Growing momentum for the 24-team playoff

katatonic2

Sophomore
Dec 1, 2025
159
116
43
After SEC coaches scuttled the previous plan with the 4-4-2-2-1-1 auto bids format (since they thought it was in their best interest to have more open bids); coaches Smart and Heupel have thrown support behind the B1G's 24 team playoff.

A bit surprised that Smart has changed his mind so early as even with the SEC adding another conference game, UGA should be in pretty much every year even with the current 12 team format (guess he's getting concerned with how much $ the Texas schools and others with deep pocketed donors can throw into their programs).

With someone with the credibility/weight like Smart now supporting the 24 team format, expect more and more SEC coaches to join which will force Sankey to change his tune (again).

Going beyond a 16 team playoff will open the door to more networks/streaming services being able to bid on games, whereas currently, ESPN has a monopoly.

Don't have much of an issue going to 24 teams, especially if 8 teams play in a "play-in" in lieu of the increasingly irrelevant and potentially damaging conference championship game; so it would essentially be a 16 team playoff with 4 play-in games.

The play-in games would not only have significantly more on the line, but would help alleviate the problem with uneven schedules (better to have things settled on the gridiron than in a committee room).

Much has been made of how NIL and the portal has spread out the talent, but another factor helping that has been greater accessibility to competing for the national championship.

When it was just the top 2 ranked teams (or even the top 4), it was basically the same 5-7 schools that had access.

Players want to be able to compete for the natty, and as the no. of teams in the playoff have expanded, we have seen greater disbursement of talent.

This not only helps in making the pathway to the playoff more accessible for the Cats, but helps in talent acquisition as well.

Another considering is the growing noise about a "superleague" which encompasses every P4 school where broadcasting rights would be bundled together (hurting the B1G and SEC and helping the ACC and B12).


 
Last edited:

AdamOnFirst

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
10,068
1,664
113
Sankey does take his marching orders from Kirby Smart, he takes them from Bristol, CT
 

Sheffielder

Senior
Sep 1, 2004
9,900
704
113
As someone who is against a giant playoff field, it is clear to me that, unfortunately, dissenting voices in this conversation will ultimately just look like stodgy Luddites who can get with the times, rather than people who appreciate college football as being different from the NFL and CBB...and see this whole thing being driven by a tv guy who really has no roots or loyalty to the sport itself.

People already asked me why I bothered going to the bowl game in December, since NU wasn't in the playoffs. Sigh...
 

NU'06er

Sophomore
May 2, 2024
176
115
43
As someone who is against a giant playoff field, it is clear to me that, unfortunately, dissenting voices in this conversation will ultimately just look like stodgy Luddites who can get with the times, rather than people who appreciate college football as being different from the NFL and CBB...and see this whole thing being driven by a tv guy who really has no roots or loyalty to the sport itself.

People already asked me why I bothered going to the bowl game in December, since NU wasn't in the playoffs. Sigh...

In theory, the point of a playoff is to ensure that the best team is determined on the field. Standing alone, I'm in favor of that.

I just think the more the playoff expands to satisfy the TV gods, the less likely the best team is actually what emerges.

Very glad the get-the-monkey-off-your-back Gator Bowl win happened before this era could devalue it.
 

Sheffielder

Senior
Sep 1, 2004
9,900
704
113
In theory, the point of a playoff is to ensure that the best team is determined on the field. Standing alone, I'm in favor of that.

I just think the more the playoff expands to satisfy the TV gods, the less likely the best team is actually what emerges.

Very glad the get-the-monkey-off-your-back Gator Bowl win happened before this era could devalue it.

Let's say we go to 24 teams.

In the very first year, we'll have a marginal 7-5 or 8-4 team making the field.

Then people will complain about that.

Then some of those people will say 12 games isn't enough to really vet a 24-team field. "Look at the NFL - imagine if they only played 12 games per year" one talking head (probably from ESPN) will say. And then we'll creep up to 14 games, until it's decided 14 isn't enough either.

And it will be the final death blow to bowl games...because those don't matter, right? Because the only reason a college kid would ever want to play football is to make the playoffs. No possible way they'd just want to play one extra game with their friends for life, and no chance any of us would want to travel or pay to see it.

Positively none of this is in the best interest of ensuring "the best team" is decided on the field. This all just leads to a sport that looks more like a temu version of the NFL.
 

katatonic2

Sophomore
Dec 1, 2025
159
116
43
Miami almost missed the playoffs and they made it to the championship game.

There were a no. of teams like the Domers, UT, Iowa, Vsndy, USC that could have won a game or make a run.

As stated before, there would be play in games - which would help determine worthy teams in this day and age of uneven schedules; an 8-4 can very well be better than a 9-3 team having played a tougher schedule.

Also, programs have been canceling tough OOC games left and right in fear of an extra loss keeping them out of the PO.

Widen the opportunity for a chance to play for a national title, we'll see more dispersion of talent across more schools, which will only help NU.
 
Last edited:

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
27,614
2,956
113
Let's say we go to 24 teams.

In the very first year, we'll have a marginal 7-5 or 8-4 team making the field.

Then people will complain about that.

Then some of those people will say 12 games isn't enough to really vet a 24-team field. "Look at the NFL - imagine if they only played 12 games per year" one talking head (probably from ESPN) will say. And then we'll creep up to 14 games, until it's decided 14 isn't enough either.

And it will be the final death blow to bowl games...because those don't matter, right? Because the only reason a college kid would ever want to play football is to make the playoffs. No possible way they'd just want to play one extra game with their friends for life, and no chance any of us would want to travel or pay to see it.

Positively none of this is in the best interest of ensuring "the best team" is decided on the field. This all just leads to a sport that looks more like a temu version of the NFL.
I got news for you. The “best team” often isn’t decided on the field. It happens all the time in sports. Having your team with a chance, even if remote it’s what draws us in. It’s called hope. Watching the same 8 teams rotate in each year is called boredom for everyone else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CoralSpringsCat

phatcat_rivals223240

All-Conference
Nov 5, 2001
18,908
1,060
113
Miami almost missed the playoffs and they made it to the championship game.

There were a no. of teams like the Domers, UT, Iowa, Vsndy, USC that could have won a game or make a run.

As stated before, there would be play in games - which would help determine worthy teams in this day and age of uneven schedules; an 8-4 can very well be better than a 9-3 team having played a tougher schedule.

Also, programs have been canceling tough OOC games left and right in fear of an extra loss keeping them out of the PO.

Widen the opportunity for a chance to play for a national title, we'll see more dispersion of talent across more schools, which will only help NU.
Who cares is Miami almost missed the field, then got hot at the right time and almost won? How about winning the regular season games that matter? OSU won last year after choking against Mich and getting hot in the playoffs. This isn't hockey, Mr. Gilmore, no matter how much you want it to be. Limp along and sneak into the playoffs. TWENTY FOUR teams?!?

Meanwhile, that will rarely happen to NU, so our unnecessary stadium will become more of a white elephant, hosting meaningless regular season games. Look how exciting it was to win at Wrigley and sneak into a minor bowl. Not any more
 

CatManTrue

All-American
Oct 4, 2008
16,535
5,695
97
Who cares is Miami almost missed the field, then got hot at the right time and almost won? How about winning the regular season games that matter? OSU won last year after choking against Mich and getting hot in the playoffs. This isn't hockey, Mr. Gilmore, no matter how much you want it to be. Limp along and sneak into the playoffs. TWENTY FOUR teams?!?

Meanwhile, that will rarely happen to NU, so our unnecessary stadium will become more of a white elephant, hosting meaningless regular season games. Look how exciting it was to win at Wrigley and sneak into a minor bowl. Not any more
Joe Biden Politics GIF by The Democrats
 

katatonic2

Sophomore
Dec 1, 2025
159
116
43
Who cares is Miami almost missed the field, then got hot at the right time and almost won? How about winning the regular season games that matter? OSU won last year after choking against Mich and getting hot in the playoffs. This isn't hockey, Mr. Gilmore, no matter how much you want it to be. Limp along and sneak into the playoffs. TWENTY FOUR teams?!?

Meanwhile, that will rarely happen to NU, so our unnecessary stadium will become more of a white elephant, hosting meaningless regular season games. Look how exciting it was to win at Wrigley and sneak into a minor bowl. Not any more

Teams get "hot" because they improve over the course of a season, get healthy, etc

The regular season never really mattered as much since due to vagaries of CFB (different conferences, etc), things like the "eye-test,," pre-season rankings, ESPiN pumping up schools in a certain conference, etc come into play way more than they should.

And this is even more true with over-sized conferences which results in very uneven schedules (see PSU's schedule versus that of the Cats or dOSU).

Again, we are talking about a certain no. (probably at the least 4) play-in games.

Let's say the Cats finish 8-4.

Wouldn't you want them to be able to have a play-in game with the school that's ahead of them in the standings at 9-3, but one that played a much easier schedule?

Deciding things on the field is better/fairer than letting a committee decide too much...

Also, I'd rather watch a play-in game with a playoff spot on the line than a conference championship where only seeding is on the line.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Purple Pile Driver

phatcat_rivals223240

All-Conference
Nov 5, 2001
18,908
1,060
113
I don't care that they "improve" over the season. Either the regular season is meaningful (pre.expanded playoffs when next-level bowls were an enjoyable reward) or meaningless (with expanding to 24 and then 32). I'm sorry, if you lost 4 games, you have no business playing for the national championship. Getting "hot" like Miami and also OSU last year proves nothing.

I'm an old man yelling at clouds. Playoffs are wildly popular and lucrative so we will have more. Period. But a team winning a 24/32 team field is a tournament winner, and not the "best" team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CatManTrue

CatManTrue

All-American
Oct 4, 2008
16,535
5,695
97
I don't care that they "improve" over the season. Either the regular season is meaningful (pre.expanded playoffs when next-level bowls were an enjoyable reward) or meaningless (with expanding to 24 and then 32). I'm sorry, if you lost 4 games, you have no business playing for the national championship. Getting "hot" like Miami and also OSU last year proves nothing.

I'm an old man yelling at clouds. Playoffs are wildly popular and lucrative so we will have more. Period. But a team winning a 24/32 team field is a tournament winner, and not the "best" team.
Baby Boomers GIF by MOODMAN
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Purple Pile Driver

prez77

Junior
Dec 27, 2024
576
254
57
I got news for you. The “best team” often isn’t decided on the field. It happens all the time in sports. Having your team with a chance, even if remote it’s what draws us in. It’s called hope. Watching the same 8 teams rotate in each year is called boredom for everyone else.
It's hardly the same 8 - The national champion is INDIANA of all places. They beat Miami - good but not a perennial and Notre Dame didn't make it. In the portal/NIL era, literally anyone can make a run.