Final Four (first coach to accomplish this)
  • Led five different programs to the NCAA Tournament
  • One of the few coaches to reach the Final Four at three different schools
  • Over 800 career coaching wins (college level)
  • Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame inductee (2013)
  • Multiple National Coach of the Year awards
  • Known for pioneering full-court pressing defenses and high-tempo offenses
  • Developed dozens of NBA players and first-round draft picks
  • Successfully rebuilt multiple struggling programs into national contenders within a few seasons

Alot of older people I've talked to laugh at me when I propose this. I was a child when he won here and a teenager during the Louisville scandal. So I don’t really understand why someone with this resume who wants to coach here is opposed by a lot of older UK fans.

We're the 9th best basketball team in the SEC. How are we above bringing him back? Please help me understand
I am 71 life long fan. I would hire him tomorrow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wildcatdon

Cerberus

Freshman
Mar 17, 2026
49
58
18
We have the guy we need in place now! Learned the ropes from the master himself. In five or six years we will be back and view this as nothing more than a bump in the road. Our administration will give him all the time he needs and then some.